This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/sep/26/no-deal-brexit-will-be-catastrophic-say-british-farmers-national-farmers-union-eu
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| No-deal Brexit 'would stop British farming exports for six months' | No-deal Brexit 'would stop British farming exports for six months' |
| (4 months later) | |
| The National Farmers Union has warned of “catastrophic” consequences for the industry if there is no Brexit deal, after being warned by the EU that the UK faces a six-month wait to be certified as an approved third-country supplier. | The National Farmers Union has warned of “catastrophic” consequences for the industry if there is no Brexit deal, after being warned by the EU that the UK faces a six-month wait to be certified as an approved third-country supplier. |
| This would be a major setback to the food and drink sector, where exports to the EU are worth £13.2bn a year. | This would be a major setback to the food and drink sector, where exports to the EU are worth £13.2bn a year. |
| The NFU says it has been told informally that although Britain is in complete regulatory alignment with the EU, if there is no deal, the same health checks countries such as China and the US undergo will apply to UK suppliers. | The NFU says it has been told informally that although Britain is in complete regulatory alignment with the EU, if there is no deal, the same health checks countries such as China and the US undergo will apply to UK suppliers. |
| “What we are talking about in effect is a six-month trade embargo until such time we can get the product in, from that point we will face the European’s external tariff wall meaning we will be priced out of the market,” said the NFU’s director general, Terry Jones. | “What we are talking about in effect is a six-month trade embargo until such time we can get the product in, from that point we will face the European’s external tariff wall meaning we will be priced out of the market,” said the NFU’s director general, Terry Jones. |
| It has been told that 6,000 meat processing plants that export to the EU will have to undergo individual audits by British authorities. | It has been told that 6,000 meat processing plants that export to the EU will have to undergo individual audits by British authorities. |
| These will then be checked by EU officials and then put to a standing veterinary committee for approval, a process that the NFU has calculated will take six months “at a conservative reading”. | These will then be checked by EU officials and then put to a standing veterinary committee for approval, a process that the NFU has calculated will take six months “at a conservative reading”. |
| These checks will also be conducted on any other companies supplying food and drink to the EU, including those exporting bottled water, honey, jam, dairy and other fresh foods. | These checks will also be conducted on any other companies supplying food and drink to the EU, including those exporting bottled water, honey, jam, dairy and other fresh foods. |
| “‘No deal is unpalatable and catastrophic for the industry and the more we hear, the more certain we are that our lines all along are right,” said NFU president, Minette Batters. | “‘No deal is unpalatable and catastrophic for the industry and the more we hear, the more certain we are that our lines all along are right,” said NFU president, Minette Batters. |
| The NFU has been in lengthy discussions with both the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) and DG Sante, the EU’s directorate-general for health and food safety, to help prepare for no deal. | The NFU has been in lengthy discussions with both the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) and DG Sante, the EU’s directorate-general for health and food safety, to help prepare for no deal. |
| Jones says the UK government has plans in place to keep imports up by allowing goods to enter without checks to Britain and with tariffs reduced to keep food inflation below 5%. | Jones says the UK government has plans in place to keep imports up by allowing goods to enter without checks to Britain and with tariffs reduced to keep food inflation below 5%. |
| “So to keep the shelves full and keep the food inflation down, we’re going to adopt one stance, but it’s very clear from the discussions the government is having with the EU that on 30 March, the clock starts around us being approved as a third-country supplier. They cannot start these checks before,” he said. | “So to keep the shelves full and keep the food inflation down, we’re going to adopt one stance, but it’s very clear from the discussions the government is having with the EU that on 30 March, the clock starts around us being approved as a third-country supplier. They cannot start these checks before,” he said. |
| Theresa May will not be able to do anything to keep exports up in a no-deal scenario, until after the UK officially quits the bloc. The EU could introduce emergency legislation to keep food from Britain flowing, but “that is their call, not our call” said Batters. | Theresa May will not be able to do anything to keep exports up in a no-deal scenario, until after the UK officially quits the bloc. The EU could introduce emergency legislation to keep food from Britain flowing, but “that is their call, not our call” said Batters. |
| While the NFU and others have been sounding the alarm for months that Britain would face food shortages in the event of no deal and subsequent delays in Calais and Dover, it is concerned that not enough attention has been paid to the livelihoods of farmers, particular those who rear animals. | While the NFU and others have been sounding the alarm for months that Britain would face food shortages in the event of no deal and subsequent delays in Calais and Dover, it is concerned that not enough attention has been paid to the livelihoods of farmers, particular those who rear animals. |
| It points out that British diners are so fussy about their meat that it is difficult to sell cheaper cuts, such as the brown meat in chicken thighs or what is known as the “fifth quarter” in cattle and sheep, including tripe, tongue, heart and kidney. | It points out that British diners are so fussy about their meat that it is difficult to sell cheaper cuts, such as the brown meat in chicken thighs or what is known as the “fifth quarter” in cattle and sheep, including tripe, tongue, heart and kidney. |
| Sheep farmers are heavily reliant on exports – while British demand for lamb peaks at Easter, the French enjoy it all year round. | Sheep farmers are heavily reliant on exports – while British demand for lamb peaks at Easter, the French enjoy it all year round. |
| Similarly southern Europeans are happy to eat the internal part of animals or brown chicken meat, using tripe in stews or sweetbreads as delicacies in upmarket restaurants. | Similarly southern Europeans are happy to eat the internal part of animals or brown chicken meat, using tripe in stews or sweetbreads as delicacies in upmarket restaurants. |
| “We love white meat here and southern Europeans love grey and brown meat and farming relies on what is known as carcass balance, selling the entire animal,” says Jones. | “We love white meat here and southern Europeans love grey and brown meat and farming relies on what is known as carcass balance, selling the entire animal,” says Jones. |
| The NFU says it has established through its conversations that Defra already has huge teams working on a plan of action to audit farms and processing plants. However, legally they cannot submit that plan until 30 March 2019, when the UK has left the EU. | The NFU says it has established through its conversations that Defra already has huge teams working on a plan of action to audit farms and processing plants. However, legally they cannot submit that plan until 30 March 2019, when the UK has left the EU. |
| The EU has indicated that it would take three months at least to go through the Defra plan for certification and the plan must then be submitted to the “relevant veterinary standing committee” for approval. | The EU has indicated that it would take three months at least to go through the Defra plan for certification and the plan must then be submitted to the “relevant veterinary standing committee” for approval. |
| “It first requires Defra to audit each one [supplier] to certify that it is happy that each one complies with EU law, but then the commission must audit that work, that depends on EC resource available at the commission and the timing of the vote in the standing committee,” said Jones. | “It first requires Defra to audit each one [supplier] to certify that it is happy that each one complies with EU law, but then the commission must audit that work, that depends on EC resource available at the commission and the timing of the vote in the standing committee,” said Jones. |
| “In theory the UK already has a plan as it meets all the regulations now, but from a legal point of view and based on the broader conversation with DG Sante this makes six months a conservative estimate,” he said. | “In theory the UK already has a plan as it meets all the regulations now, but from a legal point of view and based on the broader conversation with DG Sante this makes six months a conservative estimate,” he said. |
| The catastrophic downsides do not end there. Even if there is a deal, the UK loses the chance of exporting meat through the Dover-Calais route. Under EU law all animal and agrifood including animal feed and plant produce has to go through health checks and the necessary border inspection posts do not exist at Calais. | The catastrophic downsides do not end there. Even if there is a deal, the UK loses the chance of exporting meat through the Dover-Calais route. Under EU law all animal and agrifood including animal feed and plant produce has to go through health checks and the necessary border inspection posts do not exist at Calais. |
| This is because checks have not been needed for anyone trading within the single market. | This is because checks have not been needed for anyone trading within the single market. |
| The nearest border inspection posts are Zeebrugge and Rotterdam which have historically acted as the gateway for non-EU traffic, or Liverpool on the route to Ireland. | The nearest border inspection posts are Zeebrugge and Rotterdam which have historically acted as the gateway for non-EU traffic, or Liverpool on the route to Ireland. |
| Defra said it was “taking steps to minimise disruption in the event of no deal”. | Defra said it was “taking steps to minimise disruption in the event of no deal”. |
| Its no-deal technical notice confirmed that “the EU would require the UK to be a listed third country” and it could not “be certain of the EU response or timing” for an application. Without this “no deal could take place”. | Its no-deal technical notice confirmed that “the EU would require the UK to be a listed third country” and it could not “be certain of the EU response or timing” for an application. Without this “no deal could take place”. |
| Brexit | Brexit |
| European Union | European Union |
| Europe | Europe |
| Farming | Farming |
| Food & drink industry | Food & drink industry |
| The meat industry | The meat industry |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |