This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/04/world/europe/trump-video-nato.html

The article has changed 10 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 6 Version 7
Trump Calls Trudeau ‘Two-Faced’ After Comments Caught on Video Trump Abruptly Exits NATO Gathering After Embarrassing Video Emerges
(about 5 hours later)
LONDON — President Trump on Wednesday called Prime Minister Justin Trudeau of Canada “two-faced,” after a video surfaced that showed him venting to other world leaders about Mr. Trump’s behavior at a NATO anniversary celebration designed specifically to avoid unwanted disruptions. LONDON — President Trump arrived in London Monday evening planning to tout a foreign policy accomplishment his presidential campaign wants him to run on: successfully pressuring allies to pay more toward the costs of running NATO.
“Well, he’s two-faced,” the president said when asked about the video. After a long pause, he added, “He’s a nice guy. I find him to be a very nice guy.” Less than 48 hours later — after he was put on the defensive in front of the cameras and then was the subject of gossip at a private reception of world leaders, a moment caught in a viral video — Mr. Trump canceled a planned news conference before heading back to Washington earlier than planned.
Mr. Trump, who was taking questions from reporters ahead of a meeting with Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany, attributed Mr. Trudeau’s frustration to the American leader’s pressure campaign to increase Canada’s military spending to 2 percent of its economic output. The timing was not perfect. Mr. Trump had hoped the 70th anniversary celebration of NATO might provide a flattering stage and a triumphant narrative, even as Democrats on Capitol Hill on Wednesday trotted out sober legal scholars to testify at the House Judiciary Committee’s first public impeachment hearing.
But instead of creating a split screen, Mr. Trump failed to produce the statesmanlike narrative his campaign had hoped for. The result was he appeared boxed in both at home and abroad, ultimately overshadowed by diplomatic dynamics that put him on his back foot.
“We’ll go directly back,” Mr. Trump told reporters before a meeting on Wednesday with Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany, as he surprised his aides by abruptly scrapping plans for a formal news conference. “I think we’ve answered plenty of questions.”
Mr. Trump had, in fact, answered hours of scattershot questions from the news media by the time the gathering was over. But his quiet departure from Britain — without a splashy tabloid newspaper interview or a sit-down with a friendly television personality, or the set-piece final news conference he typically conducts when abroad — seemed to show an uncharacteristic admission of defeat.
“The NATO declaration and meeting outcome was successful but all the political fireworks around the leaders’ meeting was not,” said Heather A. Conley, director of the Europe program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. “There simply was nothing else to say other than to continue to further complicate NATO political dynamics.”
Mr. Trump arrived in London already something of a persona non grata. His political kindred spirit, Prime Minister Boris Johnson of Britain, had made it clear he had no interest in any show of support from a president who is seen by many of Mr. Johnson’s supporters as radioactive. He warned Mr. Trump to stay out of the British election, set for Dec. 12.
But the dim view that many European leaders themselves hold of Mr. Trump later burst into public view by accident. A video surfaced that showed grinning world leaders at a Buckingham Palace reception on Tuesday night, apparently commiserating in what they thought was a private conversation about the unmanageable behavior of the American president.
“He was late because he takes a 40-minute news conference at the top,” Prime Minister Justin Trudeau of Canada said to a small group that included President Emmanuel Macron of France, Prime Minister Mark Rutte of the Netherlands, Mr. Johnson and Princess Anne.
In the video, which was posted online by the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, Mr. Trudeau does not mention Mr. Trump by name. But later in the day, he acknowledged he had been discussing the American president.
“You just watch his team’s jaws drop to the floor,” Mr. Trudeau said at another point in the video, expressing astonishment at Mr. Trump’s behavior. Mr. Macron is also seen participating animatedly in the conversation, but his comments cannot be heard. Mr. Johnson is seen smiling. Princess Anne looks on.
None of the world leaders seemed to realize the conversation was being recorded. But the video played directly into Mr. Trump’s own fixation with rival leaders laughing at him, or at the United States.
By Wednesday afternoon, some of the participants were seeking to distance themselves from the perceived criticism of Mr. Trump.
During a news conference, Mr. Johnson claimed ignorance of the widely circulated video.
“I don’t know where that has come from,” he said. “I really don’t know what is being referred to there.”
Mr. Johnson even managed to get through the entire news conference without uttering Mr. Trump’s name.
In the past, Mr. Trump has been loathe to give up the spotlight, especially if he would be ceding it to a televised impeachment hearing unfolding on Capitol Hill.
“President Trump has committed impeachable high crimes and misdemeanors by corruptly abusing the office of the presidency,” Noah Feldman, a professor at Harvard University, testified on Wednesday in Washington as Mr. Trump was wrapping up the last of his meetings with European leaders abroad.
Mr. Feldman was one of three constitutional scholars invited by Democrats to testify at the hearing. All three said Mr. Trump’s efforts to pressure Ukraine for political gain met the historical definition of impeachable offenses.
But Mr. Trump did not have a positive story to tell that would distract from the hearing. The narrative unfolding in London was of his soured relationships with foreign leaders.
“He’s two-faced,” Mr. Trump said of Mr. Trudeau, when asked about the viral video. He attributed Mr. Trudeau’s apparent frustration to the American leader’s pressure campaign to increase Canada’s military spending to 2 percent of its economic output.
“He should be paying more than he’s paying,” Mr. Trump said. “I called him out on that, and I’m sure he wasn’t happy about it, but that’s the way it is.”“He should be paying more than he’s paying,” Mr. Trump said. “I called him out on that, and I’m sure he wasn’t happy about it, but that’s the way it is.”
The brief video showed grinning world leaders at a Buckingham Palace reception on Tuesday night, apparently commiserating about the president. Mr. Trump was already on the defensive after a 45-minute joint appearance on Tuesday with Mr. Macron, who arrived at the celebration fresh off an explosive interview with The Economist magazine, in which he said the loss of American leadership in Europe has led to “the brain death of NATO.”
In the video, which was posted online by the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, Mr. Trudeau is heard discussing Mr. Trump’s behavior during the first day of the two-day NATO meeting. Mr. Trump spoke to reporters for more than two hours in total on Tuesday, which appeared to astonish Mr. Trudeau. During their news conference, the French president aggressively challenged Mr. Trump’s vision for NATO and broached tensions over Turkey’s incursion into Northern Syria, which Mr. Trump had helped facilitate. For Mr. Trump, it was a rare face-to-face meeting with another world leader in which he was not driving the conversation.
“He was late because he takes a 40-minute press conference at the top,” Mr. Trudeau says — an apparent reference to Mr. Trump — to a small group that includes President Emmanuel Macron of France, Prime Minister Boris Johnson of Britain, Prime Minister Mark Rutte of the Netherlands and Princess Anne. Mr. Macron appeared to be relishing the role of the newly anointed disrupter-in-chief of NATO. But Mr. Trudeau tried to downplay the tension.
Mr. Trudeau does not mention Mr. Trump by name during the exchange, in which the Canadian leader discusses the day’s bilateral meetings. Although the Canadian prime minister admitted in a news conference that he was talking about Mr. Trump in the video, he said his “jaws drop” comment referred only to the surprise announcement that the upcoming Group of 7 summit would be held at Camp David, rather than as Mr. Trump had originally proposed at the Trump National Doral golf resort in Miami.
“You just watch his team’s jaws drop to the floor,” Mr. Trudeau says at another point. Mr. Macron is also seen participating animatedly in the conversation, but his comments cannot be heard. Mr. Johnson is seen smiling. Mr. Trudeau added, “I have a very good relationship with President Trump and his team.”
None of the world leaders seem to realize that the conversation is being recorded. By the afternoon, some of the participants were seeking to distance themselves from the perceived criticism of Mr. Trump. Mr. Trump seemed pleased with his own retort. “That was funny when I said that guy was two-faced,” Mr. Trump said, in a second hot-mic moment of the two-day gathering — a private exchange with another attendee at a luncheon for countries that had met a military spending benchmark required by NATO.
During a news conference, Mr. Johnson claimed that he had not been party to any discussion about Mr. Trump. “That’s complete nonsense, and I don’t know where that has come from,” he said. “I really don’t know what is being referred to there.” Later in the day, the mood in a room where Mr. Trump was meeting with the Italian prime minister grew palpably tense as the president turned his focus to the Democratic-led impeachment effort back home, calling a report released by the House Intelligence Committee “a joke.”
Mr. Trudeau admitted that he had been talking about Mr. Trump in the video, but said at a news conference that his “jaws drop” comment referred only to the surprise announcement that the upcoming Group of 7 summit would be held at Camp David rather than at the Trump National Doral golf resort in Miami. Mr. Trudeau added, “I have a very good relationship with President Trump and his team.” He said it was a “disgrace” that the hearing was taking place “on a day like this where we’re in England and some of the most powerful countries in the world are having very important NATO meetings.”
The Canadian premier’s remark was not the only moment that upended hopes for a drama-free NATO gathering — and wasn’t even the only hot-mic incident of the two-day meeting. Mr. Trump was recorded on Wednesday afternoon having a private discussion about his back-and-forth with Mr. Trudeau. After calling Democrats “unpatriotic,” Mr. Trump also questioned whether Democrats “loved our country.”
“That was funny when I said that guy was two-faced,” he said to an attendee after a luncheon for countries meeting the 2 percent military spending benchmark. Mr. Trump has long bridled at the thought that other world leaders might poke fun at the United States. Part of his 2016 presidential campaign pitch to voters was that his election would change how America was viewed abroad.
It was also not the first time that Mr. Trump and Mr. Trudeau have publicly clashed, or that Mr. Trump has accused Mr. Trudeau of misrepresenting himself. “The world is laughing at us,” he said frequently during the campaign, criticizing the leadership of President Barack Obama.
Last year, Mr. Trump derided the Canadian leader as “very dishonest and weak” after Mr. Trudeau pledged at a Group of 7 summit in Quebec City that he would retaliate against United States tariffs on steel and aluminum products. Mr. Trump wrote on Twitter at the time that Mr. Trudeau had acted “so meek and mild” when they met face to face.
Nor was the back-and-forth with Mr. Trudeau the first tense moment of the president’s two-day visit.
On Tuesday, Mr. Macron put Mr. Trump on the defensive during a 45-minute joint appearance, in which he aggressively challenged the American president’s vision for NATO and his handling of a military conflict involving Turkey. For Mr. Trump, it was a rare face-to-face meeting with another world leader in which he was not driving the conversation.
Mr. Trump has long bridled at the idea of other world leaders poking fun at the United States, and part of his 2016 presidential campaign pitch to voters was that his election would change how America was viewed abroad. “The world is laughing at us,” he said frequently during the campaign, criticizing the leadership of President Barack Obama.
In June 2017, when he announced that the United States would withdraw from the Paris climate agreement, Mr. Trump said: “We don’t want other leaders and other countries laughing at us anymore. And they won’t be. They won’t be.”In June 2017, when he announced that the United States would withdraw from the Paris climate agreement, Mr. Trump said: “We don’t want other leaders and other countries laughing at us anymore. And they won’t be. They won’t be.”
In 2018, laughter broke out at the United Nations General Assembly when Mr. Trump claimed that his administration had “accomplished more than almost any administration in the history of our country.” But in 2018, laughter broke out at the United Nations General Assembly when Mr. Trump claimed that his administration had “accomplished more than almost any administration in the history of our country.”
The president insisted at the time that he was not the target, saying, “They weren’t laughing at me, they were laughing with me.”The president insisted at the time that he was not the target, saying, “They weren’t laughing at me, they were laughing with me.”
None of the NATO leaders on Wednesday publicly acknowledged that they were talking about Mr. Trump in the uncomfortable video. But the clip loomed over the gathering of NATO leaders on Wednesday morning at The Grove, a country resort in Hertfordshire, where they met for a group photograph and welcome ceremony. Mr. Trump left NATO with another positive gloss on an embarrassing meeting. “We had a really good day and a good day yesterday,” he said.
The leaders took the stage one at a time to greet Mr. Johnson and the NATO secretary general, Jens Stoltenberg, and pose briefly before the assembled news cameras. Megan Specia contributed reporting from London.
Mr. Johnson greeted Mr. Trudeau with a handshake and a soft pat on the arm as they stood onstage together. Mr. Macron said hello to Mr. Johnson with a tap on the hand, and lingered, making jovial small talk before exiting the stage.
Mr. Trump arrived late to the meeting, just outside London, and shortly before he was due to emerge on the stage, an aide appeared to inform Mr. Johnson of a delay.
“We’re live now,” Mr. Johnson, who seemed perturbed, said to the aide before asking how long the delay would be. “A half an hour? 45 minutes?”
“How are we doing?” Johnson asked the aide few minutes later. “Come on!”
After the two co-hosts lingered onstage for about five minutes, rocking back and forth on their heels, Mr. Trump emerged and patted Mr. Johnson on the back.
Later in the morning, Mr. Trump politely shook hands and exchanged a few words with Mr. Trudeau before the general meeting of NATO leaders. Mr. Trump also wrote on Twitter that he had “enjoyed my meeting with the Prime Minister @BorisJohnson of the United Kingdom at @10DowningStreet last night,” noting that the two had discussed “numerous subjects including @NATO and Trade.”
In addition to Mr. Trump’s meeting with Ms. Merkel, he was scheduled to hold meetings with the prime minsters of Denmark and Italy.
Mr. Trump had also been expected to hold a news conference before his departure, but on Wednesday he appeared to abruptly cancel those plans. “We’ll go directly back,” he said. “I think we’ve done plenty of press conferences. Unless you’re demanding a press conference. But I think we’ve answered plenty of questions.”
The viral video clip was not only seen as a potential embarrassment for Mr. Trump. Mr. Trudeau also drew criticism for speaking so freely in a setting where his remarks could be recorded.
“By this point in his tenure, the prime minister should realise that events with pool cameras need to be approached and managed as on the record events,” Andrew MacDougall, who was a spokesman for Mr. Trudeau’s predecessor, Stephen Harper, wrote on Twitter.
“Hopefully this gaffe doesn’t wind the President up at a sensitive time” for United States-Canada relations, Mr. MacDougall wrote.
Megan Specia contributed reporting from London, and Ian Austen from Ottawa.