This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/01/us/death-toll-texas-shooting.html

The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 4 Version 5
Death Toll in West Texas Shooting Climbs to 7 Shooting Spree Across 15 Miles in West Texas Terrorized Two Towns and Killed 7
(about 3 hours later)
ODESSA, Tex. — A shooting spree that unfolded Saturday afternoon during a chaotic, high-speed police chase in West Texas was not an act of terrorism, law enforcement authorities said as they continued to piece together what had led a gunman to open fire on motorists and police officers while driving along a 15-mile stretch of highways and shopping centers. ODESSA, Tex. — The 36-year-old man who terrorized two West Texas towns with an assault-style rifle Saturday had been fired from his trucking job a few hours before he led the authorities on a chaotic high-speed chase that ended with his death and the deaths of seven others.
Still, Odessa police officials said at a news conference Sunday afternoon at the University of Texas Permian Basin that they did not have a clear motive for the attack, which left seven dead and 22 others wounded, their bodies sprawled amid more than 15 crime scenes that scores of law enforcement officers continued to process. Along a 15-mile stretch between the sister cities of Midland and Odessa, the aftermath of the gunman’s rampage — in which he indiscriminately fired on motorists and police officers with an AR-15-style rifle while driving — clashed with the typically serene and dusty rural landscape of the region.
On Sunday, the authorities continued to collect evidence from more than 15 crime scenes, scattered along highways, car dealerships and shopping malls, marked by police tape, bullet-riddled cars and a wrecked postal van the gunman had hijacked.
[Read more about how the Odessa shooting unfolded.][Read more about how the Odessa shooting unfolded.]
The authorities initially refused to identify the gunman Sunday, with Michael Gerke, chief of the Odessa Police Department, telling reporters at the news conference that they would not “give him any notoriety for what he did.” The authorities initially refused to name the gunman on Sunday, wanting not to give him “any notoriety for what he did,” said Michael Gerke, the police chief of Odessa. But they later issued a statement identifying the gunman as Seth Aaron Ator, of Odessa.
They later identified him as Seth Aaron Ator, 36, of Odessa. Police officers shot and killed Mr. Ator in the parking lot of a movie theater in Odessa, ending a shooting spree that began after the authorities had tried to pull him over for failing to signal a left turn. Although officials said in interviews that the gunman had been fired from his job with a trucking company on Saturday morning, the authorities stressed that they had not yet established a clear motive to explain the level of violence and firepower.
Chief Gerke said the gunman had used an AR-15-style rifle, but it was not clear Sunday whether it had been acquired legally. The gunman had a criminal record, but did not have any open warrants for his arrest when the police pulled him over Saturday afternoon before the shooting, Chief Gerke said. “There are no definite answers as to motive or reasons at this point,” Chief Gerke said, “but we are fairly certain that the subject did act alone.”
The chief said it was not immediately known whether the gunman had legally purchased the rifle. Similar assault-style weapons have been used in most of the deadliest shootings this decade, including at a country music festival in Las Vegas, a church in Sutherland Springs, Tex., a nightclub in Orlando, Fla., and outside a bar in Dayton, Ohio last month. Assault-style weapons were largely banned from 1994 until 2004, and remain at the center of a continuing national conversation about gun control.
While the gunman in the latest attack had a criminal record, there were no open warrants for his arrest when the police tried to pull him over Saturday afternoon, Chief Gerke said. Mr. Ator had been arrested in August 2001 in McLennan County near Waco on misdemeanor charges of criminal trespass and evading arrest, according to state records.
“This is a different type of active shooter that we were involved with, because he was mobile, and that creates some very special type of issues,” Chief Gerke said.“This is a different type of active shooter that we were involved with, because he was mobile, and that creates some very special type of issues,” Chief Gerke said.
The gunman fled from state troopers who had tried to pull him over, and then hijacked a United States Postal Service van, killing its driver before indiscriminately firing while he drove. In cellphone video from witnesses that captured the final moments of the attack, the postal van speeds into view and slams into a police cruiser outside a movie theater in Odessa. A burst of gunfire followed as officers who had been chasing the van rushed out and shot the gunman, who appeared to still be inside the van. The gunman sped away from the state troopers who had tried to pull him over, and then hijacked a United States Postal Service van, killed its driver, and began firing at people randomly as he drove. In cellphone video from witnesses that captured the final moments of the shooting spree, the postal van speeds into view and slams into a police cruiser outside the movie theater in Odessa. A burst of gunfire followed as officers who had been chasing the van rushed out and shot the gunman, who appeared to still be inside the van.
The authorities said Sunday that the seven people killed in the attack ranged in age from 15 to 57, including 29-year-old Mary Granados, whom U.S.P.S. officials said was a letter carrier. In a statement, the department said it was “shocked and saddened” and was working closely with other agencies on the investigation. The authorities said Sunday that the seven people killed in the attack ranged in age from 15 to 57, including Mary Granados, 29, the driver of the postal van. The Postal Inspection Service said Ms. Granados was a letter carrier, that it was “shocked and saddened” at her death, and that it was working closely with other agencies on the investigation.
Three law enforcement officers were among the wounded, as was a 17-month-old toddler who was recovering Sunday from injuries that included shrapnel in her chest. A total of 22 people were wounded, officials said, including three law enforcement officers and a 17-month-old toddler who was recovering Sunday from injuries that included shrapnel in her chest.
The chief suggested that the gunman may have intended to enter the crowded movie theater in Odessa where the chase ended. The attack on Saturday spread panic and fear for hours across West Texas, hundreds of miles from the border city of El Paso, where four weeks earlier a gunman had killed 22 people at a Walmart in an anti-Hispanic attack.
“It begs the question, why go to the theater if you’re not planning on entering the theater, and please understand that, on a Saturday afternoon in Odessa, Tex., that is one of the most crowded places to be,” he said. On Sunday afternoon, federal agents executed a search warrant at what appeared to be Mr. Ator’s residence, in a remote area of mobile homes at the western edge of Ector County, which includes Odessa. A neighbor, Rocio Martinez, 29, described Mr. Ator as a “loner” who kept to himself and who sometimes frightened her because he was always firing guns outside.
The attack on Saturday spread panic and fear for hours across West Texas, hundreds of miles from the border city of El Paso, where just 28 days earlier a gunman had killed 22 people at a Walmart in an anti-Hispanic attack. “Although I feel bad about the situation, I feel at ease knowing that he was killed,” Ms. Martinez said. “That tells me the threat has been removed, and my family is safe again.”
Local and state officials said the shooting had begun with the attempted traffic stop on Interstate 20, a busy artery connecting Midland to Odessa. Local and state officials said the shooting had begun at 3:13 p.m. Saturday with the attempted traffic stop on Interstate 20, a busy artery that connects Midland and Odessa. The authorities said Mr. Ator was driving west in a gold car and was near the Midland airport.
At 3:13 p.m. Saturday, state troopers with the Texas Department of Public Safety tried to pull over a man driving a gold car for failing to signal a left turn, the authorities said. The car was headed west and was near the Midland airport. Before it came to a complete stop, the driver pointed a rifle toward the rear window and fired several shots at the state troopers, injuring one, the Department of Public Safety said in a statement. Before his vehicle came to a complete stop, the gunman pointed a rifle toward the rear window and fired several shots at the state troopers, injuring one, the Department of Public Safety said in a statement.
The gunman then drove west toward Odessa, shooting a person as he sped away on I-20 and east Loop 338. The shooting continued, and bodies were left in the wake as the gunman continued driving, eventually speeding into the Cinergy movie theater on Highway 191. He shot an Odessa police officer and a Midland police officer before officers returned fire and killed him, the authorities said. The gunman then drove west toward Odessa, shooting a person as he sped away on Interstate 20 and then on East Loop 338, a connecting highway. The shooting continued, and bodies were left in its wake as the gunman continued driving, eventually speeding into the parking lot of the Cinergy movie theater on Highway 191. He shot an Odessa police officer and a Midland police officer before officers returned fire and killed him, the authorities said.
On Sunday morning, the white postal van and the Odessa police vehicle remained in the same spot where the shooting had ended. Agents from the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives were among the officers examining the crime scene on Sunday. On Sunday morning, the white postal van and the Odessa police vehicle remained where they were when the shooting had ended. Agents from the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives were among the officers examining the crime scene on Sunday.
Christopher H. Combs, the special agent in charge of the F.B.I.’s San Antonio office, said federal agents were executing a search warrant at a residence in Odessa on Sunday afternoon, but declined to say whether it was the gunman’s home. Christopher H. Combs, the special agent in charge of the F.B.I.’s San Antonio office, said the shooting was not connected to either domestic or international terrorism.
Special Agent Combs and Gov. Greg Abbott, both of whom attended the news conference at the university on Sunday, expressed sadness, frustration and a kind of exhaustion over the series of mass shootings in Texas in recent years. Since the shooting rampage that targeted police officers in downtown Dallas in 2016, there have been five mass shootings in Texas in 37 months, all of which Mr. Abbott and his staff have responded to. Special Agent Combs and Gov. Greg Abbott, both of whom spoke at the news conference Sunday, expressed sadness, frustration and a kind of exhaustion over the series of mass shootings in Texas in recent years, Beginning with a rampage that targeted police officers in downtown Dallas in 2016, killing five officers and wounding another nine, there have been five mass shootings in Texas in a stretch of three years.
“I’m heartbroken by the crying of the people of the State of Texas,” the governor said. “I’m tired of the dying of the people of the State of Texas. Too many Texans are in mourning. Too many Texans have lost their lives. The status quo in Texas is unacceptable and action is needed.”“I’m heartbroken by the crying of the people of the State of Texas,” the governor said. “I’m tired of the dying of the people of the State of Texas. Too many Texans are in mourning. Too many Texans have lost their lives. The status quo in Texas is unacceptable and action is needed.”
Mr. Abbott, a Republican who has been a longtime advocate for gun rights, said the state must keep guns out of the hands of criminals like the gunman in Odessa, “while also assuring that we safeguard Second Amendment rights, and we must do it fast.”Mr. Abbott, a Republican who has been a longtime advocate for gun rights, said the state must keep guns out of the hands of criminals like the gunman in Odessa, “while also assuring that we safeguard Second Amendment rights, and we must do it fast.”
More than a dozen people were still being treated at hospitals Saturday and Sunday. The wounded state trooper was in serious but stable condition, and doctors were optimistic he would make a full recovery, officials said. The two Midland and Odessa police officers were in stable condition. More than a dozen people injured in the shooting spree were still being treated at hospitals on Sunday. The wounded state trooper was in serious but stable condition, and doctors were optimistic he would make a full recovery, officials said. The two Midland and Odessa police officers were in stable condition.
The injured Midland officer, Zack Owens, was shot several times in an arm and hand, but relatives said his most serious injury had resulted from having glass shards in one eye. The injured Midland officer, Zack Owens, was shot several times in an arm and a hand, but relatives said his most serious injury had resulted from having glass shards in one eye. The wife of his cousin set up a donation page on GoFundMe, a crowdfunding site, to help pay his medical expenses. By Sunday evening more than $57,000 had been raised.
Officer Owens’ brother, Jake Owens, is also an officer with the Midland Police Department. Abigail McCullough, the wife of Mr. Owens’ cousin, set up a donation page on GoFundMe, a crowdfunding site, to help pay the medical expenses for Zack Owens. By Sunday, more than $57,000 had been raised. The 17-month-old girl who was shot was identified by family friends as Anderson Davis. A GoFundMe page for Anderson, which had raised more than $145,000 Sunday evening, said the toddler had been wounded by a bullet fragment.
The 17-month-old girl who was shot was identified by family friends as Anderson Davis. A GoFundMe page for Anderson said the toddler had been wounded by a bullet fragment. The page was created by Haylee Wilkerson, a friend of Anderson’s mother, and had raised more than $145,000 by Sunday. A note from Anderson’s mother on the page said her daughter’s vital signs were good and that she had shrapnel in her chest, her front teeth had been knocked out, and she had a hole through her bottom lip and tongue. But Anderson was alive, she wrote, which was “a prayer answered bigger than I’ve ever had to pray.”
A note from Anderson’s mother on the page said her daughter was alive, which was “a prayer answered bigger than I’ve ever had to pray.” Her mother wrote that Anderson’s vitals were good and that she had shrapnel in her chest, her front teeth had been knocked out, and she had a hole through her bottom lip and tongue. In a text to Mr. Abbott, which he read aloud to reporters during the news conference, Anderson’s mother said that her daughter would be undergoing surgery on Monday to remove the shrapnel and to fix her lip and mouth. “Toddlers are funny, because they can get shot but still want to run around and play,” she wrote.
Mr. Abbott told reporters that he had received a text from Anderson’s mother, and he read parts of it aloud during the news conference. The debate over gun control continued Sunday, a day when 10 new laws loosening firearms restrictions took effect in Texas. The state has among the most liberal gun laws in the nation, according to Guns & Ammo magazine.
“‘Thank God she’s alive and relatively well,’” the governor read. “She goes on to say that, ‘Toddlers are funny, because they can get shot, but still want to run around and play.’” She also told Mr. Abbott that Anderson would be undergoing surgery on Monday to remove the shrapnel from her chest, to fix her lip and mouth, and to allow doctors to get a better look at her tongue.
Ten new laws loosening firearms restrictions took effect on Sunday in Texas, a state where gun rights have long been celebrated and protected. Texas has among the most liberal gun laws in the nation, according to Guns & Ammo magazine.
One of the new laws prevents condominium and rental housing complex owners from prohibiting firearms or ammunition from being stored or carried onto their properties. Another prohibits school districts from enforcing gun safety rules for staff and visitors who keep firearms or ammunition inside their locked vehicles on school grounds, as long as weapons are not “in plain view.”One of the new laws prevents condominium and rental housing complex owners from prohibiting firearms or ammunition from being stored or carried onto their properties. Another prohibits school districts from enforcing gun safety rules for staff and visitors who keep firearms or ammunition inside their locked vehicles on school grounds, as long as weapons are not “in plain view.”
In a statement that praised the rules last week, the National Rifle Association said the measures were examples of the state legislature and governor “protecting your Second Amendment rights.” In a statement that praised the new rules last week, the National Rifle Association said the measures were examples of the state legislature and governor “protecting your Second Amendment rights.”
Mr. Abbott on Sunday defended those new laws as having been enacted “for the purpose of making our community safer.” Mr. Abbott defended those new laws on Sunday as having been enacted “for the purpose of making our community safer.”
President Trump praised police and emergency workers in West Texas on Sunday and called the gunman a “very sick person.” In Washington, President Trump praised the police and emergency workers in West Texas on Sunday and called the gunman a “very sick person.”
“It’s tragic, but they did an incredible job under the circumstances,” Mr. Trump said after stepping off Marine One on his return to the White House. “Another very sick person. So I just want to thank everybody involved. And always, you say, as bad as it was, it could have been worse. But it was certainly bad. A very, very sad situation.”“It’s tragic, but they did an incredible job under the circumstances,” Mr. Trump said after stepping off Marine One on his return to the White House. “Another very sick person. So I just want to thank everybody involved. And always, you say, as bad as it was, it could have been worse. But it was certainly bad. A very, very sad situation.”
The president said a package of legislation was being prepared in response to the recent spate of mass shootings and would be presented to Congress, but he declined to discuss details.The president said a package of legislation was being prepared in response to the recent spate of mass shootings and would be presented to Congress, but he declined to discuss details.
“This really hasn’t changed anything,” Mr. Trump said, adding, “We’re looking at a lot of different bills.”“This really hasn’t changed anything,” Mr. Trump said, adding, “We’re looking at a lot of different bills.”
Regarding proposals to tighten background checks on gun purchases, he said: “I will say that for the most part, sadly, if you look at the last four or five, going back even five or six or seven years — for the most part, as strong as you make your background checks, they would not have stopped any of it. So it’s a big problem. It’s a mental problem.”Regarding proposals to tighten background checks on gun purchases, he said: “I will say that for the most part, sadly, if you look at the last four or five, going back even five or six or seven years — for the most part, as strong as you make your background checks, they would not have stopped any of it. So it’s a big problem. It’s a mental problem.”
Residents in Odessa, a city of 120,000, remained on edge Sunday. Though Odessa and El Paso are separated by nearly 300 miles, the cities share some ties and a Western sensibility.Residents in Odessa, a city of 120,000, remained on edge Sunday. Though Odessa and El Paso are separated by nearly 300 miles, the cities share some ties and a Western sensibility.
On Saturday night, at the University of Texas Permian Basin, Stephanie Stonecliffe watched as her children played with rocks. She said her friend had been shopping at the Walmart in El Paso when the gunman there opened fire.On Saturday night, at the University of Texas Permian Basin, Stephanie Stonecliffe watched as her children played with rocks. She said her friend had been shopping at the Walmart in El Paso when the gunman there opened fire.
“Eventually I knew it was going to happen closer to home, especially with what’s going on in the world,” said Ms. Stonecliffe, who moved to the area recently from College Station, Tex. “This just tells me the world’s getting a little bit more dangerous.”“Eventually I knew it was going to happen closer to home, especially with what’s going on in the world,” said Ms. Stonecliffe, who moved to the area recently from College Station, Tex. “This just tells me the world’s getting a little bit more dangerous.”