This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-45693211
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 5 | Version 6 |
---|---|
What will the FBI investigation into Kavanaugh actually do? | What will the FBI investigation into Kavanaugh actually do? |
(1 day later) | |
Now that President Donald Trump has ordered an FBI investigation into sexual misconduct allegations against Brett Kavanaugh - his nominee for the Supreme Court - many are wondering about the work being conducted by investigators and what they are likely to ultimately conclude. | Now that President Donald Trump has ordered an FBI investigation into sexual misconduct allegations against Brett Kavanaugh - his nominee for the Supreme Court - many are wondering about the work being conducted by investigators and what they are likely to ultimately conclude. |
A full Senate vote on whether Mr Kavanaugh gets a seat on America's top court has been delayed for a week, while the FBI works. | A full Senate vote on whether Mr Kavanaugh gets a seat on America's top court has been delayed for a week, while the FBI works. |
Investigators, the committee said, are "limited to current credible allegations" and must complete their assignment "no later than one week from today" [Friday 28 September]. | Investigators, the committee said, are "limited to current credible allegations" and must complete their assignment "no later than one week from today" [Friday 28 September]. |
So what exactly is the FBI doing? | So what exactly is the FBI doing? |
Hasn't the FBI checked out Kavanaugh already? | Hasn't the FBI checked out Kavanaugh already? |
Yes. The FBI has completed a traditional background check - provided to any federal appointee - on Judge Kavanaugh, who is currently an appeal court judge. | Yes. The FBI has completed a traditional background check - provided to any federal appointee - on Judge Kavanaugh, who is currently an appeal court judge. |
In his confirmation hearing, the judge himself said he had been through "six separate FBI background investigations over 26 years". | In his confirmation hearing, the judge himself said he had been through "six separate FBI background investigations over 26 years". |
This new investigation will focus on the recent allegations of what agents call "derogatory information". | This new investigation will focus on the recent allegations of what agents call "derogatory information". |
Agents may review documents, speak to new witnesses, or revisit previous ones - including the judge and his main accuser, Prof Christine Blasey Ford, whom he denies sexually assaulting as a teenager in the 1980s. | Agents may review documents, speak to new witnesses, or revisit previous ones - including the judge and his main accuser, Prof Christine Blasey Ford, whom he denies sexually assaulting as a teenager in the 1980s. |
But, they typically never look back as far as 36 years ago, when Prof Ford says the assault took place. | |
Lawyer Greg Rinckey told the Associated Press news agency that agents were normally looking for a "current problem", meaning any issue that has arisen in the past seven to 10 years. | Lawyer Greg Rinckey told the Associated Press news agency that agents were normally looking for a "current problem", meaning any issue that has arisen in the past seven to 10 years. |
Former FBI Assistant Director Chris Swecker told Fox News that, according to FBI guidelines, investigators typically look back no further than 18 years. | Former FBI Assistant Director Chris Swecker told Fox News that, according to FBI guidelines, investigators typically look back no further than 18 years. |
Who is being be interviewed? | |
Democrats have been keen to hear more from Mark Judge, a boyhood friend of Judge Kavanaugh's, who Prof Ford said was in the room when she was assaulted. | Democrats have been keen to hear more from Mark Judge, a boyhood friend of Judge Kavanaugh's, who Prof Ford said was in the room when she was assaulted. |
Mr Judge told the Senate Judiciary Committee in a written statement that he did not recall any such incident - but he was not asked to testify in person. | Mr Judge told the Senate Judiciary Committee in a written statement that he did not recall any such incident - but he was not asked to testify in person. |
As of Wednesday, they had interviewed five people including Mr Judge, according to US media. | |
Neither Mr Kavanaugh nor Prof Ford have been interviewed by the FBI. | |
Four of those interviewed attended a 1 July 1982 event which was listed on a calendar that Mr Kavanaugh has produced to serve as his alibi. | |
Democrats also want agents to investigate allegations made by women other than Prof Ford, which are also denied by the judge. | Democrats also want agents to investigate allegations made by women other than Prof Ford, which are also denied by the judge. |
They include a claim from his Yale classmate Deborah Ramirez, who alleges that he exposed his genitals in her face during a drinking game at a college party. | They include a claim from his Yale classmate Deborah Ramirez, who alleges that he exposed his genitals in her face during a drinking game at a college party. |
Ms Ramirez's lawyer confirmed she had a two hour interview with the FBI on Sunday, but later complained that agents had not bothered to contact 20 people who Ms Ramirez said were in the room when the alleged abuse occurred. | |
Another set of claims have been made by Julie Swetnick - a US government employee - alleging that Judge Kavanaugh was involved in the drugging and sexual assault of girls at house parties in the 1980s. | Another set of claims have been made by Julie Swetnick - a US government employee - alleging that Judge Kavanaugh was involved in the drugging and sexual assault of girls at house parties in the 1980s. |
In an interview with NBC on Monday, Ms Swetnick said she remembered Judge Kavanaugh as a "very sloppy drunk, very mean drunk," who she saw often groping girls. | In an interview with NBC on Monday, Ms Swetnick said she remembered Judge Kavanaugh as a "very sloppy drunk, very mean drunk," who she saw often groping girls. |
