This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/aug/30/alex-salmond-crowdfunding-scottish-independence

The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Alex Salmond is using crowdfunding to signal his power. That’s wrong Alex Salmond is using crowdfunding to signal his power. That’s wrong
(35 minutes later)
One of my recent donations to crowdfunding pages was in memory of a friend’s spouse for research into a rare form of cancer. Another was to keep a local community centre going, and a third to help someone with huge medical bills in the US after an accident. One of my recent donations to crowdfunding pages was in memory of a friend’s spouse for research into a rare form of cancer. Another was to keep a local community centre going, and a third to help someone with huge medical bills in the United States after an accident.
I am not here to talk about my altruism – far from it – but to explain how I and many others treat crowdsourcing. The fact that Alex Salmond, the former leader of the SNP, is using crowdfunding to pay his legal costs for a judicial review into the Scottish government’s handling of sexual harassment claims against him is somewhat gobsmacking.I am not here to talk about my altruism – far from it – but to explain how I and many others treat crowdsourcing. The fact that Alex Salmond, the former leader of the SNP, is using crowdfunding to pay his legal costs for a judicial review into the Scottish government’s handling of sexual harassment claims against him is somewhat gobsmacking.
Salmond, is of course innocent until proven guilty, and has quit the SNP to fight his cause. There will be a police investigation into the allegations. As soon as he asked for support – he originally sought £50,000 – his supporters raised £63,000 within a few hours and at the time of writing the total had passed £76,000. Many of his supporters claim this is a “smear” campaign run by Westminster to undermine Scottish independence. Salmond is of course innocent until proven guilty, and has quit the SNP to fight his cause. There will be a police investigation into the allegations. As soon as he asked for support – he originally sought £50,000 – his supporters raised £63,000 within a few hours and at the time of writing the total had passed £76,000. Many of his supporters claim this is a “smear” campaign run by Westminster to undermine Scottish independence.
I am a longtime and staunch supporter of Scottish independence (you can check my record) but all of this leaves an extremely nasty taste in the mouth. Allegations of sexual harassment are serious and need to be dealt with by due process. Again, I presume Salmond’s innocence, but wonder why this wealthy man (he makes a lot of money from his Kremlin-backed RT show among other things) must use crowdfunding to clear his name.I am a longtime and staunch supporter of Scottish independence (you can check my record) but all of this leaves an extremely nasty taste in the mouth. Allegations of sexual harassment are serious and need to be dealt with by due process. Again, I presume Salmond’s innocence, but wonder why this wealthy man (he makes a lot of money from his Kremlin-backed RT show among other things) must use crowdfunding to clear his name.
Some of the fallout generally from the #MeToo movement has revealed a dazed and confused response to individuals. There is legal process but narratives of redemption and forgiveness are also woven which many of us feel can be deeply inappropriate.Some of the fallout generally from the #MeToo movement has revealed a dazed and confused response to individuals. There is legal process but narratives of redemption and forgiveness are also woven which many of us feel can be deeply inappropriate.
Money, of course, talks and it also protects. I am relieved to see that Jennifer Lawrence, whose nude photos were leaked in 2014, way before the #MeToo movement, has finally got some justice. George Garofano, one of the men who hacked Lawrence and several other stars in 2014, has been sentenced to eight months in prison with three years of supervised release. Garofano pleaded for a lesser sentence, saying: “It will take me a while to forgive myself for this, and I am disappointed in myself.” He brother claimed that Garofano had been in “emotional prison”. Right. Remind me who the victim is here? At the time Lawrence was only 24 but incredibly lucid. She said that this was a “sexual crime “ and “a violation” and she spoke out passionately about it. Money, of course, talks and it also protects. I am relieved to see that Jennifer Lawrence, whose nude photos were leaked in 2014, way before the #MeToo movement, has finally got some justice. George Garofano, one of the men who hacked Lawrence and several other stars in 2014, was given eight months in prison with three years of supervised release. Garofano pleaded for a lesser sentence, saying: “It will take me a while to forgive myself for this, and I am disappointed in myself.” His brother claimed that Garofano had been in “emotional prison”. Right. Remind me who the victim is here? At the time Lawrence was only 24 but incredibly lucid. She said that this was a “sexual crime “ and “a violation” and she spoke out passionately about it.
