This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/business/nils-pratley-on-finance/2018/oct/24/clean-results-are-a-weak-boast-but-barclays-overhaul-deserves-time-to-work
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Patisserie Valerie is saved but mystery of how it got into sticky mess deepens | Patisserie Valerie is saved but mystery of how it got into sticky mess deepens |
| (8 days later) | |
| Hurrah, Patisserie Valerie is saved for the nation: the winding-up petition against the main trading subsidiary has been dismissed. It was the expected outcome, of course, because the executive chairman, Luke Johnson, had already dug into his back pocket for £20m to lead fundraising to pay the taxman and cover the company’s much larger cash hole. Well played, Johnson, you did the decent thing. | Hurrah, Patisserie Valerie is saved for the nation: the winding-up petition against the main trading subsidiary has been dismissed. It was the expected outcome, of course, because the executive chairman, Luke Johnson, had already dug into his back pocket for £20m to lead fundraising to pay the taxman and cover the company’s much larger cash hole. Well played, Johnson, you did the decent thing. |
| Yet the mystery of how the chain found itself in such a sticky mess deepened with another announcement. It turns out that the parent company’s last annual report was plain wrong when it described how many share options had been granted to the chief executive, Paul May, and the finance director, Chris Marsh. The mistake covered two years of grant – 2015 and 2016. | Yet the mystery of how the chain found itself in such a sticky mess deepened with another announcement. It turns out that the parent company’s last annual report was plain wrong when it described how many share options had been granted to the chief executive, Paul May, and the finance director, Chris Marsh. The mistake covered two years of grant – 2015 and 2016. |
| The misreporting probably has no relevance to the wider investigation into alleged “financial irregularities”. Yet making correct disclosures about options is routine stuff. Public companies do all the time. Patisserie, in its now familiar head-scratching manner, merely says it is “seeking to understand” what happened. | The misreporting probably has no relevance to the wider investigation into alleged “financial irregularities”. Yet making correct disclosures about options is routine stuff. Public companies do all the time. Patisserie, in its now familiar head-scratching manner, merely says it is “seeking to understand” what happened. |
| Investors would like to know, too. Indeed, many would probably be more comfortable if the internal investigation into the financial calamity was led by outsiders, rather than the board. A team from PwC has been hired to assist with gathering facts – but that’s not same as conducting a properly independent inquiry. | Investors would like to know, too. Indeed, many would probably be more comfortable if the internal investigation into the financial calamity was led by outsiders, rather than the board. A team from PwC has been hired to assist with gathering facts – but that’s not same as conducting a properly independent inquiry. |
| Overhaul at Barclays deserves time to work | Overhaul at Barclays deserves time to work |
| One can understand why Jes Staley’s self-satisfied tone might irritate your average activist investor. Barclays’ chief executive unveiled the third-quarter update with a very weak boast. It was the second quarter in a row of “clean results” for Barclays, said Staley proudly. Clean, in this context, means the absence of big bills to cover past bad behaviour or to settle litigation. But six months is no time at all. Save the fanfare for when you can display unblemished profit and loss accounts covering many years. | One can understand why Jes Staley’s self-satisfied tone might irritate your average activist investor. Barclays’ chief executive unveiled the third-quarter update with a very weak boast. It was the second quarter in a row of “clean results” for Barclays, said Staley proudly. Clean, in this context, means the absence of big bills to cover past bad behaviour or to settle litigation. But six months is no time at all. Save the fanfare for when you can display unblemished profit and loss accounts covering many years. |
| Still, if one ignores the crowing over nothing, Staley laid out a fair case for why his strategic overhaul of Barclays should be given time to work, which is the main debate around the bank now that Edward Bramson, the supposedly terrifying activist agitator, is prowling around. | Still, if one ignores the crowing over nothing, Staley laid out a fair case for why his strategic overhaul of Barclays should be given time to work, which is the main debate around the bank now that Edward Bramson, the supposedly terrifying activist agitator, is prowling around. |