Will the FBI reach a definitive conclusion? | Will the FBI reach a definitive conclusion? |
Not exactly. When the timeframe is up, the FBI will pass its findings to the White House - which will give them to the Senate. The contents are not expected to be made public. | Not exactly. When the timeframe is up, the FBI will pass its findings to the White House - which will give them to the Senate. The contents are not expected to be made public. |
As many senators and conservative commentators have pointed out, the FBI files a report but does not reach any conclusion regarding the credibility or significance of allegations. | As many senators and conservative commentators have pointed out, the FBI files a report but does not reach any conclusion regarding the credibility or significance of allegations. |
"They could interview someone who says I saw Judge Kavanaugh get beamed down from a UFO - he's an alien," Mr Swecker told CNN. | "They could interview someone who says I saw Judge Kavanaugh get beamed down from a UFO - he's an alien," Mr Swecker told CNN. |
"They wouldn't say 'we disproved this, [or] they didn't disprove this.' | "They wouldn't say 'we disproved this, [or] they didn't disprove this.' |
"They report any corroborating information that they obtain, or any contradicting information," he said, but added that "they do not make conclusions" in their interview reports, which are known as 302 forms. | "They report any corroborating information that they obtain, or any contradicting information," he said, but added that "they do not make conclusions" in their interview reports, which are known as 302 forms. |
Former FBI Assistant Director Steve Pomerantz told Fox News: "Hopefully they provide enough information within their reports that allow a reasonable person to reach a conclusion based on the work that they've done. | Former FBI Assistant Director Steve Pomerantz told Fox News: "Hopefully they provide enough information within their reports that allow a reasonable person to reach a conclusion based on the work that they've done. |
"So it's simplistic to say they don't reach a conclusion." | "So it's simplistic to say they don't reach a conclusion." |
Because it is not a criminal inquiry, witnesses are not compelled to co-operate with the investigation. | Because it is not a criminal inquiry, witnesses are not compelled to co-operate with the investigation. |
However, lying to an FBI agent does carry the threat of federal charges, as former Trump officials Paul Manafort or Michael Cohen could tell you. | However, lying to an FBI agent does carry the threat of federal charges, as former Trump officials Paul Manafort or Michael Cohen could tell you. |
Why did Trump order another investigation? | Why did Trump order another investigation? |
Mr Trump gave the order at the request of the Senate Judiciary Committee, after Arizona Republican Jeff Flake sensationally changed his mind about backing the judge. | Mr Trump gave the order at the request of the Senate Judiciary Committee, after Arizona Republican Jeff Flake sensationally changed his mind about backing the judge. |
His party has only a 51-49 Senate majority. That means that if all Democrats vote against confirming Kavanaugh, he can only afford for one Republican to join them - since in a tie, Vice-President Mike Pence would get the casting vote. | His party has only a 51-49 Senate majority. That means that if all Democrats vote against confirming Kavanaugh, he can only afford for one Republican to join them - since in a tie, Vice-President Mike Pence would get the casting vote. |
The Republican side can't afford to lose Senator Flake's vote - and a week-long FBI investigation clearly looked like a price worth paying. | The Republican side can't afford to lose Senator Flake's vote - and a week-long FBI investigation clearly looked like a price worth paying. |
Some observers believe the FBI inquiry will strengthen the resolve of uncertain Republican senators - because unless something dramatic is unearthed, they will feel more confident in rejecting Prof Ford's claims. | Some observers believe the FBI inquiry will strengthen the resolve of uncertain Republican senators - because unless something dramatic is unearthed, they will feel more confident in rejecting Prof Ford's claims. |
One last thing... Why only a week? | One last thing... Why only a week? |
Prof Ford's lawyer, Debra Katz, said her client welcomed the FBI's involvement, but questioned the week-long time limit. | Prof Ford's lawyer, Debra Katz, said her client welcomed the FBI's involvement, but questioned the week-long time limit. |
"A thorough FBI investigation is critical to developing all the relevant facts... No artificial limits as to time or scope should be imposed on this investigation," she said. | "A thorough FBI investigation is critical to developing all the relevant facts... No artificial limits as to time or scope should be imposed on this investigation," she said. |
The timing matters because Republicans are keen to get their Supreme Court nominee confirmed before the US mid-term elections on 6 November. And Democrats would profit from seeing that process delayed - or blocked altogether. | The timing matters because Republicans are keen to get their Supreme Court nominee confirmed before the US mid-term elections on 6 November. And Democrats would profit from seeing that process delayed - or blocked altogether. |
As a conservative, it is believed Mr Kavanaugh would swing America's top court to the right for years to come - which could have deep repercussions for social issues like abortion rights, and challenges to government policy. | As a conservative, it is believed Mr Kavanaugh would swing America's top court to the right for years to come - which could have deep repercussions for social issues like abortion rights, and challenges to government policy. |
That's especially the case as the nine Supreme Court judges are appointed for life. | That's especially the case as the nine Supreme Court judges are appointed for life. |
So overall, there's a lot riding on the FBI over the few remaining days. | So overall, there's a lot riding on the FBI over the few remaining days. |