This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-50083910
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Adoption breakdown: 'No support' for violent children | |
(about 8 hours later) | |
Heartbroken mothers have described the anguish of returning their adopted children into care after they became violent. | Heartbroken mothers have described the anguish of returning their adopted children into care after they became violent. |
The women felt they had "no choice" but to give up their children because of the difficulty of getting any support. | The women felt they had "no choice" but to give up their children because of the difficulty of getting any support. |
The government said "many children leaving care will have experienced trauma". | The government said "many children leaving care will have experienced trauma". |
Psychologists have called for better assessment for children and specialist training for parents. | Psychologists have called for better assessment for children and specialist training for parents. |
The charity Adoption UK said about two-thirds of adoptive parents encounter aggression or violence from their children, while a lawyer specialising in adoption cases told the BBC his firm got referrals from all over the country from families who felt lacking in support. | The charity Adoption UK said about two-thirds of adoptive parents encounter aggression or violence from their children, while a lawyer specialising in adoption cases told the BBC his firm got referrals from all over the country from families who felt lacking in support. |
Some names and details have been changed to protect the identity of the interviewees. | Some names and details have been changed to protect the identity of the interviewees. |
'I needed treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder' | 'I needed treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder' |
Marie adopted as a single mum and said she had no idea she "would or could" become the victim of violence and verbal abuse from her daughter. | Marie adopted as a single mum and said she had no idea she "would or could" become the victim of violence and verbal abuse from her daughter. |
"There were times when it didn't feel safe for either of us," she said. | "There were times when it didn't feel safe for either of us," she said. |
"She tried to jump out of an upstairs window saying she wanted to die and I was trying to restrain her. | "She tried to jump out of an upstairs window saying she wanted to die and I was trying to restrain her. |
"On another occasion she went to the kitchen drawer and took out a knife and asked me to kill her." | "On another occasion she went to the kitchen drawer and took out a knife and asked me to kill her." |
Marie was headbutted and kicked in the stomach by her adopted daughter as well as receiving verbal abuse. | Marie was headbutted and kicked in the stomach by her adopted daughter as well as receiving verbal abuse. |
She did not want to give her daughter back but said in the end she felt there was nothing else she could do. | She did not want to give her daughter back but said in the end she felt there was nothing else she could do. |
"I'd been fighting it for quite a while, several people suggested that would be the best option, they were saying 'no-one would blame you' but I did blame myself. | "I'd been fighting it for quite a while, several people suggested that would be the best option, they were saying 'no-one would blame you' but I did blame myself. |
"It took me several years and treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder myself before I forgave myself for that decision," Marie said. | "It took me several years and treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder myself before I forgave myself for that decision," Marie said. |
"I just didn't have a choice I just couldn't carry on." | "I just didn't have a choice I just couldn't carry on." |
'Returning my daughter ended my career' | 'Returning my daughter ended my career' |
Claire felt like she was unable to keep her adopted daughter safe. | Claire felt like she was unable to keep her adopted daughter safe. |
"The police would bring her in through the front door, she would climb out of her window and the police would be looking for her again," she said. | "The police would bring her in through the front door, she would climb out of her window and the police would be looking for her again," she said. |
On two occasions she had to call the police because her daughter was destroying items in the house, smashing windows and being threatening. | On two occasions she had to call the police because her daughter was destroying items in the house, smashing windows and being threatening. |
"Police reports show that they could hear her screaming and swearing at me in the background when I was on the phone to them," Claire said. | "Police reports show that they could hear her screaming and swearing at me in the background when I was on the phone to them," Claire said. |
When court proceedings began to return her into care, Claire's daughter had a psychological assessment and the report said "love was not enough". | When court proceedings began to return her into care, Claire's daughter had a psychological assessment and the report said "love was not enough". |
"I had a career in education that I could not carry on because I'm seen as an abuser because my daughter has gone back into the care system," Claire said. | "I had a career in education that I could not carry on because I'm seen as an abuser because my daughter has gone back into the care system," Claire said. |
"There's no allowance for the fact I'm not her birth mum, I didn't cause this trauma, I was simply trying to do the right thing by her and offer her a stable, happy family life." | "There's no allowance for the fact I'm not her birth mum, I didn't cause this trauma, I was simply trying to do the right thing by her and offer her a stable, happy family life." |
'I don't think it would have been any harder if my child had died' | 'I don't think it would have been any harder if my child had died' |
Linda adopted her child as a toddler but eventually returned them into the care system after 12 years. | Linda adopted her child as a toddler but eventually returned them into the care system after 12 years. |
At first they were only violent to older children but eventually the situation became too much to bear. | At first they were only violent to older children but eventually the situation became too much to bear. |
Child and adolescent mental health workers said their behaviour was too extreme to be treated. | Child and adolescent mental health workers said their behaviour was too extreme to be treated. |
"When I look back I really don't know how we've survived, any of us," Linda said. | "When I look back I really don't know how we've survived, any of us," Linda said. |
Linda blames her child's violent and difficult behaviour on traumatic experiences they had gone through before being adopted. | Linda blames her child's violent and difficult behaviour on traumatic experiences they had gone through before being adopted. |
There was a history of neglect and abuse in the family home where Linda's child once lived. | There was a history of neglect and abuse in the family home where Linda's child once lived. |
Linda said she would always feel responsible for her child. | Linda said she would always feel responsible for her child. |
"I don't think it would have been any harder if they'd died," Linda said. | "I don't think it would have been any harder if they'd died," Linda said. |
"I wish my child never had to have those first two years with their birth family. | "I wish my child never had to have those first two years with their birth family. |
"Maybe if they'd have come sooner they'd have been less damaged." | "Maybe if they'd have come sooner they'd have been less damaged." |
How common is adoption breakdown? | How common is adoption breakdown? |
According to Adoption UK, up to 65% of adoptive parents experience violence or aggression. | According to Adoption UK, up to 65% of adoptive parents experience violence or aggression. |
In 2014, the first national study of adoption breakdown put the figure at about 3%. | In 2014, the first national study of adoption breakdown put the figure at about 3%. |
But a lawyer who specialises in adoption cases said that was "probably understating the problem". | But a lawyer who specialises in adoption cases said that was "probably understating the problem". |
Nigel Priestley said: "We get referrals from all over the country and many parents are finding the support they desperately need simply isn't there for them." | Nigel Priestley said: "We get referrals from all over the country and many parents are finding the support they desperately need simply isn't there for them." |
The Department for Education does not collect official statistics on adoption breakdown. | The Department for Education does not collect official statistics on adoption breakdown. |
A spokesperson said: "We recognise that many children leaving care will have experienced trauma in their lives and will need support to help them thrive in their new families. | A spokesperson said: "We recognise that many children leaving care will have experienced trauma in their lives and will need support to help them thrive in their new families. |
"Every decision regarding adoption is made with the best interests of the child at heart and is always based on the individual child's needs." | "Every decision regarding adoption is made with the best interests of the child at heart and is always based on the individual child's needs." |
What can be done to help adopted children and their parents? | What can be done to help adopted children and their parents? |
Families can currently apply for grants of up to £5,000 for therapy from the government's adoption support fund. | Families can currently apply for grants of up to £5,000 for therapy from the government's adoption support fund. |
Specialist therapist Dr Renee Marks said trauma affected the way a child's brain developed. | Specialist therapist Dr Renee Marks said trauma affected the way a child's brain developed. |
The earlier a child encountered a traumatic experience, the more profound the impact would be on the brain. | The earlier a child encountered a traumatic experience, the more profound the impact would be on the brain. |
"I think the children need to have a full assessment in terms of their psychological needs and level of trauma prior to the placement in adoption," she said. | "I think the children need to have a full assessment in terms of their psychological needs and level of trauma prior to the placement in adoption," she said. |
"Adoptive parents have to know exactly what they are going to have to encounter, they need specific training for that child." | "Adoptive parents have to know exactly what they are going to have to encounter, they need specific training for that child." |
Sue Armstrong-Brown, the chief executive of Adoption UK, said there was a growing understanding of the support parents and children required but a "completely fit for purpose" adoption system was still needed. | Sue Armstrong-Brown, the chief executive of Adoption UK, said there was a growing understanding of the support parents and children required but a "completely fit for purpose" adoption system was still needed. |
"When we do have one it will be completely child-centred and put the need for support to recover from trauma at its heart. | "When we do have one it will be completely child-centred and put the need for support to recover from trauma at its heart. |
"That will look like every child having an assessment of need at placement and regularly afterwards," she said. | "That will look like every child having an assessment of need at placement and regularly afterwards," she said. |
"It will look like a support plan that follows the child around, that's fully resourced throughout their lifetime. | "It will look like a support plan that follows the child around, that's fully resourced throughout their lifetime. |
"It will look like much better support and information for families from the start." | "It will look like much better support and information for families from the start." |
If you or someone you know has been affected by adoption issues, help and support is available at bbc.co.uk/actionline | If you or someone you know has been affected by adoption issues, help and support is available at bbc.co.uk/actionline |
Inside Out examines adoption disruption on BBC One at 19:30 GMT on Monday 28 October and can also be seen afterwards on the iPlayer. | Inside Out examines adoption disruption on BBC One at 19:30 GMT on Monday 28 October and can also be seen afterwards on the iPlayer. |
Previous version
1
Next version