| Bramson, since announcing control of a 5% stake in March, has yet to utter a meaningful word publicly, but it’s safe to assume he would like Barclays to be smaller in investment banking and to abandon the game of being a European challenger to the big Wall Street firms. According to this vision, Barclays would be more like Lloyds, a plainer, UK-focused bank concentrated on retail and everyday business banking. | Bramson, since announcing control of a 5% stake in March, has yet to utter a meaningful word publicly, but it’s safe to assume he would like Barclays to be smaller in investment banking and to abandon the game of being a European challenger to the big Wall Street firms. According to this vision, Barclays would be more like Lloyds, a plainer, UK-focused bank concentrated on retail and everyday business banking. |
| In isolation, it’s not the worst idea. Big retail banks can make a packet when they don’t have to pay colossal sums in compensation to customers who have been gouged with payment protection insurance and suchlike. The problem in Barclays’ case, however, is that a purer retail-led model can’t be willed into existence easily. Once you’re on the investment banking merry-go-round, it’s hard to dismount safely or quickly. | In isolation, it’s not the worst idea. Big retail banks can make a packet when they don’t have to pay colossal sums in compensation to customers who have been gouged with payment protection insurance and suchlike. The problem in Barclays’ case, however, is that a purer retail-led model can’t be willed into existence easily. Once you’re on the investment banking merry-go-round, it’s hard to dismount safely or quickly. |
| Deutsche Bank is currently providing a fine example of how not to do it. The German bank is shedding a few investment bankers, but revenues are collapsing at a faster rate. Its staggered retreat looks clumsy and expensive. Staley’s plan for Barclays’ equivalent unit sounds better – manage the risks properly and avoid the misadventures of former years. | Deutsche Bank is currently providing a fine example of how not to do it. The German bank is shedding a few investment bankers, but revenues are collapsing at a faster rate. Its staggered retreat looks clumsy and expensive. Staley’s plan for Barclays’ equivalent unit sounds better – manage the risks properly and avoid the misadventures of former years. |
| The approach still has to produce the goods, but the strategy hasn’t obviously gone wrong on Staley’s watch. Barclays had a half-decent third quarter in investment banking, boosting revenues from equities and fixed-income trading and gaining market share. The division’s return on equity – a purer financial measure for a bank – is still way below the juicy numbers from the consumer and cards divisions. But Staley makes a fair point when he says consumer-related lending ought to be generating superior returns when unemployment is low in both Barclays’ main markets of the UK and US. Diversification, runs the theory, will come into its own when the economic cycle turns. | The approach still has to produce the goods, but the strategy hasn’t obviously gone wrong on Staley’s watch. Barclays had a half-decent third quarter in investment banking, boosting revenues from equities and fixed-income trading and gaining market share. The division’s return on equity – a purer financial measure for a bank – is still way below the juicy numbers from the consumer and cards divisions. But Staley makes a fair point when he says consumer-related lending ought to be generating superior returns when unemployment is low in both Barclays’ main markets of the UK and US. Diversification, runs the theory, will come into its own when the economic cycle turns. |
| The share price remains ugly, of course. At 171p, Barclays is priced at just 65% of its book value, which is another reason why Staley should save the celebrations for another day. But, on strategy, he’s winning the argument. There is a broad acceptance among shareholders that a U-turn would create more problems than it would solve. | The share price remains ugly, of course. At 171p, Barclays is priced at just 65% of its book value, which is another reason why Staley should save the celebrations for another day. But, on strategy, he’s winning the argument. There is a broad acceptance among shareholders that a U-turn would create more problems than it would solve. |
| Bramson, one suspects, will struggle to stir a rebellion. That’s his problem – and one he’ll have to explain to investors in his Sherborne vehicle. Punting on a UK-based bank ahead of Brexit always looked a strange bet. | Bramson, one suspects, will struggle to stir a rebellion. That’s his problem – and one he’ll have to explain to investors in his Sherborne vehicle. Punting on a UK-based bank ahead of Brexit always looked a strange bet. |
| Food & drink industry | Food & drink industry |
| Nils Pratley on finance | Nils Pratley on finance |
| Barclays | Barclays |
| Banking | Banking |
| Patisserie Valerie | |
| comment | comment |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |