This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/media/2019/nov/05/tories-unrepentant-about-doctored-video-of-keir-starmer-tv-appearance
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Tories unrepentant over misleadingly edited Keir Starmer TV footage | Tories unrepentant over misleadingly edited Keir Starmer TV footage |
| (about 11 hours later) | |
| Good Morning Britain presenter Piers Morgan says Conservative version is unfair | Good Morning Britain presenter Piers Morgan says Conservative version is unfair |
| The Conservatives have misleadingly edited a video of the Labour MP Sir Keir Starmer to give the impression he failed to answer a question on the party’s Brexit position during an interview with ITV’s Good Morning Britain. | The Conservatives have misleadingly edited a video of the Labour MP Sir Keir Starmer to give the impression he failed to answer a question on the party’s Brexit position during an interview with ITV’s Good Morning Britain. |
| In the Tory version of the video, produced by the party for its social media channels, Starmer is shown unable to speak after being asked about Labour’s position on the EU, with his face appearing under the caption “Labour has no plan for Brexit”. | In the Tory version of the video, produced by the party for its social media channels, Starmer is shown unable to speak after being asked about Labour’s position on the EU, with his face appearing under the caption “Labour has no plan for Brexit”. |
| In reality, the shadow Brexit secretary did provide a lengthy answer regarding his discussions with other EU countries over the past three years and insisted: “A customs union and single market alignment and protection of workers’ rights and environmental rights and consumer rights is something that can be negotiated.” | In reality, the shadow Brexit secretary did provide a lengthy answer regarding his discussions with other EU countries over the past three years and insisted: “A customs union and single market alignment and protection of workers’ rights and environmental rights and consumer rights is something that can be negotiated.” |
| Good Morning Britain presenter Piers Morgan said that Starmer’s answer may have been “unconvincing” but the way the video was edited by the Tories was “misleading and unfair”. | Good Morning Britain presenter Piers Morgan said that Starmer’s answer may have been “unconvincing” but the way the video was edited by the Tories was “misleading and unfair”. |
| After being called out on the party’s decision to edit the video, the Conservative party failed to apologise and appeared to revel in the extra attention. Its press office encouraged more people to watch the original “car-crash interview” on Good Morning Britain. | After being called out on the party’s decision to edit the video, the Conservative party failed to apologise and appeared to revel in the extra attention. Its press office encouraged more people to watch the original “car-crash interview” on Good Morning Britain. |
| Morgan tweeted in response: “You doctored the end of the clip you originally put out, to make it look like @Keir_Starmer had no answer to my question. In fact he answered immediately. You could have had plenty of fun with that interview anyway - why fake it?” | Morgan tweeted in response: “You doctored the end of the clip you originally put out, to make it look like @Keir_Starmer had no answer to my question. In fact he answered immediately. You could have had plenty of fun with that interview anyway - why fake it?” |
| In response, the Tory party tweeted a new video with the comment: “Fair point @piersmorgan. Is this version better?” The new film is almost identical to the original, but instead of misleadingly showing Starmer blinking and licking his lips as he fails to respond to Morgan’s question, it instead freezes the frame on his face and zooms in. | In response, the Tory party tweeted a new video with the comment: “Fair point @piersmorgan. Is this version better?” The new film is almost identical to the original, but instead of misleadingly showing Starmer blinking and licking his lips as he fails to respond to Morgan’s question, it instead freezes the frame on his face and zooms in. |
| Conservative chairman James Cleverley told BBC Breakfast the video was “obviously edited” and denied it had been “doctored”, saying the difference mattered because the words had different connotations: “The idea that people couldn’t see that it wasn’t a shorter form of video, that’s not a credible position to put forward.” | |
| The incident highlights the difficulty in reporting on misinformation and online duplicity during a general election. The extra attention given to misleading social media posts often creates a feedback loop, with algorithms on Twitter and Facebook responding to the high levels of user engagement by pushing it into more people’s feeds. | The incident highlights the difficulty in reporting on misinformation and online duplicity during a general election. The extra attention given to misleading social media posts often creates a feedback loop, with algorithms on Twitter and Facebook responding to the high levels of user engagement by pushing it into more people’s feeds. |
| This has led to fears that there is very little to be lost by political parties reinforcing lies and deceptive material in a media environment where the aim is often to get attention at all costs and by any means. After the misleading edit of the video was highlighted by the BBC journalist Daniel Sandford, the video attracted almost a million additional views. |