This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/mar/12/tory-brexiter-support-for-may-deal-to-hinge-on-legal-advice
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 4 | Version 5 |
|---|---|
| Tory Brexiter support for May deal to hinge on legal advice | Tory Brexiter support for May deal to hinge on legal advice |
| (14 days later) | |
| Conservative Brexiters have said they will assess the EU’s new assurances based on whether the UK could leave the backstop “at the time of our choosing”, with the decision likely to hinge on the revised legal advice of the attorney general, Geoffrey Cox. | Conservative Brexiters have said they will assess the EU’s new assurances based on whether the UK could leave the backstop “at the time of our choosing”, with the decision likely to hinge on the revised legal advice of the attorney general, Geoffrey Cox. |
| Variously described as an insurance policy or safety net, the backstop is a device in the withdrawal agreement intended to ensure that there will not be a hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, even if no formal deal can be reached on trade and security arrangements. | |
| It would mean that if there were no workable agreement on such matters, Northern Ireland would stay in the customs union and much of the single market, guaranteeing a friction-free border with the Republic. This would keep the Good Friday agreement intact. | It would mean that if there were no workable agreement on such matters, Northern Ireland would stay in the customs union and much of the single market, guaranteeing a friction-free border with the Republic. This would keep the Good Friday agreement intact. |
| Both the UK and EU signed up to the basic idea in December 2017 as part of the initial Brexit deal, but there have been disagreements since on how it would work. | Both the UK and EU signed up to the basic idea in December 2017 as part of the initial Brexit deal, but there have been disagreements since on how it would work. |
| The DUP have objected to it, as it potentially treats Northern Ireland differently from the rest of the UK, creating a customs divide in the Irish Sea, which is anathema to the unionist party. | |
| Hardline Tory Eurosceptics also object to it, as they perceive it to be a trap that could potentially lock the UK into the EU’s customs union permanently if the UK & EU cannot seal a free trade agreement. That would prevent the UK from doing its own free trade deals with nations outside the bloc. | |
| Joint interpretative instrument | Joint interpretative instrument |
| A legal add-on to the withdrawal agreement was given to Theresa May in January 2019 to try to get her deal through the UK parliament. It gives legal force to a letter from Jean-Claude Juncker and Donald Tusk, the presidents of the commission and council. This stated the EU’s intention to negotiate an alternative to the backstop so it would not be triggered, or, if it was triggered, to get out of it as quickly as possible. | |
| Unilateral statement from the UK | Unilateral statement from the UK |
| This set out the British position that, if the backstop were to become permanent and talks on an alternative were going nowhere, the UK believes it would be able to exit the arrangement. | |
| Additional language in political declaration | Additional language in political declaration |
| This emphasises the urgency felt on both sides to negotiate an alternative to the backstop, and flesh out what a technological fix would look like. However, it failed to persuade the attorney general, Geoffrey Cox, who said that while it ‘reduces the risk’ of the UK being trapped in a backstop indefinitely, it does not remove it. | |
| Boris Johnson declared the Northern Ireland backstop ‘dead’ during his leadership campaign, and promised to throw it out of any deal he renegotiated with the EU. The EU has repeatedly stated that it will not reopen the withdrawal agreement for renegotiation. | |
| Daniel Boffey, Martin Belam and Peter Walker | Daniel Boffey, Martin Belam and Peter Walker |
| Michael Gove said it was “make your mind up time for all of us” and that MPs would have to balance “a series of risks” when they voted on Theresa May’s Brexit deal on Tuesday evening. | Michael Gove said it was “make your mind up time for all of us” and that MPs would have to balance “a series of risks” when they voted on Theresa May’s Brexit deal on Tuesday evening. |
| “If we don’t back this new improved deal tonight, we may find ourselves having Brexit delayed and diluted, which I think would be a grave error and would not honour the vote of 17.4 million people,” the environment secretary told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme. | “If we don’t back this new improved deal tonight, we may find ourselves having Brexit delayed and diluted, which I think would be a grave error and would not honour the vote of 17.4 million people,” the environment secretary told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme. |
| “And there’s another risk that sees us leaving the EU without a deal and that would undoubtedly cause a degree of economic turbulence which would hit jobs and affect the economic prosperity of our citizens.” | “And there’s another risk that sees us leaving the EU without a deal and that would undoubtedly cause a degree of economic turbulence which would hit jobs and affect the economic prosperity of our citizens.” |
| May made an 11th-hour dash to Strasbourg on Monday night, announcing the revisions at a joint press conference with Jean-Claude Juncker, the European commission president. | May made an 11th-hour dash to Strasbourg on Monday night, announcing the revisions at a joint press conference with Jean-Claude Juncker, the European commission president. |
| Juncker said the legal add-on to the Brexit deal, which emphasises the temporary nature of the backstop, “complements the withdrawal agreement without reopening it”. | Juncker said the legal add-on to the Brexit deal, which emphasises the temporary nature of the backstop, “complements the withdrawal agreement without reopening it”. |
| Cox was to published revised legal analysis of the revisions on Tuesday morning and the Speaker, John Bercow, has hinted he would be open to MPs efforts’ to force Cox to the chamber to answer questions before the debate on the deal is opened by May on Tuesday afternoon. | Cox was to published revised legal analysis of the revisions on Tuesday morning and the Speaker, John Bercow, has hinted he would be open to MPs efforts’ to force Cox to the chamber to answer questions before the debate on the deal is opened by May on Tuesday afternoon. |
| The former Tory leader and Brexiter Iain Duncan Smith urged May to give MPs another 24 hours before voting. | The former Tory leader and Brexiter Iain Duncan Smith urged May to give MPs another 24 hours before voting. |
| “If it is correct that this backstop is both temporary and we can leave it at the moment of our choosing, that means we become a balanced partner in the negotiations,” he told Today. “That is how critical this really is. What we decide today will decide whether or not we will get a good relationship afterwards or whether we get spoon-fed what the EU wants us to be.” | “If it is correct that this backstop is both temporary and we can leave it at the moment of our choosing, that means we become a balanced partner in the negotiations,” he told Today. “That is how critical this really is. What we decide today will decide whether or not we will get a good relationship afterwards or whether we get spoon-fed what the EU wants us to be.” |
| David Davis, the former Brexit secretary, said of the votes of Eurosceptics: “All now depends on the attorney general’s legal advice. It is critical that he confirms we can escape this backstop.” | David Davis, the former Brexit secretary, said of the votes of Eurosceptics: “All now depends on the attorney general’s legal advice. It is critical that he confirms we can escape this backstop.” |
| Jacob Rees-Mogg, who chairs the European Reasearch Group (ERG) of Eurosceptic Tories, said many Conservatives would be heavily influenced by the view of the Democratic Unionist party, but he was open-minded. | Jacob Rees-Mogg, who chairs the European Reasearch Group (ERG) of Eurosceptic Tories, said many Conservatives would be heavily influenced by the view of the Democratic Unionist party, but he was open-minded. |
| “I’m not sure the agreements with the EU are a major change, that they continue to be promises of goodwill,” he told Today. “So my focus will be on whether the unilateral declaration is genuinely unilateral.” | “I’m not sure the agreements with the EU are a major change, that they continue to be promises of goodwill,” he told Today. “So my focus will be on whether the unilateral declaration is genuinely unilateral.” |
| The ERG has said a group of eight lawyers, seven of them MPs, would scrutinise and pass judgment on Cox’s final analysis of the offer. | The ERG has said a group of eight lawyers, seven of them MPs, would scrutinise and pass judgment on Cox’s final analysis of the offer. |
| The Brexit state of play: a guide to this week's crucial votes | The Brexit state of play: a guide to this week's crucial votes |
| The seven MPs are Nigel Dodds – the deputy leader of the DUP, whose opinion carries weight with Eurosceptic Conservatives – as well as the former Brexit secretary Dominic Raab, the ex-ministers David Jones and Suella Braverman, the veteran Brexiter Bill Cash, and the backbenchers Michael Tomlinson and Robert Courts. They are joined by Martin Howe QC, the chair of the pro-leave group Lawyers for Britain. | The seven MPs are Nigel Dodds – the deputy leader of the DUP, whose opinion carries weight with Eurosceptic Conservatives – as well as the former Brexit secretary Dominic Raab, the ex-ministers David Jones and Suella Braverman, the veteran Brexiter Bill Cash, and the backbenchers Michael Tomlinson and Robert Courts. They are joined by Martin Howe QC, the chair of the pro-leave group Lawyers for Britain. |
| The group is expected to decide whether to recommend accepting the assurances later in the afternoon. | The group is expected to decide whether to recommend accepting the assurances later in the afternoon. |
| Gove, a leader of the Vote Leave campaign, said the EU had “made clear that the backstop is intended to be temporary, that is clear, it is in black and white and it’s a legally binding declaration”. | Gove, a leader of the Vote Leave campaign, said the EU had “made clear that the backstop is intended to be temporary, that is clear, it is in black and white and it’s a legally binding declaration”. |
| The new assurances have three parts. The first is a joint interpretative instrument, designed to give legally binding assurances to the letter written by Juncker and the chief EU negotiator, Michel Barnier, in January that the backstop cannot be a permanent solution to the Northern Ireland border issue. The document is intended to have equal legal weight to the withdrawal agreement itself. | The new assurances have three parts. The first is a joint interpretative instrument, designed to give legally binding assurances to the letter written by Juncker and the chief EU negotiator, Michel Barnier, in January that the backstop cannot be a permanent solution to the Northern Ireland border issue. The document is intended to have equal legal weight to the withdrawal agreement itself. |
| The second is a joint statement on the future trade relationship that says that both sides will pursue “alternative arrangements” to the backstop over the next 20 months in good faith. | The second is a joint statement on the future trade relationship that says that both sides will pursue “alternative arrangements” to the backstop over the next 20 months in good faith. |
| Thirdly, the UK has issued its own unilateral declaration, asserting that it will apply to the independent arbitration panel to dismantle the backstop provisions if the government believes the EU is not making efforts to end the arrangement. | Thirdly, the UK has issued its own unilateral declaration, asserting that it will apply to the independent arbitration panel to dismantle the backstop provisions if the government believes the EU is not making efforts to end the arrangement. |
| May will need to convince the vast majority of Tory Brexiters and the DUP in order for her deal to pass and is likely to face continued opposition from Tory remainers, Labour and most opposition parties. About 20 Labour MPs are believed to be seriously considering voting for the deal, with some party sources suggesting the number may be as high as 60. | May will need to convince the vast majority of Tory Brexiters and the DUP in order for her deal to pass and is likely to face continued opposition from Tory remainers, Labour and most opposition parties. About 20 Labour MPs are believed to be seriously considering voting for the deal, with some party sources suggesting the number may be as high as 60. |
| Will Brexit be decided today? | Will Brexit be decided today? |
| The shadow Brexit secretary, Keir Starmer, said there was nothing in the assurances that had not been present before the last meaningful vote, and that May had failed on one of her key aims: to change the text of the withdrawal agreement. | The shadow Brexit secretary, Keir Starmer, said there was nothing in the assurances that had not been present before the last meaningful vote, and that May had failed on one of her key aims: to change the text of the withdrawal agreement. |
| He said the UK’s unilateral declaration was meaningless. “This is a bit like someone saying: ‘I have read my home insurance agreement, this is what I think it means,’” he told Today. | He said the UK’s unilateral declaration was meaningless. “This is a bit like someone saying: ‘I have read my home insurance agreement, this is what I think it means,’” he told Today. |
| However, Gove said the unilateral declaration “had not been rejected or undermined by the EU, so that too has political and legal standing and is legally material”. | However, Gove said the unilateral declaration “had not been rejected or undermined by the EU, so that too has political and legal standing and is legally material”. |
| Starmer, the former director of public prosecutions, released his own legal assessment of the deal on Tuesday morning. | Starmer, the former director of public prosecutions, released his own legal assessment of the deal on Tuesday morning. |
| “Having studied the documents, I would be surprised if they are sufficient to enable the attorney general to change the central plank of his December legal advice,” it said. | “Having studied the documents, I would be surprised if they are sufficient to enable the attorney general to change the central plank of his December legal advice,” it said. |
| Cox’s legal advice said the backstop “would endure indefinitely until a superseding agreement takes its place in whole or in part”. | Cox’s legal advice said the backstop “would endure indefinitely until a superseding agreement takes its place in whole or in part”. |
| Starmer’s advice said: “The withdrawal agreement does not include a mechanism for unilateral exit from – or termination of – the backstop (or any other part of the agreement) even where bad faith is made out. | Starmer’s advice said: “The withdrawal agreement does not include a mechanism for unilateral exit from – or termination of – the backstop (or any other part of the agreement) even where bad faith is made out. |
| “Turning the content of the 14 January letter from Donald Tusk and Jean-Claude Juncker into a joint interpretative declaration does not change that. Nor in my view does anything else agreed last night.” | “Turning the content of the 14 January letter from Donald Tusk and Jean-Claude Juncker into a joint interpretative declaration does not change that. Nor in my view does anything else agreed last night.” |
| Brexit | Brexit |
| European Union | European Union |
| Foreign policy | Foreign policy |
| Europe | Europe |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |