This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-48461160

The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 1 Version 2
Rape victims' therapy guidance needs urgent review - Labour Rape victims' therapy guidance needs urgent review - Labour
(about 2 hours later)
Labour is calling for an urgent review into therapy for rape victims, amid claims the current guidance discourages people from seeking counselling.Labour is calling for an urgent review into therapy for rape victims, amid claims the current guidance discourages people from seeking counselling.
CPS guidance states complainants should avoid discussing details of their abuse with a therapist while a trial is ongoing and that therapy notes could be used as evidence in court.CPS guidance states complainants should avoid discussing details of their abuse with a therapist while a trial is ongoing and that therapy notes could be used as evidence in court.
Shadow attorney general Shami Chakrabarti said this was "cruel".Shadow attorney general Shami Chakrabarti said this was "cruel".
The government said guidance "actively encourages" therapy for victims.The government said guidance "actively encourages" therapy for victims.
Labour's move follows a Vice investigation, which claimed rape victims were being told not to seek full therapy by police and specialist services.Labour's move follows a Vice investigation, which claimed rape victims were being told not to seek full therapy by police and specialist services.
The guidance is aimed at those involved in arranging therapy, therapists and lawyers involved in making decisions in relevant cases in England and Wales. It was introduced in 2002, when Labour was in government.The guidance is aimed at those involved in arranging therapy, therapists and lawyers involved in making decisions in relevant cases in England and Wales. It was introduced in 2002, when Labour was in government.
It says that pre-trial discussions of alleged sexual assault "may lead to allegations of coaching and, ultimately, the failure of the criminal case", and advises that therapists should avoid exploring in detail the substance of the specific sexual assault allegations.It says that pre-trial discussions of alleged sexual assault "may lead to allegations of coaching and, ultimately, the failure of the criminal case", and advises that therapists should avoid exploring in detail the substance of the specific sexual assault allegations.
It also states that records of therapy "must be maintained so they can be produced if required by the court".It also states that records of therapy "must be maintained so they can be produced if required by the court".
The guidance adds, however, that aspects of the therapy that "have no material relevance to criminal proceedings will not have to be disclosed".The guidance adds, however, that aspects of the therapy that "have no material relevance to criminal proceedings will not have to be disclosed".
Separate CPS guidance from 2012 on prosecuting rape cases states that victims "should not feel reluctant to seek professional assistance".Separate CPS guidance from 2012 on prosecuting rape cases states that victims "should not feel reluctant to seek professional assistance".
Whether they should receive therapy before a criminal trial is "not a decision for the police or the CPS", it adds, although the CPS should be informed if therapy is either proposed or undertaken.Whether they should receive therapy before a criminal trial is "not a decision for the police or the CPS", it adds, although the CPS should be informed if therapy is either proposed or undertaken.
A spokesman for the Ministry of Justice said a court would only order disclosure of counselling notes "if there were real grounds to believe the evidence could affect the outcome of the case". Chantel's story: 'Confusing and disappointing'
"It is vital that victims are confident they will be treated with the utmost fairness by the justice system," the MoJ added.
Rebecca Hitchen, campaign manager for End Violence Against Women, said the "confusing" and "cruel" guidance should be reviewed.
She added it was "shocking" that rape victims were being deterred from accessing "life-saving" specialist support because of issues with the criminal justice system.
Chantel - not her real name - told the BBC's Victoria Derbyshire programme she was raped and reported it to police "literally hours" after it took place.Chantel - not her real name - told the BBC's Victoria Derbyshire programme she was raped and reported it to police "literally hours" after it took place.
However, she said she was told by a rape crisis centre that she could not have counselling but only pre-trial therapy, until any criminal case was over.However, she said she was told by a rape crisis centre that she could not have counselling but only pre-trial therapy, until any criminal case was over.
"It was kind of confusing that you've gone through this event and done exactly what you're meant to do... it's kind of disappointing," she said."It was kind of confusing that you've gone through this event and done exactly what you're meant to do... it's kind of disappointing," she said.
"I'm having pre-trial therapy so basically I'm not allowed to talk about the event that happened to me.""I'm having pre-trial therapy so basically I'm not allowed to talk about the event that happened to me."
'Actively discouraged' A spokesman for the Ministry of Justice said a court would only order disclosure of counselling notes "if there were real grounds to believe the evidence could affect the outcome of the case".
Katie Russell, from the charity Rape Crisis, said that while the complainant's consent is generally required to disclose counselling notes, some may feel under pressure to give their consent, fearing their case may be detrimentally affected if they did not.
She said guidelines should be reviewed to consider how relevant counselling notes were to the criminal justice process. While they can be used by the prosecution to support a victim's testimony, she said therapy notes could also be used to "undermine their credibility".
Ms Russell said that while Rape Crisis offered pre-trial therapy and would never encourage or discourage anyone from seeking treatment, it was still "common" for victims to be told by a police officer or sexual assault referral centre that they should not access services.
"At the moment we are in this absurd position where some victims and survivors feel they are being made to choose between their own personal emotional recovery or pursuing criminal justice," she said.
She added that while pre-trial therapy sessions could be helpful for some survivors, for others it could be "enormously frustrating and distressing".
Ms Russell said it was not uncommon for trials to last as long as two years and being unable to access in-depth counselling in this time could add to survivors' emotional distress.
Rebecca Hitchen, campaign manager for End Violence Against Women, also said the "confusing" and "cruel" guidance should be reviewed.
She added it was "shocking" that rape victims were being deterred from accessing "life-saving" specialist support.
Baroness Chakrabarti told BBC Radio 4's Today programme there was evidence women were being "actively discouraged" from seeking counselling because of the "clumsy and contradictory" guidance.Baroness Chakrabarti told BBC Radio 4's Today programme there was evidence women were being "actively discouraged" from seeking counselling because of the "clumsy and contradictory" guidance.
The shadow attorney general said that she had been told by mental health professionals that with appropriate training and guidance, victims should be able to obtain support without risking trials being prejudiced.The shadow attorney general said that she had been told by mental health professionals that with appropriate training and guidance, victims should be able to obtain support without risking trials being prejudiced.
"But of course it takes resources to do this properly and that's my fear - that once again you have got a criminal justice system on its knees," she added."But of course it takes resources to do this properly and that's my fear - that once again you have got a criminal justice system on its knees," she added.
"Corners are being cut and it's the most vulnerable victims that are paying the price.""Corners are being cut and it's the most vulnerable victims that are paying the price."
It comes after it was revealed that rape victims in England and Wales would be asked to hand their phones over to police - or risk prosecutions not going ahead.It comes after it was revealed that rape victims in England and Wales would be asked to hand their phones over to police - or risk prosecutions not going ahead.