This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-50167927
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Ending the taboo of soldiers with 'broken faces' | Ending the taboo of soldiers with 'broken faces' |
(3 days later) | |
Warning: This story contains a graphic image. | Warning: This story contains a graphic image. |
A World War One memorial to soldiers whose story has been described as an unresolved "taboo" is set to be unveiled. | A World War One memorial to soldiers whose story has been described as an unresolved "taboo" is set to be unveiled. |
Historian Ellie Grigsby has designed a statue commemorating the thousands of soldiers who suffered terrible facial disfigurements and who often found themselves shunned rather than welcomed back as heroes. | Historian Ellie Grigsby has designed a statue commemorating the thousands of soldiers who suffered terrible facial disfigurements and who often found themselves shunned rather than welcomed back as heroes. |
The statue is to be unveiled at a private event by descendants of some of the soldiers, at Queen Mary's Hospital in Sidcup, Kent, where many of the men were treated. | |
Ms Grigsby has researched the soldiers with "broken faces", whose uncomfortable memory she says has been neglected in war commemorations. | Ms Grigsby has researched the soldiers with "broken faces", whose uncomfortable memory she says has been neglected in war commemorations. |
Mirrors banned | Mirrors banned |
Her postgraduate research at Goldsmiths, University of London, found that many soldiers who returned, with their faces changed by shell and shrapnel injuries, faced social rejection and isolation. | Her postgraduate research at Goldsmiths, University of London, found that many soldiers who returned, with their faces changed by shell and shrapnel injuries, faced social rejection and isolation. |
"I came across stories of mirrors being banned from hospital wards, children cowering from their fathers who came home from the front with a new face, and sweethearts who couldn't bear to look at their lovers," she says. | "I came across stories of mirrors being banned from hospital wards, children cowering from their fathers who came home from the front with a new face, and sweethearts who couldn't bear to look at their lovers," she says. |
With today's awareness of mental health problems, Ms Grigsby says their post-war experiences must have been deeply traumatic. | With today's awareness of mental health problems, Ms Grigsby says their post-war experiences must have been deeply traumatic. |
The homecoming for these disfigured young men could involve a complete loss of status, broken relationships and being turned away from jobs. | The homecoming for these disfigured young men could involve a complete loss of status, broken relationships and being turned away from jobs. |
She researched one soldier who was rejected by his wife - "she couldn't bear to look at him" - and was not allowed to serve customers in his old job as a tailor. But in a twist in the tale, he ended up marrying his wife's sister. | She researched one soldier who was rejected by his wife - "she couldn't bear to look at him" - and was not allowed to serve customers in his old job as a tailor. But in a twist in the tale, he ended up marrying his wife's sister. |
It wasn't only about appearances. Some soldiers who had injuries to their jaws and mouths struggled to eat for the rest of their lives. | It wasn't only about appearances. Some soldiers who had injuries to their jaws and mouths struggled to eat for the rest of their lives. |
Buried in a mask | Buried in a mask |
In some cases, where parts of the face were missing or irretrievably mutilated, men wore metal masks. | In some cases, where parts of the face were missing or irretrievably mutilated, men wore metal masks. |
These tin masks were painted and had artificial moustaches and eyebrows to reflect how the soldier once looked, based on photos from before the war. | These tin masks were painted and had artificial moustaches and eyebrows to reflect how the soldier once looked, based on photos from before the war. |
Ms Grigsby says some disfigured soldiers wore these masks all the time, at home as well as in public, never showing their injuries. | Ms Grigsby says some disfigured soldiers wore these masks all the time, at home as well as in public, never showing their injuries. |
"They never showed their family, some children wondered their whole lives what the face looked like, because they never saw it," she says. | "They never showed their family, some children wondered their whole lives what the face looked like, because they never saw it," she says. |
Some were even buried still wearing a mask. "They lost not just their faces but their identities," says Ms Grigsby. | Some were even buried still wearing a mask. "They lost not just their faces but their identities," says Ms Grigsby. |
They had literally become the unacceptable face of war. | They had literally become the unacceptable face of war. |
Pioneer surgery | Pioneer surgery |
The efforts by doctors to help these soldiers, carrying out thousands of operations, drove advances in reconstructive surgery. | The efforts by doctors to help these soldiers, carrying out thousands of operations, drove advances in reconstructive surgery. |
These medical pioneers, who used their experiences at the hospital in Sidcup, have been widely recognised. | These medical pioneers, who used their experiences at the hospital in Sidcup, have been widely recognised. |
But Ms Grigsby says the injured soldiers themselves have had much less attention - with an awkwardness and public discomfort about their fate. | But Ms Grigsby says the injured soldiers themselves have had much less attention - with an awkwardness and public discomfort about their fate. |
The monument to be unveiled will include words from Ward Muir, an orderly working at the hospital who wrote about working with men whose "hideous" appearances could be so unnerving. | The monument to be unveiled will include words from Ward Muir, an orderly working at the hospital who wrote about working with men whose "hideous" appearances could be so unnerving. |
"He finds that he must fraternise with his fellow men at whom he cannot look without the grievous risk of betraying by his expression, how awful is their appearance," he wrote. | "He finds that he must fraternise with his fellow men at whom he cannot look without the grievous risk of betraying by his expression, how awful is their appearance," he wrote. |
"Hideous is the only word for those smashed faces. To talk to a lad who six months ago, was probably a wholesome and pleasing specimen of youth, and is now a gargoyle, and a broken one at that, is something of an ordeal." | "Hideous is the only word for those smashed faces. To talk to a lad who six months ago, was probably a wholesome and pleasing specimen of youth, and is now a gargoyle, and a broken one at that, is something of an ordeal." |
'Airbrushed' out of memorials | 'Airbrushed' out of memorials |
Ms Grigsby has become a campaigner for their cause - raising the funds for the monument, with her design including a real World War One helmet. | Ms Grigsby has become a campaigner for their cause - raising the funds for the monument, with her design including a real World War One helmet. |
But why would someone in their 20s be so engaged by this? | But why would someone in their 20s be so engaged by this? |
She says the shunning of people over their appearance has a particular resonance for today's young people who are under constant pressure over how they look. | She says the shunning of people over their appearance has a particular resonance for today's young people who are under constant pressure over how they look. |
"Social media has a huge influence on how people identify as individuals," she says. | "Social media has a huge influence on how people identify as individuals," she says. |
In a culture of selfies and "narcissism", the idea of being blamed for looking unusual or unattractive still has a contemporary relevance, she says. | In a culture of selfies and "narcissism", the idea of being blamed for looking unusual or unattractive still has a contemporary relevance, she says. |
There is also a sense of righting an injustice. Ms Grigsby says there are many memorials to World War One, with often elegant depictions of heroic soldiers. | There is also a sense of righting an injustice. Ms Grigsby says there are many memorials to World War One, with often elegant depictions of heroic soldiers. |
But she says there has been an "airbrushing" of the stories of men whose personal struggles continued for decades after the war. | But she says there has been an "airbrushing" of the stories of men whose personal struggles continued for decades after the war. |
"Memory is a choice," she says. | "Memory is a choice," she says. |
Previous version
1
Next version