This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2019/nov/28/morrison-albanese-coalition-medevac-taylor-politcs-live

The article has changed 22 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 11 Version 12
Scott Morrison still under pressure over Angus Taylor response – question time live Scott Morrison still under pressure over Angus Taylor response – question time live
(31 minutes later)
PM concedes a misstep in his defence of minister as Labor continues its attack. All the day’s events, livePM concedes a misstep in his defence of minister as Labor continues its attack. All the day’s events, live
Senate question time has been all Angus Taylor all the time. Mathias Cormann stuck by Taylor and read a long list of his achievements - a list which did not include reducing emissions, despite him being the minister for emissions reduction.
Then Labor switches tack to Simon Birmingham - querying why he had said on the ABC that Taylor sourced the erroneous document from the City of Sydney website, but in the Senate he said only that that is what Taylor has advised.Murray Watt started singing The Wheels on the Bus (Go Round and Round), in reference to his belief Birmingham’s earlier answer had thrown Taylor under the bus.
Birmingham said he received briefings from Taylor, and repeated that he was advised it was sourced from the City of Sydney website. “They can continue to ask again and they’re going to get the same answer again.”
Labor’s Penny Wong then asked who doctored the document, and Birmingham rejected the premise because “according to Mr Taylor” it was downloaded from the council website. Wong makes much of the fact he won’t say in parliament that he doesn’t know who doctored it.
Anthony Albanese to Scott Morrison:
My question is addressed to the Prime Minister. How can the Prime Minister claim that the Opposition made no objection to his statement that he would call the New South Wales police commissioner about the substance of Strike Force Garrad into one of his cabinet ministers when the Prime Minister has prevented the Parliament debating this deepening scandal 20 times this week.
Morrison:
Labor points out it did not vote against the bill, but the prime minister has concluded his answer.
So many chains to pull. So little time.
It’s a small point, and I am sure a lot of people would argue semantics, but on the “who did you think I was going to call defence/I told you I was going to do it” that Scott Morrison is using, he didn’t actually say he would call the NSW police commissioner - my look over of the Hansard shows he said variations of this:
Which is not ‘I am calling the police commissioner’.
That could have meant a departmental officer will call a NSW police departmental officer, to receive the same advice. Not I’m going to give the Commish a call directly about an investigation involving one of my ministers.
Anthony Albanese to Scott Morrison:
Morrison:
The man who accused those of caring about climate change of being inner-city raving lunatics, wants the chamber to know he has been “really disappointed in the antics this week”.
Excuse me while I wipe that wet lettuce off my face.
If you ever wandered what a fusty nut missing a kernel looked like, I invite you to look into the chamber as the deputy prime minister takes this dixer.
ARE YOU FRICKING KIDDING ME?
Anthony Albanese to Scott Morrison:
Former anti-corruption commissioner and supreme court judge David Ipp AO QC has said in relation to the prime minister’s phone call to the New South Wales police commissioner, and I quote, ‘You can’t see that it’s information that relates to matters of state interest. It can only relate to matters of party interest.’ How on earth was that phone call appropriate?
Morrison:
Zali Steggall used her 90-second statement just before question time to call for silence for Australia’s domestic violence victims:
Anne Davies has an update on the Angus Taylor investigation:
Scott Morrison:
“Political games” is getting quite the go here. Looks like the government has found it’s line for the day.
If you have a go at political games, you’ll get a go at political games.
Anthony Albanese to Scott Morrison:
This morning [Scott Morrison] refused to attend this chamber and correct the record and apologise for misleading the House. Why does the Prime Minister think the usual standards of integrity and accountability don’t apply to him?
Morrison:
I don’t accept the assertion that has been put forward by the Leader of the Opposition. The matters that he referred to yesterday, Mr Speaker.
With regard to the attribution of a quote. When it was brought to my attention I took immediate action to ensure that the House was informed of that correction. Now, Mr Speaker, I hear the interjection of the Leader of the Opposition ... The reason I wrote a letter last night is because I was on a plane on the way to Sydney for a family event which the Leader of the Opposition knew about.
... Mr Speaker, that letter which I authorised was provided to the House and it was tabled here by the attorney general to ensure the House was immediately informed of the necessary correction that had to be made.
... Now, Mr Speaker, that was followed up with a further letter to the clerk and as you advised the House last night these are the appropriate forms of the House to correct the record. So if the Leader of the Opposition wants to take issue with the Speaker on this matter he’s at liberty do so.
But here we are in question time, in the nation’s capital...
The Leader of the Opposition is bickering about a quotation in an answer to a question which has been corrected for the record. This is what the Leader of the Opposition believes are the real issues facing this country.
And the political games that the Leader of the Opposition, the tawdry political games ... has been engaged in, in this House this week, found their overreach particularly today when the Leader of the Opposition voted to see that the member for Herbert could no longer be heard when he was speaking, Mr Speaker, on the issue of veteran suicide.
... So the political games being played by the Leader of the Opposition and the Labor party this week descended so low that a veteran of this country speaking about veteran suicide ...
Anthony Albanese has taken the rare step of making a 90-second statement (they are usually for backbenchers) – and he has timed it on the list for just as Scott Morrison walks into the chamber.Anthony Albanese has taken the rare step of making a 90-second statement (they are usually for backbenchers) – and he has timed it on the list for just as Scott Morrison walks into the chamber.
“An ad man with no plan, a showman, covering up a scam,” says Albanese, as Morrison takes his seat.“An ad man with no plan, a showman, covering up a scam,” says Albanese, as Morrison takes his seat.
Who’s that MP?Who’s that MP?
It’s Tony Pasin.It’s Tony Pasin.
It was just hard to place him, given he was sitting in the back benches (Pasin likes to make a beeline for the front bench during division votes. Almost without fail. A MP can dream, I suppose)It was just hard to place him, given he was sitting in the back benches (Pasin likes to make a beeline for the front bench during division votes. Almost without fail. A MP can dream, I suppose)
Members have begun their 90 second statements in the House, which means it is almost time for question time.
We’ll head into the chamber, but we all know what this hour will be about.
Five. More. To. Go.
Labor is still gagging government ministers and MPs in the chamber to make their point about the government gagging debate on Angus Taylor.
Every time a division is called, all the MPs have to run back to the chamber. Labor MPs might be prepared, but the government MPs are not.
The focus. The stance. The furrowed brow.
Take note, fellow nodders.
On the ministerial standards questions, this is what Anthony Albanese had to say:
Q: So, you would stand down one of your shadow ministers in similar circumstances, and you undertake here today to do that if any of your shadow ministers are under police investigations?
AA: If I was a minister, if I’m elected to government, I will uphold the ministerial code of conduct.
Q: So, only in government?
AA: Well, the ministerial code of conduct – the hint is, it’s a ministerial code of conduct. So, in terms of processes, the ministerial code of conduct should be followed. That’s why it’s there, for a reason. Because ministers make decisions, and they can’t be in a situation whereby they are compromised.
Q: So, there are different standards for shadow ministers under investigation, they can continue?
AA: Well, I’m not going to answer hypotheticals. I’m answering this specific question about ministerial code of conduct that applies to ministers and has applied for a very long period of time, and has always, always been the case. And what we see here, unlike what happened under Prime Minister Howard, but also under Tony Abbott and Malcolm Turnbull, where we had people like Arthur Sinodinos, Sussan Ley, other people, standing aside.
Sam Watson will be very missed. Ken Wyatt has issued a statement on his passing:
Anthony Albanese and Tony Burke have put out a statement on Clive James:
This is now on its way to the Senate
Why we are all talking about Scott Morrison taking in Mick Fuller’s bins when they were Shire neighbours being a “joke” (which Ben Fordham also raised as a joke on his 2GB show yesterday), just a reminder that on 13 December last year, following the original bin revelation, was this conversation:
Ben Fordham: Because, once upon a time when you were neighbours, according to the commissioner, and I think this has been confirmed, you used to bring his bin in. When he’d leave the bin outside, the wheelie bin outside, and he was too lazy himself to bring it in, you would collect his bin and wheel it in for him. True or false?
PM: That’s what good neighbours do. That’s what they do. Mick is a great bloke and that’s the Shire way.
BF: How come you don’t do it anymore?
PM: Well, I don’t take the bins out anymore.
BF: Why?
PM: Because I haven’t even found where they are yet.
BF: Ah of course, at Kirribilli House.
PM: At my place, Jen would be home more often than not to take the bins out as I’d be travelling or something.
BF: Hang on, hang on, hang on. When you say my place, you mean our place?
PM: No, no, when I lived in the Shire.
BF: Oh OK, I’m just clarifying there.
PM: That’s very true Ben, and you’re right to point that out.
Often neighbours would do that for each other, mate. I think that’s done in most parts of the country and Mick’s a good bloke.
BF: Well if you really loved him you’d be driving from Kirribilli House back to the Shire just to make sure the bin was in.
PM: Fair point, I think that’s a fair point.