This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-45423835
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Kosovo-Serbia talks: Why land swap could bridge divide | Kosovo-Serbia talks: Why land swap could bridge divide |
(17 days later) | |
A historic moment or a proposal that would mean war? When it comes to Kosovo's putative territory swap with Serbia, it depends who you ask. | A historic moment or a proposal that would mean war? When it comes to Kosovo's putative territory swap with Serbia, it depends who you ask. |
Speculation abounds that the two parties could make the concept official as early as Friday, when their presidents meet for scheduled talks in Brussels. | Speculation abounds that the two parties could make the concept official as early as Friday, when their presidents meet for scheduled talks in Brussels. |
The idea seems simple. | The idea seems simple. |
The Presevo Valley in southern Serbia, where the population is mostly ethnic Albanian, would join Kosovo. | The Presevo Valley in southern Serbia, where the population is mostly ethnic Albanian, would join Kosovo. |
In return, Serbia would re-establish full control over the majority ethnic-Serb area of Kosovo to the north of the River Ibar, which runs through the heart of Mitrovica. | In return, Serbia would re-establish full control over the majority ethnic-Serb area of Kosovo to the north of the River Ibar, which runs through the heart of Mitrovica. |
An end to deadlock? | An end to deadlock? |
Proponents say a territory swap would, potentially, end the stalemate which has persisted for 10 years, since Kosovo unilaterally declared its independence from Serbia. | Proponents say a territory swap would, potentially, end the stalemate which has persisted for 10 years, since Kosovo unilaterally declared its independence from Serbia. |
"Border change may seem distasteful, but many regard it as a practical solution," says James Ker-Lindsay, a Balkans specialist at the London School of Economics. | "Border change may seem distasteful, but many regard it as a practical solution," says James Ker-Lindsay, a Balkans specialist at the London School of Economics. |
"If there were a consensual agreement between the two sides, it would open the way for a full normalisation of relations between Belgrade and Pristina and allow Kosovo finally to become a member of the United Nations." | "If there were a consensual agreement between the two sides, it would open the way for a full normalisation of relations between Belgrade and Pristina and allow Kosovo finally to become a member of the United Nations." |
But before the idea has even been fully articulated, it is already taking flak. | But before the idea has even been fully articulated, it is already taking flak. |
The Western Balkans went through a convulsion of border changes in the 1990s. | The Western Balkans went through a convulsion of border changes in the 1990s. |
More than 100,000 people died and millions were displaced in ethnically driven conflicts. | More than 100,000 people died and millions were displaced in ethnically driven conflicts. |
A recipe for conflict? | A recipe for conflict? |
Paddy Ashdown oversaw the aftermath in Bosnia, as the international High Representative. He has co-authored an appeal to the European Union's foreign policy chief, Federica Mogherini, to stamp out any talk of a territory swap. | Paddy Ashdown oversaw the aftermath in Bosnia, as the international High Representative. He has co-authored an appeal to the European Union's foreign policy chief, Federica Mogherini, to stamp out any talk of a territory swap. |
"Moving borders like this will not solve divisions, it will deepen them," said the letter, warning that nationalist politicians might use a territory swap to agitate for the break-up of Bosnia. | "Moving borders like this will not solve divisions, it will deepen them," said the letter, warning that nationalist politicians might use a territory swap to agitate for the break-up of Bosnia. |
"Sustainable peace can only come when we learn to live in multi-ethnic communities, rather than re-drawing borders to create mono-ethnic ones. [There is] no policy more likely to lead us back to division and conflict in the Balkans than the one which some are apparently now supporting." | "Sustainable peace can only come when we learn to live in multi-ethnic communities, rather than re-drawing borders to create mono-ethnic ones. [There is] no policy more likely to lead us back to division and conflict in the Balkans than the one which some are apparently now supporting." |
More stories from Kosovo and Serbia | More stories from Kosovo and Serbia |
Ms Mogherini has a key role to play. She chairs the normalisation talks in Brussels between Serbia's President Aleksandar Vucic, and his opposite number from Kosovo, Hashim Thaci. | Ms Mogherini has a key role to play. She chairs the normalisation talks in Brussels between Serbia's President Aleksandar Vucic, and his opposite number from Kosovo, Hashim Thaci. |
Without explicitly mentioning a territory swap, she has been urging the two sides to settle their differences. | Without explicitly mentioning a territory swap, she has been urging the two sides to settle their differences. |
"The time has come to put an end to that conflict," she said on Monday. | "The time has come to put an end to that conflict," she said on Monday. |
"I am confident that presidents Vucic and Thaci will manage to achieve a binding legal agreement for the normalisation of relations and this agreement will comply with international law and it will help for the stability of the entire region." | "I am confident that presidents Vucic and Thaci will manage to achieve a binding legal agreement for the normalisation of relations and this agreement will comply with international law and it will help for the stability of the entire region." |
Brussels 'the key' for Kosovo and Serbia | Brussels 'the key' for Kosovo and Serbia |
Ms Mogherini's predecessor, Cathy Ashton, initiated the normalisation talks. She told the BBC that both presidents were "trying to get to a conclusion" but that international approval would be the key to any deal. | Ms Mogherini's predecessor, Cathy Ashton, initiated the normalisation talks. She told the BBC that both presidents were "trying to get to a conclusion" but that international approval would be the key to any deal. |
"The key to the solution will be how Brussels responds. They will look to Berlin and talk to Paris and others. In the end, it's about EU membership for both." | "The key to the solution will be how Brussels responds. They will look to Berlin and talk to Paris and others. In the end, it's about EU membership for both." |
Germany has been vocal in its opposition to border changes, but it is short of backup from other EU member states, with the UK otherwise engaged. | Germany has been vocal in its opposition to border changes, but it is short of backup from other EU member states, with the UK otherwise engaged. |
Small wonder that the EU commissioner for enlargement, Johannes Hahn, has been talking about a "historic moment" for Serbia and Kosovo. | Small wonder that the EU commissioner for enlargement, Johannes Hahn, has been talking about a "historic moment" for Serbia and Kosovo. |
Local concerns are another matter. Nationalists in both Serbia and Kosovo will be reluctant to make a deal that gives the other side succour. | Local concerns are another matter. Nationalists in both Serbia and Kosovo will be reluctant to make a deal that gives the other side succour. |
The former Kosovo Liberation Army commander and current prime minister, Ramush Haradinaj, has been vehemently opposed, saying that changing borders would lead to war. | The former Kosovo Liberation Army commander and current prime minister, Ramush Haradinaj, has been vehemently opposed, saying that changing borders would lead to war. |
Meanwhile ethnic Serbs living south of the Ibar are worried they will be abandoned if the north reverts to Serbia. | Meanwhile ethnic Serbs living south of the Ibar are worried they will be abandoned if the north reverts to Serbia. |
A European diplomat told the BBC that the territory swap was "serious from the Serb side" but that a lack of unity in Pristina could be a problem. | A European diplomat told the BBC that the territory swap was "serious from the Serb side" but that a lack of unity in Pristina could be a problem. |
"Thaci has gone solo on this so far - he hasn't been making the arguments to get people on board. It could be a compelling proposition, but he needs to sell it." | "Thaci has gone solo on this so far - he hasn't been making the arguments to get people on board. It could be a compelling proposition, but he needs to sell it." |
The United States has indicated that it would not stand in the way of any bilateral deal. The stance of Serbia's ally, Russia, is harder to gauge; President Vladimir Putin is due to visit Belgrade next month. | The United States has indicated that it would not stand in the way of any bilateral deal. The stance of Serbia's ally, Russia, is harder to gauge; President Vladimir Putin is due to visit Belgrade next month. |
Why now? | Why now? |
There are significant prizes on offer for both sides, if they can agree a deal. | There are significant prizes on offer for both sides, if they can agree a deal. |
Kosovo may finally be recognised by the 80-odd countries which have refused to acknowledge its legitimacy. | Kosovo may finally be recognised by the 80-odd countries which have refused to acknowledge its legitimacy. |
And Serbia would fulfil a key condition for its membership of the EU. | And Serbia would fulfil a key condition for its membership of the EU. |
With Macedonia and Greece settling their long-standing dispute, there is fresh momentum to solve another Balkan conundrum. | With Macedonia and Greece settling their long-standing dispute, there is fresh momentum to solve another Balkan conundrum. |
For Kosovo and Serbia, the door is open. | For Kosovo and Serbia, the door is open. |
Correction 20 September 2018: An earlier version of the map wrongly depicted the Medvedja area of Serbia and has been amended. |
Previous version
1
Next version