This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jun/04/tories-britain-attitude-immigration-javid-gove-davidson
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| The Tories should listen to the public, not their leader, on immigration | The Tories should listen to the public, not their leader, on immigration |
| (about 1 month later) | |
| The campaign to secure a new referendum on remaining in the EU faces a relentlessly ticking clock. Converting Jeremy Corbyn’s frontbench and enough Conservative backbenchers to the cause would leave little time to hold a public vote by the time Britain is due to leave the EU. Unless negotiations collapse entirely, it seems a long shot. | The campaign to secure a new referendum on remaining in the EU faces a relentlessly ticking clock. Converting Jeremy Corbyn’s frontbench and enough Conservative backbenchers to the cause would leave little time to hold a public vote by the time Britain is due to leave the EU. Unless negotiations collapse entirely, it seems a long shot. |
| Yet is there a glimmer of hope that things can change, with the evidence that the British public have become more positive about immigration? Michael Gove’s claim that Britain is one of the most pro-migrant countries in Europe was greeted with scorn by many of his referendum opponents, recalling how Vote Leave stoked fears of a Turkish invasion in 2016. Yet the Scottish Conservative leader, Ruth Davidson – a remainer in 2016 – saw in the surprising change of attitudes an opportunity to ditch a failed net migration target that has been missed every quarter for eight years. | Yet is there a glimmer of hope that things can change, with the evidence that the British public have become more positive about immigration? Michael Gove’s claim that Britain is one of the most pro-migrant countries in Europe was greeted with scorn by many of his referendum opponents, recalling how Vote Leave stoked fears of a Turkish invasion in 2016. Yet the Scottish Conservative leader, Ruth Davidson – a remainer in 2016 – saw in the surprising change of attitudes an opportunity to ditch a failed net migration target that has been missed every quarter for eight years. |
| The public are both less bothered by immigration and more positive about migrants who come here. Immigration is now a considerably lower priority for voters than the NHS, and its economic and cultural impacts are viewed more positively – though most would still prefer the pace of migration to slow down. | The public are both less bothered by immigration and more positive about migrants who come here. Immigration is now a considerably lower priority for voters than the NHS, and its economic and cultural impacts are viewed more positively – though most would still prefer the pace of migration to slow down. |
| The Gove-Davidson axis is a Tory dream ticket. But does it have legs? | Matthew d’Ancona | The Gove-Davidson axis is a Tory dream ticket. But does it have legs? | Matthew d’Ancona |
| Gove attributed the change in attitudes to a greater sense of control after the referendum vote. His critics suggested the shift might be despite Brexit, rather than because of it. These may be complementary rather than competing explanations: different people change their views for different reasons. When Ipsos Mori asked those with more positive attitudes why their views had shifted, equal proportions said that they were either more aware of positive contributions now, or were expecting Brexit to lead to change. | Gove attributed the change in attitudes to a greater sense of control after the referendum vote. His critics suggested the shift might be despite Brexit, rather than because of it. These may be complementary rather than competing explanations: different people change their views for different reasons. When Ipsos Mori asked those with more positive attitudes why their views had shifted, equal proportions said that they were either more aware of positive contributions now, or were expecting Brexit to lead to change. |
| So this shift in public opinion may not be one that would sweep remain to victory in a new vote. Nine out of 10 voters say they would vote the same way on Brexit, despite the shift on immigration. A new referendum would reheat and repolarise the immigration debate, returning to what most people still see as a binary question: remain or leave, free movement or the ability to set limits. Unless EU governments made the sort of offer which David Cameron could not secure in 2016, pro-EU voices would again divide between defending free movement or campaigning to reform it (as half of remain voters would prefer) – or simply just trying to change the subject as soon as possible. | So this shift in public opinion may not be one that would sweep remain to victory in a new vote. Nine out of 10 voters say they would vote the same way on Brexit, despite the shift on immigration. A new referendum would reheat and repolarise the immigration debate, returning to what most people still see as a binary question: remain or leave, free movement or the ability to set limits. Unless EU governments made the sort of offer which David Cameron could not secure in 2016, pro-EU voices would again divide between defending free movement or campaigning to reform it (as half of remain voters would prefer) – or simply just trying to change the subject as soon as possible. |
| In the post-referendum landscape, we face a new, less binary question on immigration: what should we do now? Even two years on, this “what next?” debate has yet to begin in earnest, given the government’s tendency to delay substantive choices about Brexit. | In the post-referendum landscape, we face a new, less binary question on immigration: what should we do now? Even two years on, this “what next?” debate has yet to begin in earnest, given the government’s tendency to delay substantive choices about Brexit. |
