This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-46454891
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Prime Minister's Questions: The key bits and the verdict | Prime Minister's Questions: The key bits and the verdict |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| Theresa May went head-to-head with Jeremy Corbyn in the House of Commons. Here's what happened. | Theresa May went head-to-head with Jeremy Corbyn in the House of Commons. Here's what happened. |
| With Westminster in near meltdown over Brexit, Jeremy Corbyn threw the prime minister a curve ball and went on her government's record on poverty. | With Westminster in near meltdown over Brexit, Jeremy Corbyn threw the prime minister a curve ball and went on her government's record on poverty. |
| For the second week in a row, he quoted a damning report by the United Nations on the government's "brutal policies" towards the poor. Was she "shocked" by this, he asked, and why had she not replied to a letter he had written to her about it. | For the second week in a row, he quoted a damning report by the United Nations on the government's "brutal policies" towards the poor. Was she "shocked" by this, he asked, and why had she not replied to a letter he had written to her about it. |
| "We don't agree with this report," said Mrs May. "Absolute poverty," she said, was at "record lows" and "more people were in work than ever before". Youth unemployment had almost halved and wages were rising, she added. | "We don't agree with this report," said Mrs May. "Absolute poverty," she said, was at "record lows" and "more people were in work than ever before". Youth unemployment had almost halved and wages were rising, she added. |
| Mr Corbyn called on her to halt the roll-out of universal credit, which he described as a "hostile environment" for benefit claimants. | Mr Corbyn called on her to halt the roll-out of universal credit, which he described as a "hostile environment" for benefit claimants. |
| The government had "listened" to criticism of universal credit and made changes, said Mrs May, and it encouraged people into work and simplified the benefit system. | The government had "listened" to criticism of universal credit and made changes, said Mrs May, and it encouraged people into work and simplified the benefit system. |
| Mr Corbyn quoted a report from the Trussell Trust, the main food bank charity in the UK, which criticised the "five week wait" new universal credit claimants face. | Mr Corbyn quoted a report from the Trussell Trust, the main food bank charity in the UK, which criticised the "five week wait" new universal credit claimants face. |
| People in areas where universal credit was being introduced, including Anglessey, Blackpool, Milton Keynes, parts of Liverpool and London, and elsewhere, "risk being left with no money for Christmas", said Mr Corbyn. | People in areas where universal credit was being introduced, including Anglessey, Blackpool, Milton Keynes, parts of Liverpool and London, and elsewhere, "risk being left with no money for Christmas", said Mr Corbyn. |
| Mrs May claimed "no one" will have to wait for money "if they need it" because the government had made it easier to get advances and 100% of new claimants would get payments up front. | Mrs May claimed "no one" will have to wait for money "if they need it" because the government had made it easier to get advances and 100% of new claimants would get payments up front. |
| Mr Corbyn dismissed these measures as a "loan that's offered for some people". The Trussell Trust was predicting "record demand" for food banks this December, he said. | Mr Corbyn dismissed these measures as a "loan that's offered for some people". The Trussell Trust was predicting "record demand" for food banks this December, he said. |
| "Food banks are not just a photo opportunity for Conservative MPs," declared the Labour leader, "all of whom supported the cuts in benefit that led to the poverty in this country". The Joseph Rowntree Foundation has said "in-work poverty was rising faster than the overall employment rate", he went on. | "Food banks are not just a photo opportunity for Conservative MPs," declared the Labour leader, "all of whom supported the cuts in benefit that led to the poverty in this country". The Joseph Rowntree Foundation has said "in-work poverty was rising faster than the overall employment rate", he went on. |
| Why did the UK suffer from "the weakest wage growth of all G20 nations", he asked the PM. | Why did the UK suffer from "the weakest wage growth of all G20 nations", he asked the PM. |
| Mrs May accused Labour of wanting to "go back to square one" by scrapping universal credit, which would leave people trapped on benefits. | Mrs May accused Labour of wanting to "go back to square one" by scrapping universal credit, which would leave people trapped on benefits. |
| The Labour leader quoted the chief economist of the Bank of England on wage growth, which prompted an eruption of noise from the Tory benches. | The Labour leader quoted the chief economist of the Bank of England on wage growth, which prompted an eruption of noise from the Tory benches. |
| "The prime minister may be laughing at this, but it's the reality of people's lives," cried Mr Corbyn. | "The prime minister may be laughing at this, but it's the reality of people's lives," cried Mr Corbyn. |
| Speaker Bercow stepped in to calm things down, allowing Mr Corbyn to quote another UN report, from two years ago, on the UK government's "systematic violation" of the rights of disabled people. | Speaker Bercow stepped in to calm things down, allowing Mr Corbyn to quote another UN report, from two years ago, on the UK government's "systematic violation" of the rights of disabled people. |
| The government was helping disabled people get into work, said Mrs May, before talking about the "difficult decisions" the government had been forced to make by Labour's "mismanagement" of the economy, as evidenced by Labour MP Liam Byrne's famous note about there being "no money left". | The government was helping disabled people get into work, said Mrs May, before talking about the "difficult decisions" the government had been forced to make by Labour's "mismanagement" of the economy, as evidenced by Labour MP Liam Byrne's famous note about there being "no money left". |
| Whenever the PM talks about difficult decisions, said Mr Corbyn, "the poorest lose out". He then launched into a full-throated attack on ministers he claimed had labelled disabled people "scroungers" and the unemployed "skivers". | Whenever the PM talks about difficult decisions, said Mr Corbyn, "the poorest lose out". He then launched into a full-throated attack on ministers he claimed had labelled disabled people "scroungers" and the unemployed "skivers". |
| When, he said, would the government scrap the benefits freeze, repeal the "bedroom tax", scrap the "two child cap" and "halt the roll-out of of universal credit". | When, he said, would the government scrap the benefits freeze, repeal the "bedroom tax", scrap the "two child cap" and "halt the roll-out of of universal credit". |
| Mrs May replied that the "poorest lose out when a Labour government comes in". | Mrs May replied that the "poorest lose out when a Labour government comes in". |
| What else came up? | What else came up? |
| It was left to the SNP's leader at Westminster Ian Blackford to lead the attack on Brexit, claiming the government was in "crisis" - and urging the PM to take responsibility for "concealing the facts" on her deal by not publishing its legal advice until forced to do so by MPs. | It was left to the SNP's leader at Westminster Ian Blackford to lead the attack on Brexit, claiming the government was in "crisis" - and urging the PM to take responsibility for "concealing the facts" on her deal by not publishing its legal advice until forced to do so by MPs. |
| He accused the PM of "misleading the house, inadvertently or otherwise", earning him a rebuke from Speaker Bercow - MPs are not allowed to accuse other MPs of lying. | He accused the PM of "misleading the house, inadvertently or otherwise", earning him a rebuke from Speaker Bercow - MPs are not allowed to accuse other MPs of lying. |
| Alright, said Mr Blackford "perhaps inadvertently" - prompting another warning from Mr Bercow. | Alright, said Mr Blackford "perhaps inadvertently" - prompting another warning from Mr Bercow. |
| "There can be no imputation of dishonour and insertion of the word 'perhaps' - he wants to keep his options open," said the Speaker. Mr Blackford dropped the "perhaps". | "There can be no imputation of dishonour and insertion of the word 'perhaps' - he wants to keep his options open," said the Speaker. Mr Blackford dropped the "perhaps". |
| The PM replied that the legal advice was no different to the statement made by Attorney General Geoffrey Cox on Monday. | The PM replied that the legal advice was no different to the statement made by Attorney General Geoffrey Cox on Monday. |
