This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-46807083
The article has changed 14 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 6 | Version 7 |
---|---|
Stormont EU 'veto' power plans published by government | Stormont EU 'veto' power plans published by government |
(35 minutes later) | |
Stormont would be given the power to vote on new EU rules if the border backstop comes into force after Brexit, the government has proposed. | Stormont would be given the power to vote on new EU rules if the border backstop comes into force after Brexit, the government has proposed. |
It comes as Prime Minister Theresa May continues in her bid to win over MPs opposed to her Brexit deal. | It comes as Prime Minister Theresa May continues in her bid to win over MPs opposed to her Brexit deal. |
MPs are set to debate the withdrawal agreement ahead of a crucial vote in the House of Commons next week. | MPs are set to debate the withdrawal agreement ahead of a crucial vote in the House of Commons next week. |
Cabinet Office Minister David Lidington said the plans amounted to giving the Northern Ireland Assembly a "veto". | Cabinet Office Minister David Lidington said the plans amounted to giving the Northern Ireland Assembly a "veto". |
The Democratic Unionist Party, who Mrs May relies on for her Commons majority, described the proposals as "meaningless" and of "no real significance". | The Democratic Unionist Party, who Mrs May relies on for her Commons majority, described the proposals as "meaningless" and of "no real significance". |
Sinn Féin said it was opposed to any Stormont "veto" mechanism. | Sinn Féin said it was opposed to any Stormont "veto" mechanism. |
Northern Ireland has been without a functioning devolved government since the executive collapsed in January 2017. | Northern Ireland has been without a functioning devolved government since the executive collapsed in January 2017. |
What is the government proposing? | What is the government proposing? |
The backstop is a position of last resort to maintain a soft border on the island of Ireland. | The backstop is a position of last resort to maintain a soft border on the island of Ireland. |
It would involve Northern Ireland staying in large parts of the EU single market, unless and until a long-term deal emerged that kept the border as open as it is now. | It would involve Northern Ireland staying in large parts of the EU single market, unless and until a long-term deal emerged that kept the border as open as it is now. |
The proposals, published on Wednesday, set out a number of roles for the assembly. | The proposals, published on Wednesday, set out a number of roles for the assembly. |
These include: | These include: |
However, there is debate as to whether the proposals amount to an outright veto. | However, there is debate as to whether the proposals amount to an outright veto. |
Analysis: United in opposition | Analysis: United in opposition |
By Chris Page, BBC News Ireland Correspondent | By Chris Page, BBC News Ireland Correspondent |
Northern Ireland's two largest parties fundamentally disagree on Brexit - the DUP support it, while Sinn Féin are strongly opposed. | Northern Ireland's two largest parties fundamentally disagree on Brexit - the DUP support it, while Sinn Féin are strongly opposed. |
But both parties are dismissive of the government's ideas on involving Stormont in decisions on EU trade rules. | |
Sinn Féin are mindful that the devolved assembly's cross-community voting rules - which mean a majority of unionists and nationalists must agree on contentious proposals in order for them to pass - would mean that the DUP (and other unionists) could block backstop-related measures even if there is a numerical majority in favour of them. | Sinn Féin are mindful that the devolved assembly's cross-community voting rules - which mean a majority of unionists and nationalists must agree on contentious proposals in order for them to pass - would mean that the DUP (and other unionists) could block backstop-related measures even if there is a numerical majority in favour of them. |
However, the DUP are rejecting the government's plans because they don't believe the proposals go far enough to protect the unionist position - they say Stormont would be consulted on EU trade issues, but not have a legally-binding veto. | However, the DUP are rejecting the government's plans because they don't believe the proposals go far enough to protect the unionist position - they say Stormont would be consulted on EU trade issues, but not have a legally-binding veto. |
How have Northern Ireland's parties reacted? | How have Northern Ireland's parties reacted? |
DUP MP Gavin Robinson said he did not think the proposals would lead to his party backing the withdrawal agreement. | DUP MP Gavin Robinson said he did not think the proposals would lead to his party backing the withdrawal agreement. |
"The withdrawal agreement says that even if there was disagreement in Stormont, even if Stormont decided that a proposal from the European Union wasn't in the best interests of Northern Ireland, the UK government would legislate over our heads," the Belfast East MP told BBC News NI. | "The withdrawal agreement says that even if there was disagreement in Stormont, even if Stormont decided that a proposal from the European Union wasn't in the best interests of Northern Ireland, the UK government would legislate over our heads," the Belfast East MP told BBC News NI. |
"So in giving a consultative role, it doesn't sound to me that the proposal that will be outlined is going to be the sort of comfort that people were seeking." | |
"Anything that gives the DUP or extreme unionism any veto on progress in this society will be totally unacceptable," Sinn Féin's John O'Dowd said. | "Anything that gives the DUP or extreme unionism any veto on progress in this society will be totally unacceptable," Sinn Féin's John O'Dowd said. |
Mr O'Dowd added that the backstop was "as good as it gets." | Mr O'Dowd added that the backstop was "as good as it gets." |
"I'm of the view that there are elements of the DUP who now want a no deal, who would be perfectly happy with all that a no deal brings with it and have linked themselves to the extreme right wing of the Tory party," he said. | "I'm of the view that there are elements of the DUP who now want a no deal, who would be perfectly happy with all that a no deal brings with it and have linked themselves to the extreme right wing of the Tory party," he said. |
Ulster Unionist Party leader Robin Swann described the document as "insulting". | |
"No amount of political assurances or explanatory notes will change the fact that there are fundamental problems with the backstop and the democratic deficit it will create," he said. | |
Haven't we been here before? | Haven't we been here before? |
In October 2018 it was reported that the British government would contain some kind of role for assembly members over what kind of backstop would emerge if there was a no-deal Brexit. | |
Sinn Féin and the SDLP rejected the suggestions at the time. | Sinn Féin and the SDLP rejected the suggestions at the time. |
When the backstop was first agreed in December 2017 the joint statement from the UK and EU said if there was no agreement on how to prevent a hard border, then there would be no new regulatory barriers between Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK unless the assembly agreed that Northern Ireland needed "distinct arrangements". | |
Why have the proposals come forward now? | Why have the proposals come forward now? |
A vote on the draft withdrawal agreement is scheduled to take place in the House of Commons on Tuesday, after the original vote was cancelled on 11 December. | A vote on the draft withdrawal agreement is scheduled to take place in the House of Commons on Tuesday, after the original vote was cancelled on 11 December. |
Mrs May relies on the support of the DUP's 10 MPs and it is highly unlikely the withdrawal agreement will be approved by Parliament if they vote against it. | |
The DUP has repeatedly said it is opposed to the backstop and the withdrawal agreement is worse than a no-deal Brexit. | |
Mrs May has been seeking extra written assurances from European leaders to try and gain the support of the DUP and many Conservative MPs who oppose her deal. |