This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/inequality/2019/may/16/why-we-are-troubled-by-elitist-inequality-review

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
This inequality review is elitist – it needs broader expertise Why we are troubled by elitist inequality review
(about 1 hour later)
We welcome the idea of a major review of inequality (Britain ‘risks heading to US levels of inequality’, 14 May). With Brexit looming and recent analyses linking income inequality to voting for rightwing populists, mass shootings, mental ill health, status consumerism and domestic violence, this is indeed a critical issue for our times.We welcome the idea of a major review of inequality (Britain ‘risks heading to US levels of inequality’, 14 May). With Brexit looming and recent analyses linking income inequality to voting for rightwing populists, mass shootings, mental ill health, status consumerism and domestic violence, this is indeed a critical issue for our times.
However, there is widespread concern about the composition of this review’s “expert panel”, which has a majority of white economists. Although the panel includes an expert on health inequalities, none of the world’s leading experts on the health and psychosocial effects of income inequality itself are included, nor is there expertise in the spatial aspects of inequality. And there is a conspicuous absence of world-leading economists for whom income inequality is their primary focus – no Piketty, no Stiglitz, no Galbraith, no Frank, no Fitoussi, no Palma, no Chang, no Milanovic. Sir Angus Deaton, leading the review, stated in the journal Science in 2014 that he “get[s] angry” about the theory that inequality has psychological and social effects on health – perhaps he has changed his mind now that his own research has uncovered rising deaths from addiction and suicide in the US, but there are many researchers with much greater depth in this area. Even more troubling, there is no ethnic minority representation on the “expert panel”, no people with lived experience of inequality, no representatives of charities, trade unions or other NGOs. The number of disciplines represented is also small, although the impact of inequality goes far beyond economics.However, there is widespread concern about the composition of this review’s “expert panel”, which has a majority of white economists. Although the panel includes an expert on health inequalities, none of the world’s leading experts on the health and psychosocial effects of income inequality itself are included, nor is there expertise in the spatial aspects of inequality. And there is a conspicuous absence of world-leading economists for whom income inequality is their primary focus – no Piketty, no Stiglitz, no Galbraith, no Frank, no Fitoussi, no Palma, no Chang, no Milanovic. Sir Angus Deaton, leading the review, stated in the journal Science in 2014 that he “get[s] angry” about the theory that inequality has psychological and social effects on health – perhaps he has changed his mind now that his own research has uncovered rising deaths from addiction and suicide in the US, but there are many researchers with much greater depth in this area. Even more troubling, there is no ethnic minority representation on the “expert panel”, no people with lived experience of inequality, no representatives of charities, trade unions or other NGOs. The number of disciplines represented is also small, although the impact of inequality goes far beyond economics.
We, and others, have been researching, educating and campaigning on inequality for many years, we understand the issues and we know what needs to be done. We cannot wait five years for a report from a worryingly elitist review. Getting policymakers and politicians to tackle inequality will require grassroots support from those most affected and is needed urgently.We, and others, have been researching, educating and campaigning on inequality for many years, we understand the issues and we know what needs to be done. We cannot wait five years for a report from a worryingly elitist review. Getting policymakers and politicians to tackle inequality will require grassroots support from those most affected and is needed urgently.
Kate Pickett Professor of epidemiology and research champion for justice and equality, University of YorkRichard Wilkinson Emeritus professor of social epidemiology, University of NottinghamDanny Dorling Harold Mackinder professor of geography, University of OxfordDr Faiza Shaheen Director, CLASSDimitris Ballas Professor of economic geography, University of GroningenGuy Standing Professor of development studies, Soas University of LondonDr Lorenza Antonucci School of social policy, University of BirminghamRoberto De Vogli Associate professor, department of development and social psychology, and Human Rights Centre, University of PaduaAnn Pettifor Director of Policy Research in Macroeconomics (PRIME)Paul C Sutton Professor of geography and the environment, University of DenverSusan Himmelweit Emeritus professor of economics, Open University, Women’s Budget GroupDr Johnna Montgomerie Reader in international political economy, King’s College LondonJohn Weeks Professor emeritus, Soas University of LondonDirk Philipsen Associate research professor of economic history, Duke UniversityDr Mary-Ann Stephenson Director, Women’s Budget GroupRuth Pearson Emeritus professor of development studies, University of Leeds, and management committee, Women’s Budget GroupDr Andrea Westall Senior visiting fellow, Open University, and Commissioner for Sustainable EqualityCharlotte O’Brien Professor of law, University of YorkRev Paul Nicolson Founder, Taxpayers Against PovertyMichael Pirson Associate professor of management, global sustainability, and social entrepreneurship, Fordham UniversityLouka T Katseli Professor of economics, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, and co-chair of the Independent Commission on Sustainable Equality, Progressive SocietyLindsay Stringer Professor of environment and development, University of LeedsJulia K Steinberger Professor of social ecology and ecological economics, University of LeedsHunter Lovins President, Natural Capitalism SolutionsJonathan Bradshaw Professor emeritus of social policy, University of YorkRobert Costanza VC’s chair in public policy, Australian National UniversityJames Ward Associate professor, school of natural and built environments, University of South AustraliaTim Doran Professor of health policy, University of YorkDr Keri Chiveralls Adjunct research fellow, Central Queensland UniversityMary Anne Mercer Senior lecturer emerita, Department of Global Health, University of WashingtonDr Stephen Bezruchka Senior lecturer in health services and global health, University of WashingtonRoger Burrows Professor of cities, Newcastle UniversityIda Kubiszewski Associate professor in public policy, Australian National UniversityBev Skeggs Professor of sociology, University of LancasterRowland Atkinson Research chair in inclusive societies, University of SheffieldKristín Vala Ragnarsdóttir Professor of sustainability science, University of IcelandRichard Murphy Professor of practice in international political economy, City, University of London, and director of Tax Research UKJacqueline McGlade Professor of resilience and sustainable development, University College LondonDamien Morrison Trustee, Tax WatchNick Meynen Policy officer for environmental and economic justice, European Environmental BureauKate Pickett Professor of epidemiology and research champion for justice and equality, University of YorkRichard Wilkinson Emeritus professor of social epidemiology, University of NottinghamDanny Dorling Harold Mackinder professor of geography, University of OxfordDr Faiza Shaheen Director, CLASSDimitris Ballas Professor of economic geography, University of GroningenGuy Standing Professor of development studies, Soas University of LondonDr Lorenza Antonucci School of social policy, University of BirminghamRoberto De Vogli Associate professor, department of development and social psychology, and Human Rights Centre, University of PaduaAnn Pettifor Director of Policy Research in Macroeconomics (PRIME)Paul C Sutton Professor of geography and the environment, University of DenverSusan Himmelweit Emeritus professor of economics, Open University, Women’s Budget GroupDr Johnna Montgomerie Reader in international political economy, King’s College LondonJohn Weeks Professor emeritus, Soas University of LondonDirk Philipsen Associate research professor of economic history, Duke UniversityDr Mary-Ann Stephenson Director, Women’s Budget GroupRuth Pearson Emeritus professor of development studies, University of Leeds, and management committee, Women’s Budget GroupDr Andrea Westall Senior visiting fellow, Open University, and Commissioner for Sustainable EqualityCharlotte O’Brien Professor of law, University of YorkRev Paul Nicolson Founder, Taxpayers Against PovertyMichael Pirson Associate professor of management, global sustainability, and social entrepreneurship, Fordham UniversityLouka T Katseli Professor of economics, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, and co-chair of the Independent Commission on Sustainable Equality, Progressive SocietyLindsay Stringer Professor of environment and development, University of LeedsJulia K Steinberger Professor of social ecology and ecological economics, University of LeedsHunter Lovins President, Natural Capitalism SolutionsJonathan Bradshaw Professor emeritus of social policy, University of YorkRobert Costanza VC’s chair in public policy, Australian National UniversityJames Ward Associate professor, school of natural and built environments, University of South AustraliaTim Doran Professor of health policy, University of YorkDr Keri Chiveralls Adjunct research fellow, Central Queensland UniversityMary Anne Mercer Senior lecturer emerita, Department of Global Health, University of WashingtonDr Stephen Bezruchka Senior lecturer in health services and global health, University of WashingtonRoger Burrows Professor of cities, Newcastle UniversityIda Kubiszewski Associate professor in public policy, Australian National UniversityBev Skeggs Professor of sociology, University of LancasterRowland Atkinson Research chair in inclusive societies, University of SheffieldKristín Vala Ragnarsdóttir Professor of sustainability science, University of IcelandRichard Murphy Professor of practice in international political economy, City, University of London, and director of Tax Research UKJacqueline McGlade Professor of resilience and sustainable development, University College LondonDamien Morrison Trustee, Tax WatchNick Meynen Policy officer for environmental and economic justice, European Environmental Bureau
• In 1968, when I went to university in Coventry, the local car workers successfully struck for a weekly wage of £40. They were accused of grabbing more than their share of the “national cake”. Fifty years on, the share of the national cake that goes to the workers who produce it has declined from roughly 70% to 50%; the rest goes to shareholders as unearned income.• In 1968, when I went to university in Coventry, the local car workers successfully struck for a weekly wage of £40. They were accused of grabbing more than their share of the “national cake”. Fifty years on, the share of the national cake that goes to the workers who produce it has declined from roughly 70% to 50%; the rest goes to shareholders as unearned income.
The IFS Deaton review will consider how this has come about, but surely it is evident that this has been the project of Thatcherism, with its legislation against the rights of workers and their trade unions. The Blair-Brown governments failed to reverse this and sought to mask its effects by boosting state benefits to working families.The IFS Deaton review will consider how this has come about, but surely it is evident that this has been the project of Thatcherism, with its legislation against the rights of workers and their trade unions. The Blair-Brown governments failed to reverse this and sought to mask its effects by boosting state benefits to working families.
The review will investigate inequality and the “aspects of it [that] are perceived to be fair and unfair”. But the Brexit debate has shown how easy it is to build perceptions of unfairness, with talk of bullying bureaucracies and metropolitan elites. It’s not difficult to set up oppositions between south and north, or between young and old. Until the balance between workers and shareholders is shifted back in workers’ favour, inequality and the dangers of populist political rhetoric can only grow.David SangBrightonThe review will investigate inequality and the “aspects of it [that] are perceived to be fair and unfair”. But the Brexit debate has shown how easy it is to build perceptions of unfairness, with talk of bullying bureaucracies and metropolitan elites. It’s not difficult to set up oppositions between south and north, or between young and old. Until the balance between workers and shareholders is shifted back in workers’ favour, inequality and the dangers of populist political rhetoric can only grow.David SangBrighton
• It is hardly surprising that two nations whose development has been driven by financial gain and greed share a common trend of growing inequality. It is inevitable that countries like the UK and US that measure success by economic growth will always favour those who already have wealth. In the circumstances it seems unfathomable that it needs five years to conclude that the rich get richer and the poor get poorer.Ian MitchellPreston• It is hardly surprising that two nations whose development has been driven by financial gain and greed share a common trend of growing inequality. It is inevitable that countries like the UK and US that measure success by economic growth will always favour those who already have wealth. In the circumstances it seems unfathomable that it needs five years to conclude that the rich get richer and the poor get poorer.Ian MitchellPreston
• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com
• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters
• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition• Do you have a photo you’d like to share with Guardian readers? Click here to upload it and we’ll publish the best submissions in the letters spread of our print edition
InequalityInequality
EconomicsEconomics
Economic policyEconomic policy
Trade unionsTrade unions
lettersletters
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook
Share on TwitterShare on Twitter
Share via EmailShare via Email
Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn
Share on PinterestShare on Pinterest
Share on WhatsAppShare on WhatsApp
Share on MessengerShare on Messenger
Reuse this contentReuse this content