This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-44843403
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Singapore's first Premier League recruit must first do national service | Singapore's first Premier League recruit must first do national service |
| (4 days later) | |
| The first Singaporean footballer to sign a professional contract with an English Premier League club has been denied the chance to defer mandatory military service. | The first Singaporean footballer to sign a professional contract with an English Premier League club has been denied the chance to defer mandatory military service. |
| Benjamin Davis, 17, who has a two-year deal with Fulham, had applied to defer from national service (NS). | Benjamin Davis, 17, who has a two-year deal with Fulham, had applied to defer from national service (NS). |
| Authorities said that he did not "meet the criteria for deferment". | Authorities said that he did not "meet the criteria for deferment". |
| But Davis's father said it was "unrealistic" that he would be expected to take two years out of football. | But Davis's father said it was "unrealistic" that he would be expected to take two years out of football. |
| All Singaporean men over 18 have to serve in either the armed forces, the police or the civil defence force for two years as part of their NS requirements. Benjamin turns 18 this November. | All Singaporean men over 18 have to serve in either the armed forces, the police or the civil defence force for two years as part of their NS requirements. Benjamin turns 18 this November. |
| "As all male Singaporeans liable for full-time NS put aside personal pursuits to dutifully enlist... it would not be fair to approve applications for deferment for individuals to pursue their own careers and development," said the Ministry of Defence in a statement. | "As all male Singaporeans liable for full-time NS put aside personal pursuits to dutifully enlist... it would not be fair to approve applications for deferment for individuals to pursue their own careers and development," said the Ministry of Defence in a statement. |
| "In sports, deferments are granted only to those who represent Singapore in international competitions like the Olympic Games and are potential medal winners for Singapore." | "In sports, deferments are granted only to those who represent Singapore in international competitions like the Olympic Games and are potential medal winners for Singapore." |
| Benjamin joined Fulham on a two-year scholarship last year. He signed a professional contract this month, becoming the first Singaporean to do so with a top-level English club. He currently plays for Fulham's Under-18 team. | Benjamin joined Fulham on a two-year scholarship last year. He signed a professional contract this month, becoming the first Singaporean to do so with a top-level English club. He currently plays for Fulham's Under-18 team. |
| The Premier League has a strong following in Singapore and many in the city state are unhappy with the decision over Davis. | The Premier League has a strong following in Singapore and many in the city state are unhappy with the decision over Davis. |
| Harvey Davis told the BBC that his son was looking to appeal against the defence ministry's decision. | Harvey Davis told the BBC that his son was looking to appeal against the defence ministry's decision. |
| "I think it's unrealistic to expect someone to take two years out from a professional football career and then just step back in afterwards," he said. "At this critical stage, it just doesn't make any sense." | "I think it's unrealistic to expect someone to take two years out from a professional football career and then just step back in afterwards," he said. "At this critical stage, it just doesn't make any sense." |
| Mr Davis added: "We understand the importance of serving NS. My oldest son has already served and Benjamin will serve... [but it's] a matter of timing." | Mr Davis added: "We understand the importance of serving NS. My oldest son has already served and Benjamin will serve... [but it's] a matter of timing." |
| Philippe Aw, a Singaporean professional football coach, told the BBC that the two years of service would "affect [Benjamin's] development, for sure". | |
| "It is possible to serve NS and train for football, but they cannot train like a professional and it will slow down their development," he said. "NS men need to perform their duties then train, and then work again. Their bodies will not recover to an optimum state." | "It is possible to serve NS and train for football, but they cannot train like a professional and it will slow down their development," he said. "NS men need to perform their duties then train, and then work again. Their bodies will not recover to an optimum state." |
| 'Denied an amazing opportunity' | 'Denied an amazing opportunity' |
| On social media, many spoke out against the decision to deny the NS deferment. | On social media, many spoke out against the decision to deny the NS deferment. |
| "This boy is denied an amazing opportunity. I am [at a] loss for words," said one user on Facebook. | "This boy is denied an amazing opportunity. I am [at a] loss for words," said one user on Facebook. |
| "Can NS be more flexible? This is our only chance [to] succeed in the English Premier League," another added. | "Can NS be more flexible? This is our only chance [to] succeed in the English Premier League," another added. |
| Some also pointed out that Singapore's deputy prime minister had praised World Cup champions France in a Facebook post for producing home-grown football players. | Some also pointed out that Singapore's deputy prime minister had praised World Cup champions France in a Facebook post for producing home-grown football players. |
| And there were those that called for Benjamin to give up his Singapore citizenship. | And there were those that called for Benjamin to give up his Singapore citizenship. |
| "[There's] no need to stay in Singapore if you feel pastures are better elsewhere," one person said. | "[There's] no need to stay in Singapore if you feel pastures are better elsewhere," one person said. |
| Benjamin currently holds Thai, British and Singaporean passports - his mother is Thai and his father is originally from the UK. | Benjamin currently holds Thai, British and Singaporean passports - his mother is Thai and his father is originally from the UK. |
| When asked if Benjamin would give up his Singapore citizenship, Mr Davis said: "I wouldn't know what choice we would have if we are forced into that position. | When asked if Benjamin would give up his Singapore citizenship, Mr Davis said: "I wouldn't know what choice we would have if we are forced into that position. |
| "Ben wants to play for Singapore, he feels he can contribute and make Singapore proud. But if he isn't given the chance, then how can he do this?" | "Ben wants to play for Singapore, he feels he can contribute and make Singapore proud. But if he isn't given the chance, then how can he do this?" |
| Singapore has in the past granted NS deferments to three athletes. One of them was swimmer Joseph Schooling, who went on to win the nation's first ever Olympic gold medal at the 2016 Games. | Singapore has in the past granted NS deferments to three athletes. One of them was swimmer Joseph Schooling, who went on to win the nation's first ever Olympic gold medal at the 2016 Games. |