This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/magazine/7909688.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Using pure logic | Using pure logic |
| (about 23 hours later) | |
| THE BIG IDEA 60 seconds to change the world Can a simple idea help make the world a better place? Each week we ask a guest to outline an idea to improve all our lives. Here, mathematician Manil Suri suggests that children should be encouraged to find answers purely using logic. | THE BIG IDEA 60 seconds to change the world Can a simple idea help make the world a better place? Each week we ask a guest to outline an idea to improve all our lives. Here, mathematician Manil Suri suggests that children should be encouraged to find answers purely using logic. |
| Everyone should think for themselves more, rather than relying on ideology. | Everyone should think for themselves more, rather than relying on ideology. |
| Don't ride along with the teachings of your left- or right-wing politics - or even worse, your religion I'd say. | Don't ride along with the teachings of your left- or right-wing politics - or even worse, your religion I'd say. |
| Instead, try to reason out the correct path from common sense and basic humanist principles. FROM BBC WORLD SERVICE More from The ForumDownload the 60 Second Podcast | Instead, try to reason out the correct path from common sense and basic humanist principles. FROM BBC WORLD SERVICE More from The ForumDownload the 60 Second Podcast |
| Many of us actually might be already too set in our ways to make this change but we can all train children around us to behave this way. | Many of us actually might be already too set in our ways to make this change but we can all train children around us to behave this way. |
| They have a natural curiosity, which gives rise to a hundred questions for each answer, and it behoves us not to squelch this spirit. | They have a natural curiosity, which gives rise to a hundred questions for each answer, and it behoves us not to squelch this spirit. |
| What I mean by that is that rather than getting irritated or invoking God or tradition, we need to patiently show then how to rely on logic to arrive at the best answer. | What I mean by that is that rather than getting irritated or invoking God or tradition, we need to patiently show then how to rely on logic to arrive at the best answer. |
| And thus, trained to not accept notions at face value but to rely on their own reasoning power - they might one day grow up and challenge us to do the same. | And thus, trained to not accept notions at face value but to rely on their own reasoning power - they might one day grow up and challenge us to do the same. |
| Manil Suri is Professor of Mathematics at the University of Maryland Baltimore County and a novelist. | Manil Suri is Professor of Mathematics at the University of Maryland Baltimore County and a novelist. |
| Below is a selection of your comments. | |
| I think that Philosophy as a whole should be the central core of education. Perhaps if we had a population more formally educated in thinking, ethics and learning, then we might avoid some of the unreasoned beliefs, urban myths and non-thinking behaviour evident in today's society.Steve Cowie, Llandudno | |
| Common sense and basic humanist principles' are not necessarily 'common' to everyone, nor are they a 'basic' framework we can assume exists naturally in everyone's mind. This sort of abstract universalised idea of what is involved in reasoning conceals ideologies behind a veneer of being common to all. We may end up leading children to believe that they are thinking for themselves when they have only internalised the ideologies we have fed them.AH, Cambridge | |
| As a mother, my best day was when my daughter learned the word 'Why?'. Many mothers groan but I delighted in it and always answer her questions. As a teacher, I see my role being to replace an empty mind with an open and enquiring oneMegan, Cheshire UK | |
| Simple and spot on, imagine if more people had this clarity of thought.=Anthony, London | |
| Not all things can be arrived at by logic alone, unless that is you are a machine!S Warman, Crewe | |
| Logic alone will not always get you the correct answer. We need also to take into account empirical facts. But there are not always enough hard facts to decide the matter.Ian, Nottingham | |
| This is one of the most profound yet simplest ideas, we should all think for ourselves.Nick, Brynteg, Angelsey | |
| When children realize that any position can be credibly argued for, they will become cynical and disenchanted with truth. The young need passionate role models, not an introduction to lawyering. Patrick, Chicago, USA | |
| Nice little ad for humanism. It all sounds very nice, but please define "common sense" for us. And yes, list a few "basic humanist principles", I'll start with a few, self-preservation, dog-eat-dog and survival of the fittest.Phil J Walton, Panchkula, India | |
| Everyone should question what is taught, especially religion and politics. Blind belief is the supreme ignorance that leads to confrontation and intolerance, while questioning leads to understanding, improvement and tolerance. Good on you. Manil.Albert E. James, Vancouver, Canada | |
| Logic is always a good idea but I think it also needs to be backed up by long-term thinking, not short-term thinking. What's logical in the short term can be disastrous in the long term. It needs to go hand in hand with responsibility on a bigger scale.Mick, Groningen, Netherlands | |
| What a terrible idea to only use logic. Obviously, this comes from someone comfortable only using half his mind.Simone, Miami Beach, Florida |
Previous version
1
Next version