This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/17/us/amputee-deputy-tucson-arizona.html
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Arizona Deputy Placed on Leave After Tackling 15-Year-Old With No Limbs | Arizona Deputy Placed on Leave After Tackling 15-Year-Old With No Limbs |
| (about 5 hours later) | |
| A shirtless 15-year-old boy with no arms and no legs was held facedown on the kitchen floor of his Arizona group home by a deputy more than twice his size, an eight-minute video released last week shows. | A shirtless 15-year-old boy with no arms and no legs was held facedown on the kitchen floor of his Arizona group home by a deputy more than twice his size, an eight-minute video released last week shows. |
| The teenager was arrested and later charged with disorderly conduct, his lawyer said. That prompted him to release the video to a local TV station, which published the footage on Wednesday. By the next day, prosecutors had dropped the charge, and the deputy, Manuel Van Santen, was put on administrative leave on Friday. | |
| “It’s a horrible spectacle,” said Joel Feinman, the teenager’s lawyer. “He was assaulted by a man with a badge and a gun, just screamed and cursed at.” | “It’s a horrible spectacle,” said Joel Feinman, the teenager’s lawyer. “He was assaulted by a man with a badge and a gun, just screamed and cursed at.” |
| The episode began after a woman working at a group home in Tucson called the police around 10 a.m. on Sept. 26, saying the 15-year-old, Immanuel, was screaming and had knocked over a garbage can. The teenager was upset because he wanted to go back to school, according to Mr. Feinman, who did not release the boy’s last name because of his age. | The episode began after a woman working at a group home in Tucson called the police around 10 a.m. on Sept. 26, saying the 15-year-old, Immanuel, was screaming and had knocked over a garbage can. The teenager was upset because he wanted to go back to school, according to Mr. Feinman, who did not release the boy’s last name because of his age. |
| Immanuel, who lived at the group home, was yelling and tried to move past Deputy Van Santen when he arrived, Mr. Feinman said. That’s when the deputy tackled him and pinned him down in a headlock. | Immanuel, who lived at the group home, was yelling and tried to move past Deputy Van Santen when he arrived, Mr. Feinman said. That’s when the deputy tackled him and pinned him down in a headlock. |
| C. J., 16, another resident of the group home who was eating his breakfast in the next room, started recording the altercation on his cellphone after Immanuel was tackled, according to Mr. Feinman. The video, first posted by KOLD News 13, a local television station based in Tucson, showed Immanuel frantically screaming to be let go. | C. J., 16, another resident of the group home who was eating his breakfast in the next room, started recording the altercation on his cellphone after Immanuel was tackled, according to Mr. Feinman. The video, first posted by KOLD News 13, a local television station based in Tucson, showed Immanuel frantically screaming to be let go. |
| After nearly two minutes on the ground, Immanuel stopped protesting and the deputy stood up, continuing to yell at the boy. When C. J. interrupted the deputy, he was also arrested, Mr. Feinman said. | After nearly two minutes on the ground, Immanuel stopped protesting and the deputy stood up, continuing to yell at the boy. When C. J. interrupted the deputy, he was also arrested, Mr. Feinman said. |
| Both Immanuel and C. J. were detained for disorderly conduct, taken to a juvenile detention center, processed and then released. C. J. was not formerly charged, Mr. Feinman added. | Both Immanuel and C. J. were detained for disorderly conduct, taken to a juvenile detention center, processed and then released. C. J. was not formerly charged, Mr. Feinman added. |
| The Pima County Attorney’s Office dropped the charges against Immanuel after seeing the video, said the chief criminal deputy, Jonathan C. Mosher. | |
| “Our office was not given any opportunity to review this video until Nov. 14,” Mr. Mosher said Sunday. “The same day we first saw the video, we took action to dismiss the charges pertaining to this incident.” | |
| Deputy Van Santen, an 11-year veteran of the Pima County Sheriff’s Department, was placed on administrative leave pending an internal investigation, according to James Allerton, an officer with the department. He declined to comment further on the episode. | Deputy Van Santen, an 11-year veteran of the Pima County Sheriff’s Department, was placed on administrative leave pending an internal investigation, according to James Allerton, an officer with the department. He declined to comment further on the episode. |
| Deputy Van Santen did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Sunday. | Deputy Van Santen did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Sunday. |
| All of the boys in the group home are in the custody of the Arizona Department of Child Safety, Mr. Feinman said. They live there because they have been abused, neglected or abandoned, he added. | All of the boys in the group home are in the custody of the Arizona Department of Child Safety, Mr. Feinman said. They live there because they have been abused, neglected or abandoned, he added. |
| “These are boys that have already been traumatized, and we are just adding trauma upon trauma, abuse upon abuse,” Mr. Feinman said. | “These are boys that have already been traumatized, and we are just adding trauma upon trauma, abuse upon abuse,” Mr. Feinman said. |
| As a public defender, Mr. Feinman said he regularly sees alarming things as part of his job, but this episode was especially disturbing. | As a public defender, Mr. Feinman said he regularly sees alarming things as part of his job, but this episode was especially disturbing. |
| “The deputy treated Immanuel with contempt, especially given how old he is, his physical condition and what he had already been through,” Mr. Feinman said. “He did not pause to think for a moment that the boy deserved to be treated like a child and a human being.” | “The deputy treated Immanuel with contempt, especially given how old he is, his physical condition and what he had already been through,” Mr. Feinman said. “He did not pause to think for a moment that the boy deserved to be treated like a child and a human being.” |