This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-46017521
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Unpublished medical research 'a threat to public health' | Unpublished medical research 'a threat to public health' |
(4 days later) | |
Important information on the efficacy of new drugs and treatments is going unpublished, posing a risk to health, says a report by MPs. | Important information on the efficacy of new drugs and treatments is going unpublished, posing a risk to health, says a report by MPs. |
The House of Commons Science and Technology Committee says despite repeated warnings, not enough is being done to make sure the results of all clinical trials are reported. | The House of Commons Science and Technology Committee says despite repeated warnings, not enough is being done to make sure the results of all clinical trials are reported. |
Nearly half of clinical trials go unreported, evidence suggests. | Nearly half of clinical trials go unreported, evidence suggests. |
It means some clinical decisions are made without all the available data. | It means some clinical decisions are made without all the available data. |
In some cases, this might endanger human life, says the group of MPs. | In some cases, this might endanger human life, says the group of MPs. |
They give the example of heart drug lorcainide, which was tested in 1980. | They give the example of heart drug lorcainide, which was tested in 1980. |
'Publication bias' | 'Publication bias' |
The results showed that people who were taking it were more likely to die than those who were not, but those findings were not published until 1993 - long after it was made available to patients in the US. | The results showed that people who were taking it were more likely to die than those who were not, but those findings were not published until 1993 - long after it was made available to patients in the US. |
The committee also heard that "publication bias" may have led to UK public money being wasted, for example when the government's decided to spend £424m to stockpile Tamiflu in response to the H1N1 "swine flu" epidemic in 2009. | The committee also heard that "publication bias" may have led to UK public money being wasted, for example when the government's decided to spend £424m to stockpile Tamiflu in response to the H1N1 "swine flu" epidemic in 2009. |
Dr Simon Kolstoe, a researcher at the University of Portsmouth and chairman of two ethics committees, told the committee: "Eight out of the 10 trials that were used by the company to show the drug was useful in preventing complications such as pneumonia had never actually been peer-reviewed or published." | Dr Simon Kolstoe, a researcher at the University of Portsmouth and chairman of two ethics committees, told the committee: "Eight out of the 10 trials that were used by the company to show the drug was useful in preventing complications such as pneumonia had never actually been peer-reviewed or published." |
He said this meant governments were "relying on a marketing spiel claiming successful trials of this drug, rather than being able to consider the actual evidence of the drug efficacy for themselves". | He said this meant governments were "relying on a marketing spiel claiming successful trials of this drug, rather than being able to consider the actual evidence of the drug efficacy for themselves". |
The NHS Health Research Authority (HRA) has been responsible for "promoting research transparency" since 2014, but the committee says not enough has been done to improve reporting rates. | The NHS Health Research Authority (HRA) has been responsible for "promoting research transparency" since 2014, but the committee says not enough has been done to improve reporting rates. |
Public money | Public money |
MPs want the HRA to produce a strategy for fixing this problem and say its performance should be measured against progress. | MPs want the HRA to produce a strategy for fixing this problem and say its performance should be measured against progress. |
The HRA says it is working with the industry to promote transparency. | The HRA says it is working with the industry to promote transparency. |
Committee chairman Norman Lamb said: "Many of these trials are funded with public money and the taxpayer has a right to expect those who benefit from public funding to follow the rules and publish in full." | Committee chairman Norman Lamb said: "Many of these trials are funded with public money and the taxpayer has a right to expect those who benefit from public funding to follow the rules and publish in full." |
He said it was particularly disappointing that trusted bodies such as Public Health England and a range of NHS Foundation Trusts were included in those failing to report results from clinical trials. | He said it was particularly disappointing that trusted bodies such as Public Health England and a range of NHS Foundation Trusts were included in those failing to report results from clinical trials. |
A trials tracker website, called the EU Clinical Trials Register, claims that Public Health England has three overdue trials relating to meningitis vaccination. | A trials tracker website, called the EU Clinical Trials Register, claims that Public Health England has three overdue trials relating to meningitis vaccination. |
Dr Mary Ramsay, head of immunisations at Public Health England, said: "The science and technology committee report, and research published in the BMJ, highlights that we have not complied with the EU Clinical Trials Register reporting requirements for three trials. | |
"We apologise for this and are putting it right as quickly as possible. | |
"We are committed to transparency and for two of these studies we have published results publically in academic journals and online at clinicaltrials.gov. The samples from a third trial are still being analysed and results will be added to the platform as soon as possible." |
Previous version
1
Next version