This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/nov/16/josh-frydenberg-malaysia-mahathir-mohamad-antisemitic-comments
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Australia's treasurer attacks Malaysian PM Mahathir for 'antisemitic' comments | Australia's treasurer attacks Malaysian PM Mahathir for 'antisemitic' comments |
| (17 days later) | |
| Australia’s treasurer has hit back at Mahathir Mohamad’s warning that Australia moving its embassy in Israel could encourage terrorism by citing a history of antisemitic remarks by the Malaysian prime minister. | Australia’s treasurer has hit back at Mahathir Mohamad’s warning that Australia moving its embassy in Israel could encourage terrorism by citing a history of antisemitic remarks by the Malaysian prime minister. |
| The deputy Liberal leader, Josh Frydenberg, accused Mahatir of having form in making “derogatory comments” about Jews in the past, including calling them “hook-nosed”, questioning the number of people killed in the Holocaust and banning the classic Holocaust film Schindler’s List. | The deputy Liberal leader, Josh Frydenberg, accused Mahatir of having form in making “derogatory comments” about Jews in the past, including calling them “hook-nosed”, questioning the number of people killed in the Holocaust and banning the classic Holocaust film Schindler’s List. |
| Frydenberg made the comments at a press conference and an interview on Radio National on Friday, as he maintained the pressure on the prime minister, Scott Morrison, to make a decision on the embassy independent of the rising backlash from Australia’s near neighbours. | Frydenberg made the comments at a press conference and an interview on Radio National on Friday, as he maintained the pressure on the prime minister, Scott Morrison, to make a decision on the embassy independent of the rising backlash from Australia’s near neighbours. |
| Morrison’s trip to the East Asia and Asean summits in Singapore has been dominated by the Israeli embassy issue, after a public warning from the Indonesian trade minister that Jakarta would not sign off on a free-trade deal with Canberra if the move proceeded and Mahatir’s comments that “adding to the cause for terrorism is not going to be helpful”. | Morrison’s trip to the East Asia and Asean summits in Singapore has been dominated by the Israeli embassy issue, after a public warning from the Indonesian trade minister that Jakarta would not sign off on a free-trade deal with Canberra if the move proceeded and Mahatir’s comments that “adding to the cause for terrorism is not going to be helpful”. |
| Frydenberg told reporters in Melbourne that Australia “will make its own decisions in its own national interest”. | Frydenberg told reporters in Melbourne that Australia “will make its own decisions in its own national interest”. |
| Speaking of the Malaysian prime minister, he told Radio National: “Dr Mahathir does have form, as you know, he’s made a number of derogatory comments in the past about Jews being hook-nosed, he has questioned the number of people that have been killed in the Holocaust and he also saw the banning of Schindler’s List — the movie about the saviour of millions of people by righteous gentiles through that horrible period in world history.” | Speaking of the Malaysian prime minister, he told Radio National: “Dr Mahathir does have form, as you know, he’s made a number of derogatory comments in the past about Jews being hook-nosed, he has questioned the number of people that have been killed in the Holocaust and he also saw the banning of Schindler’s List — the movie about the saviour of millions of people by righteous gentiles through that horrible period in world history.” |
| Malaysian prime minister calls Jews 'hook-nosed' | |
| Frydenberg went on to make the case for the embassy move. | Frydenberg went on to make the case for the embassy move. |
| “Australia already recognises Israel’s sovereignty over West Jerusalem,” he told reporters. “It’s where the Israeli parliament is. It’s where the Australian ambassador presents his or her credentials. It will be the capital of Israel under any two-state solution.” | “Australia already recognises Israel’s sovereignty over West Jerusalem,” he told reporters. “It’s where the Israeli parliament is. It’s where the Australian ambassador presents his or her credentials. It will be the capital of Israel under any two-state solution.” |
| Frydenberg said negotiations between the Israelis and the Palestinians had “frozen” because “Israel does not have a negotiating partner at the table”. | Frydenberg said negotiations between the Israelis and the Palestinians had “frozen” because “Israel does not have a negotiating partner at the table”. |
| “Israel is the only country in the world where Australia doesn’t put its embassy in that nation’s capital. It stands alone. | “Israel is the only country in the world where Australia doesn’t put its embassy in that nation’s capital. It stands alone. |
| “There seems to be a double standard within parts of the United Nations and the human rights council when it comes to Israel, when it comes to other countries.” | “There seems to be a double standard within parts of the United Nations and the human rights council when it comes to Israel, when it comes to other countries.” |
| Frydenberg brushed off the backlash, saying “of course” Australia would have a different view of the relationship with Israel than Indonesia and Malaysia, which are both majority-Muslim nations. | Frydenberg brushed off the backlash, saying “of course” Australia would have a different view of the relationship with Israel than Indonesia and Malaysia, which are both majority-Muslim nations. |
| At a press conference in Darwin, Morrison said that Mahatir had raised his concerns “courteously” at the end of their bilateral meeting and his view was “not unexpected”. | At a press conference in Darwin, Morrison said that Mahatir had raised his concerns “courteously” at the end of their bilateral meeting and his view was “not unexpected”. |
| “I think what Josh [Frydenberg] said today was filling in the history of [Mahatir’s] record on various issues over time,” he said. “I think those issues are well known and … his contribution to the public record on those topics [is] well known. | “I think what Josh [Frydenberg] said today was filling in the history of [Mahatir’s] record on various issues over time,” he said. “I think those issues are well known and … his contribution to the public record on those topics [is] well known. |
| “I do not resile one inch from the fact that I think this is an issue that the Australian government should be able to consider.” | “I do not resile one inch from the fact that I think this is an issue that the Australian government should be able to consider.” |
| The Israel shift, flagged in the run-up to the Wentworth byelection, has become a major political headache for Morrison, and has prompted government colleagues to question his judgment. | The Israel shift, flagged in the run-up to the Wentworth byelection, has become a major political headache for Morrison, and has prompted government colleagues to question his judgment. |
| Some moderates want Morrison to dump the idea, but government conservatives favour the shift. The defence minister, Christopher Pyne, repeated a position on Thursday that he favoured two diplomatic presences – an Australian embassy in West Jerusalem and a separate facility in East Jerusalem in the event of a Palestinian state – and he suggested that was the policy that Morrison was pursuing. | Some moderates want Morrison to dump the idea, but government conservatives favour the shift. The defence minister, Christopher Pyne, repeated a position on Thursday that he favoured two diplomatic presences – an Australian embassy in West Jerusalem and a separate facility in East Jerusalem in the event of a Palestinian state – and he suggested that was the policy that Morrison was pursuing. |
| The former trade minister Steve Ciobo reportedly told his Indonesian counterpart there was “less than a 5% chance” of the move going ahead. Morrison has dismissed that report as a “complete furphy”. | The former trade minister Steve Ciobo reportedly told his Indonesian counterpart there was “less than a 5% chance” of the move going ahead. Morrison has dismissed that report as a “complete furphy”. |
| “This is what I have advised the Indonesian government: Australia will make its own decision when it comes to our foreign policy,” he told ABC Radio in Darwin on Friday. | “This is what I have advised the Indonesian government: Australia will make its own decision when it comes to our foreign policy,” he told ABC Radio in Darwin on Friday. |
| Malaysian PM warns Australia moving Israel embassy would add to terror threat | |
| Morrison said the government would consider the embassy move “if we believed that it would advance the issue of the two-state solution”. | Morrison said the government would consider the embassy move “if we believed that it would advance the issue of the two-state solution”. |
| The prime minister accused the Labor leader, Bill Shorten, of “taking his cues from powers outside of Australia” to decide the embassy issue. | The prime minister accused the Labor leader, Bill Shorten, of “taking his cues from powers outside of Australia” to decide the embassy issue. |
| Earlier Labor’s foreign affairs spokeswoman, Penny Wong, told Radio National the Coalition’s proposal to consider the embassy move showed Morrison’s “poor judgment” because it “trashed bipartisan policy” and had been announced against advice and without cabinet agreement. | Earlier Labor’s foreign affairs spokeswoman, Penny Wong, told Radio National the Coalition’s proposal to consider the embassy move showed Morrison’s “poor judgment” because it “trashed bipartisan policy” and had been announced against advice and without cabinet agreement. |
| Wong said the cost of the proposal “is now being demonstrated” and urged Morrison to “accept he made the wrong judgment” and return to the bipartisan position . | Wong said the cost of the proposal “is now being demonstrated” and urged Morrison to “accept he made the wrong judgment” and return to the bipartisan position . |
| “No country should dictate our foreign policy,” she said. “It should be determined by looking at the national interest. That is not what occurred here – Mr Morrison made a rash, precipitous, judgment because he thought this would win votes in Wentworth.” | “No country should dictate our foreign policy,” she said. “It should be determined by looking at the national interest. That is not what occurred here – Mr Morrison made a rash, precipitous, judgment because he thought this would win votes in Wentworth.” |
| Wong accused the government of being in a state of “chaos” over the decision, citing Ciobo’s reported remarks and the Liberal senator Eric Abetz’s threat to Australia’s foreign aid to Indonesia: | Wong accused the government of being in a state of “chaos” over the decision, citing Ciobo’s reported remarks and the Liberal senator Eric Abetz’s threat to Australia’s foreign aid to Indonesia: |
| If Indonesia really wants to dictate Aus foreign policy on the middle east, should we rethink the $360 million each year we give them in aid? Instead, how about we calmly finalise this FTA which will lift many Indonesians out of poverty and assist Australian farmers and jobs. | If Indonesia really wants to dictate Aus foreign policy on the middle east, should we rethink the $360 million each year we give them in aid? Instead, how about we calmly finalise this FTA which will lift many Indonesians out of poverty and assist Australian farmers and jobs. |
| Mahathir Mohamad | Mahathir Mohamad |
| Josh Frydenberg | Josh Frydenberg |
| Malaysia | Malaysia |
| Israel | Israel |
| Asean (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) | Asean (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) |
| Australian politics | Australian politics |
| Indonesia | Indonesia |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |