This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-48419144
The article has changed 15 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 8 | Version 9 |
|---|---|
| European elections 2019: Jeremy Corbyn refuses to explicitly back another referendum | European elections 2019: Jeremy Corbyn refuses to explicitly back another referendum |
| (30 minutes later) | |
| Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has refused to explicitly back the idea of another referendum - despite increasing calls from within his party to do so. | Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has refused to explicitly back the idea of another referendum - despite increasing calls from within his party to do so. |
| He was speaking after the party won 14% of the vote in EU elections. | He was speaking after the party won 14% of the vote in EU elections. |
| Senior Labour figures including deputy leader Tom Watson and shadow foreign secretary Emily Thornberry have called for Labour to be clearer in its support for a fresh Brexit referendum. | Senior Labour figures including deputy leader Tom Watson and shadow foreign secretary Emily Thornberry have called for Labour to be clearer in its support for a fresh Brexit referendum. |
| Mr Corbyn said any deal with the EU should be put to a "public vote". | Mr Corbyn said any deal with the EU should be put to a "public vote". |
| "We had a very clear policy all along," Mr Corbyn said. "We will call for a general election and a referendum to decide on the future." | "We had a very clear policy all along," Mr Corbyn said. "We will call for a general election and a referendum to decide on the future." |
| When asked if he would back a second referendum, and campaign for the UK to remain in the EU, he said there should be "an agreement made" (with the EU) which would then be "put to a public vote". | When asked if he would back a second referendum, and campaign for the UK to remain in the EU, he said there should be "an agreement made" (with the EU) which would then be "put to a public vote". |
| Mr Corbyn also denied claims from Labour MP David Lammy that the party had "tried to ride two horses" and "fell flat on our faces". | |
| Labour has tried to keep both Leave and Remain supporters on side by saying it accepts the result of the 2016 vote but also keeping the option of another referendum on the table if it is unable to force a general election or achieve a Brexit deal with the Tories it can endorse. | |
| "What we've tried to do is bring people together, whether they voted Leave or Remain, they still face problems of a Tory government in disintegration," Mr Corbyn said. | |
| The Labour leader said the party was "listening carefully" to its members and supporters - who would be consulted before the issue was brought back to the party's conference in September. | The Labour leader said the party was "listening carefully" to its members and supporters - who would be consulted before the issue was brought back to the party's conference in September. |
| Meanwhile, shadow chancellor John McDonnell told the BBC another referendum may be the only way to break the Brexit deadlock. | |
| Faced with the prospect of a "Brexiteer extremist" leading the Conservative Party, Mr McDonnell said Labour would back a fresh Brexit vote to prevent a "catastrophic" no-deal scenario. | |
| "Of course we want a general election, but realistically, after last night there aren't many Tory MPs who're going to vote for a general election - it would be like turkeys voting for Christmas - so our best way of doing that is going back to the people in a referendum," he said. | |
| "If there can be a deal, great, but it needs to go back to the people," he added. | |
| "If it's a no deal we've got to block it and the one way of doing that is I think going back to the people and arguing the case against it." | |
| With only Northern Ireland left to declare, Labour is on 14% of the vote - worse than the party's previous low in 2009 - and finished in fifth place in Scotland. | With only Northern Ireland left to declare, Labour is on 14% of the vote - worse than the party's previous low in 2009 - and finished in fifth place in Scotland. |
| Across Britain, it is in third place, behind the Liberal Democrats (20%) and the Brexit Party (32%). | Across Britain, it is in third place, behind the Liberal Democrats (20%) and the Brexit Party (32%). |
| Deputy leader Tom Watson said the party needed "a change of direction urgently" following the "disastrous" results. | Deputy leader Tom Watson said the party needed "a change of direction urgently" following the "disastrous" results. |
| In a statement, he said the likely election of a "hardline Brexiteer" as Conservative leader put additional pressure on Labour to change its approach. | In a statement, he said the likely election of a "hardline Brexiteer" as Conservative leader put additional pressure on Labour to change its approach. |
| Mr Watson said: "It is now a serious concern that the next Tory prime minister runs down the clock until 31 October and crashes out of the EU with no deal. We cannot let that happen. | Mr Watson said: "It is now a serious concern that the next Tory prime minister runs down the clock until 31 October and crashes out of the EU with no deal. We cannot let that happen. |
| "Labour is rightly calling for a general election. But we cannot go into an election with our current Brexit position." | "Labour is rightly calling for a general election. But we cannot go into an election with our current Brexit position." |
| Shadow foreign secretary Emily Thornberry said Labour's election campaign lacked clarity on Brexit and the party should now campaign to remain in the EU. | Shadow foreign secretary Emily Thornberry said Labour's election campaign lacked clarity on Brexit and the party should now campaign to remain in the EU. |
| Ms Thornberry told the BBC that Labour had done "everything we can to try and get a decent policy on leaving the European Union" but now faced a Conservative leadership which would "insist" on a no-deal Brexit. | Ms Thornberry told the BBC that Labour had done "everything we can to try and get a decent policy on leaving the European Union" but now faced a Conservative leadership which would "insist" on a no-deal Brexit. |
| The party must be "equally clear" by supporting another referendum, she said. | The party must be "equally clear" by supporting another referendum, she said. |
| Meanwhile, shadow Brexit secretary Sir Keir Starmer tweeted that the only way to break the Brexit "impasse" was "to go back to the public with a choice between a credible leave option and remain". | Meanwhile, shadow Brexit secretary Sir Keir Starmer tweeted that the only way to break the Brexit "impasse" was "to go back to the public with a choice between a credible leave option and remain". |
| Analysis | Analysis |
| By Jessica Parker, BBC political correspondent | By Jessica Parker, BBC political correspondent |
| It has long been suggested that the Labour Party leadership has adopted a position of "constructive ambiguity" when it comes to Brexit. So in plain English: fence-sitting. | It has long been suggested that the Labour Party leadership has adopted a position of "constructive ambiguity" when it comes to Brexit. So in plain English: fence-sitting. |
| But that fence has proved to be an increasingly shaky perch and last night's result has all but blown it down. | But that fence has proved to be an increasingly shaky perch and last night's result has all but blown it down. |
| However, despite the heavy winds, it's still not clear which way Jeremy Corbyn will fall on this question of a further referendum. | However, despite the heavy winds, it's still not clear which way Jeremy Corbyn will fall on this question of a further referendum. |
| He has talked today about putting any deal to a public vote - but when questioned what a public vote actually means he suggested that a general election is still the priority. | He has talked today about putting any deal to a public vote - but when questioned what a public vote actually means he suggested that a general election is still the priority. |
| Crucially, the Labour leader has said that members and supporters will be consulted before the issue is brought before party conference in September. Cue a big old argument. | Crucially, the Labour leader has said that members and supporters will be consulted before the issue is brought before party conference in September. Cue a big old argument. |
| Because while there are many Labour supporters who believe that the party must establish itself as a clear force for Remain there are also those who think that full-throated backing for another referendum could do Labour huge electoral damage in Leave-supporting areas in the Midlands and the north of England. | Because while there are many Labour supporters who believe that the party must establish itself as a clear force for Remain there are also those who think that full-throated backing for another referendum could do Labour huge electoral damage in Leave-supporting areas in the Midlands and the north of England. |
| Also, September is months away. It is questionable whether Jeremy Corbyn can realistically keep his balance on that oh-so-shaky fence all the way until autumn. | Also, September is months away. It is questionable whether Jeremy Corbyn can realistically keep his balance on that oh-so-shaky fence all the way until autumn. |
| Former Labour communications director Alastair Campbell told the BBC he had voted for the Liberal Democrats "for the first time in my life". | Former Labour communications director Alastair Campbell told the BBC he had voted for the Liberal Democrats "for the first time in my life". |
| "I felt on this issue the Labour party has let its own supporters down, its members down and the country down in the way that it has failed properly to develop a policy that the party and country could unite around." | "I felt on this issue the Labour party has let its own supporters down, its members down and the country down in the way that it has failed properly to develop a policy that the party and country could unite around." |
| Shadow justice secretary Richard Burgon admitted it had been a "deeply disappointing night" for his party. | Shadow justice secretary Richard Burgon admitted it had been a "deeply disappointing night" for his party. |
| He told BBC Radio 4's Today programme a no-deal Brexit was becoming more and more likely and Labour must "use whatever mechanism we can" - including a public vote - to stop such a scenario. | He told BBC Radio 4's Today programme a no-deal Brexit was becoming more and more likely and Labour must "use whatever mechanism we can" - including a public vote - to stop such a scenario. |
| Mr Corbyn blamed the results on "Tory failure" to deliver Brexit, turning the EU elections into a "proxy second referendum" where single-issue parties such as the Brexit Party would thrive. | Mr Corbyn blamed the results on "Tory failure" to deliver Brexit, turning the EU elections into a "proxy second referendum" where single-issue parties such as the Brexit Party would thrive. |
| He said: "With the Conservatives disintegrating and unable to govern, and parliament deadlocked, this issue will have to go back to the people, whether through a general election or a public vote. | He said: "With the Conservatives disintegrating and unable to govern, and parliament deadlocked, this issue will have to go back to the people, whether through a general election or a public vote. |
| "Labour will bring our divided country together so we can end austerity and tackle inequality." | "Labour will bring our divided country together so we can end austerity and tackle inequality." |
| 'Mealy-mouthed approach' | 'Mealy-mouthed approach' |
| But Labour's MPs are divided on Brexit. Labour MP for Tottenham, David Lammy, called for the party to "get its act together" and come out fully in support of another referendum. | But Labour's MPs are divided on Brexit. Labour MP for Tottenham, David Lammy, called for the party to "get its act together" and come out fully in support of another referendum. |
| "We simply cannot go on with this mealy-mouthed approach to a confirmatory vote," he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme. | "We simply cannot go on with this mealy-mouthed approach to a confirmatory vote," he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme. |
| But other Labour MPs in Leave-voting areas - like Don Valley MP Caroline Flint - said it would be a "mistake" for the party to appeal only to Remain voters. | But other Labour MPs in Leave-voting areas - like Don Valley MP Caroline Flint - said it would be a "mistake" for the party to appeal only to Remain voters. |
| Labour chairman Ian Lavery told BBC Radio 4 that the results were disappointing, but that the Conservatives performed worse. | Labour chairman Ian Lavery told BBC Radio 4 that the results were disappointing, but that the Conservatives performed worse. |
| He said: "We're the party who try to bring everyone together, it's been challenging trying to get that view across on the doorstep." | He said: "We're the party who try to bring everyone together, it's been challenging trying to get that view across on the doorstep." |