This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2018/dec/03/liberals-coalition-turnbull-craig-kelly-preselection-question-time-labor-politics-live
The article has changed 20 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 14 | Version 15 |
|---|---|
| Scott Morrison faces MPs after intervention in Craig Kelly saga – politics live | Scott Morrison faces MPs after intervention in Craig Kelly saga – politics live |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| It’s the last sitting week of the parliamentary year. | |
| The year’s almost over. It’s too much to start asking for honest language now, right? So who’s in the mood for euphemism and mixed metaphors? | |
| Here’s Barnaby Joyce talking about the Morrison government’s “religious freedom” plans. As an aside, it’s not clear what half of this stuff has to do with the bill: | |
| “Constitutionally we’ve always believed that we’ve had the right, the freedom, to basically invest in our own religion, and invest in our own schools. | |
| “Invest in those schools that promote the values, ah, that we believe give people the safest path, ah, on that ocean. The safest voyage on that ocean. Where you decide to go is really your own business but, um, there has been a real sense of concern, palpable concern, that’s come into this building by reason of a sense that, ah, the State will rule supreme in the school, no matter if it’s a state government school or an independent school. | |
| “People have a right to believe what they wish but when that right to believe what they wish overruns the rights of everybody else who have a different view within that school then it’s something has to be called into question. | |
| “There are things that are just indelible. And we have to accept them. People are born with an XX chromosome, homogametic, or they’re born with an XY chromosome, heterogametic, and that determines basically whether you’re male or female. | |
| “The concerns that people have and say ‘well we’ll put that aside or we’re not allowed to mention it,’ that is in itself creates problems, especially, with um, it’s been brought to my attention when a person at a female school, and all-girl school, says well what happens when someone presents and says ‘well I’ve determined that, you know, I want to be female and I want to come to this school’? How’s that going to be dealt with?” | |
| Penny Wong has given notice of a motion that Labor will be attempting to bring the religious schools bill to vote again tomorrow. | |
| If successful, it will be up for consideration again from noon on Wednesday. | |
| From Mike Bowers’s lens to your eyeballs: | |
| Question time ends. | Question time ends. |
| Tony Burke stands up after learning of this: | Tony Burke stands up after learning of this: |
| I have just been kicked out of #QT because you can allegedly see too much skin. His insane #Auspol pic.twitter.com/51KipESXlG | I have just been kicked out of #QT because you can allegedly see too much skin. His insane #Auspol pic.twitter.com/51KipESXlG |
| He says that it is a rule he has never heard before – and if it needs to be fixed, it should be fixed. | He says that it is a rule he has never heard before – and if it needs to be fixed, it should be fixed. |
| Kerryn Phelps asks Christian Porter why the government won’t pass the religious discrimination bill, Porter said that the government “wants to get this done”, but the compromise won’t go far enough to support what the government wants and it “has to be a balance of passage”. | Kerryn Phelps asks Christian Porter why the government won’t pass the religious discrimination bill, Porter said that the government “wants to get this done”, but the compromise won’t go far enough to support what the government wants and it “has to be a balance of passage”. |
| Mark Butler asks Scott Morrison about Craig Kelly’s threat to move to the crossbench and Malcolm Turnbull’s opinion that saving him would be the “worst and weakest response”. | Mark Butler asks Scott Morrison about Craig Kelly’s threat to move to the crossbench and Malcolm Turnbull’s opinion that saving him would be the “worst and weakest response”. |
| Morrison says that Kelly never made the threat. | Morrison says that Kelly never made the threat. |
| I can’t tell you much more, because, like a lot of people in this place I could name, the transcription service has given up. | I can’t tell you much more, because, like a lot of people in this place I could name, the transcription service has given up. |
| Christopher Pyne has just had a chat with Scott Morrison and then wandered over to have a chat to the crossbench. | Christopher Pyne has just had a chat with Scott Morrison and then wandered over to have a chat to the crossbench. |
| He gets whatever answer he wants and wanders back to Morrison. | He gets whatever answer he wants and wanders back to Morrison. |
| David Littleproud gets the next dixer and it looks like he is sticking to the ‘no yelling is good yelling’ qt approach. | David Littleproud gets the next dixer and it looks like he is sticking to the ‘no yelling is good yelling’ qt approach. |
| After successfully calling Ken O’Dowd and Barnaby Joyce under this tactic, Tony Burke is now moving to have Craig Kelly answer a question. | After successfully calling Ken O’Dowd and Barnaby Joyce under this tactic, Tony Burke is now moving to have Craig Kelly answer a question. |
| Burke: “I refer to the member’s motion on the notice paper which relates to the national energy guarantee and that it provides certainty for investors. Under standing orders this motion will be removed from the notice paper if it is not selected for debate again. When will the motion be debated again, will it be removed from the notice paper if it is not selected? | Burke: “I refer to the member’s motion on the notice paper which relates to the national energy guarantee and that it provides certainty for investors. Under standing orders this motion will be removed from the notice paper if it is not selected for debate again. When will the motion be debated again, will it be removed from the notice paper if it is not selected? |
| Christopher Pyne rises to interject. Tony Smith calls on him “on irony first”. | Christopher Pyne rises to interject. Tony Smith calls on him “on irony first”. |
| Smith, who has been here before, allows the question. | Smith, who has been here before, allows the question. |
| Craig Kelly uses the opportunity to again prove he does not know how microphones work and starts screaming about 45% targets being the worst in the entire world and Labor not caring. | Craig Kelly uses the opportunity to again prove he does not know how microphones work and starts screaming about 45% targets being the worst in the entire world and Labor not caring. |
| He sits down, with plenty of time on the clock, to applause from his side of the chamber, while Tony Burke asks for an extension of time. | He sits down, with plenty of time on the clock, to applause from his side of the chamber, while Tony Burke asks for an extension of time. |
| Tony Smith again points out that you can only have an extension of time if you have run out of time. | Tony Smith again points out that you can only have an extension of time if you have run out of time. |
| Labor has made its point though. It’s Kelly’s bloated aubergine rant which will make the news bulletins and the whole place looks like a dog’s breakfast. And that’s being kind. | Labor has made its point though. It’s Kelly’s bloated aubergine rant which will make the news bulletins and the whole place looks like a dog’s breakfast. And that’s being kind. |
| Chris Bowen to Josh Frydenberg: | Chris Bowen to Josh Frydenberg: |
| I refer to statements made by industry groups that the government’s propose to powers represent deep and genuine sovereign risk or discourage badly needed investment in the energy sector and will only lead to increased investment uncertainty and prices. Even the government’s big stick really just a big mistake that will lead to sovereign risk and higher power prices? Why is this Liberal government abandoned its policy commitment to free enterprise?” | I refer to statements made by industry groups that the government’s propose to powers represent deep and genuine sovereign risk or discourage badly needed investment in the energy sector and will only lead to increased investment uncertainty and prices. Even the government’s big stick really just a big mistake that will lead to sovereign risk and higher power prices? Why is this Liberal government abandoned its policy commitment to free enterprise?” |
| Frydenberg: | Frydenberg: |
| “The member for McMahon must have a short memory because of the last time the Labor party was in government at a federal level, power prices doubled! Went up by over 100%, Mr Speaker. They ignored the warnings on gas, and as the member for Hume knows, they left us with potential shortfalls in the domestic gas market.” | “The member for McMahon must have a short memory because of the last time the Labor party was in government at a federal level, power prices doubled! Went up by over 100%, Mr Speaker. They ignored the warnings on gas, and as the member for Hume knows, they left us with potential shortfalls in the domestic gas market.” |
| And now they are coming up with the pink batteries to solving energy issues. | And now they are coming up with the pink batteries to solving energy issues. |
| And what about a replication nationally of what we saw in South Australia? The big experiment in South Australia, Mr Speaker. | And what about a replication nationally of what we saw in South Australia? The big experiment in South Australia, Mr Speaker. |
| When it comes to the coalition, 458,000 Australian families and 39,000 small businesses are today getting a better deal on their energy prices thanks to the work of the Morrison government. | When it comes to the coalition, 458,000 Australian families and 39,000 small businesses are today getting a better deal on their energy prices thanks to the work of the Morrison government. |
| Because we are putting energy users consumers, businesses and families first. | Because we are putting energy users consumers, businesses and families first. |
| Whereas the Labor party is siding with the energy companies. The fact is there is market misconduct. | Whereas the Labor party is siding with the energy companies. The fact is there is market misconduct. |
| “There is market misconduct and we had to take the necessary action so they will be a range of remedies that are available, they range from a warning notice to enforceable undertakings to financial under penalties and fines and finally as a last resort to divert them.” | “There is market misconduct and we had to take the necessary action so they will be a range of remedies that are available, they range from a warning notice to enforceable undertakings to financial under penalties and fines and finally as a last resort to divert them.” |
| These other steps that need to be taken to ensure that energy consumers get the lowest possible prices. | These other steps that need to be taken to ensure that energy consumers get the lowest possible prices. |
| “And if I was the member for McMahon, I would be worrying about the 3,000 retirees in his electorate who are going to be worse off and the 7,000 families who negative gear, all of whom will be worse off in the member for McMahon’s electorate as a result of Labor’s policy.” | “And if I was the member for McMahon, I would be worrying about the 3,000 retirees in his electorate who are going to be worse off and the 7,000 families who negative gear, all of whom will be worse off in the member for McMahon’s electorate as a result of Labor’s policy.” |
| Sigh. | Sigh. |
| It is at this point I scream internally that the SA blackouts were caused by a giant fricking storm which knocked out the transmitters and you can have all the power in the world but it’s useless without the things that transmit it, but I am as dead inside as the government backbench. | It is at this point I scream internally that the SA blackouts were caused by a giant fricking storm which knocked out the transmitters and you can have all the power in the world but it’s useless without the things that transmit it, but I am as dead inside as the government backbench. |
| Over in the Senate: | Over in the Senate: |
| Jenny McAllister: Given Mr Morrison has refused to save Jane Prentice, Ann Sudmalis, and Senators Molan and Gichuhi – but has today intervened to save Craig Kelly: How does Mr Morrison decide when to intervene? Why is there a quota for clowns, but not for women? | Jenny McAllister: Given Mr Morrison has refused to save Jane Prentice, Ann Sudmalis, and Senators Molan and Gichuhi – but has today intervened to save Craig Kelly: How does Mr Morrison decide when to intervene? Why is there a quota for clowns, but not for women? |
| Cory Bernardi: Point of order. You can’t refer to members of parliament as clowns | Cory Bernardi: Point of order. You can’t refer to members of parliament as clowns |
| Jacinta Collins: The prime minister called you all Muppets! | Jacinta Collins: The prime minister called you all Muppets! |
| Scott Ryan: I actually could not hear the 2nd part of that question due to noise from my right. So if there was something unparliamentary I’d ask for it to be withdrawn but I did not hear the second part of that question. I was giving the Minister the courtesy to respond. He may have heard it. If there was nothing on that someone can bring something on Hansard to my attention. | Scott Ryan: I actually could not hear the 2nd part of that question due to noise from my right. So if there was something unparliamentary I’d ask for it to be withdrawn but I did not hear the second part of that question. I was giving the Minister the courtesy to respond. He may have heard it. If there was nothing on that someone can bring something on Hansard to my attention. |
| Bernardi: Senator McAllister suggested that the Prime Minister failed to intervene in the preselection of clowns, It’s simply inappropriate and Senator McAllister knows. She should withdraw. | Bernardi: Senator McAllister suggested that the Prime Minister failed to intervene in the preselection of clowns, It’s simply inappropriate and Senator McAllister knows. She should withdraw. |
| Derryn Hinch: Isn’t truth a defence in New South Wales? | Derryn Hinch: Isn’t truth a defence in New South Wales? |
| The opposition are calling Angus Taylor “Biggus Stickus” and calling out lines from Monty Pythons Life of Brian during #weleaseWoger #QT @AmyRemeikis @GuardianAus #PoliticsLive pic.twitter.com/0kUN4wPhi7 | The opposition are calling Angus Taylor “Biggus Stickus” and calling out lines from Monty Pythons Life of Brian during #weleaseWoger #QT @AmyRemeikis @GuardianAus #PoliticsLive pic.twitter.com/0kUN4wPhi7 |