This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/jul/16/david-dungay-inquest-told-inadequate-resuscitation-may-have-contributed-to-death

The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 3 Version 4
David Dungay inquest: shocking video shows prison officers restraining inmate before death David Dungay inquest: shocking video shows prison officers restraining inmate before death
(about 1 hour later)
A shocking video of the death in custody of a prison inmate has been played to a New South Wales coroner’s court, depicting five officers restraining a man who said 12 times that he could not breathe before dying.A shocking video of the death in custody of a prison inmate has been played to a New South Wales coroner’s court, depicting five officers restraining a man who said 12 times that he could not breathe before dying.
The court also heard a suggestion that attempts by health staff to resuscitate him were “lost by the inadequate and interrupted care he received”, which was so ineffective that any chance of survival was lost.The court also heard a suggestion that attempts by health staff to resuscitate him were “lost by the inadequate and interrupted care he received”, which was so ineffective that any chance of survival was lost.
The inquest into the death of David Dungay Jr, a 26-year-old Indigenous Dunghutti man, viewed the graphic footage of the eight-minute ordeal, which began with officers from an immediate action team (IAT) at Sydney’s Long Bay jail rushing Dungay’s cell and restraining him face-down on the bed.The inquest into the death of David Dungay Jr, a 26-year-old Indigenous Dunghutti man, viewed the graphic footage of the eight-minute ordeal, which began with officers from an immediate action team (IAT) at Sydney’s Long Bay jail rushing Dungay’s cell and restraining him face-down on the bed.
He was transferred to another cell where he was restrained again, injected with a powerful sedative, Midazolam, and a few minutes later stopped breathing.He was transferred to another cell where he was restrained again, injected with a powerful sedative, Midazolam, and a few minutes later stopped breathing.
The video was played to the court until the moment Dungay became non-responsive.The video was played to the court until the moment Dungay became non-responsive.
The court will hear from a number of witnesses including expert testimony from an emergency physician, Prof Anthony Brown, who will testify on his finding that a failure by staff to adequately administer first aid removed any chance of survival for Dungay.The court will hear from a number of witnesses including expert testimony from an emergency physician, Prof Anthony Brown, who will testify on his finding that a failure by staff to adequately administer first aid removed any chance of survival for Dungay.
In his opening address, counsel assisting Jason Downing, said Brown would give evidence that while the initial attempts at resuscitation by officers were appropriate, and medical treatment of the “highest standard”, those of the Justice Health staff were “incompatible with survival”.In his opening address, counsel assisting Jason Downing, said Brown would give evidence that while the initial attempts at resuscitation by officers were appropriate, and medical treatment of the “highest standard”, those of the Justice Health staff were “incompatible with survival”.
“[Brown] was highly critical of the failure to provide continuous external cardiac massage and he stated there was no effective or consistent ventilation given to Mr Dungay for the majority of the period between the onset of cardiorespiratory arrest and the arrival of the NSW ambulance team,” Downing said.“[Brown] was highly critical of the failure to provide continuous external cardiac massage and he stated there was no effective or consistent ventilation given to Mr Dungay for the majority of the period between the onset of cardiorespiratory arrest and the arrival of the NSW ambulance team,” Downing said.
Combined with other failings, this “lack of provision of continuous basic life support” meant the attempts at resuscitation were “effectively without value”.Combined with other failings, this “lack of provision of continuous basic life support” meant the attempts at resuscitation were “effectively without value”.
Downing noted that it was “unclear” whether Dungay would have survived even if Justice Health officers had provided adequate life support, but Brown’s evidence suggested that “whatever chance Mr Dungay had was lost by the inadequate and interrupted care he received from Justice Health”.Downing noted that it was “unclear” whether Dungay would have survived even if Justice Health officers had provided adequate life support, but Brown’s evidence suggested that “whatever chance Mr Dungay had was lost by the inadequate and interrupted care he received from Justice Health”.
The attempts at care were filmed but that portion of footage was not shown to the court on Monday. The eight minutes preceding Dungay’s death was shown, prompting members of his family to leave the room.The attempts at care were filmed but that portion of footage was not shown to the court on Monday. The eight minutes preceding Dungay’s death was shown, prompting members of his family to leave the room.
The footage shows five officers rushing and physically restraining Dungay in his cell, 71, sitting on him and then moving him to the floor. He is handcuffed and walked to cell 77. Officers warn him not to spit.The footage shows five officers rushing and physically restraining Dungay in his cell, 71, sitting on him and then moving him to the floor. He is handcuffed and walked to cell 77. Officers warn him not to spit.
Throughout the incident Dungay shouts that he cannot breathe and begs to be let go. He shrieks and cries.Throughout the incident Dungay shouts that he cannot breathe and begs to be let go. He shrieks and cries.
In cell 77 his pants are pulled down and a nurse injects him with Midazolam. He cries and yells: “I can’t breathe.”In cell 77 his pants are pulled down and a nurse injects him with Midazolam. He cries and yells: “I can’t breathe.”
A guard responds: “If you’re talking, you can breathe.”A guard responds: “If you’re talking, you can breathe.”
Dungay is quiet and a guard tells him they are going to leave him there for the night. It is silent, then an officer shouts “Dungay, Dungay” before the video stops.Dungay is quiet and a guard tells him they are going to leave him there for the night. It is silent, then an officer shouts “Dungay, Dungay” before the video stops.
After counsel assisting finished his opening statement, the commissioner of corrective services told the court, via a statement through his lawyer, that a number of policy and procedural changes had been made because of Dungay’s death.After counsel assisting finished his opening statement, the commissioner of corrective services told the court, via a statement through his lawyer, that a number of policy and procedural changes had been made because of Dungay’s death.