| She said she had already told MPs there was no unilateral right of exit from the Northern Irish backstop but it is very unlikely to be used, she added. | She said she had already told MPs there was no unilateral right of exit from the Northern Irish backstop but it is very unlikely to be used, she added. |
| The SNP's Joanna Cherry also asked about the PM's Brexit deal. | The SNP's Joanna Cherry also asked about the PM's Brexit deal. |
| Conservative MP Helen Whately highlighted to women the importance of smear tests. | |
| The Verdict | The Verdict |
| Here is BBC Parliamentary Correspondent Mark Darcy's take on the session: | Here is BBC Parliamentary Correspondent Mark Darcy's take on the session: |
| Whatever else happened, this edition of PMQs did not heap further pressure on the prime minister. | Whatever else happened, this edition of PMQs did not heap further pressure on the prime minister. |
| On most occasions, I can see some point in Jeremy Corbyn's approach of talking about bread and butter public services, rather than targeting the issue of the day in SW1 - but with Theresa May under massive pressure, having just lost three Commons votes, and apparently heading for defeat in a vote on the central policy of her government, it seemed rather an odd choice not to pile into the government's woes. | On most occasions, I can see some point in Jeremy Corbyn's approach of talking about bread and butter public services, rather than targeting the issue of the day in SW1 - but with Theresa May under massive pressure, having just lost three Commons votes, and apparently heading for defeat in a vote on the central policy of her government, it seemed rather an odd choice not to pile into the government's woes. |
| So while his Brexit Secretary, Sir Keir Starmer, was tweeting about the unhelpful things the government's own lawyer was saying about her proposed Brexit deal, the Labour leader defaulted to poverty, austerity and universal credit. | So while his Brexit Secretary, Sir Keir Starmer, was tweeting about the unhelpful things the government's own lawyer was saying about her proposed Brexit deal, the Labour leader defaulted to poverty, austerity and universal credit. |
| Important issues, to be sure, but the right ones? On this, of all days? When Mr Corbyn's avowed intent is to use its Brexit divisions bring down the government? | Important issues, to be sure, but the right ones? On this, of all days? When Mr Corbyn's avowed intent is to use its Brexit divisions bring down the government? |
| It is possible across six questions, to pivot from one subject to another, but Mr Corbyn chose not to do so. | It is possible across six questions, to pivot from one subject to another, but Mr Corbyn chose not to do so. |
| The SNP's Iain Blackford did ask about Brexit - and seemed to be shaping to ask whether Scotland could get the same deal as Northern Ireland, before rather running aground, when he implied (twice) that the prime minister had deliberately misled Parliament. | The SNP's Iain Blackford did ask about Brexit - and seemed to be shaping to ask whether Scotland could get the same deal as Northern Ireland, before rather running aground, when he implied (twice) that the prime minister had deliberately misled Parliament. |
| SNP MPs don't tend to mind being pulled up for infringing this particular Westminster taboo, but it took the edge of a question which could have discomforted Scottish Conservatives, who're already feeling a little vulnerable. | SNP MPs don't tend to mind being pulled up for infringing this particular Westminster taboo, but it took the edge of a question which could have discomforted Scottish Conservatives, who're already feeling a little vulnerable. |
| The prime minister has had several very uncomfortable interludes at the despatch box - and this was not one of them. | The prime minister has had several very uncomfortable interludes at the despatch box - and this was not one of them. |
| The session defaulted into a pretty standard exchange of charges and counter-charges, and the subsequent Brexit questions from people like Labour's Kevin Brennan and Plaid's Liz Saville Roberts could not be pressed, because both were limited to a single intervention. | The session defaulted into a pretty standard exchange of charges and counter-charges, and the subsequent Brexit questions from people like Labour's Kevin Brennan and Plaid's Liz Saville Roberts could not be pressed, because both were limited to a single intervention. |
| The overwhelming impression was of a beleaguered PM powering on, and taking no further damage. | The overwhelming impression was of a beleaguered PM powering on, and taking no further damage. |