This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2019/oct/14/coalition-labor-morrison-albanese-lambie-politics-live

The article has changed 22 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 2 Version 3
Government accidentally emails talking points to the media – politics live Government accidentally emails talking points to the media – politics live
(32 minutes later)
From AAP:
Aged care royal commission chair Richard Tracey QC has died.
The former Federal Court judge died on Friday, the aged care royal commission announced on Monday at the beginning of a Melbourne public hearing examining workforce issues.
Commissioners Lynelle Briggs said Mr Tracey died in California, where he was being treated for cancer diagnosed seven weeks earlier.
Australian Associated Press is reporting the aged care royal commission chair Richard Tracey has died.
We will bring you more on that when we can.
The House and Senate are both about to sit:
The House will sit today. Daily Program: Monday, 14 October 2019 https://t.co/EEU94stF9P
The #Senate meets at 10 this morning. Our order of business (the Red) is available from ParlWork https://t.co/W0mvG4D8zj
The committee for the latest inquiry into the family law court will most likely be announced today. That’s the one Pauline Hanson has been elevated to deputy-chair on, despite her already having announced her (abhorrent and evidence-less) views going into it.
There has been a push on to have Zali Steggall – who has a background in family law – to sit on the committee. We’ll see if that pays off.
In brighter news, the annual “Girls Takeover Parliament” event is on this week.
It’s run by Jasiri Australia, which is a “youth-led, expert-guided social enterprise committed to seeing gender equality in our communities and in our leadership”.
The bipartisan event will see 60 young women paired up with MPs and senators. At the end of the event a charter will be presented to Scott Morrison.
Meanwhile, the parliamentary inquiry into the worst of all hours – question time – continues.
The parliament is looking at how it, and other parliamentary procedures, could be made better.
Question time is the one hour of parliament that is broadcast. Which means it is the one hour of parliamentary proceedings that most people see. And it’s a joke. It is an absolute farce, which does nothing to promote trust and faith in our democratic system. It is ridiculous theatre that leaves every person who takes part in it worse.
That’s just my opinion of course (DEATH TO DIXERS) but it seems, from the submissions the inquiry has received so far, to be a common opinion.
If you can’t be bothered putting in a submission, you can take this survey the committee has set up , which is open until 31 October.
And on the ACCC inquiry announced today by Josh Frydenberg, the government wants you to know:And on the ACCC inquiry announced today by Josh Frydenberg, the government wants you to know:
ACCC BANK INQUIRYACCC BANK INQUIRY
The Government has directed the ACCC to undertake an inquiry into the pricing of residential mortgage products, particularly after the banks failed to pass on the RBA’s recent interest rate cuts in full.The Government has directed the ACCC to undertake an inquiry into the pricing of residential mortgage products, particularly after the banks failed to pass on the RBA’s recent interest rate cuts in full.
The Inquiry will focus on the period from 1 January 2019. Since this date, there have been three cuts (June, July and October) by the RBA to the official cash rate.The Inquiry will focus on the period from 1 January 2019. Since this date, there have been three cuts (June, July and October) by the RBA to the official cash rate.
Together these cuts have reduced the cash rate by 75 basis points, and the big four banks have passed on an average 57 basis points in owner-occupied home loan rates.Together these cuts have reduced the cash rate by 75 basis points, and the big four banks have passed on an average 57 basis points in owner-occupied home loan rates.
The major banks have decided to put their profits before their customers, and that’s not a good outcome for their customers or the economy.The major banks have decided to put their profits before their customers, and that’s not a good outcome for their customers or the economy.
As the Reserve Bank Governor pointed out recently “lower interest rates put more money into the hands of the household sector and, at some point, this extra money gets spent and this helps the overall economy.”As the Reserve Bank Governor pointed out recently “lower interest rates put more money into the hands of the household sector and, at some point, this extra money gets spent and this helps the overall economy.”
The inquiry will ensure the pricing practices of the banks are better understood and made more transparent by;The inquiry will ensure the pricing practices of the banks are better understood and made more transparent by;
understanding how banks make pricing decisions for residential mortgages – which is particularly important in the current context of banks not passing on the RBA rate cuts in full.understanding how banks make pricing decisions for residential mortgages – which is particularly important in the current context of banks not passing on the RBA rate cuts in full.
assessing how prices differ for new and existing customers. assessing how prices differ for new and existing customers.
investigating barriers to switching.investigating barriers to switching.
understanding how banks make pricing decisions for residential mortgages – which is particularly important in the current context of banks not passing on the RBA rate cuts in full.understanding how banks make pricing decisions for residential mortgages – which is particularly important in the current context of banks not passing on the RBA rate cuts in full.
assessing how prices differ for new and existing customers.assessing how prices differ for new and existing customers.
investigating barriers to switching.investigating barriers to switching.
The inquiry will consider pricing across the entire residential mortgage market by major banks, smaller banks, and non-bank lenders. But the big four banks will be a key focus of this inquiry, given they hold around 75 percent of residential mortgage debt.The inquiry will consider pricing across the entire residential mortgage market by major banks, smaller banks, and non-bank lenders. But the big four banks will be a key focus of this inquiry, given they hold around 75 percent of residential mortgage debt.
The Government is committed to increasing competition in banking and promoting good consumer outcomes in the mortgage market to ensure that consumers can get a better deal.The Government is committed to increasing competition in banking and promoting good consumer outcomes in the mortgage market to ensure that consumers can get a better deal.
The consumer data right provides consumers with greater access to their personal information giving them power to securely transfer their banking data to other providers to get a better deal. This is one of a number of policies the government is implementing to increase competition.The consumer data right provides consumers with greater access to their personal information giving them power to securely transfer their banking data to other providers to get a better deal. This is one of a number of policies the government is implementing to increase competition.
understanding how banks make pricing decisions for residential mortgages – which is particularly important in the current context of banks not passing on the RBA rate cuts in full.understanding how banks make pricing decisions for residential mortgages – which is particularly important in the current context of banks not passing on the RBA rate cuts in full.
assessing how prices differ for new and existing customers.assessing how prices differ for new and existing customers.
investigating barriers to switching.investigating barriers to switching.
If asked how this differs to the Royal Commission and previous ACCC inquiries?If asked how this differs to the Royal Commission and previous ACCC inquiries?
The Financial Services Royal Commission specifically focused on misconduct rather than the way that Banks are pricing their mortgages.The Financial Services Royal Commission specifically focused on misconduct rather than the way that Banks are pricing their mortgages.
The ACCC’s previous Residential Mortgage Price Inquiry specifically focused on whether the Major Bank Levy affected the prices charged for residential mortgages.The ACCC’s previous Residential Mortgage Price Inquiry specifically focused on whether the Major Bank Levy affected the prices charged for residential mortgages.
The government has also decided to acknowledge the IMF climate report which said Australia would fail to meet its Paris target:The government has also decided to acknowledge the IMF climate report which said Australia would fail to meet its Paris target:
We’re taking meaningful action to reduce global emissions with our $3.5 billion Climate Solutions Package that will deliver the 328 million tonnes of abatement needed to meet our 2030 Paris target.We’re taking meaningful action to reduce global emissions with our $3.5 billion Climate Solutions Package that will deliver the 328 million tonnes of abatement needed to meet our 2030 Paris target.
Our national target is achievable, balanced and responsible, and is part of coordinated global action to deliver a healthy environment for future generations while keeping our economy strong.Our national target is achievable, balanced and responsible, and is part of coordinated global action to deliver a healthy environment for future generations while keeping our economy strong.
In the electricity sector, we are reducing emissions while maintaining reliable and secure supply:In the electricity sector, we are reducing emissions while maintaining reliable and secure supply:
The latest official projections show the National Electricity Market (NEM) is on track to be 26 per cent below 2005 levels by 2022, 8 years early.The latest official projections show the National Electricity Market (NEM) is on track to be 26 per cent below 2005 levels by 2022, 8 years early.
On the back of $25 billion of committed investment in clean energy, Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like France, Germany & the UK:On the back of $25 billion of committed investment in clean energy, Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like France, Germany & the UK:
The latest official projections show the National Electricity Market (NEM) is on track to be 26 per cent below 2005 levels by 2022, 8 years early.The latest official projections show the National Electricity Market (NEM) is on track to be 26 per cent below 2005 levels by 2022, 8 years early.
On the back of $25 billion of committed investment in clean energy, Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like France, Germany & the UK:On the back of $25 billion of committed investment in clean energy, Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like France, Germany & the UK:
The latest official projections show the National Electricity Market (NEM) is on track to be 26 per cent below 2005 levels by 2022, 8 years early.The latest official projections show the National Electricity Market (NEM) is on track to be 26 per cent below 2005 levels by 2022, 8 years early.
On the back of $25 billion of committed investment in clean energy, Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like France, Germany & the UK:On the back of $25 billion of committed investment in clean energy, Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like France, Germany & the UK:
If asked - IMF climate change report saying we will not meet our 2030 target:If asked - IMF climate change report saying we will not meet our 2030 target:
We’ll meet our target without introducing a carbon tax.We’ll meet our target without introducing a carbon tax.
When Labor were in Government and introduced a carbon tax, energy prices went up and industry threatened to take jobs offshore.When Labor were in Government and introduced a carbon tax, energy prices went up and industry threatened to take jobs offshore.
The IMF report does not take into account our $3.5 billion package which maps out to the last tonne how we will deliver the 328mt of abatement needed to reduce emissions to 26 to 28 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030.The IMF report does not take into account our $3.5 billion package which maps out to the last tonne how we will deliver the 328mt of abatement needed to reduce emissions to 26 to 28 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030.
The report also states that under a $75 carbon tax, retail electricity prices would increase by 70-90 per cent in Australia.The report also states that under a $75 carbon tax, retail electricity prices would increase by 70-90 per cent in Australia.
That is not something we are going to do to Australian households and small businesses.That is not something we are going to do to Australian households and small businesses.
When asked about that on Friday, Josh Frydenberg seemed to miss the question and answered along the lines of ‘who said that? Labor?’ which is a standard response these days. When asked about that on Friday, Josh Frydenberg seemed to miss the question and answered along the lines of “who said that? Labor?” which is a standard response these days.
The government is also pretty into what the party who is not in government is doing. Joel Fitzgibbon has given them some extra steam here:The government is also pretty into what the party who is not in government is doing. Joel Fitzgibbon has given them some extra steam here:
LABOR DIVISION ON ENERGY POLICYLABOR DIVISION ON ENERGY POLICY
Joel Fitzgibbon has back flipped on his recent calls for a carbon tax and again presented yet another position on energy policy - this one driven by self interest to save his own seat, following huge swings against him at the recent election. Joel Fitzgibbon has back flipped on his recent calls for a carbon tax and again presented yet another position on energy policy – this one driven by self interest to save his own seat, following huge swings against him at the recent election.
Meanwhile Bill Shorten and Penny Wong have recently said they are “proud” of Labor’s reckless 45% target and made the case to keep it.Meanwhile Bill Shorten and Penny Wong have recently said they are “proud” of Labor’s reckless 45% target and made the case to keep it.
This follows calls by the assistant climate change spokesman Pat Conroy to scrap their 45% emissions reduction target but Labor change spokesman Mark Butler won’t commit to anything.This follows calls by the assistant climate change spokesman Pat Conroy to scrap their 45% emissions reduction target but Labor change spokesman Mark Butler won’t commit to anything.
Whether it’s ‘Chairman Swanny’ calling for Labor to keep their $387 billion tax and spend agenda or Fitzgibbon looking back to the future then doing a backflip, Labor haven’t learned the lessons from the election and want to re-hash policies Australia has comprehensively rejected. Whether it’s “Chairman Swanny” calling for Labor to keep their $387 billion tax and spend agenda or Fitzgibbon looking back to the future then doing a backflip, Labor haven’t learned the lessons from the election and want to re-hash policies Australia has comprehensively rejected.
We’re taking meaningful action to reduce global emissions with our $3.5 billion Climate Solutions Package that will deliver the 328 million tonnes of abatement needed to meet our 2030 Paris target.We’re taking meaningful action to reduce global emissions with our $3.5 billion Climate Solutions Package that will deliver the 328 million tonnes of abatement needed to meet our 2030 Paris target.
Under our government Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like the UK, France and Germany.Under our government Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like the UK, France and Germany.
Joel Fitzgibbon has back flipped on his recent calls for a carbon tax and again presented yet another position on energy policy - this one driven by self interest to save his own seat, following huge swings against him at the recent election. Joel Fitzgibbon has back flipped on his recent calls for a carbon tax and again presented yet another position on energy policy – this one driven by self interest to save his own seat, following huge swings against him at the recent election.
Meanwhile Bill Shorten and Penny Wong have recently said they are “proud” of Labor’s reckless 45% target and made the case to keep it.Meanwhile Bill Shorten and Penny Wong have recently said they are “proud” of Labor’s reckless 45% target and made the case to keep it.
This follows calls by the assistant climate change spokesman Pat Conroy to scrap their 45% emissions reduction target but Labor change spokesman Mark Butler won’t commit to anything.This follows calls by the assistant climate change spokesman Pat Conroy to scrap their 45% emissions reduction target but Labor change spokesman Mark Butler won’t commit to anything.
Whether it’s ‘Chairman Swanny’ calling for Labor to keep their $387 billion tax and spend agenda or Fitzgibbon looking back to the future then doing a backflip, Labor haven’t learned the lessons from the election and want to re-hash policies Australia has comprehensively rejected. Whether it’s “Chairman Swanny” calling for Labor to keep their $387 billion tax and spend agenda or Fitzgibbon looking back to the future then doing a backflip, Labor haven’t learned the lessons from the election and want to re-hash policies Australia has comprehensively rejected.
We’re taking meaningful action to reduce global emissions with our $3.5 billion Climate Solutions Package that will deliver the 328 million tonnes of abatement needed to meet our 2030 Paris target.We’re taking meaningful action to reduce global emissions with our $3.5 billion Climate Solutions Package that will deliver the 328 million tonnes of abatement needed to meet our 2030 Paris target.
Under our government Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like the UK, France and Germany.Under our government Australia leads the world with more than double the per capita investment of countries like the UK, France and Germany.
But the best thing about this one, is that the government actually admits that emissions have increased (at least through its notes) For the records, emissions have increased every year since 2014, when the carbon price was scrapped But the best thing about this one, is that the government actually admits that emissions have increased (at least through its notes) For the records, emissions have increased every year since 2014, when the carbon price was scrapped.
If asked: recent increases in emissions:If asked: recent increases in emissions:
Emissions fell 0.4% over the first quarter of 2019.Emissions fell 0.4% over the first quarter of 2019.
Emissions for the year to March 2019 are up 0.6 % or 3.1 Mt. This small increase is due to an 18.8% increase in LNG exports. LNG production related emissions increased 4.7 Mt.Emissions for the year to March 2019 are up 0.6 % or 3.1 Mt. This small increase is due to an 18.8% increase in LNG exports. LNG production related emissions increased 4.7 Mt.
Absent the increase in LNG exports, total emissions would have declined. Australia’s LNG exports for the year to March 2019 are estimated to be worth $47.8 billion.Absent the increase in LNG exports, total emissions would have declined. Australia’s LNG exports for the year to March 2019 are estimated to be worth $47.8 billion.
While this industry’s success has increased Australia’s emissions, it has potentially reduced global emissions by up to 28% of Australia’s annual emissions by displacing coal generation in importing countries.While this industry’s success has increased Australia’s emissions, it has potentially reduced global emissions by up to 28% of Australia’s annual emissions by displacing coal generation in importing countries.
We are nearly half way towards our 2030 Paris target – emissions are down 11.7% on 2005 levels and the emissions intensity of the economy and per capita are at their lowest levels in nearly 3 decades.We are nearly half way towards our 2030 Paris target – emissions are down 11.7% on 2005 levels and the emissions intensity of the economy and per capita are at their lowest levels in nearly 3 decades.
We are also on track to overachieve on our 2020 target by 367 million tonnes.We are also on track to overachieve on our 2020 target by 367 million tonnes.
Emissions fell 0.4% over the first quarter of 2019.Emissions fell 0.4% over the first quarter of 2019.
Emissions for the year to March 2019 are up 0.6 % or 3.1 Mt. This small increase is due to an 18.8% increase in LNG exports. LNG production related emissions increased 4.7 Mt.Emissions for the year to March 2019 are up 0.6 % or 3.1 Mt. This small increase is due to an 18.8% increase in LNG exports. LNG production related emissions increased 4.7 Mt.
Absent the increase in LNG exports, total emissions would have declined. Australia’s LNG exports for the year to March 2019 are estimated to be worth $47.8 billion.Absent the increase in LNG exports, total emissions would have declined. Australia’s LNG exports for the year to March 2019 are estimated to be worth $47.8 billion.
While this industry’s success has increased Australia’s emissions, it has potentially reduced global emissions by up to 28% of Australia’s annual emissions by displacing coal generation in importing countries.While this industry’s success has increased Australia’s emissions, it has potentially reduced global emissions by up to 28% of Australia’s annual emissions by displacing coal generation in importing countries.
We are nearly half way towards our 2030 Paris target – emissions are down 11.7% on 2005 levels and the emissions intensity of the economy and per capita are at their lowest levels in nearly 3 decades.We are nearly half way towards our 2030 Paris target – emissions are down 11.7% on 2005 levels and the emissions intensity of the economy and per capita are at their lowest levels in nearly 3 decades.
We are also on track to overachieve on our 2020 target by 367 million tonnes.We are also on track to overachieve on our 2020 target by 367 million tonnes.
And this talking note, on the drug testing trial being extended, is actually a WTF moment:And this talking note, on the drug testing trial being extended, is actually a WTF moment:
DRUG TESTING TRIALDRUG TESTING TRIAL
The Morrison Government’s drug testing trials are part of our commitment to finding new and innovative ways to breaking down barriers unemployed Australians face and supporting them to get back into the workforce so they can take control of their own lives.The Morrison Government’s drug testing trials are part of our commitment to finding new and innovative ways to breaking down barriers unemployed Australians face and supporting them to get back into the workforce so they can take control of their own lives.
The Government wants to support unemployed Australians become job ready and given more than 3.5 million Australians already undergo random drug testing as part of their employment, the drug testing trial is seeking to ensure people entering Newstart and related payments can take advantage of every job offered to them.The Government wants to support unemployed Australians become job ready and given more than 3.5 million Australians already undergo random drug testing as part of their employment, the drug testing trial is seeking to ensure people entering Newstart and related payments can take advantage of every job offered to them.
This measure is about identifying people with substance abuse issues who need our help and supporting them to seek treatment through a $10 million treatment fund.This measure is about identifying people with substance abuse issues who need our help and supporting them to seek treatment through a $10 million treatment fund.
Welfare recipients who test positive will not lose a single cent of their payment but will be placed on Income Management for a period of 24 months which will quarantine 80 per cent of their welfare payment on to the Basics Card which prevents spending on drugs, alcohol and gambling. The remaining 20 per cent will be deposited in their regular account.Welfare recipients who test positive will not lose a single cent of their payment but will be placed on Income Management for a period of 24 months which will quarantine 80 per cent of their welfare payment on to the Basics Card which prevents spending on drugs, alcohol and gambling. The remaining 20 per cent will be deposited in their regular account.
A second drug test will be scheduled within 25 working days of the positive result. After a second positive test, the job seeker will be referred to a medical professional who will assess their circumstances and identify treatment options which can count towards their mutual obligation activity requirements.A second drug test will be scheduled within 25 working days of the positive result. After a second positive test, the job seeker will be referred to a medical professional who will assess their circumstances and identify treatment options which can count towards their mutual obligation activity requirements.
The two-year Drug Testing Trial will be rolled out in three locations – Logan, Qld, Canterbury-Bankstown, NSW and Mandurah, WA and will test about 5000 people entering Newstart.The two-year Drug Testing Trial will be rolled out in three locations – Logan, Qld, Canterbury-Bankstown, NSW and Mandurah, WA and will test about 5000 people entering Newstart.
The Morrison Government’s drug testing trials are part of our commitment to finding new and innovative ways to breaking down barriers unemployed Australians face and supporting them to get back into the workforce so they can take control of their own lives.The Morrison Government’s drug testing trials are part of our commitment to finding new and innovative ways to breaking down barriers unemployed Australians face and supporting them to get back into the workforce so they can take control of their own lives.
The Government wants to support unemployed Australians become job ready and given more than 3.5 million Australians already undergo random drug testing as part of their employment, the drug testing trial is seeking to ensure people entering Newstart and related payments can take advantage of every job offered to them.The Government wants to support unemployed Australians become job ready and given more than 3.5 million Australians already undergo random drug testing as part of their employment, the drug testing trial is seeking to ensure people entering Newstart and related payments can take advantage of every job offered to them.
This measure is about identifying people with substance abuse issues who need our help and supporting them to seek treatment through a $10 million treatment fund.This measure is about identifying people with substance abuse issues who need our help and supporting them to seek treatment through a $10 million treatment fund.
Welfare recipients who test positive will not lose a single cent of their payment but will be placed on Income Management for a period of 24 months which will quarantine 80 per cent of their welfare payment on to the Basics Card which prevents spending on drugs, alcohol and gambling. The remaining 20 per cent will be deposited in their regular account.Welfare recipients who test positive will not lose a single cent of their payment but will be placed on Income Management for a period of 24 months which will quarantine 80 per cent of their welfare payment on to the Basics Card which prevents spending on drugs, alcohol and gambling. The remaining 20 per cent will be deposited in their regular account.
A second drug test will be scheduled within 25 working days of the positive result. After a second positive test, the job seeker will be referred to a medical professional who will assess their circumstances and identify treatment options which can count towards their mutual obligation activity requirements.A second drug test will be scheduled within 25 working days of the positive result. After a second positive test, the job seeker will be referred to a medical professional who will assess their circumstances and identify treatment options which can count towards their mutual obligation activity requirements.
The two-year Drug Testing Trial will be rolled out in three locations – Logan, Qld, Canterbury-Bankstown, NSW and Mandurah, WA and will test about 5000 people entering Newstart.The two-year Drug Testing Trial will be rolled out in three locations – Logan, Qld, Canterbury-Bankstown, NSW and Mandurah, WA and will test about 5000 people entering Newstart.
If asked why the Government is trying to push through the testing when parliament has rejected it twice:If asked why the Government is trying to push through the testing when parliament has rejected it twice:
There is clear community support for the trial as reports in the media today further show.There is clear community support for the trial as reports in the media today further show.
The Labor Party needs to explain to the Australian people why it wants to deny the Government the opportunity to tackle a problem of drug addiction for people who are not in work.The Labor Party needs to explain to the Australian people why it wants to deny the Government the opportunity to tackle a problem of drug addiction for people who are not in work.
We hope that all parties support this legislation and will work respectfully with all parties to ensure the trial can take place and help as many people as possible.We hope that all parties support this legislation and will work respectfully with all parties to ensure the trial can take place and help as many people as possible.
There is clear community support for the trial as reports in the media today further show.There is clear community support for the trial as reports in the media today further show.
The Labor Party needs to explain to the Australian people why it wants to deny the Government the opportunity to tackle a problem of drug addiction for people who are not in work.The Labor Party needs to explain to the Australian people why it wants to deny the Government the opportunity to tackle a problem of drug addiction for people who are not in work.
We hope that all parties support this legislation and will work respectfully with all parties to ensure the trial can take place and help as many people as possible.We hope that all parties support this legislation and will work respectfully with all parties to ensure the trial can take place and help as many people as possible.
If asked about claims there is no evidence it works:If asked about claims there is no evidence it works:
Evidence shows drug addiction prevents people from working. The 2016 National Drug Strategy Household Survey (undertaken by Australian Institute of Health and Welfare) shows that unemployed people were 3.1 times more likely to use meth/amphetamines and 1.5 times more likely to use cannabis than the employed.Evidence shows drug addiction prevents people from working. The 2016 National Drug Strategy Household Survey (undertaken by Australian Institute of Health and Welfare) shows that unemployed people were 3.1 times more likely to use meth/amphetamines and 1.5 times more likely to use cannabis than the employed.
As the PM said: “This is a trial. We are trying to work out if this can work. I am really puzzled by the level of opposition to the Government trying to tackle a problem of drug addiction for people who are not in work and helping them get over it with referral to proper services and funding those services in those trial areas”.As the PM said: “This is a trial. We are trying to work out if this can work. I am really puzzled by the level of opposition to the Government trying to tackle a problem of drug addiction for people who are not in work and helping them get over it with referral to proper services and funding those services in those trial areas”.
The trial will be subject to a comprehensive evaluation on whether drug testing is an effective way of identifying unemployed Australians whose substance abuse is a barrier to work and supporting those people to undertake treatment.The trial will be subject to a comprehensive evaluation on whether drug testing is an effective way of identifying unemployed Australians whose substance abuse is a barrier to work and supporting those people to undertake treatment.
The evaluation will be conducted in parallel with the trial to allow the Government to identify any unintended consequences so these can be addressed in real time.The evaluation will be conducted in parallel with the trial to allow the Government to identify any unintended consequences so these can be addressed in real time.
Evidence shows drug addiction prevents people from working. The 2016 National Drug Strategy Household Survey (undertaken by Australian Institute of Health and Welfare) shows that unemployed people were 3.1 times more likely to use meth/amphetamines and 1.5 times more likely to use cannabis than the employed.Evidence shows drug addiction prevents people from working. The 2016 National Drug Strategy Household Survey (undertaken by Australian Institute of Health and Welfare) shows that unemployed people were 3.1 times more likely to use meth/amphetamines and 1.5 times more likely to use cannabis than the employed.
As the PM said: “This is a trial. We are trying to work out if this can work. I am really puzzled by the level of opposition to the Government trying to tackle a problem of drug addiction for people who are not in work and helping them get over it with referral to proper services and funding those services in those trial areas”.As the PM said: “This is a trial. We are trying to work out if this can work. I am really puzzled by the level of opposition to the Government trying to tackle a problem of drug addiction for people who are not in work and helping them get over it with referral to proper services and funding those services in those trial areas”.
The trial will be subject to a comprehensive evaluation on whether drug testing is an effective way of identifying unemployed Australians whose substance abuse is a barrier to work and supporting those people to undertake treatment.The trial will be subject to a comprehensive evaluation on whether drug testing is an effective way of identifying unemployed Australians whose substance abuse is a barrier to work and supporting those people to undertake treatment.
The evaluation will be conducted in parallel with the trial to allow the Government to identify any unintended consequences so these can be addressed in real time.The evaluation will be conducted in parallel with the trial to allow the Government to identify any unintended consequences so these can be addressed in real time.
If asked about the trial being likened to a Russian plan to send people who test positive for HIV to an island:If asked about the trial being likened to a Russian plan to send people who test positive for HIV to an island:
It is disappointing to note the fearmongering around the Government’s proposed drug testing trial which is a genuine attempt to help unemployed Australians overcome substance abuse which is a barrier to work.It is disappointing to note the fearmongering around the Government’s proposed drug testing trial which is a genuine attempt to help unemployed Australians overcome substance abuse which is a barrier to work.
It is disappointing to note the fearmongering around the Government’s proposed drug testing trial which is a genuine attempt to help unemployed Australians overcome substance abuse which is a barrier to work.It is disappointing to note the fearmongering around the Government’s proposed drug testing trial which is a genuine attempt to help unemployed Australians overcome substance abuse which is a barrier to work.
The Newstart talking points makes my eye twitch a little:The Newstart talking points makes my eye twitch a little:
No one is saying it’s easy to get by without a job which is why the Morrison Government is absolutely focused on helping unemployed Australians be work ready and creating jobs so working age Australians have the opportunity to gain financial independence.No one is saying it’s easy to get by without a job which is why the Morrison Government is absolutely focused on helping unemployed Australians be work ready and creating jobs so working age Australians have the opportunity to gain financial independence.
We are delivering results with more than 1.4 million jobs being created since we were elected which is about 240,000 a year compared with just 155,000 on average under Labor.We are delivering results with more than 1.4 million jobs being created since we were elected which is about 240,000 a year compared with just 155,000 on average under Labor.
The lowest proportion of working age people on welfare in 30 years is proof that our policies are working.The lowest proportion of working age people on welfare in 30 years is proof that our policies are working.
Newstart is a taxpayer funded allowance that provides a taxpayer-funded safety net for people while they look for a job. It is not a salary replacement.Newstart is a taxpayer funded allowance that provides a taxpayer-funded safety net for people while they look for a job. It is not a salary replacement.
It is already increased twice a year, every year in line with CPI which is a widely accepted measure of changes to cost of living.It is already increased twice a year, every year in line with CPI which is a widely accepted measure of changes to cost of living.
Everyone who receives Newstart Allowance is eligible for some form of additional assistance from the welfare system including rent assistance, family tax benefit or the energy supplement on top of the $559 base rate.Everyone who receives Newstart Allowance is eligible for some form of additional assistance from the welfare system including rent assistance, family tax benefit or the energy supplement on top of the $559 base rate.
About two-thirds of those granted Newstart get off the payment within 12 months.About two-thirds of those granted Newstart get off the payment within 12 months.
The Government is focused on breaking down the barriers some Australians face in returning to the workforce which is why we are investing $96 million in Try, Test and Learn which is trialling innovative pathways to work for those people at risk of long term welfare dependency.The Government is focused on breaking down the barriers some Australians face in returning to the workforce which is why we are investing $96 million in Try, Test and Learn which is trialling innovative pathways to work for those people at risk of long term welfare dependency.
The Cashless Debit Card is financial management tool helping unemployed Australians stablise their personal circumstances while our proposed Drug Testing Trial will help identify welfare recipients struggling with substance abuse and provide them with support to get back on track.The Cashless Debit Card is financial management tool helping unemployed Australians stablise their personal circumstances while our proposed Drug Testing Trial will help identify welfare recipients struggling with substance abuse and provide them with support to get back on track.
Welfare cost more than $172 billion in 2018-19, representing more than one in three dollars or 35 per cent of all spending by the Government.Welfare cost more than $172 billion in 2018-19, representing more than one in three dollars or 35 per cent of all spending by the Government.
It is the responsibility of Government to ensure our social security and welfare system is sustainable into the future, so that it can continue to provide support to those most in need.It is the responsibility of Government to ensure our social security and welfare system is sustainable into the future, so that it can continue to provide support to those most in need.
The Labor Party continues to play a cruel joke on Australians claiming to support an increase in the Newstart rate without naming the size of their supposed increase or how they would pay for it.The Labor Party continues to play a cruel joke on Australians claiming to support an increase in the Newstart rate without naming the size of their supposed increase or how they would pay for it.
Anthony Albanese wants to outsource decisions on how to spend more than a third of Government spending saying it is a “reasonable suggestion” for an independent tribunal to decide the rate of welfare payments. Not only is this irresponsible fiscal policy but it reveals the Opposition leader is not ready to lead because governments are elected to make decisions not outsource the tough ones.Anthony Albanese wants to outsource decisions on how to spend more than a third of Government spending saying it is a “reasonable suggestion” for an independent tribunal to decide the rate of welfare payments. Not only is this irresponsible fiscal policy but it reveals the Opposition leader is not ready to lead because governments are elected to make decisions not outsource the tough ones.
No one is saying it’s easy to get by without a job which is why the Morrison Government is absolutely focused on helping unemployed Australians be work ready and creating jobs so working age Australians have the opportunity to gain financial independence.No one is saying it’s easy to get by without a job which is why the Morrison Government is absolutely focused on helping unemployed Australians be work ready and creating jobs so working age Australians have the opportunity to gain financial independence.
We are delivering results with more than 1.4 million jobs being created since we were elected which is about 240,000 a year compared with just 155,000 on average under Labor.We are delivering results with more than 1.4 million jobs being created since we were elected which is about 240,000 a year compared with just 155,000 on average under Labor.
The lowest proportion of working age people on welfare in 30 years is proof that our policies are working.The lowest proportion of working age people on welfare in 30 years is proof that our policies are working.
Newstart is a taxpayer funded allowance that provides a taxpayer-funded safety net for people while they look for a job. It is not a salary replacement.Newstart is a taxpayer funded allowance that provides a taxpayer-funded safety net for people while they look for a job. It is not a salary replacement.
It is already increased twice a year, every year in line with CPI which is a widely accepted measure of changes to cost of living.It is already increased twice a year, every year in line with CPI which is a widely accepted measure of changes to cost of living.
Everyone who receives Newstart Allowance is eligible for some form of additional assistance from the welfare system including rent assistance, family tax benefit or the energy supplement on top of the $559 base rate.Everyone who receives Newstart Allowance is eligible for some form of additional assistance from the welfare system including rent assistance, family tax benefit or the energy supplement on top of the $559 base rate.
About two-thirds of those granted Newstart get off the payment within 12 months.About two-thirds of those granted Newstart get off the payment within 12 months.
The Government is focused on breaking down the barriers some Australians face in returning to the workforce which is why we are investing $96 million in Try, Test and Learn which is trialling innovative pathways to work for those people at risk of long term welfare dependency.The Government is focused on breaking down the barriers some Australians face in returning to the workforce which is why we are investing $96 million in Try, Test and Learn which is trialling innovative pathways to work for those people at risk of long term welfare dependency.
The Cashless Debit Card is financial management tool helping unemployed Australians stablise their personal circumstances while our proposed Drug Testing Trial will help identify welfare recipients struggling with substance abuse and provide them with support to get back on track.The Cashless Debit Card is financial management tool helping unemployed Australians stablise their personal circumstances while our proposed Drug Testing Trial will help identify welfare recipients struggling with substance abuse and provide them with support to get back on track.
Welfare cost more than $172 billion in 2018-19, representing more than one in three dollars or 35 per cent of all spending by the Government.Welfare cost more than $172 billion in 2018-19, representing more than one in three dollars or 35 per cent of all spending by the Government.
It is the responsibility of Government to ensure our social security and welfare system is sustainable into the future, so that it can continue to provide support to those most in need.It is the responsibility of Government to ensure our social security and welfare system is sustainable into the future, so that it can continue to provide support to those most in need.
The Labor Party continues to play a cruel joke on Australians claiming to support an increase in the Newstart rate without naming the size of their supposed increase or how they would pay for it.The Labor Party continues to play a cruel joke on Australians claiming to support an increase in the Newstart rate without naming the size of their supposed increase or how they would pay for it.
Anthony Albanese wants to outsource decisions on how to spend more than a third of Government spending saying it is a “reasonable suggestion” for an independent tribunal to decide the rate of welfare payments. Not only is this irresponsible fiscal policy but it reveals the Opposition leader is not ready to lead because governments are elected to make decisions not outsource the tough ones.Anthony Albanese wants to outsource decisions on how to spend more than a third of Government spending saying it is a “reasonable suggestion” for an independent tribunal to decide the rate of welfare payments. Not only is this irresponsible fiscal policy but it reveals the Opposition leader is not ready to lead because governments are elected to make decisions not outsource the tough ones.
If asked could you live in $40 a day?If asked could you live in $40 a day?
No one is saying it would be easy and the Government understands some Australians are doing it incredibly tough.No one is saying it would be easy and the Government understands some Australians are doing it incredibly tough.
Newstart is a safety net, it’s not meant to be a replacement for a salary.Newstart is a safety net, it’s not meant to be a replacement for a salary.
The focus of Newstart combined with our government’s additional supports and programs is to help people who find themselves on hard times and to support them to get back into the workforce.The focus of Newstart combined with our government’s additional supports and programs is to help people who find themselves on hard times and to support them to get back into the workforce.
Whether it’s Work for the Dole, Youth Jobs PaTH or ParentsNext programs, we’re helping Australians get a job so they can earn a wage that creates a better future for themselves and their families.Whether it’s Work for the Dole, Youth Jobs PaTH or ParentsNext programs, we’re helping Australians get a job so they can earn a wage that creates a better future for themselves and their families.
No one is saying it would be easy and the Government understands some Australians are doing it incredibly tough.No one is saying it would be easy and the Government understands some Australians are doing it incredibly tough.
Newstart is a safety net, it’s not meant to be a replacement for a salary.Newstart is a safety net, it’s not meant to be a replacement for a salary.
The focus of Newstart combined with our government’s additional supports and programs is to help people who find themselves on hard times and to support them to get back into the workforce.The focus of Newstart combined with our government’s additional supports and programs is to help people who find themselves on hard times and to support them to get back into the workforce.
Whether it’s Work for the Dole, Youth Jobs PaTH or ParentsNext programs, we’re helping Australians get a job so they can earn a wage that creates a better future for themselves and their families.Whether it’s Work for the Dole, Youth Jobs PaTH or ParentsNext programs, we’re helping Australians get a job so they can earn a wage that creates a better future for themselves and their families.
If asked whether an increase to Newstart would stimulate the economyIf asked whether an increase to Newstart would stimulate the economy
This Government is focused on policies like increasing productivity and moving people from welfare into work.This Government is focused on policies like increasing productivity and moving people from welfare into work.
Our policies like record infrastructure investment, tax relief and investment in schools and hospitals are creating the conditions for jobs growth across the economy and delivering services Australians rely on.Our policies like record infrastructure investment, tax relief and investment in schools and hospitals are creating the conditions for jobs growth across the economy and delivering services Australians rely on.
This Government is focused on policies like increasing productivity and moving people from welfare into work.This Government is focused on policies like increasing productivity and moving people from welfare into work.
Our policies like record infrastructure investment, tax relief and investment in schools and hospitals are creating the conditions for jobs growth across the economy and delivering services Australians rely on.Our policies like record infrastructure investment, tax relief and investment in schools and hospitals are creating the conditions for jobs growth across the economy and delivering services Australians rely on.
The government wants you to know that everything is totally fine with Gladys Liu. From the talking points:The government wants you to know that everything is totally fine with Gladys Liu. From the talking points:
Ms Liu has spent a considerable amount of time over the last three weeks reviewing her association with all community organisations. With nearly 1000 Chinese organisations alone in Victoria alone it has been a lengthy task.Ms Liu has spent a considerable amount of time over the last three weeks reviewing her association with all community organisations. With nearly 1000 Chinese organisations alone in Victoria alone it has been a lengthy task.
Ms Liu has very clearly stated that she does not wish to be a member of any organisation that has not received her explicit consent. She has asked that she be removed from all organisations that have not received her consent.Ms Liu has very clearly stated that she does not wish to be a member of any organisation that has not received her explicit consent. She has asked that she be removed from all organisations that have not received her consent.
Ms Liu is confident that she is not linked to any organisations that may have inappropriate associations.Ms Liu is confident that she is not linked to any organisations that may have inappropriate associations.
Ms Liu has spent a considerable amount of time over the last three weeks reviewing her association with all community organisations. With nearly 1000 Chinese organisations alone in Victoria alone it has been a lengthy task.Ms Liu has spent a considerable amount of time over the last three weeks reviewing her association with all community organisations. With nearly 1000 Chinese organisations alone in Victoria alone it has been a lengthy task.
Ms Liu has very clearly stated that she does not wish to be a member of any organisation that has not received her explicit consent. She has asked that she be removed from all organisations that have not received her consent.Ms Liu has very clearly stated that she does not wish to be a member of any organisation that has not received her explicit consent. She has asked that she be removed from all organisations that have not received her consent.
Ms Liu is confident that she is not linked to any organisations that may have inappropriate associations.Ms Liu is confident that she is not linked to any organisations that may have inappropriate associations.
Barnaby Joyce, who was last incensed over toilet facilities at Sydney Airport, was feeling reflective on his twitter feed this morning:
It stills gives me a thrill going to work. pic.twitter.com/G47oSsJFwW
The tweet before was about how monopoly ownership of Sydney airport was not healthy, with a shot of out-of-order urinals (save yourself and don’t look - what has been seen can not be unseen).
What was left out of the tweet was the Sydney airport was privatised in 2002 - under the Howard government.
As first reported by Rob Harris at Nine Newspapers, Barnaby Joyce is the latest person to speak out on behalf of Julian Assange. This is what Joyce had to say to reporters this morning:
I, in no way, shape or form, give a character recommendation about Mr Assange. That’s not the issue. The issue is the sovereignty of the laws. And the law is for those you both like or dislike, or have no opinion on. If a person commits a crime in Australia, then you’ll be judged by Australian law. If a person commits a crime in another country while they’re there, they should be judged by those laws. If a person is residing in Australia and commits a crime in another country, I don’t believe that that is a position for extradition. If they weren’t actually there, if they weren’t present there, that is a question for Australian law. We have to follow the principle, even if we don’t have regard for the person.
The first subject (after an election list of “priorities” was drought. What is most interesting about this one is that it highlights the parts the government knows it is vulnerable on – no actual national drought policy, issues with the farm household allowance and $5bn of that $7bn repeated total, going to a future fund.
SUPPORT FOR DROUGHT-AFFECTED AREAS
Farmers and their communities will have access to more support with the Coalition Government announcing it will provide more funding, cut red tape and increase services.
This week we announced an extra $13.2 million in support for further on-farm water infrastructure – more than 2000 farmers have already taken up the chance to improve their water access by building new bores, pipelines and desilting muddy dams and the rebate will now also be made available to farmers with permanent crops like fruit trees and vineyards.
The support package we announced last week will deliver nearly $100 million to drought-hit communities, which is on top of more than $7 billion in drought support funding already provided by the Government.
As the Prime Minister has said, supporting drought affected communities remains our Government’s most urgent priority. That is why he headed directly to drought affected Queensland after he arrives from the US.
We are delivering $33 million to resume the Drought Community Support Initiative, which will deliver up to $3000 to eligible farming households experiencing hardship due to drought.
We are providing a $13 million extension to the Drought Community Programme to deliver support at the local government level where it counts. Thirteen more Local Government Areas will be provided up to $1 million for local infrastructure and drought relief products. Those areas have been chosen based on Bureau of Meteorology data about current and future weather conditions.
We’re also:
Delivering the $5 billion Future Drought Fund to help give our farmers tools to prepare for, manage and sustain their businesses through drought.
We’ve also been slashing the complexity of the forms to apply and expanding the eligibility of the program
Delivering the $5 billion Future Drought Fund to help give our farmers tools to prepare for, manage and sustain their businesses through drought.
We’ve also been slashing the complexity of the forms to apply and expanding the eligibility of the program
Farmers and their communities will have access to more support with the Coalition Government announcing it will provide more funding, cut red tape and increase services.
This week we announced an extra $13.2 million in support for further on-farm water infrastructure – more than 2000 farmers have already taken up the chance to improve their water access by building new bores, pipelines and desilting muddy dams and the rebate will now also be made available to farmers with permanent crops like fruit trees and vineyards.
The support package we announced last week will deliver nearly $100 million to drought-hit communities, which is on top of more than $7 billion in drought support funding already provided by the Government.
As the Prime Minister has said, supporting drought affected communities remains our Government’s most urgent priority. That is why he headed directly to drought affected Queensland after he arrives from the US.
We are delivering $33 million to resume the Drought Community Support Initiative, which will deliver up to $3000 to eligible farming households experiencing hardship due to drought.
We are providing a $13 million extension to the Drought Community Programme to deliver support at the local government level where it counts. Thirteen more Local Government Areas will be provided up to $1 million for local infrastructure and drought relief products. Those areas have been chosen based on Bureau of Meteorology data about current and future weather conditions.
We’re also:
Delivering the $5 billion Future Drought Fund to help give our farmers tools to prepare for, manage and sustain their businesses through drought.
We’ve also been slashing the complexity of the forms to apply and expanding the eligibility of the program
Delivering the $5 billion Future Drought Fund to help give our farmers tools to prepare for, manage and sustain their businesses through drought.
We’ve also been slashing the complexity of the forms to apply and expanding the eligibility of the program
Delivering the $5 billion Future Drought Fund to help give our farmers tools to prepare for, manage and sustain their businesses through drought.
We’ve also been slashing the complexity of the forms to apply and expanding the eligibility of the program
If asked: calls for a national drought policy
The federal government has a national drought policy and it was outlined following the national drought summit the Government convened last year
It includes more than $7 billion worth of measures from supporting people’s mental health to additional assistance through the Farm Household Allowance, as well as our backing for 21 new water infrastructure projects
Our response is strategic, comprehensive and focused on both the short-term immediacy needs of farming families and the longer-term future for agriculture in this country
None of these talking points are Watergate. We all know that MPs have talking notes – how else do you think they all say the same thing, over and over and over again?
And there is nothing new in any of them – we all know the government’s lines on these issues.
But it is interesting that the arguments have not shifted, despite the debates having moved on – the government is still pushing the same points it has been pushing since Scott Morrison came to power.
But we have come to expect that too. Everything Morrison doesn’t want to talk about is a “bubble” issue, or something he is “not getting into” or “I’ve already answered that” and we all know the issues with getting anything out of government departments.
I made an #FOI request for the cost of @Melissa4Durack’s recent trip to Europe. This was the estimated cost of processing it - 142 hours #FOIFriday #auspol pic.twitter.com/b1eF2KrWIf
This is just more of the same.
And on welfare, which is also an issue which is not going away (and nor should it) the government wants its members spreading these messages:
Social services touches almost all Australians at some stage in their lives usually when people are at their most vulnerable which is why it is absolutely crucial that the system remains sustainable into the future so that we can continue to provide support to those most in need.
In 2018-19 the Government spent more than $170 billion a year on social security and welfare, representing more than one in three dollars or 35 per cent of all Commonwealth spending. That amount equates to about 75 per cent of the total amount paid in personal income tax
As such the system it must be targeted, sustainable and in line with the expectations of the taxpayers who fund it.
The Government’s position on Newstart, and indeed the Prime Minister’s position, is very clear: The best form of welfare is a job, and the Government is absolutely focused on getting people off of welfare and into work.
It is a taxpayer funded allowance that provides a safety net for people while they look for a job and is increased twice a year, every year in line with CPI. It is not intended to be a wage replacement.
The Morrison Government is delivering the job opportunities with more than 1.4 million jobs created since the Coalition was elected. We are also providing pathways to jobs and breaking down barriers unemployed Australians face getting back into the workforce.
Newstart Allowance is just one element of our comprehensive social security and welfare system which include additional supplements and allowances, concessional access to healthcare, and targeted support through employment services all play a role in supporting people whilst they transition back into the workforce.
Jobs growth and supporting jobseekers to fulfil mutual obligations with employment services and through activities designed to improve their job prospects has contributed to the improved lifetime cost of welfare as well as the significant reduction in people entering the welfare system and reduced persistency of payments.
The proportion of Australians receiving working-age income support payments has fallen to its lowest level in 30 years at 14.3 per cent. There are 230,000 fewer working age recipients on income support payments between June 2014 and June 2018.
Social services touches almost all Australians at some stage in their lives usually when people are at their most vulnerable which is why it is absolutely crucial that the system remains sustainable into the future so that we can continue to provide support to those most in need.
In 2018-19 the Government spent more than $170 billion a year on social security and welfare, representing more than one in three dollars or 35 per cent of all Commonwealth spending. That amount equates to about 75 per cent of the total amount paid in personal income tax
As such the system it must be targeted, sustainable and in line with the expectations of the taxpayers who fund it.
The Government’s position on Newstart, and indeed the Prime Minister’s position, is very clear: The best form of welfare is a job, and the Government is absolutely focused on getting people off of welfare and into work.
It is a taxpayer funded allowance that provides a safety net for people while they look for a job and is increased twice a year, every year in line with CPI. It is not intended to be a wage replacement.
The Morrison Government is delivering the job opportunities with more than 1.4 million jobs created since the Coalition was elected. We are also providing pathways to jobs and breaking down barriers unemployed Australians face getting back into the workforce.
Newstart Allowance is just one element of our comprehensive social security and welfare system which include additional supplements and allowances, concessional access to healthcare, and targeted support through employment services all play a role in supporting people whilst they transition back into the workforce.
Jobs growth and supporting jobseekers to fulfil mutual obligations with employment services and through activities designed to improve their job prospects has contributed to the improved lifetime cost of welfare as well as the significant reduction in people entering the welfare system and reduced persistency of payments.
The proportion of Australians receiving working-age income support payments has fallen to its lowest level in 30 years at 14.3 per cent. There are 230,000 fewer working age recipients on income support payments between June 2014 and June 2018.
If asked – 2018 Welfare Valuation Report
The latest valuation shows a 10.1 per cent reduction in the total future lifetime cost of welfare in Australia down to $5.7 trillion when compared to the re-based 30 June 2017 estimates, confirming the success of Government welfare to work initiatives.
Government initiatives have contributed to this improved lifetime cost of welfare including jobs growth and significant reductions in entries onto payments and decreases in persistency to payments.
The full 2018 valuation will be released by Government in due course.
The latest valuation shows a 10.1 per cent reduction in the total future lifetime cost of welfare in Australia down to $5.7 trillion when compared to the re-based 30 June 2017 estimates, confirming the success of Government welfare to work initiatives.
Government initiatives have contributed to this improved lifetime cost of welfare including jobs growth and significant reductions in entries onto payments and decreases in persistency to payments.
The full 2018 valuation will be released by Government in due course.
If asked why do the PIA figures differ from those reported in past years:
The 2018 Priority Investment Approach uses a 5 per cent discount rate based on advice from the Australian Government Actuary in line with other government estimations. The Government has updated the first three years of valuations in line with that decision so we are comparing apples with apples.
Changing the Discount Rate from 6 per cent to 5 per cent is not an accounting trick – it brings the valuation in line with the Budget discount rate and other Government publications, demonstrating a realistic and responsible Government response to recent economic conditions.
The 2018 Priority Investment Approach uses a 5 per cent discount rate based on advice from the Australian Government Actuary in line with other government estimations. The Government has updated the first three years of valuations in line with that decision so we are comparing apples with apples.
Changing the Discount Rate from 6 per cent to 5 per cent is not an accounting trick – it brings the valuation in line with the Budget discount rate and other Government publications, demonstrating a realistic and responsible Government response to recent economic conditions.
Another big issue for the government – border protection – was also on its talking notes list.
Kristina Keneally was on Insiders on Sunday (here is some of what she had to say) but it’s Labor’s stance on people who overstay their visas who arrive by air that the government is focusing on. Here is the government line on that for this week:
PROTECTION CLAIMS BY MIGRANTS WHO ARRIVE BY AIR
In the last three years that Labor was in office, 6900 permanent protection visas were granted by Labor to people who arrived by air. In the last three years under this Government, 4780 visas have been granted – 31 per cent less than under Labor.
The Government is focusing resources both on and offshore to prevent unmeritorious protection claims. This includes through enhancements to our intelligence systems and operational activity.
Less than 0.25% of people who arrive lawfully in Australia apply for protection, and of them the vast majority are refused.
And the numbers of those who do apply for protection are declining. In 2018-19, the number of onshore protection claims fell by 12 per cent, a result of the Government’s focus on stopping unmeritorious claims.
This number is continuing to decline at similar rate this program YTD.
People who arrive by air, do so with valid travel and identity documents. We know who they are. They are not putting their lives at risk, or the lives of their children at risk, by getting on a boat.
We won’t be taking any advice from Labor, whose mismanagement of our border was an absolute disgrace.
Labor’s boat arrivals saw 50,000 people arrive unlawfully, 8000 children were forcibly placed in detention, 1200 people lost their lives, 17 detention centres were opened – all at a cost to the Australian taxpayer of $17B.
In the last three years that Labor was in office, 6900 permanent protection visas were granted by Labor to people who arrived by air. In the last three years under this Government, 4780 visas have been granted – 31 per cent less than under Labor.
The Government is focusing resources both on and offshore to prevent unmeritorious protection claims. This includes through enhancements to our intelligence systems and operational activity.
Less than 0.25% of people who arrive lawfully in Australia apply for protection, and of them the vast majority are refused.
And the numbers of those who do apply for protection are declining. In 2018-19, the number of onshore protection claims fell by 12 per cent, a result of the Government’s focus on stopping unmeritorious claims.
This number is continuing to decline at similar rate this program YTD.
People who arrive by air, do so with valid travel and identity documents. We know who they are. They are not putting their lives at risk, or the lives of their children at risk, by getting on a boat.
We won’t be taking any advice from Labor, whose mismanagement of our border was an absolute disgrace.
Labor’s boat arrivals saw 50,000 people arrive unlawfully, 8000 children were forcibly placed in detention, 1200 people lost their lives, 17 detention centres were opened – all at a cost to the Australian taxpayer of $17B.
If asked about worker exploitation
The exploitation of any worker in Australia is something we have zero tolerance for.
We take a whole of government, multi-agency approach when it comes to the exploitation of foreign workers – this includes the Australian Federal Police, the Australian Border Force, State and Territory Police, the Australian Taxation Office and the Fair Work Ombudsman.
Labor claim to be concerned about worker exploitation, but when they were last in government they decimated the Fair Work Ombudsman’s funding by more than $20m, cut their staff by 23 per cent and had no policy to protect vulnerable workers.
We have legislated to increase penalties for worker exploitation by up to ten-fold, increased the powers of the Fair Work Ombudsman to enforce the law, and increased their resources by over $50 million and 60 new staff.
The exploitation of any worker in Australia is something we have zero tolerance for.
We take a whole of government, multi-agency approach when it comes to the exploitation of foreign workers – this includes the Australian Federal Police, the Australian Border Force, State and Territory Police, the Australian Taxation Office and the Fair Work Ombudsman.
Labor claim to be concerned about worker exploitation, but when they were last in government they decimated the Fair Work Ombudsman’s funding by more than $20m, cut their staff by 23 per cent and had no policy to protect vulnerable workers.
We have legislated to increase penalties for worker exploitation by up to ten-fold, increased the powers of the Fair Work Ombudsman to enforce the law, and increased their resources by over $50 million and 60 new staff.
Labor’s border protection policies
Abolish Temporary Protection Visas.
Abolish the fast track assessment process for boat arrivals.
Increase our permanent refugee intake by 71 per cent, cost of $6B.
Labor has already, through partnering with the Greens, passed a law that removes the Government’s ability to determine who comes to Australia from Manus or Nauru.
The leader of the opposition voted to ban boat turn-backs. The Shadow Immigration Minister Andrew Giles moved the motion.
Kristina Keneally has previously written in the Guardian to “bring the refugees to Australia”.
Labor’s track record on border security is clear. They cannot be trusted.
Abolish Temporary Protection Visas.
Abolish the fast track assessment process for boat arrivals.
Increase our permanent refugee intake by 71 per cent, cost of $6B.
Labor has already, through partnering with the Greens, passed a law that removes the Government’s ability to determine who comes to Australia from Manus or Nauru.
The leader of the opposition voted to ban boat turn-backs. The Shadow Immigration Minister Andrew Giles moved the motion.
Kristina Keneally has previously written in the Guardian to “bring the refugees to Australia”.
Labor’s track record on border security is clear. They cannot be trusted.
And for why the medevac legislation is considered so important by medical bodies, you only need to return to this story from Katharine Murphy a little earlier this year.
The medical review panel is not overturning all of the minister’s decisions. We know that, because they have to report to the parliament.
In the June quarterly report, the panel, which is chosen by the government, agreed with the minister’s decision in nine of the 15 cases he rejected.
Australian medical facilities have not been overrun. Elective surgeries have not been subjected to widespread cancellations (which was actually a claim put forward at the time) and the boats have not restarted.
But people who need it, who are under our care, are getting the treatment doctors tell us they so desperately need.
On that bolded point in the last post, these are the actual facts, as reported by Katharine Murphy when the bill was still being discussed. The minister has not lost discretion when it comes to security reasons:
What discretion does the responsible minister have?
Ministerial discretion applies in three areas.
First, the minister can refuse the transfer if he or she disagrees with the clinical assessment.
The second grounds for refusal is if the minister reasonably suspects that the transfer of the person to Australia would be prejudicial to security “within the meaning of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979, including because an adverse security assessment in respect of the person is in force under that Act”.
Sticking with security, the transfer can also be knocked back if Asio advises the minister that transfer of the person to Australia may be prejudicial to security “and that threat cannot be mitigated”.
The third grounds for refusal is if the minister knows that the transferee has a substantial criminal record (I’ll give you some definitions on that in a minute) and the minister reasonably believes the person would expose the Australian community to a serious risk of criminal conduct.
The decision needs to be made within 72 hours.
If the minister denies the transfer request on health grounds (as opposed to security or criminal grounds), then the issue goes to an Independent Health Advice Panel “as soon as practicable”.
The panel then conducts a second assessment and reports within 72 hours. If the panel reports the person should be transferred on health grounds, and the other vetoes I’ve mentioned are not in force, then the view of the panel prevails.
Here is what the government has to say about the medevac legislation. Which MP, you ask? Oh, any of them. This is what the PMO wants them to say, so expect to see varying examples of this throughout the week.
Processes for medical transfer already exist and are effective.
Section 198B of the Migration Act allows for a transitory person from a country or place outside Australia to come to Australia for a temporary purpose, for example medical or psychiatric assessment or treatment.
There are currently over 1,000 transitory persons in Australia.
The repeal of the Miscellaneous Measures Act does not remove the ability to medically transfer a transitory person to Australia.
It is important to have a single, consistent, transparent medical transfer process with all the necessary protections for the Commonwealth and individuals in place.
It is a misconception that the medical transfer provisions inserted by the Miscellaneous Measures Act introduced “doctors” into the medical transfer process.
It did not. The Department has consistently relied on clinical advice from doctors to form decisions on whether to bring a person to Australia for medical.
It is the Government’s position that it should determine who is allowed to enter Australia, and the terms and conditions to be imposed on that entry, as is the right of every sovereign nation*
Medical services in Papua New Guinea and Nauru have improved over time to more effectively respond to transferee health needs and requirements.
The need for medical transfers to third countries, including Australia, reduced as medical capacity and treatment options became more readily available in Papua New Guinea and Nauru.
Welcome to the 20th sitting day of the 46th parliament – and the third last week of joint sittings for the year.
That’s right, we only have three more weeks (or 12 more sitting days) of having both House MPs and the senators in the building at the same time. There is an extra House-only sitting next week, with a Senate-only sitting week next month, but that is it!
Before we get there, we have a bunch of things to not talk about.
We know that, because the prime minister’s office accidentally emailed the government’s talking notes for the day (the list that goes out to government MPs so they know what line to stick to when questioned on issues) to the media distribution list. I’ll bring you some from that a little later.
Josh Frydenberg has announced the ACCC will be looking into mortgage products after the big four banks neglected to pass on the latest interest rate cut from the RBA in full.
And Jacqui Lambie, as the swing vote, is facing pressure from all sides over medevac. The government wants it gone. Labor, the Greens and the independents, who worked together to get it passed, want it to stay. In a fairly unprecedented step, the nation’s medical bodies came together in a joint statement at the weekend, asking for it to remain. Lambie says she won’t horse-trade over the legislation but is staying quiet on which way she is leaning.
Lambie is taking her time this second go round in the Senate. The parliamentary report into medevac is due to be handed down on 18 October, but the Senate isn’t back until 11 November, so she still has a few weeks to think it over.
You’ll have Mike Bowers, Katharine Murphy, Sarah Martin and Paul Karp at your disposal, plus what ever percentage of me can be mustered up once I get my third coffee. Stay in touch with us on the socials, or in the comments.
Ready?
Let’s get into it.