This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/oct/02/hinkley-point-c-nuclear-mud-case-dropped-after-debate-secured

The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 1 Version 2
Hinkley Point C 'nuclear mud' case dropped after debate secured Welsh leaders urged to halt 'nuclear mud' dumping off Cardiff
(about 1 hour later)
The Welsh assembly is to debate the dumping of “nuclear mud” in the sea close to Cardiff after an eclectic group of scientists, surfers and a pop star threatened legal action over the practice. Pressure is increasing on the Labour-led Welsh government to halt the dumping of “nuclear mud” in the sea close to Cardiff after a campaign by an eclectic group of scientists, surfers and a pop star.
Cian Ciarán, the keyboard player from Super Furry Animals, had been due in court on Tuesday to argue in favour of an injunction to halt the disposal of mud excavated from the construction site of the Hinkley Point C nuclear power station in Somerset. A motion calling on the government to suspend the licence allowing mud excavated from the construction site of the Hinkley Point C nuclear power station in Somerset to be disposed of just off the Welsh capital is to be debated next week in the national assembly for Wales.
But the legal action was discontinued and a planned protest outside the court was called off at the last minute when a full debate on the issue was secured. The development prompted Cian Ciarán, the keyboard player from Super Furry Animals, to discontinue an attempt on Tuesday to obtain a court injunction to stop the dumping.
There is growing concern and anger that 300,000 tonnes of sediment from the Hinkley Point C site is being disposed of at Cardiff Grounds, a sandbank a mile and half from the Welsh capital. There is growing concern and anger that 300,000 tonnes of sediment from the Hinkley Point C site is being disposed of at the Cardiff Grounds sandbank.
Campaigners claim the mud has not been tested properly and could contain particles that may pose a health risk. They have described the sediment as “nuclear mud” and nicknamed the sea off Cardiff “Geiger Bay”, a play on Tiger Bay, the old slang name for the city’s docklands. One of their main concerns is that the sediment could be washed ashore in a storm.Campaigners claim the mud has not been tested properly and could contain particles that may pose a health risk. They have described the sediment as “nuclear mud” and nicknamed the sea off Cardiff “Geiger Bay”, a play on Tiger Bay, the old slang name for the city’s docklands. One of their main concerns is that the sediment could be washed ashore in a storm.
Shortly before the case at Cardiff civil and family justice centre was due to begin, it emerged that the legal action had been discontinued after a debate at the assembly next week was secured. It is understood that a joint motion has been put forward by Plaid Cymru and the Conservatives. Welcoming the assembly debate, Ciarán said: “This Labour government has taken the Welsh people for granted and has risked the health of the nation. For me the core message of the campaign remains unchanged: the absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence and therefore the precautionary principle should dictate a rethink. We will continue to seek the answers the Welsh public deserve.”
Neil McEvoy, an independent assembly member, tweeted: “Friends, please note that there will be no protest at court today. We have discontinued the legal challenge after gaining an assembly debate on 10 October that could stop the #GeigerBay dump, through a @Plaid_Cymru & Conservatives joint motion.” He called for the Welsh government’s patrol vessel, FPV Rhodri Morgan, to monitor the dumping that is taking place. “It is a duty for every Welsh assembly member to do right by its people and hold to account the government that granted the licence,” he said.
McEvoy has accused the Labour-led Welsh government of being out of touch on the issue. He has called for boat owners to form a “people’s flotilla” to take direct action and blockade Cardiff Grounds, and he has boarded a barge disposing of the mud to try to block the operation. Neil McEvoy, an independent assembly member, has accused the Welsh government of being out of touch on the issue. If the dumping does not cease, he wants boat owners to form a “people’s flotilla” to take direct action and blockade Cardiff Grounds.
EDF Energy, which is building Hinkley Point C on the English side of the Bristol Channel, has insisted the mud is safe, as have the Welsh government and Natural Resources Wales (NRW). He said taking on EDF Energy, which is building Hinkley Point C on the English side of the Bristol Channel, had been a huge risk.
EDF said the mud was tested by the Centre for Environment, Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (Cefas), an executive agency of the UK government, in 2009, 2013 and 2017 and the levels of radioactivity were found to be so low that they could be classed as “not radioactive” under British law. “This was always a David v Goliath case,” McEvoy said. “Cian took the brave decision to put his name to a legal challenge against a massive, billion-pound energy giant. He’s risked everything for the safety of Wales. Labour need to know that Wales is not a dumping ground for other people’s waste.”
A spokesman said the decision to drop the case was “good news for a project that is vital for the UK’s energy future and provides work for 25 Welsh companies and 1,000 Welsh workers”. The campaigners claim no proper environmental impact assessment has been carried out.
He added: “EDF did everything that it was requested to do when it applied for a licence to dredge and deposit mud in the Severn estuary. The mud is no different to mud found anywhere else up and down the coast and it has been thoroughly tested by independent experts who confirmed it poses no threat to human health or the environment.” The motion for debate, put forward jointly by the Tories and Plaid Cymru, calls on the Welsh government to “publish more detailed evidence in response to concerns regarding risks to public health and the environment”, including allowing for further testing, and to “instruct Natural Resources Wales to suspend the marine licence that enables the disposal activity and undertake a wide-ranging programme of engagement and consultation with local communities and stakeholders across south Wales”.
EDF says it is dredging mud and sediment from the seabed ahead of the drilling of six vertical shafts for the cooling water system. It says Cardiff Grounds is the only suitable site large enough to handle the amount of the type of sediment it is dredging. EDF said Ciarán’s decision to drop the legal action was “good news for a project that is vital for the UK’s energy future and provides work for 25 Welsh companies and 1,000 Welsh workers”.
Ciarán told the Guardian at the weekend: “I’m involved as a Welshman and a concerned earthling. I felt compelled to play a part. I felt at a loss over the lack of action by the Welsh Labour government and the apathy of NRW. This is about reasonable people asking reasonable questions.” A spokesperson added: “EDF did everything that it was requested to do when it applied for a licence to dredge and deposit mud in the Severn estuary. The mud is no different to mud found anywhere else up and down the coast and it has been thoroughly tested by independent experts who confirmed it poses no threat to human health or the environment.”
He said he had been out to Cardiff Grounds to view the mud dumping at close hand. “I felt angry, saddened, desperate. Potentially it’s causing irreversible harm,” he said. EDF says it is dredging mud and sediment from the seabed before the drilling of six vertical shafts for the cooling water system. It says Cardiff Grounds is the only suitable site large enough to handle the amount of the type of sediment it is dredging.
A Welsh government spokesman said: “All tests and assessments concluded the material is within safe limits, poses no radiological risk to human health or the environment and is safe and suitable to be disposed of at sea.” The Welsh government has been asked to comment. It has previously insisted the mud is safe.
Hinkley Point CHinkley Point C
Welsh politicsWelsh politics
Cardiff
WalesWales
newsnews
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook
Share on TwitterShare on Twitter
Share via EmailShare via Email
Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn
Share on PinterestShare on Pinterest
Share on Google+Share on Google+
Share on WhatsAppShare on WhatsApp
Share on MessengerShare on Messenger
Reuse this contentReuse this content