This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/oct/24/abs-dumped-census-test-forms-with-new-sexuality-questions-after-input-from-ministers-office
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| ABS dumped census test forms with new sexuality questions after input from minister's office | ABS dumped census test forms with new sexuality questions after input from minister's office |
| (32 minutes later) | |
| The Australian Bureau of Statistics printed 20,000 census test forms with new questions on gender and sexuality but dumped them after input from the assistant treasurer Michael Sukkar’s office. | The Australian Bureau of Statistics printed 20,000 census test forms with new questions on gender and sexuality but dumped them after input from the assistant treasurer Michael Sukkar’s office. |
| On Thursday the Australian Statistician, David Kalisch, revealed that Sukkar’s office did “express a preference” about inclusion of the new questions in the test, but took responsibility for dumping them by saying the “ultimate call” was his. | On Thursday the Australian Statistician, David Kalisch, revealed that Sukkar’s office did “express a preference” about inclusion of the new questions in the test, but took responsibility for dumping them by saying the “ultimate call” was his. |
| The evidence at Senate estimates cuts across an attempt by Sukkar’s office to play down its involvement. A spokesman for Sukkar told Guardian Australia this month that “at no stage was a decision sought or provided by the minister in relation to the operation of the census test”. | The evidence at Senate estimates cuts across an attempt by Sukkar’s office to play down its involvement. A spokesman for Sukkar told Guardian Australia this month that “at no stage was a decision sought or provided by the minister in relation to the operation of the census test”. |
| The decision to exclude the questions from the test strongly suggests that the Morrison government will not approve new questions to ask Australians about their gender and sexuality in the 2021 census. | The decision to exclude the questions from the test strongly suggests that the Morrison government will not approve new questions to ask Australians about their gender and sexuality in the 2021 census. |
| It is now clear that the Minister’s office has interfered with the ABS Census process.20,000 questionnaires were pulped.They didn’t want to ask questions on Sexual Orientation.Did this come from the PM?#estimates | It is now clear that the Minister’s office has interfered with the ABS Census process.20,000 questionnaires were pulped.They didn’t want to ask questions on Sexual Orientation.Did this come from the PM?#estimates |
| The two new questions on gender and sexuality were shortlisted among eight new potential topics after a consultation process in 2018. | The two new questions on gender and sexuality were shortlisted among eight new potential topics after a consultation process in 2018. |
| In early October LGBTI health stakeholders were surprised by a Guardian Australia report that the questions had not been included in the census test, run in Wagga Wagga (New South Wales) and Logan (Queensland) on 15 October. | In early October LGBTI health stakeholders were surprised by a Guardian Australia report that the questions had not been included in the census test, run in Wagga Wagga (New South Wales) and Logan (Queensland) on 15 October. |
| Kalisch told Senate estimates that the ABS ordered 40,000 forms for the census test – 20,000 with the new questions and 20,000 without. He had decided not to use the version that included the new questions. | Kalisch told Senate estimates that the ABS ordered 40,000 forms for the census test – 20,000 with the new questions and 20,000 without. He had decided not to use the version that included the new questions. |
| ABS drops reference to worsening wealth inequality to craft a 'good story' | ABS drops reference to worsening wealth inequality to craft a 'good story' |
| He said the ABS had no contact with Scott Morrison, his office or Sukkar personally about the test but: “I have had some conversations with the minister’s office about helping them understand the nature of the consideration around the decision.” | He said the ABS had no contact with Scott Morrison, his office or Sukkar personally about the test but: “I have had some conversations with the minister’s office about helping them understand the nature of the consideration around the decision.” |
| Asked if Sukkar’s office had sought to influence which questions were used, Kalisch said: “They put a view to me but ultimately it was my decision.” | Asked if Sukkar’s office had sought to influence which questions were used, Kalisch said: “They put a view to me but ultimately it was my decision.” |
| At first Kalisch said Sukkar’s office “did not provide any guidance about what should be on or off the [test] form”, before conceding “they did express a preference but ultimately it was my call”. | At first Kalisch said Sukkar’s office “did not provide any guidance about what should be on or off the [test] form”, before conceding “they did express a preference but ultimately it was my call”. |
| Asked if the preference was to exclude gender and sexuality questions, he replied: “They were contemplating what response they would make around census topics, and didn’t want the census test to pre-empt that decision.” | Asked if the preference was to exclude gender and sexuality questions, he replied: “They were contemplating what response they would make around census topics, and didn’t want the census test to pre-empt that decision.” |
| Kalisch noted there were “some sensitivities” around the questions, because “some people in the broader community” were “challenged to understand” what the question about gender meant, given that the census already asks about sex. | Kalisch noted there were “some sensitivities” around the questions, because “some people in the broader community” were “challenged to understand” what the question about gender meant, given that the census already asks about sex. |
| He said there was “sensitivity” around asking Australians’ their sexuality and he had considered making the question optional. ABS officials suggested it was not unusual to print two versions of test forms. | He said there was “sensitivity” around asking Australians’ their sexuality and he had considered making the question optional. ABS officials suggested it was not unusual to print two versions of test forms. |
| The shadow assistant treasurer Stephen Jones and Labor senator Jenny McAllister said the revelation was “deeply concerning”. | |
| “The minister’s objection to a community or their sexual orientation is no reason to refuse to collect import information to help guide government service delivery,” they said. | |
| “Even after years of progress, there are still significant health and wellbeing disparities that effect Australia’s LGBTI community.” | |
| “LGBTI Australians have been ignored in Australian policy planning for too long. All Australians deserve to be counted in the census.” | |
| Nicky Bath, executive director of the LGBTI Health Alliance, said it is “really disappointed” that after the community consultation it appears the basis for the ABS decision “wasn’t necessarily proper process and evidence”. | |
| Bath said the alliance is concerned that gender, sexuality and intersex questions may not be included until the 2026 census but it will continue to make the case despite “potential lack of commitment” from the government. | |
| “It’s not just the census – census data is the key to the door for a whole range of data-sets that local health districts and public services use to better meet community health needs.” | |
| Earlier in October an ABS spokesman explained that the decision not to ask the full suite of new questions in the test had been motivated in part by a desire to keep “the burden we placed on responding households to a minimum”. | Earlier in October an ABS spokesman explained that the decision not to ask the full suite of new questions in the test had been motivated in part by a desire to keep “the burden we placed on responding households to a minimum”. |
| Sukkar’s spokesman said the government “is currently considering the recommendations from the ABS for the 2021 Census”. | Sukkar’s spokesman said the government “is currently considering the recommendations from the ABS for the 2021 Census”. |
| Assistant minister for superannuation, Jane Hume, told Estimates a decision would be tabled in parliament in 2020 on the final questions for the 2021 census. Hume took on notice questions from Labor’s Jenny McAllister about whether there had been any contact between Sukkar and Scott Morrison about the issue. | Assistant minister for superannuation, Jane Hume, told Estimates a decision would be tabled in parliament in 2020 on the final questions for the 2021 census. Hume took on notice questions from Labor’s Jenny McAllister about whether there had been any contact between Sukkar and Scott Morrison about the issue. |
| • Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning | • Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning |
| In October the Equality Australia chief executive, Anna Brown, told Guardian Australia the decision to dump the gender and sexuality questions was “disappointing” because “it is absolutely vital for us to be counted if we are to have the diverse needs of the LGBTIQ community adequately addressed in government policy and programs”. | In October the Equality Australia chief executive, Anna Brown, told Guardian Australia the decision to dump the gender and sexuality questions was “disappointing” because “it is absolutely vital for us to be counted if we are to have the diverse needs of the LGBTIQ community adequately addressed in government policy and programs”. |
| Since becoming prime minister in August 2018, Scott Morrison has been criticised by LGBTI equality advocates for politicising sexuality and gender identity. | Since becoming prime minister in August 2018, Scott Morrison has been criticised by LGBTI equality advocates for politicising sexuality and gender identity. |
| Morrison has opposed sex education programs he agreed made his “skin curl” by teaching the fact of diversity in human sexuality, described teachers who support trans students as “gender whisperers” and demanded his department remove signage that gives people the choice of bathroom based on their gender identity. | Morrison has opposed sex education programs he agreed made his “skin curl” by teaching the fact of diversity in human sexuality, described teachers who support trans students as “gender whisperers” and demanded his department remove signage that gives people the choice of bathroom based on their gender identity. |
| Sukkar and Morrison both opposed same-sex marriage during the postal survey campaign then abstained when the bill passed parliament. Sukkar also charged taxpayers almost $1,500 to attend a campaign rally against same-sex marriage. | |
| Census | Census |
| Australian Bureau of Statistics | Australian Bureau of Statistics |
| LGBT rights | LGBT rights |
| Australian politics | Australian politics |
| Sexuality | Sexuality |
| Gender | Gender |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |