This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-48445430
The article has changed 10 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 6 | Version 7 |
---|---|
Brexit: Boris Johnson ordered to appear in court over £350m claim | Brexit: Boris Johnson ordered to appear in court over £350m claim |
(32 minutes later) | |
Boris Johnson has been ordered to appear in court over claims he lied by saying the UK gave the EU £350m a week. | Boris Johnson has been ordered to appear in court over claims he lied by saying the UK gave the EU £350m a week. |
The Tory leadership candidate has been accused of misconduct in public office after making the claim during the 2016 EU referendum campaign. | The Tory leadership candidate has been accused of misconduct in public office after making the claim during the 2016 EU referendum campaign. |
It is a private prosecution launched by campaigner Marcus Ball, who crowdfunded £200,000 for the case. | It is a private prosecution launched by campaigner Marcus Ball, who crowdfunded £200,000 for the case. |
A source close to Mr Johnson called the case a "politically motivated attempt to reverse Brexit". | |
The preliminary hearing will take place at Westminster Magistrates' Court and the case will then be sent to the Crown Court for trial. | The preliminary hearing will take place at Westminster Magistrates' Court and the case will then be sent to the Crown Court for trial. |
The BBC's assistant political editor, Norman Smith, said the allegations could not come at a worse time for Mr Johnson, and his critics are likely to use the claims against him in the upcoming contest to become next Tory leader and prime minister. | The BBC's assistant political editor, Norman Smith, said the allegations could not come at a worse time for Mr Johnson, and his critics are likely to use the claims against him in the upcoming contest to become next Tory leader and prime minister. |
The £350m figure was used by the pro-Brexit Vote Leave group throughout the referendum. It also appeared on the side of the campaign bus, which urged the UK to "fund our NHS instead". | The £350m figure was used by the pro-Brexit Vote Leave group throughout the referendum. It also appeared on the side of the campaign bus, which urged the UK to "fund our NHS instead". |
The former foreign secretary faces three allegations of misconduct in public office, between 21 February and 23 June 2016, and between 18 April and 3 May 2017. | The former foreign secretary faces three allegations of misconduct in public office, between 21 February and 23 June 2016, and between 18 April and 3 May 2017. |
The first period covers the time in which he campaigned for a Leave vote in the EU referendum, while the second covers the general election campaign that year. | The first period covers the time in which he campaigned for a Leave vote in the EU referendum, while the second covers the general election campaign that year. |
Mr Ball's lawyers lodged an application in February to summons Mr Johnson, claiming that while an MP and later a minister, he deliberately misled the public during the first campaign, and repeated the statement during the second. | Mr Ball's lawyers lodged an application in February to summons Mr Johnson, claiming that while an MP and later a minister, he deliberately misled the public during the first campaign, and repeated the statement during the second. |
Lewis Power QC, who represents Mr Ball, said Mr Johnson's conduct had been "both irresponsible and dishonest". | Lewis Power QC, who represents Mr Ball, said Mr Johnson's conduct had been "both irresponsible and dishonest". |
"Democracy demands responsible and honest leadership from those in public office," he said. | "Democracy demands responsible and honest leadership from those in public office," he said. |
'Infamous statement' | 'Infamous statement' |
Mr Power said the prosecution's application was not brought to undermine the result of the 2016 referendum and it was not about what could have been done with the saved money. | Mr Power said the prosecution's application was not brought to undermine the result of the 2016 referendum and it was not about what could have been done with the saved money. |
"The allegation with which this prosecution is concerned, put simply, is Mr Johnson repeatedly misrepresented the amount that the UK sends to Europe each week," he said. | "The allegation with which this prosecution is concerned, put simply, is Mr Johnson repeatedly misrepresented the amount that the UK sends to Europe each week," he said. |
"It is concerned with one infamous statement: 'We send the EU £350m a week.' | "It is concerned with one infamous statement: 'We send the EU £350m a week.' |
"The UK has never sent, given or provided £350m a week to Europe - that statement is simply not ambiguous." | "The UK has never sent, given or provided £350m a week to Europe - that statement is simply not ambiguous." |
What is misconduct in public office? | What is misconduct in public office? |
The source close to Mr Johnson said the decision to summon him was "extraordinary" and "risks undermining our democracy". | |
"It is not the role of criminal law to regulate political speech," they said. | |
"If this case is allowed to proceed then the state, rather than the public, will be put in charge of determining the strength of arguments at elections." | |
Mr Johnson's lawyers argued the case was "a stunt", adding: "Its true purpose is not that it should succeed, but that it should be made at all. And made with as much public fanfare as the prosecution can engender." | |
But in her written ruling, District Judge Margot Coleman said: "The applicant's case is there is ample evidence that the proposed defendant knew that the statements were false." | |
She continued: "I accept that the public offices held by Mr Johnson provide status, but with that status comes influence and authority." | |
She added that there was sufficient evidence of an issue to proceed with a trial. | |
How does a private prosecution work? | How does a private prosecution work? |
Anyone can bring a private prosecution - for example, the RSPCA pursue animal cruelty cases all the time. | Anyone can bring a private prosecution - for example, the RSPCA pursue animal cruelty cases all the time. |
But the Director of Public Prosecutions, Max Hill QC, has the power to either take over a case or stop it in its tracks. | But the Director of Public Prosecutions, Max Hill QC, has the power to either take over a case or stop it in its tracks. |
He can therefore authorise the Crown Prosecution Service to take over Mr Johnson's case if the allegations made by Mr Ball pass the CPS' own evidence test, there is a public interest in doing so, or there is a particular need to get involved. | He can therefore authorise the Crown Prosecution Service to take over Mr Johnson's case if the allegations made by Mr Ball pass the CPS' own evidence test, there is a public interest in doing so, or there is a particular need to get involved. |
The DPP can stop a private prosecution if he concludes it's vexatious, malicious or flawed for a range of other reasons. | The DPP can stop a private prosecution if he concludes it's vexatious, malicious or flawed for a range of other reasons. |
Given the district judge has already declared there is a prima facie case to be tested, the DPP may decide there's nothing he can usefully add and stay well clear. | Given the district judge has already declared there is a prima facie case to be tested, the DPP may decide there's nothing he can usefully add and stay well clear. |
So Mr Johnson's lawyers may already be looking at how to challenge the decision's lawfulness. And that could mean the case - like many other private prosecutions - becomes mired in legal argument and appeals. | So Mr Johnson's lawyers may already be looking at how to challenge the decision's lawfulness. And that could mean the case - like many other private prosecutions - becomes mired in legal argument and appeals. |