This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/oct/11/a-scary-time-for-trumps-boys-it-should-be-as-women-have-nothing-to-lose
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| A 'scary time' for Trump's boys? It should be, as women have nothing to lose | A 'scary time' for Trump's boys? It should be, as women have nothing to lose |
| (about 2 months later) | |
| The brilliant Phil Ochs – Bob Dylan’s rival, the late, tragic Phil Ochs – said of the craft that defined him: “A protest song is a song that’s so specific that you cannot mistake it for bullshit.” | The brilliant Phil Ochs – Bob Dylan’s rival, the late, tragic Phil Ochs – said of the craft that defined him: “A protest song is a song that’s so specific that you cannot mistake it for bullshit.” |
| Authenticity is rare in the era of staged Russian propaganda videos, “influencer marketing” and the kind of American president who makes 4,229 false or misleading claims in 558 days. | Authenticity is rare in the era of staged Russian propaganda videos, “influencer marketing” and the kind of American president who makes 4,229 false or misleading claims in 558 days. |
| ‘Vile hatred, hero worship': Christine Blasey Ford faces an unsettling future | |
| So the nature of humanity to cherish scarcities perhaps then explains the immediate worldwide popularity of “A Scary Time”. Composed and sung on the ukulele by a young Texan woman, Lynzy Lab Stewart, it satisfies that definition of a protest song with some precision. It was uploaded on 8 October. As I write this, the song’s already clocked 25 million views and has become a media story worldwide. | So the nature of humanity to cherish scarcities perhaps then explains the immediate worldwide popularity of “A Scary Time”. Composed and sung on the ukulele by a young Texan woman, Lynzy Lab Stewart, it satisfies that definition of a protest song with some precision. It was uploaded on 8 October. As I write this, the song’s already clocked 25 million views and has become a media story worldwide. |
| It's a really scary time for dudes right now. So I wrote a song about it. Go #vote friends! #TheResistance #1Thing @ACLU @WC4SJ #letsmakesomenoise pic.twitter.com/hz7E3xMRqR | It's a really scary time for dudes right now. So I wrote a song about it. Go #vote friends! #TheResistance #1Thing @ACLU @WC4SJ #letsmakesomenoise pic.twitter.com/hz7E3xMRqR |
| It’s a riff on Donald Trump’s recent quote regarding Brett Kavanaugh, the partisan Republican judge and then nominee for America’s highest court, credibly accused by three separate women of sexual misconduct or assault. “It’s a very scary time for young men in America when you can be guilty of something that you may not be guilty of,” Trump proclaimed. | It’s a riff on Donald Trump’s recent quote regarding Brett Kavanaugh, the partisan Republican judge and then nominee for America’s highest court, credibly accused by three separate women of sexual misconduct or assault. “It’s a very scary time for young men in America when you can be guilty of something that you may not be guilty of,” Trump proclaimed. |
| Since that time, an FBI investigation exonerated Kavanaugh of Dr Christine Blasey Ford’s sexual assault – somehow, without interviewing either of them. | Since that time, an FBI investigation exonerated Kavanaugh of Dr Christine Blasey Ford’s sexual assault – somehow, without interviewing either of them. |
| Then, the president mocked and belittled Ford by publicly lying about her testimony. | Then, the president mocked and belittled Ford by publicly lying about her testimony. |
| Boys were shown just how precisely scary rape allegations can be when Kavanaugh was then, um, rewarded with appointment to the supreme court of the United States. | Boys were shown just how precisely scary rape allegations can be when Kavanaugh was then, um, rewarded with appointment to the supreme court of the United States. |
| And, at his confirmation ceremony, Kavanaugh demonstrated the sincere level of his respect for women – by shoving his wife. | And, at his confirmation ceremony, Kavanaugh demonstrated the sincere level of his respect for women – by shoving his wife. |
| Yes – there’s rather a lot of bullshit around. And, in song, Lab Stewart skewers it all. | Yes – there’s rather a lot of bullshit around. And, in song, Lab Stewart skewers it all. |
| If a critical mass of women cease to believe that justice serves them, they will apply justice of their own | If a critical mass of women cease to believe that justice serves them, they will apply justice of their own |
| To pop’s familiar 4/4 time, her vocals are as light as a sea breeze while her lyrics catalogue the routines of terrified self-protection into which women who live in the west are inured. | To pop’s familiar 4/4 time, her vocals are as light as a sea breeze while her lyrics catalogue the routines of terrified self-protection into which women who live in the west are inured. |
| It’s a destabilising juxtaposition. “I can’t walk to my car late at night while on the phone,” she sings, “I can’t open up my windows when I’m home alone, I can’t go to a bar without a chaperone and I can’t wear a miniskirt if it’s the only one I own … ” Then comes the chorus, with a punch: “But sure is a scary time for boys!” | It’s a destabilising juxtaposition. “I can’t walk to my car late at night while on the phone,” she sings, “I can’t open up my windows when I’m home alone, I can’t go to a bar without a chaperone and I can’t wear a miniskirt if it’s the only one I own … ” Then comes the chorus, with a punch: “But sure is a scary time for boys!” |
| Trump’s rightwing mythology of confected male victimhood is ruined by the song’s procession of false equivalencies. “It’s really tough when your reputation’s on the line and any woman you’ve assaulted could turn up anytime,” she sings. | Trump’s rightwing mythology of confected male victimhood is ruined by the song’s procession of false equivalencies. “It’s really tough when your reputation’s on the line and any woman you’ve assaulted could turn up anytime,” she sings. |
| Ochs, a lifelong activist, once explained that a single “good song with a message can bring a point more deeply to more people than a thousand rallies”. | Ochs, a lifelong activist, once explained that a single “good song with a message can bring a point more deeply to more people than a thousand rallies”. |
