This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jan/10/jeremy-corbyn-election-nightmare-labour-brexit

The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
If Jeremy Corbyn gets his election, it would be a nightmare for Labour An election would be a headache for Labour – and all-out war for the Tories
(about 2 hours later)
Jeremy Corbyn called for a general election in a speech in Wakefield on Thursday morning. That’s what oppositions do, so what’s new? The government’s essential, all-consuming, defining policy of our era is about to be voted down in parliament. The shadow of the loss of 5,000 Jaguar Land Rover jobs sharpens the immediacy of the nightmare – with Brexit said to be partly to blame. As Corbyn declared: “A government that cannot get its business through the House of Commons is no government at all.”Jeremy Corbyn called for a general election in a speech in Wakefield on Thursday morning. That’s what oppositions do, so what’s new? The government’s essential, all-consuming, defining policy of our era is about to be voted down in parliament. The shadow of the loss of 5,000 Jaguar Land Rover jobs sharpens the immediacy of the nightmare – with Brexit said to be partly to blame. As Corbyn declared: “A government that cannot get its business through the House of Commons is no government at all.”
That used to mean a government fell, and a prime minister resigned, with an election inevitable. No longer. Instead, here is a government with no majority, surviving only on bungs to a handful of unionist extremists who don’t represent remain-voting Northern Ireland. Even then, it still loses vote after humiliating vote, with no intention of resigning in the honourable, old-fashioned way. If John Bercow – this morning dubbed “speaker of the devil” by the Sun – is stretching the rules, he is only responding to this extraordinary constitutional crisis. The spirit of his role is to stand up for parliament, as this majority-less government makes serial attempts to deny MPs any say. That used to mean a government fell and a prime minister resigned, with an election inevitable. No longer. Instead, here is a government with no majority, surviving only on bungs to a handful of unionist extremists who don’t represent remain-voting Northern Ireland. Even then, it still loses vote after humiliating vote, with no intention of resigning in the honourable, old-fashioned way. If John Bercow – this morning called “speaker of the devil” by the Sun – is stretching the rules, he is only responding to this extraordinary constitutional crisis. The spirit of his role is to stand up for parliament, as this majority-less government makes serial attempts to deny MPs any say.
An election called now would cause both major parties near-terminal dilemmas in how to fight itAn election called now would cause both major parties near-terminal dilemmas in how to fight it
If, as expected, the PM’s deal fails on 15 January, Labour will immediately call for a vote of no confidence in her government, as it should. But it’s unlikely any Tories will vote to bring themselves down, causing an immediate election. The Labour conference prescribed a sequence for what happens next, deciding to keep open all options, including a second referendum.If, as expected, the PM’s deal fails on 15 January, Labour will immediately call for a vote of no confidence in her government, as it should. But it’s unlikely any Tories will vote to bring themselves down, causing an immediate election. The Labour conference prescribed a sequence for what happens next, deciding to keep open all options, including a second referendum.
But what if Corbyn got his wish? It is just possible: if the likes of Amber Rudd and Dominic Grieve think their own government is driving Britain headlong into a no-deal exit, they might pull the emergency brake and vote themselves down. But an election called now would cause both major parties near-terminal dilemmas in how to fight it. Labour might hope and try to make it about other issues, but this time there would be no ducking the question. On Thursday, Corbyn talked of a victorious Labour government re-opening negotiations on better terms. That’s what he must say this week, in the prescribed sequencing, but next week that will change. It is entirely impossible that Labour, its members, its MPs and polling pressure from its voters, could allow a campaign in favour of any kind of Brexit. But nor, many say, could it baldly call for remain. It would have to put a referendum into its manifesto, with the party supporting remain. There would be dissenters. But what if Corbyn got his wish? It is just possible: if the likes of Amber Rudd and Dominic Grieve think their own government is driving Britain headlong into a no-deal exit, they might pull the emergency brake and vote themselves down. But an election called now would cause both major parties near-terminal dilemmas in how to fight it. Labour might hope, and try, to make it about other issues, but this time there would be no ducking the question. On Thursday, Corbyn talked of a victorious Labour government reopening negotiations on better terms. That’s what he must say this week, in the prescribed sequencing, but next week that will change. It is entirely impossible that Labour, its members, its MPs and polling pressure from its voters could allow a campaign in favour of any kind of Brexit; but nor, many say, could it baldly call for remain. It would have to put a referendum into its manifesto, with the party supporting remain. There would be dissenters.
But that would be nothing compared with the warfare that would break out over the Tory manifesto in an election now. The party would fragment in radically different directions, European Research Group versus remainers, referendumites, Canadians and Norwegians. Besides, they would need a new leader fast and their membership would choose a more divisive ardent Brexiteer. But that would be nothing compared with the warfare that would break out over the Tory manifesto in an election now. The party would fragment in radically different directions: European Research Group v remainers, referendumites, Canadians and Norwegians. Besides, they would need a new leader fast, and their membership would choose a more divisive ardent Brexiteer.
A chaotic general election might be catnip to political commentators, psephologists and constitutional academics, fuelling speculation that out of this mayhem new parties might be forged in a changed political landscape. Frankly, I see no significant change without proportional representation. Until then, iron electoral lore locks all change within the two and half parties we have, crushing newcomers. Voters will still have to hold their noses and vote for the portmanteau party they least dislike, far left and far right of each party obliged to cohabit unhappily. Just possibly out of all this might come popular demand for electoral reform, an understanding that this is no dry constitutional Westminster topic, but a burning democratic right to vote for a party of their own choice. There’s no sign of this as yet. A chaotic general election might be catnip to political commentators, psephologists and constitutional academics, fuelling speculation that out of this mayhem new parties might be forged in a changed political landscape. Frankly, I see no significant change without proportional representation. Until then, iron electoral lore locks all change within the two and half parties we have, crushing newcomers. Voters will still have to hold their noses and vote for the portmanteau party they least dislike, far left and far right of each party obliged to cohabit unhappily. Just possibly out of all this might come popular demand for electoral reform – an understanding that this is no dry constitutional Westminster topic but a burning democratic right to vote for a party of their own choice. There’s no sign of this as yet.
Brexit: May loses grip on deal after fresh Commons humiliationBrexit: May loses grip on deal after fresh Commons humiliation
Back to Labour and Corbyn’s speech: I remain optimistic that Labour will do the right thing at every crucial stage in this Brexit agony. It has so far. Labour people have been infuriated by Corbyn’s apparent – and probable – support for Brexit; his lifelong views unchanged. But what matters is what he does. Step by step, shadow Brexit secretary Keir Starmer and shadow chancellor John McDonnell, the tacticians who never take their eye off an ultimate Labour victory, have been careful not to get ahead of the game, cautious not to offend Labour leave seats. The Mirror reports that some 20 Labour MPs in leave seats might vote for May’s deal if an amendment passes guaranteeing working and environmental rights. I have my doubts: some might abstain – but vote for this Tory government? Surely not. Back to Labour and Corbyn’s speech: I remain optimistic that Labour will do the right thing at every crucial stage in this Brexit agony. It has so far. Labour people have been infuriated by Corbyn’s apparent – and probable – support for Brexit, his lifelong views unchanged. But what matters is what he does. Step by step the shadow Brexit secretary, Keir Starmer, and shadow chancellor, John McDonnell, the tacticians who never take their eye off an ultimate Labour victory, have been sure not to get ahead of the game, careful not to offend Labour leave seats. The Mirror reports that some 20 Labour MPs in leave seats might vote for May’s deal if an amendment passes guaranteeing working and environmental rights. I have my doubts: some might abstain – but vote for this Tory government? Surely not.
If/when May’s deal falls, and Labour fails to summon up an election, there will be just three days – probably only hours – for Labour to declare its next step. In that time, May is obliged to produce her plan B or a tweaked plan A again. Here comes the crunch. Convenient flannelling and ambivalence will end. On Tuesday, Starmer suggested article 50 and withdrawal would have to be extended, but he knows that’s only likely to be allowed for an election or a referendum, not for more dithering. Corbyn didn’t mention that in his speech, nor has he called for a referendum, yet, sticking to a Labour Brexit plan: but then timing is everything. Thursday was not the day – but decision time will come after next Tuesday. If/when May’s deal falls, and Labour fails to summon up an election, there will be just three days – probably only hours – for Labour to declare its next step. In that time, May is obliged to produce her plan B or a tweaked plan A again. Here comes the crunch. Convenient flannelling and ambivalence will end. On Tuesday, Starmer suggested article 50 and withdrawal would have to be extended, but he knows that’s likely to be allowed only for an election or a referendum, not for more dithering. Corbyn didn’t mention that in his speech. Nor has he called for a referendum yet, sticking to a Labour Brexit plan: but then timing is everything. This was not the day – but decision time will come after next Tuesday.
Labour’s tacticians will be acutely mindful of the stark polling figures. When YouGov asked how people would vote if Labour supported going ahead with Brexit, Labour slumped to third place, at 22%, behind the Liberal Democrats, who jumped to 26%. That’s a mistake Labour will never make, whatever Corbyn’s private predilections.Labour’s tacticians will be acutely mindful of the stark polling figures. When YouGov asked how people would vote if Labour supported going ahead with Brexit, Labour slumped to third place, at 22%, behind the Liberal Democrats, who jumped to 26%. That’s a mistake Labour will never make, whatever Corbyn’s private predilections.
• Polly Toynbee is a Guardian columnist• Polly Toynbee is a Guardian columnist
LabourLabour
First thoughtsFirst thoughts
BrexitBrexit
Jeremy CorbynJeremy Corbyn
Keir StarmerKeir Starmer
John McDonnellJohn McDonnell
Conservatives
commentcomment
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook
Share on TwitterShare on Twitter
Share via EmailShare via Email
Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn
Share on PinterestShare on Pinterest
Share on Google+Share on Google+
Share on WhatsAppShare on WhatsApp
Share on MessengerShare on Messenger
Reuse this contentReuse this content