This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/sep/27/theresa-may-un-iran-brexit-analysis
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Thanks to Brexit, the British voice counts for less at the UN | Thanks to Brexit, the British voice counts for less at the UN |
| (4 days later) | |
| A mixture of personal praise of Donald Trump, sympathy for the UK after the chemical attack in Salisbury and safety in sheer numbers protected Theresa May from being on the front rank of international leaders who lined up at the UN general assembly to criticize Donald Trump’s Iran policy. | A mixture of personal praise of Donald Trump, sympathy for the UK after the chemical attack in Salisbury and safety in sheer numbers protected Theresa May from being on the front rank of international leaders who lined up at the UN general assembly to criticize Donald Trump’s Iran policy. |
| Other European leaders – including Margot Wallstrom the Swedish foreign minister and Emmanuel Macron, the global torch bearer of multilateralism – openly rebuked Trump at the Security Council meeting on Wednesday. | Other European leaders – including Margot Wallstrom the Swedish foreign minister and Emmanuel Macron, the global torch bearer of multilateralism – openly rebuked Trump at the Security Council meeting on Wednesday. |
| “We have tried sanctions over the years. We tried isolation, and it only gave the most conservative forces in Iran more power,” said Wallstrom. Macron suggested that Trump had no long-term strategy. | “We have tried sanctions over the years. We tried isolation, and it only gave the most conservative forces in Iran more power,” said Wallstrom. Macron suggested that Trump had no long-term strategy. |
| Off stage, the Austrian President Alexander Van der Bellen was even more direct, saying that “a war with Iran will sooner or later be envisaged.” | Off stage, the Austrian President Alexander Van der Bellen was even more direct, saying that “a war with Iran will sooner or later be envisaged.” |
| May, by contrast, was matter-of-fact in her disagreement with the US, preferring to focus her fire on Russia for its “desperate fabrications” over Salisbury – remarks that provoked a stinging rebuke from the somewhat cornered Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrov. | May, by contrast, was matter-of-fact in her disagreement with the US, preferring to focus her fire on Russia for its “desperate fabrications” over Salisbury – remarks that provoked a stinging rebuke from the somewhat cornered Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrov. |
| The prime minister tried to minimise her differences with Trump by praising him personally for his leadership role in seeking to reach an agreement with North Korea, which she described as the world’s most potent nuclear threat. She made no comment on the wider damage caused by Trump’s decision to tear up the nuclear deal with Iran. | The prime minister tried to minimise her differences with Trump by praising him personally for his leadership role in seeking to reach an agreement with North Korea, which she described as the world’s most potent nuclear threat. She made no comment on the wider damage caused by Trump’s decision to tear up the nuclear deal with Iran. |
| But there was no disguising the fact that the UK finds itself in the awkward position of being at odds with Trump over a central issue of his administration: how to make Iran change course. | But there was no disguising the fact that the UK finds itself in the awkward position of being at odds with Trump over a central issue of his administration: how to make Iran change course. |
| May and her new foreign secretary Jeremy Hunt, have joined with France, Germany, Russia and China in concluding that Iran is complying with the nuclear deal, and – whatever its malign behaviour elsewhere there is no evidence that a sanctions squeeze will produce a more flexible mindset in Tehran – let alone regime change. | May and her new foreign secretary Jeremy Hunt, have joined with France, Germany, Russia and China in concluding that Iran is complying with the nuclear deal, and – whatever its malign behaviour elsewhere there is no evidence that a sanctions squeeze will produce a more flexible mindset in Tehran – let alone regime change. |
| That view is held strongly throughout the foreign office, and national security network, despite the frustration of some of the UK’s closest allies in the Gulf such as the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia. | That view is held strongly throughout the foreign office, and national security network, despite the frustration of some of the UK’s closest allies in the Gulf such as the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia. |
| The UAE – ferocious networkers in British government circles – have for more than a year tried to persuade the UK to confront Iran over its behaviour in Iraq, Yemen and Syria. | The UAE – ferocious networkers in British government circles – have for more than a year tried to persuade the UK to confront Iran over its behaviour in Iraq, Yemen and Syria. |
| The language between the US and the EU over sanctions is also becoming fruity. | The language between the US and the EU over sanctions is also becoming fruity. |
| Earlier this week, Mike Pompeo, the US secretary of state, described EU efforts to shield European firms trading with Iran as “one of the most counterproductive measures imaginable for regional global peace and security. By sustaining revenues to the regime you are solidifying Iran’s ranking as [the] No. 1 state sponsor of terror.” | Earlier this week, Mike Pompeo, the US secretary of state, described EU efforts to shield European firms trading with Iran as “one of the most counterproductive measures imaginable for regional global peace and security. By sustaining revenues to the regime you are solidifying Iran’s ranking as [the] No. 1 state sponsor of terror.” |
| It is not a conversation that UK officials enjoy, as they seek to show Britain can have leverage over Iran. | It is not a conversation that UK officials enjoy, as they seek to show Britain can have leverage over Iran. |
| But in truth, the British voice on everything else at the UN counts for less than it did under Tony Blair, Gordon Brown – or even David Cameron. | But in truth, the British voice on everything else at the UN counts for less than it did under Tony Blair, Gordon Brown – or even David Cameron. |
| May’s forays onto the international stage have been perfunctory; by contrast Brown was at the UN on Monday drawing the crowds as he banged the drum to find ways to raise extra cash for education in Africa. | May’s forays onto the international stage have been perfunctory; by contrast Brown was at the UN on Monday drawing the crowds as he banged the drum to find ways to raise extra cash for education in Africa. |
| But if May has any foreign policy theme, it is submerged by Brexit. | But if May has any foreign policy theme, it is submerged by Brexit. |
| Broadcasters accompanying her to New York were each allocated four questions – and each confined themselves to Brexit – as if Iran, the UK’s aid budget, Myanmar, Yemen or even the UK military bombing of Syria were non-issues. | Broadcasters accompanying her to New York were each allocated four questions – and each confined themselves to Brexit – as if Iran, the UK’s aid budget, Myanmar, Yemen or even the UK military bombing of Syria were non-issues. |
| Such monomania leaves the impression that the UK is a country apart, involved in its own conversation, and checked out from the world debates. | Such monomania leaves the impression that the UK is a country apart, involved in its own conversation, and checked out from the world debates. |
| That is not a true picture of British diplomatic effectiveness at the UN – but sometimes impressions become the reality. | That is not a true picture of British diplomatic effectiveness at the UN – but sometimes impressions become the reality. |
| Even if all goes to plan with Brexit, next year’s general assembly will be just as hard. | Even if all goes to plan with Brexit, next year’s general assembly will be just as hard. |
| For the first time in decades, Britain will find itself as a non European Union member, forced to justify its claim to be one of the five permanent members of the UN security council – and British leaders (whoever they may be) will have to work even harder just to be heard. | For the first time in decades, Britain will find itself as a non European Union member, forced to justify its claim to be one of the five permanent members of the UN security council – and British leaders (whoever they may be) will have to work even harder just to be heard. |
| Theresa May | Theresa May |
| Donald Trump | Donald Trump |
| United Nations | United Nations |
| Iran | Iran |
| Middle East and North Africa | Middle East and North Africa |
| analysis | analysis |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |