This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-50148094
The article has changed 10 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 5 | Version 6 |
---|---|
Brexit: PM to push for election if EU agrees three-month delay | |
(about 1 hour later) | |
The PM will push for a general election if the EU agrees to delay Brexit until January, No 10 has indicated. | |
Boris Johnson "paused" his Brexit bill on Tuesday after MPs rejected his plan to get it signed off in three days. | Boris Johnson "paused" his Brexit bill on Tuesday after MPs rejected his plan to get it signed off in three days. |
Now EU leaders will consider whether to grant a delay to the 31 October Brexit deadline and what length it should be. | Now EU leaders will consider whether to grant a delay to the 31 October Brexit deadline and what length it should be. |
A letter Mr Johnson was forced by law to send to the bloc after failing to secure backing for his deal on Saturday calls for a three-month extension. | A letter Mr Johnson was forced by law to send to the bloc after failing to secure backing for his deal on Saturday calls for a three-month extension. |
What happens now? | |
Although Downing Street has suggested its plan is to push for an election, the prime minister cannot force one unilaterally. | |
The move would need the backing of Parliament, and opposition MPs have previously ruled out holding one until the prospect of no-deal on 31 October was ruled out. | |
Justice Secretary Robert Buckland told BBC Breakfast that "regrettably it does seem that a general election is the only way to sort this impasse out". | |
His opposite number, Labour's Richard Burgon, told BBC Radio 4's Today programme his party would agree to a general election if the EU granted an extension because it meant a no-deal Brexit would certainly be "off the table". | |
There are other options though - Conservative David Lidington, former de facto deputy prime minister under Theresa May, is urging the government to try again to pass its Brexit legislation - the Withdrawal Agreement Bill (WAB) - with an amended timetable. | |
He suggested the government should first ask the Labour Party how long its MPs needed to scrutinise the bill. | |
There is also the option of a further referendum, although it would require a Brexit delay and, most likely, a change of government first. | |
However, Mr Burgon said holding a referendum before an election - favoured by some of his Labour colleagues - was "fantasy politics". | |
MPs had been due to debate the WAB over Wednesday and Thursday, but will now return to discussing the contents of the Queen's Speech - which put forward the government's domestic agenda for the new session of Parliament. | |
There is a tension in the Tory party today - some would rather try again to get the bill through. Those MPs were cock-a-hoop at the fact they had managed to get 19 Labour MPs to cross the threshold to potentially back this kind of Brexit deal - even though that is a million miles away from it getting safe passage through Parliament. | |
But in the heart in Downing Street the instinct is: if a delay is agreed they throw everything into an election instead. | |
No 10's fear is, even if they say "maybe we could pass the bill in a fortnight," that delay might turn into a long one, tangling with Parliament and losing control of the timetable. | |
Just as Parliament doesn't trust the prime minister, the prime minister and his team don't trust Parliament. | |
Opposition parties have no interest really in helping Boris Johnson to complete the passage of this bill. They want to disrupt it for perfectly obvious and legitimate political reasons. | |
So as things stand, the prime minister would rather trigger an election... But it is not in his gift. | |
Read more from the BBC's political editor | |
What happened on Tuesday? | |
On Tuesday, MPs approved the WAB on its first hurdle through the Commons - called the second reading - by 329 votes to 299. | |
But minutes later Mr Johnson was defeated - by a majority of 14 - in a second vote on a fast-tracked timetable for the bill. | But minutes later Mr Johnson was defeated - by a majority of 14 - in a second vote on a fast-tracked timetable for the bill. |
The prime minister insisted to MPs it was still his policy that the UK should leave the EU on Halloween, but acknowledged he would have wait to hear what other leaders said. | |
Following Tuesday's votes, Mr Corbyn said his party was prepared to work with the government to agree "a reasonable timetable" to enable the Commons to debate and scrutinise the Brexit legislation properly. | |
His offer potentially opens the way for Parliament to approve the bill before the end of the year. | |
But it also opens up increased opportunities for MPs to seek to amend the legislation in ways the government would find unacceptable - such as by including a customs union or second referendum. | |
EU Council President Donald Tusk said he would recommend European leaders backed an extension to the Brexit deadline, though he did not say what length it should be. He said he would "propose a written procedure", thus negating the need for another summit meeting. | |
Could the EU agree to an extension? | |
Germany's Die Welt newspaper sums up EU thoughts on Brexit this morning with the headline: "The only thing that is clear is that Brexit is not happening on 31 October." | Germany's Die Welt newspaper sums up EU thoughts on Brexit this morning with the headline: "The only thing that is clear is that Brexit is not happening on 31 October." |
EU leaders must now agree on whether to grant the UK another Brexit extension and if so: how long for? | EU leaders must now agree on whether to grant the UK another Brexit extension and if so: how long for? |
Don't forget every country has a veto on this. But after speaking extensively to EU diplomats and politicians, the consensus EU-side seems to be to say yes. | Don't forget every country has a veto on this. But after speaking extensively to EU diplomats and politicians, the consensus EU-side seems to be to say yes. |
The EU's decision is expected by the end of the week, but you can expect a lot of EU grumbling beforehand. France's Europe minister was unsurprisingly (France has settled into role of "Brexit bad cop") one of first to speak on the record last night. | The EU's decision is expected by the end of the week, but you can expect a lot of EU grumbling beforehand. France's Europe minister was unsurprisingly (France has settled into role of "Brexit bad cop") one of first to speak on the record last night. |
She noted that time alone wouldn't solve the UK's Brexit conundrum and she said the EU would want to hear UK's justification for another extension - i.e. what will be done with the time? | She noted that time alone wouldn't solve the UK's Brexit conundrum and she said the EU would want to hear UK's justification for another extension - i.e. what will be done with the time? |
EU leaders are fully aware the PM's hand was forced by Parliament to request a three-month extension. Brussels does not want to get embroiled in heated UK debate, so it seems most likely it will say yes to that rather than "impose" their own "EU extension". | EU leaders are fully aware the PM's hand was forced by Parliament to request a three-month extension. Brussels does not want to get embroiled in heated UK debate, so it seems most likely it will say yes to that rather than "impose" their own "EU extension". |
Read more from the BBC's Europe editor. | Read more from the BBC's Europe editor. |
How could a general election happen? | |
Under the Fixed-term Parliaments Act, the prime minister needs to have the backing of two thirds of MPs to hold a snap poll. This has been rejected twice by MPs. | |
Another route to an election is a one-line bill, that requires only a simple majority. | |
But former Tory MP Ken Clarke told the BBC that any such bill was likely to incur a host of amendments, given Mr Johnson does not have a majority. | |
That included attempts to allow 16 and 17-year-olds to vote - something the government is likely to resist. | |
There is also the option of a vote of no confidence in the government, something which Jeremy Corbyn says he wants but only once the threat of a no-deal Brexit on 31 October has been removed. | |
Mr Johnson could even call one in his own government, but Parliamentary rules state that if it passes, the Commons has 14 days to form an alternative administration, so the PM would run the risk of being forced out of Downing Street if opposition parties can unite around a different leader. | |
If an election were to be triggered this week, the earliest it could take place would be Thursday 28 November, as the law requires 25 days between an election being called in Parliament and polling day. | If an election were to be triggered this week, the earliest it could take place would be Thursday 28 November, as the law requires 25 days between an election being called in Parliament and polling day. |
Many observers think a 5 or 12 December election is more likely - but in general, parties tend to prefer polls in lighter, warmer months when the perceived wisdom is that campaigning is easier and voters are more likely to turn out. | |