They included a new “use of force policy”, designed to detail the warning signs of positional asphyxia, including an inmate saying they could not breathe.They included a new “use of force policy”, designed to detail the warning signs of positional asphyxia, including an inmate saying they could not breathe.
“It is a misconception that a restrained person who can talk must be able to breathe,” he said.“It is a misconception that a restrained person who can talk must be able to breathe,” he said.
The face-down manner in which Dungay was restrained will be a key part of evidence.The face-down manner in which Dungay was restrained will be a key part of evidence.
Speaking outside the court, Dungay’s mother Leetona said wanted the video to go public to prevent another mother going through what she’d gone through.Speaking outside the court, Dungay’s mother Leetona said wanted the video to go public to prevent another mother going through what she’d gone through.
“It’s a terrible way to get justice - that you have to watch the way your son dies at the hands of people,” she said.
“I would like them to be accountable for what they have done, and for them to tell the truth.”
She said she hoped the inquest prompted pledges from Corrections to retrain staff.
“They never do nothing right, did you see on the CCTV? 12 times: I can’t breathe. Slow breathing, a slow death that would have been.”
Dungay’s nephew, Paul, said it was a traumatic experience that would haunt the family.
“At the end of this, it’s a bit much to wish for, but I’d like the corrective officers and all that were involved to be held accountable for their actions on the day.”
“Tell the truth, be straight up about it, cop it on the chin.”
Evidence emerged that five of the six IAT officers were untrained in the risks of positional asphyxiation. A detective sergeant tasked with investigating the death criticised himself and fellow investigating officers for not asking the IAT members about their training.Evidence emerged that five of the six IAT officers were untrained in the risks of positional asphyxiation. A detective sergeant tasked with investigating the death criticised himself and fellow investigating officers for not asking the IAT members about their training.
“The position was something that I was aware of through my training as being a dangerous position to put someone in,” he said.“The position was something that I was aware of through my training as being a dangerous position to put someone in,” he said.
“I myself wouldn’t want to keep someone in that position longer than I had to … once you had that person under the level of control that was needed.”“I myself wouldn’t want to keep someone in that position longer than I had to … once you had that person under the level of control that was needed.”
He said in his 16-year career of policing he couldn’t remember ever not knowing that it was dangerous.He said in his 16-year career of policing he couldn’t remember ever not knowing that it was dangerous.
Later on Monday a corrections officer, referred to as C, who was present that day told the court she did not know what positional asphyxiation was, and had received no training about the risk of sudden death if someone is restrained incorrectly.Later on Monday a corrections officer, referred to as C, who was present that day told the court she did not know what positional asphyxiation was, and had received no training about the risk of sudden death if someone is restrained incorrectly.
A senior officer from that day, under the pseudonym E, also gave evidence that he “never” used Aboriginal welfare officers or delegates in the mental health ward, despite knowing they were available in Long Bay jail.A senior officer from that day, under the pseudonym E, also gave evidence that he “never” used Aboriginal welfare officers or delegates in the mental health ward, despite knowing they were available in Long Bay jail.
Nor did he request a doctor make an assessment about what could be done to manage Dungay.Nor did he request a doctor make an assessment about what could be done to manage Dungay.
Downing also flagged disputed accounts of what happened, including a nurse and officers each saying the other had been the first to raise concern that Dungay might adversely affect his blood sugar levels by eating the biscuits – which led to the cell raid.Downing also flagged disputed accounts of what happened, including a nurse and officers each saying the other had been the first to raise concern that Dungay might adversely affect his blood sugar levels by eating the biscuits – which led to the cell raid.
That nurse also said a treating doctor had agreed Dungay should be given a shot of Midazolam. That doctor denies ordering the Midazolam “or indeed any other medication”, Downing said.That nurse also said a treating doctor had agreed Dungay should be given a shot of Midazolam. That doctor denies ordering the Midazolam “or indeed any other medication”, Downing said.
The court heard of David’s severe mental health issues, including medical reports which noted he suffered auditory and visual hallucinations, and was treated with antipsychotic medication.The court heard of David’s severe mental health issues, including medical reports which noted he suffered auditory and visual hallucinations, and was treated with antipsychotic medication.
It also heard of his long struggle to manage his diabetes. There were several incidents and reports from his periods of incarceration that contained concerns he was self-harming by “deliberately mismanaging” his condition, and that he could be non-compliant with medication.It also heard of his long struggle to manage his diabetes. There were several incidents and reports from his periods of incarceration that contained concerns he was self-harming by “deliberately mismanaging” his condition, and that he could be non-compliant with medication.
On the day of his death Dungay had high blood sugar levels but was asymptomatic, and his history suggested it was low blood sugar that led to medical episodes. The legal representative of the Dungay family raised questions such as why the guards needed to use such force to stop him eating biscuits. “Why couldn’t they just do nothing?”On the day of his death Dungay had high blood sugar levels but was asymptomatic, and his history suggested it was low blood sugar that led to medical episodes. The legal representative of the Dungay family raised questions such as why the guards needed to use such force to stop him eating biscuits. “Why couldn’t they just do nothing?”
The inquiry continues.The inquiry continues.
Deaths in custodyDeaths in custody
New South WalesNew South Wales
Indigenous AustraliansIndigenous Australians
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook
Share on TwitterShare on Twitter
Share via EmailShare via Email
Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn
Share on PinterestShare on Pinterest
Share on Google+Share on Google+
Share on WhatsAppShare on WhatsApp
Share on MessengerShare on Messenger
Reuse this contentReuse this content