Since #MeToo started we have seem momentum gather but then falter. Many were surprised to see comedian Louis CK pop into Comedy Cellar in New York to do an unannounced set less than a year after admitting to masturbating in front of women he worked with. Since #MeToo started we have seem momentum gather but then falter. Many were surprised to see Louis CK pop into a comedy club in New York to do an unannounced set less than a year after admitting to masturbating in front of women he worked with.
He received a standing ovation. This comedian, known for his “honesty” and confrontation with complex realities, has yet to explain how he and his team spent more than a decade quashing stories of his sexual misconduct. Is 10 months of an extremely wealthy man’s silence enough? Who gets to forgive him? His fans? Who still suffers the damage? Who still suffers the damage done to them? The women whose careers he most certainly undermined? He received a standing ovation. This comedian, known for his “honesty” and confrontation with complex realities, has yet to explain how he and his team spent more than a decade quashing stories of his sexual misconduct. Is 10 months of an extremely wealthy man’s silence enough? Who gets to forgive him? His fans? Who still suffers the damage? The women whose careers he most certainly undermined?
I am not suggesting Salmond did anything remotely like this but surely it is perfectly possible to support Scottish independence and to let the Scottish government do its work. What this crowdfunding exercise conveys to women who have endured sexual harassment I wonder. Crowdfund your legal fees against well-known rich men or forget it? I am not suggesting Salmond did anything remotely like this, but surely it is perfectly possible to support Scottish independence and to let the Scottish government do its work. What this crowdfunding exercise conveys to women who have endured sexual harassment I wonder. Crowdfund your legal fees against well-known rich men or forget it?
This is certainly a strange place to be in at the moment with different causes jostling for priority. But one thing is clear. Salmond, innocent or guilty, is signalling his power in a way I find deeply worrying. The message being sent out to women is that if you are going to make accusations you will be up against enormous power and wealth. This is a strange place to be in at the moment, with different causes jostling for priority. But one thing is clear. Salmond, innocent or guilty, is signalling his power in a way I find deeply worrying. The message being sent out to women is that if you make accusations you will be up against enormous power and wealth.
Jennifer Lawrence had enough money and power herself to win her case in a way that many young women would not. Good for her. I would donate to crowdfunders for victims of sexual assault to pursue their cases any day of the week, but Salmond’s decision sticks in my craw. The ego of these men is revealing, is it not? Yes, they are innocent until found guilty. But they also have the option of remaining silent or raising money for women whose lives and careers have been ruined by sexual harassment or assault. Standing ovations for comedians and massive donations to crowdfunders send the same old signal to us: what happens to women is always less important than the reputation of “great” men. Jennifer Lawrence had enough money and power to win her case in a way that many young women would not. Good for her. I would donate to crowdfunders for victims of sexual assault to pursue their cases any day of the week, but Salmond’s decision sticks in my craw. The ego of these men is revealing, is it not? Yes, they are innocent until found guilty. But they also have the option of remaining silent or raising money for women whose lives and careers have been ruined by sexual harassment or assault. Standing ovations for comedians and massive donations to crowdfunders send the same old signal to us: what happens to women is always less important than the reputation of “great” men.
• Suzanne Moore is a Guardian columnist• Suzanne Moore is a Guardian columnist
Alex Salmond #MeToo movement
First thoughtsFirst thoughts
Alex Salmond
Sexual harassmentSexual harassment
CrowdfundingCrowdfunding
CrowdsourcingCrowdsourcing
Scottish National party (SNP)Scottish National party (SNP)
Scotland
commentcomment
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook
Share on TwitterShare on Twitter
Share via EmailShare via Email
Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn
Share on PinterestShare on Pinterest
Share on Google+Share on Google+
Share on WhatsAppShare on WhatsApp
Share on MessengerShare on Messenger
Reuse this contentReuse this content