| That’s because protest songs reach into human spaces that not all physical mobilisations can. And they coalesce communities when listeners discover experiences thought to be individual are actually shared. Read the comments from women under posts of the video; you don’t need to live in America to realise the same, specific, fear-based regimentation of female behaviour the song describes exists everywhere. | That’s because protest songs reach into human spaces that not all physical mobilisations can. And they coalesce communities when listeners discover experiences thought to be individual are actually shared. Read the comments from women under posts of the video; you don’t need to live in America to realise the same, specific, fear-based regimentation of female behaviour the song describes exists everywhere. |
| I’m older than Lab Stewart, and Australian – but I don’t go to bars alone, answer the door in silk pyjamas, jog at night with headphones in, as she describes, and for her same reasons: because the threat of sudden male violence is a tangible omnipresence that all women are taught from childhood to fear. | I’m older than Lab Stewart, and Australian – but I don’t go to bars alone, answer the door in silk pyjamas, jog at night with headphones in, as she describes, and for her same reasons: because the threat of sudden male violence is a tangible omnipresence that all women are taught from childhood to fear. |
| When protest songs catch on like this, it’s because they speak to a resistance towards the cultural values that formerly coerced collective behavior unnoticed. They’re both a direct political challenge to a prevailing status quo, and an index of a threat to that status quo that’s growing. | When protest songs catch on like this, it’s because they speak to a resistance towards the cultural values that formerly coerced collective behavior unnoticed. They’re both a direct political challenge to a prevailing status quo, and an index of a threat to that status quo that’s growing. |
| It’s why the repression of protest artists is a characteristic of authoritarian regimes; it was a symbolic affirmation of regained cultural control in the 1970s when Pinochet’s Chilean junta had singer Víctor Jara– Phil Ochs’s friend – arrested, tortured, murdered and mutilated. | It’s why the repression of protest artists is a characteristic of authoritarian regimes; it was a symbolic affirmation of regained cultural control in the 1970s when Pinochet’s Chilean junta had singer Víctor Jara– Phil Ochs’s friend – arrested, tortured, murdered and mutilated. |
| The emergence of a feminist protest song as a viral hit does not exist a universe away from the traditions of confrontation between cultural resisters and the state. Is it hard to believe that the Trumpist mob will weaponise the internet’s infinite avenues of intimidation against the girl with the ukulele? | The emergence of a feminist protest song as a viral hit does not exist a universe away from the traditions of confrontation between cultural resisters and the state. Is it hard to believe that the Trumpist mob will weaponise the internet’s infinite avenues of intimidation against the girl with the ukulele? |
| Christine Blasey Ford spoke but Kavanaugh just gets closer. So what now for women? | Van Badham | |
| Not when the feminist movement is mobilising the most coherent grassroots political opposition to Trump. | Not when the feminist movement is mobilising the most coherent grassroots political opposition to Trump. |
| While most Republicans and their fans were crowing the appointment of Kavanaugh as a victory, only GOP senator Lisa Murkowski – who supported the man but voted against him – seemed to grasp the danger his selection posed to her own side. “I think we’re at a place where we need to begin thinking about the credibility and integrity of our institutions,” she said. “We’re dealing with issues right now that are bigger than the nominee.” | While most Republicans and their fans were crowing the appointment of Kavanaugh as a victory, only GOP senator Lisa Murkowski – who supported the man but voted against him – seemed to grasp the danger his selection posed to her own side. “I think we’re at a place where we need to begin thinking about the credibility and integrity of our institutions,” she said. “We’re dealing with issues right now that are bigger than the nominee.” |
| Those issues are the very legitimacy of governmental and judicial authority in America, and beyond. | Those issues are the very legitimacy of governmental and judicial authority in America, and beyond. |
| The ability to maintain a status quo is weakened when division entrenches. By choosing to provoke rather than neutralise opposition, Trump’s movement has enhanced and empowered it. Their man has been credibly accused of being a liar and credibly accused of sexual assault; promoting Kavanaugh to a placement of judgment over others weakens the authority of that personal judgment but erodes faith, trust and respect in systems of authority itself. | The ability to maintain a status quo is weakened when division entrenches. By choosing to provoke rather than neutralise opposition, Trump’s movement has enhanced and empowered it. Their man has been credibly accused of being a liar and credibly accused of sexual assault; promoting Kavanaugh to a placement of judgment over others weakens the authority of that personal judgment but erodes faith, trust and respect in systems of authority itself. |
| As those whose advantage is dependent on maintaining the status quo, the Trumpists are endangering themselves by encouraging resistance, specifically, to the law. If a critical mass of women cease to believe that justice serves them, they will apply justice of their own. | As those whose advantage is dependent on maintaining the status quo, the Trumpists are endangering themselves by encouraging resistance, specifically, to the law. If a critical mass of women cease to believe that justice serves them, they will apply justice of their own. |
| This is the incendiary authenticity that burns at the core of Lynzy Lab Stewart’s pretty song: women have nothing to lose by fighting the bullshit. It’s a scary time for Trump’s boys, indeed. | This is the incendiary authenticity that burns at the core of Lynzy Lab Stewart’s pretty song: women have nothing to lose by fighting the bullshit. It’s a scary time for Trump’s boys, indeed. |
| Gender | Gender |
| Opinion | Opinion |
| Donald Trump | Donald Trump |
| Brett Kavanaugh | Brett Kavanaugh |
| Crime - Australia | Crime - Australia |
| US supreme court | US supreme court |
| comment | comment |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |