This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-46358969
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 7 | Version 8 |
---|---|
Fast fashion: 'How do you justify selling a £2 T-shirt?' | Fast fashion: 'How do you justify selling a £2 T-shirt?' |
(about 1 hour later) | |
Big-name retailers have defended selling clothes for £5 or less, saying their ability to sell clothes so cheaply is down to business models. | Big-name retailers have defended selling clothes for £5 or less, saying their ability to sell clothes so cheaply is down to business models. |
MPs investigating the impact of so-called "fast fashion" asked the firms how they could justify such low prices. | MPs investigating the impact of so-called "fast fashion" asked the firms how they could justify such low prices. |
Primark's spokesman Paul Lister said the firm spent nothing on advertising and had tight profit margins. | Primark's spokesman Paul Lister said the firm spent nothing on advertising and had tight profit margins. |
Representatives from brands including Boohoo, Misguided, Asos, Burberry and Marks & Spencer also gave evidence. | Representatives from brands including Boohoo, Misguided, Asos, Burberry and Marks & Spencer also gave evidence. |
The Commons environmental audit committee (EAC) is examining the impact of clothes production, especially those items produced cheaply and quickly in response to trends - known as "fast fashion". | The Commons environmental audit committee (EAC) is examining the impact of clothes production, especially those items produced cheaply and quickly in response to trends - known as "fast fashion". |
Labour MP Mary Creagh, chair of the committee, asked Primark's head of ethical trade and environmental sustainability, Paul Lister: "How can you justify selling T-shirts in your stores for as little as £2 or £3, and how can you be making a profit on those?" | Labour MP Mary Creagh, chair of the committee, asked Primark's head of ethical trade and environmental sustainability, Paul Lister: "How can you justify selling T-shirts in your stores for as little as £2 or £3, and how can you be making a profit on those?" |
He replied: "Primark has never done any significant advertising at all, and that can save us in any year £100m to £150m, compared to some of our larger rivals. That goes straight into price. That keeps our pricing low." | He replied: "Primark has never done any significant advertising at all, and that can save us in any year £100m to £150m, compared to some of our larger rivals. That goes straight into price. That keeps our pricing low." |
"It's our business model that takes us to a £2 T-shirt." | "It's our business model that takes us to a £2 T-shirt." |
On waste, Mr Lister said Primark had very little unused stock and was planning to launch a take-back scheme for consumers next year, where old clothes can be returned and used again by overseas charities. | On waste, Mr Lister said Primark had very little unused stock and was planning to launch a take-back scheme for consumers next year, where old clothes can be returned and used again by overseas charities. |
Ms Creagh suggested that by making garments so cheaply, they were being devalued. | Ms Creagh suggested that by making garments so cheaply, they were being devalued. |
But Mr Lister insisted: "Every item that we make, we're looking at durability… we are proud of the quality and durability of our garments, they're not built to throw away." | But Mr Lister insisted: "Every item that we make, we're looking at durability… we are proud of the quality and durability of our garments, they're not built to throw away." |
What is fast fashion? | What is fast fashion? |
The term describes our high rate of fashion consumption fuelled by the availability of new and cheap clothing. | The term describes our high rate of fashion consumption fuelled by the availability of new and cheap clothing. |
Producing clothes requires climate-changing emissions. Global textile production produces 1.2bn tonnes of carbon emissions a year - more than international flights and maritime shipping. | Producing clothes requires climate-changing emissions. Global textile production produces 1.2bn tonnes of carbon emissions a year - more than international flights and maritime shipping. |
Last month, MPs on the EAC concluded that the fast fashion industry was a major source of the greenhouse gases that are overheating the planet. | Last month, MPs on the EAC concluded that the fast fashion industry was a major source of the greenhouse gases that are overheating the planet. |
MPs believe that the throwaway nature of fashion is also fuelling fast turnarounds among suppliers, which may result in poor working conditions. | MPs believe that the throwaway nature of fashion is also fuelling fast turnarounds among suppliers, which may result in poor working conditions. |
Elsewhere, Carol Kane, joint CEO of online fashion house Boohoo, was asked how the company could sell dresses for as little as £5 when the minimum wage was £7.83. | |
She said this only applied to a small number of dresses intentionally sold at a loss, to drive more traffic to the site. | She said this only applied to a small number of dresses intentionally sold at a loss, to drive more traffic to the site. |
Ms Kane, asked if consumers were now too accustomed to cheap, disposable clothes, said: "I believe this all comes back to consumer demand. I've been in the industry for 32 years, and in that time I've seen prices decline." | Ms Kane, asked if consumers were now too accustomed to cheap, disposable clothes, said: "I believe this all comes back to consumer demand. I've been in the industry for 32 years, and in that time I've seen prices decline." |
Speaking on the same issue, Jamie Beck, from the Arcadia group, which includes Topshop, Dorothy Perkins and Burton, said: "These garments aren't designed to be a disposable item, to be bought for [just] a holiday. They're designed to be long-lasting." | Speaking on the same issue, Jamie Beck, from the Arcadia group, which includes Topshop, Dorothy Perkins and Burton, said: "These garments aren't designed to be a disposable item, to be bought for [just] a holiday. They're designed to be long-lasting." |
During the hearing, high-end fashion brand Burberry also defended criticism from MPs for dumping clothes. | During the hearing, high-end fashion brand Burberry also defended criticism from MPs for dumping clothes. |
Earlier this year, the firm was strongly criticised for burning £30m ($40m) of stock. It admitted destroying the unsold clothes, accessories and perfume instead of selling them off cheaply, in order to protect the brand's exclusivity and value. | Earlier this year, the firm was strongly criticised for burning £30m ($40m) of stock. It admitted destroying the unsold clothes, accessories and perfume instead of selling them off cheaply, in order to protect the brand's exclusivity and value. |
Leanne Wood, Burberry's chief of corporate affairs, told MPs the firm was "committed" to stopping the activity, but added: "It is an industry practice. We're the only luxury business that's reported it in their accounts… but it is something that happens in the industry." | Leanne Wood, Burberry's chief of corporate affairs, told MPs the firm was "committed" to stopping the activity, but added: "It is an industry practice. We're the only luxury business that's reported it in their accounts… but it is something that happens in the industry." |
Boohoo, Misguided and Asos were also quizzed on relationships with suppliers accused of exploiting workers in Britain. | |
Paul Smith, head of product quality and supply at Misguided, said the firm had cut the number of businesses it worked with in Leicester - where many of the factories are based - from 35 to just 20 due to concerns about pay and conditions at some sites there. | |
After the hearing, Ms Creagh said: "Evidence we heard today justifies our concerns that the current system allows fashion retailers to mark their own homework when it comes to workers' rights, fair pay and sustainability. | After the hearing, Ms Creagh said: "Evidence we heard today justifies our concerns that the current system allows fashion retailers to mark their own homework when it comes to workers' rights, fair pay and sustainability. |
"Marks and Spencer are supposed to be a leading light in corporate responsibility, but even they pulled out of a scheme seeking to achieve living wages for garment workers through collective bargaining. | "Marks and Spencer are supposed to be a leading light in corporate responsibility, but even they pulled out of a scheme seeking to achieve living wages for garment workers through collective bargaining. |
"Boohoo did not convince us that it had a grip on the potential illegal underpayment of their Leicester-based workers." | "Boohoo did not convince us that it had a grip on the potential illegal underpayment of their Leicester-based workers." |
She added that it was "shocking" to learn during the hearing that Misguided staff who went to check on conditions at a factory were allegedly assaulted by its owners, adding that it "begs the question - what on Earth was going on inside?". |