This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/26/opinion/cuny-cuts-ben-lerner.html
The article has changed 14 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 11 | Version 12 |
|---|---|
| The Backward Logic of Austerity Threatens America’s Most Vibrant Campus | The Backward Logic of Austerity Threatens America’s Most Vibrant Campus |
| (1 day later) | |
| Last month the administration at Brooklyn College, part of the City University of New York, announced that — in anticipation of a coming budget crisis — departments must reduce their course offerings by 25 percent. This will mean firing large numbers of adjunct professors, some of whom will lose their health insurance, in the middle of a pandemic. (Mass firings have already started at other CUNY campuses, 450 to date at John Jay alone; they could happen at Brooklyn any day.) Remaining classes will then swell, which is bad for in-person education, but worse if classes remain online, as anybody who has tried to teach on Zoom can attest. The administration has said the projected savings from terminating adjuncts and ballooning classes at Brooklyn College would be $1.4 million. On the scale of New York State’s budget, the system’s main funding source, that’s a rounding error; for our adjuncts and our students, it’s a disaster. After years of being brutalized by Albany, CUNY has apparently so thoroughly internalized the backward logic of austerity that it responds to crisis by attacking itself. | Last month the administration at Brooklyn College, part of the City University of New York, announced that — in anticipation of a coming budget crisis — departments must reduce their course offerings by 25 percent. This will mean firing large numbers of adjunct professors, some of whom will lose their health insurance, in the middle of a pandemic. (Mass firings have already started at other CUNY campuses, 450 to date at John Jay alone; they could happen at Brooklyn any day.) Remaining classes will then swell, which is bad for in-person education, but worse if classes remain online, as anybody who has tried to teach on Zoom can attest. The administration has said the projected savings from terminating adjuncts and ballooning classes at Brooklyn College would be $1.4 million. On the scale of New York State’s budget, the system’s main funding source, that’s a rounding error; for our adjuncts and our students, it’s a disaster. After years of being brutalized by Albany, CUNY has apparently so thoroughly internalized the backward logic of austerity that it responds to crisis by attacking itself. |
| Can I skip the part where I drive home the importance of public education by highlighting a brilliant student and what she’s achieved despite economic hardship? I know and admire scores of such students, but this isn’t only about the stars. It’s about the commons, the fact that an outstanding public education should be available to everyone, in New York and beyond. CUNY is the nation’s largest urban education system; its 275,000 students are spread across 25 campuses. Brooklyn College, like the rest of CUNY, crackles with energy and intelligence; its diversity represents a wealth that transcends any fiscal metric; that’s why it is, despite decades of disinvestment from the state, the most vibrant campus I know, here or abroad. | Can I skip the part where I drive home the importance of public education by highlighting a brilliant student and what she’s achieved despite economic hardship? I know and admire scores of such students, but this isn’t only about the stars. It’s about the commons, the fact that an outstanding public education should be available to everyone, in New York and beyond. CUNY is the nation’s largest urban education system; its 275,000 students are spread across 25 campuses. Brooklyn College, like the rest of CUNY, crackles with energy and intelligence; its diversity represents a wealth that transcends any fiscal metric; that’s why it is, despite decades of disinvestment from the state, the most vibrant campus I know, here or abroad. |
| It also largely runs on underpaid adjuncts (who are often graduate students). In recent weeks, these adjuncts and their students have struggled valiantly to move the university online, as Zoom classes become sites not only for learning but also for mutual aid. (The correlation of Covid-19 deaths with race and class is well documented; the CUNY student body is around 30 percent Latinx; 25 percent black; 21 percent Asian; and 23 percent white, many of whom are white immigrants. Nearly a third of our students at Brooklyn have sick family members; many are in mourning.) CUNY adjunct faculty members and their students are often the city’s essential workers, stocking the grocery stores or driving Ubers or ambulances (is an Uber ambulance next for the privatized city — or is that already here?) while caring for older and younger family members. And then they show up to take or teach the chemistry or composition class, to reassert with every virtual meeting the actual stakes of living and learning together. | It also largely runs on underpaid adjuncts (who are often graduate students). In recent weeks, these adjuncts and their students have struggled valiantly to move the university online, as Zoom classes become sites not only for learning but also for mutual aid. (The correlation of Covid-19 deaths with race and class is well documented; the CUNY student body is around 30 percent Latinx; 25 percent black; 21 percent Asian; and 23 percent white, many of whom are white immigrants. Nearly a third of our students at Brooklyn have sick family members; many are in mourning.) CUNY adjunct faculty members and their students are often the city’s essential workers, stocking the grocery stores or driving Ubers or ambulances (is an Uber ambulance next for the privatized city — or is that already here?) while caring for older and younger family members. And then they show up to take or teach the chemistry or composition class, to reassert with every virtual meeting the actual stakes of living and learning together. |
| Austerity is powerful people saying “we’ll have to endure painful cuts” when “we” means “everybody but us.” In the coming months, CUNY might well be told by Albany to slash its payrolls and compromise its classes. At that point, the CUNY leadership, along with our strong union and student activists, along with anybody who cares about the city, should fight back. It should demand that Gov. Andrew Cuomo increase taxes on the wealthy, issue bonds the Federal Reserve will buy, or otherwise find ways to make our city university system a priority. In early February, a poll conducted for the American Federation of Teachers found that some 90 percent of New Yorkers support taxing the wealthy to raise public revenue. Democrats control both houses of the State Legislature and the executive. The rhetoric of austerity is as empty as the luxury towers we pass by on our socially distanced walks. | Austerity is powerful people saying “we’ll have to endure painful cuts” when “we” means “everybody but us.” In the coming months, CUNY might well be told by Albany to slash its payrolls and compromise its classes. At that point, the CUNY leadership, along with our strong union and student activists, along with anybody who cares about the city, should fight back. It should demand that Gov. Andrew Cuomo increase taxes on the wealthy, issue bonds the Federal Reserve will buy, or otherwise find ways to make our city university system a priority. In early February, a poll conducted for the American Federation of Teachers found that some 90 percent of New Yorkers support taxing the wealthy to raise public revenue. Democrats control both houses of the State Legislature and the executive. The rhetoric of austerity is as empty as the luxury towers we pass by on our socially distanced walks. |
| The adjuncts I work with typically have — or at least they had — several jobs in addition to their own teaching; how else to survive in a city from which all but the very rich are increasingly priced out? And still these adjuncts are spending unpaid extra hours with their students, standing with them in this disastrous time, trying to remind them of other times and human possibilities through the study of a poem or work of political theory or a strand of DNA. The CUNY administration should be asking how it can best support these important teachers now. Let’s start by not firing them. | The adjuncts I work with typically have — or at least they had — several jobs in addition to their own teaching; how else to survive in a city from which all but the very rich are increasingly priced out? And still these adjuncts are spending unpaid extra hours with their students, standing with them in this disastrous time, trying to remind them of other times and human possibilities through the study of a poem or work of political theory or a strand of DNA. The CUNY administration should be asking how it can best support these important teachers now. Let’s start by not firing them. |
| Updated Aug. 21, 2020 | |
| The latest on how schools are reopening amid the pandemic. | The latest on how schools are reopening amid the pandemic. |
| This pandemic has made painfully clear both our shared vulnerability and its uneven distribution. So far, our underrecognized and underpaid front line workers — a great number of them CUNY students and graduates — have been receiving nightly applause. Applaud their adjunct teachers, too. But we owe the adjuncts more than applause: We must stop — in the realm of education and beyond, in this city and beyond — the broken record of austerity, in which crises caused or compounded by underfunding public institutions are used to justify another round of cuts. | This pandemic has made painfully clear both our shared vulnerability and its uneven distribution. So far, our underrecognized and underpaid front line workers — a great number of them CUNY students and graduates — have been receiving nightly applause. Applaud their adjunct teachers, too. But we owe the adjuncts more than applause: We must stop — in the realm of education and beyond, in this city and beyond — the broken record of austerity, in which crises caused or compounded by underfunding public institutions are used to justify another round of cuts. |
| Ben Lerner is a professor of English at Brooklyn College and the author, most recently, of “The Topeka School,” a novel. | Ben Lerner is a professor of English at Brooklyn College and the author, most recently, of “The Topeka School,” a novel. |
| The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. We’d like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips. And here’s our email: letters@nytimes.com. | The Times is committed to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. We’d like to hear what you think about this or any of our articles. Here are some tips. And here’s our email: letters@nytimes.com. |
| Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram. | Follow The New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram. |