| Ministers should have more confidence in the public. The National Conversation on Immigration has seen British Future and Hope Not Hate hold citizens’ panels in 60 towns and cities across every nation and region to inform the home affairs select committee investigation into future immigration choices. It has found that most people are “balancers”: open to students and skills, preferring controls on low-skilled migration, but open to using them pragmatically where jobs need filling. Low trust in the competence of governments is combined with warmth towards migrants who come to contribute to our society. | Ministers should have more confidence in the public. The National Conversation on Immigration has seen British Future and Hope Not Hate hold citizens’ panels in 60 towns and cities across every nation and region to inform the home affairs select committee investigation into future immigration choices. It has found that most people are “balancers”: open to students and skills, preferring controls on low-skilled migration, but open to using them pragmatically where jobs need filling. Low trust in the competence of governments is combined with warmth towards migrants who come to contribute to our society. |
| There is no guarantee that attitudes may not shift back. However, the post-referendum trends do also reflect a gradual longer-term shift, particularly across generations, linked to the rise in higher education and increased social contact in a more diverse society – though social polarisation explains how more positive general attitudes can coexist with a spike in reported hate crime from a shrinking but vociferous racist fringe. | There is no guarantee that attitudes may not shift back. However, the post-referendum trends do also reflect a gradual longer-term shift, particularly across generations, linked to the rise in higher education and increased social contact in a more diverse society – though social polarisation explains how more positive general attitudes can coexist with a spike in reported hate crime from a shrinking but vociferous racist fringe. |
| If a new referendum would likely replay the tense immigration debate, there is still an opportunity to build a consensus on a managed and welcoming post-Brexit system. There should be greater political accountability, with an annual Migration Day – similar to the budget – preceded by public engagement around the country that addresses both the pressures and gains of migration. | If a new referendum would likely replay the tense immigration debate, there is still an opportunity to build a consensus on a managed and welcoming post-Brexit system. There should be greater political accountability, with an annual Migration Day – similar to the budget – preceded by public engagement around the country that addresses both the pressures and gains of migration. |
| A new migration deal with Europe that is as open to European skills as now, with pragmatic controls on low-skilled migration, would command a broad public and political consensus in the UK. Nobody can know how the EU would respond until the UK has a negotiating position, but a constructive offer could pave the way towards a close post-Brexit partnership with the EU that most MPs across the Commons would back. | A new migration deal with Europe that is as open to European skills as now, with pragmatic controls on low-skilled migration, would command a broad public and political consensus in the UK. Nobody can know how the EU would respond until the UK has a negotiating position, but a constructive offer could pave the way towards a close post-Brexit partnership with the EU that most MPs across the Commons would back. |
| The Observer view on the UK’s increasingly harsh immigration policy | Observer editorial | The Observer view on the UK’s increasingly harsh immigration policy | Observer editorial |
| The new home secretary, Sajid Javid, has a big opportunity. Brexit and Windrush offer a reset moment for immigration – if he has the confidence to press the reset button, that is. The emerging Javid-Gove-Davidson axis offers a powerful alliance to break out of the referendum trenches inside government, and develop a position with cross-party appeal. | The new home secretary, Sajid Javid, has a big opportunity. Brexit and Windrush offer a reset moment for immigration – if he has the confidence to press the reset button, that is. The emerging Javid-Gove-Davidson axis offers a powerful alliance to break out of the referendum trenches inside government, and develop a position with cross-party appeal. |
| Yet government policy has been slow to change. Refusing visas to 1,500 doctors whom NHS trusts want to employ is the most egregious example of government policy being tougher than the British public viewpoint – as it has been on students, EU nationals and the treatment of the Windrush generation. | Yet government policy has been slow to change. Refusing visas to 1,500 doctors whom NHS trusts want to employ is the most egregious example of government policy being tougher than the British public viewpoint – as it has been on students, EU nationals and the treatment of the Windrush generation. |
| Leading Conservatives are increasingly aware that many people are changing their minds on immigration. Their problem will be persuading a stubborn prime minister to change hers too. | Leading Conservatives are increasingly aware that many people are changing their minds on immigration. Their problem will be persuading a stubborn prime minister to change hers too. |
| • Sunder Katwala is director of British Future and former general secretary of the Fabian Society | • Sunder Katwala is director of British Future and former general secretary of the Fabian Society |
| Conservatives | Conservatives |
| Opinion | Opinion |
| Migration | Migration |
| Immigration and asylum | Immigration and asylum |
| Sajid Javid | Sajid Javid |
| Michael Gove | Michael Gove |
| Ruth Davidson | Ruth Davidson |
| Brexit | Brexit |
| comment | comment |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |