This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-51910099
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Coronavirus: Is drinking cow urine any help? | Coronavirus: Is drinking cow urine any help? |
| (about 11 hours later) | |
| India has had relatively few confirmed cases of coronavirus - but there's been plenty of misleading advice on how to tackle it. | India has had relatively few confirmed cases of coronavirus - but there's been plenty of misleading advice on how to tackle it. |
| BBC News has been fact-checking some of the most prominent examples. | |
| Cow urine and dung | Cow urine and dung |
| There is a long tradition in India of promoting cow urine and dung as traditional remedies for various diseases. | There is a long tradition in India of promoting cow urine and dung as traditional remedies for various diseases. |
| And an MP from the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), Suman Haripriya, has suggested they could be used against the coronavirus. | And an MP from the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), Suman Haripriya, has suggested they could be used against the coronavirus. |
| There have been previous studies into the potential anti-bacterial properties of cow urine. | There have been previous studies into the potential anti-bacterial properties of cow urine. |
| And a Hindu nationalist group has held a cow-urine drinking event in the capital, Delhi, to promote its use for tackling the virus. | And a Hindu nationalist group has held a cow-urine drinking event in the capital, Delhi, to promote its use for tackling the virus. |
| But Dr Shailendra Saxena, of the Indian Virological Society, told BBC News: "There is no medical evidence to show that cow urine has anti-viral characteristics. | But Dr Shailendra Saxena, of the Indian Virological Society, told BBC News: "There is no medical evidence to show that cow urine has anti-viral characteristics. |
| "Moreover, using cow-dung could prove counter-productive as bovine faecal matter could contain a coronavirus which might replicate in humans." | "Moreover, using cow-dung could prove counter-productive as bovine faecal matter could contain a coronavirus which might replicate in humans." |
| Alcohol-free hand sanitiser | Alcohol-free hand sanitiser |
| As well as cow-dung soap, Cowpathy has been selling alcohol-free hand sanitiser with "distilled cow urine obtained from indigenous cows" online since 2018. | As well as cow-dung soap, Cowpathy has been selling alcohol-free hand sanitiser with "distilled cow urine obtained from indigenous cows" online since 2018. |
| Currently out of stock, the product page says: "Due to high demand, we are currently limiting the purchase quantity per customer for this product to maximize access for our customers." | Currently out of stock, the product page says: "Due to high demand, we are currently limiting the purchase quantity per customer for this product to maximize access for our customers." |
| Meanwhile, Ramdev, a yoga guru on a popular Hindi news channel, has suggested making herbal hand sanitisers at home. | Meanwhile, Ramdev, a yoga guru on a popular Hindi news channel, has suggested making herbal hand sanitisers at home. |
| He also said consuming a concoction of ayurvedic herb giloy, turmeric and basil leaves could help prevent coronavirus. | He also said consuming a concoction of ayurvedic herb giloy, turmeric and basil leaves could help prevent coronavirus. |
| But the World Health Organization and the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) say it is important to use alcohol-based hand sanitisers. | But the World Health Organization and the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) say it is important to use alcohol-based hand sanitisers. |
| And Prof Sally Bloomfield, at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, says any homemade hand sanitiser will be ineffective as even vodka contains only 40% alcohol. | And Prof Sally Bloomfield, at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, says any homemade hand sanitiser will be ineffective as even vodka contains only 40% alcohol. |
| Vegetarianism | Vegetarianism |
| Last week, Anil Vij, the Health Minister of Haryana state, in northern India, made an appeal for people not to eat meat. | Last week, Anil Vij, the Health Minister of Haryana state, in northern India, made an appeal for people not to eat meat. |
| "Be vegetarian," he tweeted. | "Be vegetarian," he tweeted. |
| "Do not create viruses like coronavirus, which pose a danger to humanity, by having [meat of] different kinds of animals." | "Do not create viruses like coronavirus, which pose a danger to humanity, by having [meat of] different kinds of animals." |
| A Hindu nationalist group, meanwhile, claimed the coronavirus had come to punish meat-eaters. | A Hindu nationalist group, meanwhile, claimed the coronavirus had come to punish meat-eaters. |
| But after the ministry that oversees livestock production said it had led to a fall in the sales of eggs and chicken, the Indian government's fact-checking service posted a rebuttal of the claim. | But after the ministry that oversees livestock production said it had led to a fall in the sales of eggs and chicken, the Indian government's fact-checking service posted a rebuttal of the claim. |
| And government minister Giriraj Singh said the Indian food regulator had found no evidence for it. | And government minister Giriraj Singh said the Indian food regulator had found no evidence for it. |
| 'Anti-coronavirus' mattress | 'Anti-coronavirus' mattress |
| The coronavirus pandemic has also led some businesses to sell products they claim can fight the virus. | The coronavirus pandemic has also led some businesses to sell products they claim can fight the virus. |
| A 15,000-rupee (£165) "anti-coronavirus" mattress was as advertised virus-resistant, for example. | A 15,000-rupee (£165) "anti-coronavirus" mattress was as advertised virus-resistant, for example. |
| Arihant Mattresses managing director Amar Parekh told BBC News: "It is anti-fungal, anti-allergic, dustproof and waterproof, so nothing can go inside it." | Arihant Mattresses managing director Amar Parekh told BBC News: "It is anti-fungal, anti-allergic, dustproof and waterproof, so nothing can go inside it." |
| But the advertisement had now been removed | But the advertisement had now been removed |
| "I do not want to cause harm to anyone," he said. | "I do not want to cause harm to anyone," he said. |
| "We did not do it after there was a backlash." | "We did not do it after there was a backlash." |