This article is from the source 'rtcom' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.rt.com/uk/518472-britain-rulebritannia-song-hustings-aberdeen/
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Opinions split after student banned from university union for discrimination after saying ‘Rule, Britannia’ during hustings | Opinions split after student banned from university union for discrimination after saying ‘Rule, Britannia’ during hustings |
| (6 months later) | |
| The expulsion of a 19-year-old student from a university union, for using the phrase “Rule, Britannia” during a hustings, has sparked heated debate on social media, with many seeing it as part of the ‘cancel culture’ movement. | The expulsion of a 19-year-old student from a university union, for using the phrase “Rule, Britannia” during a hustings, has sparked heated debate on social media, with many seeing it as part of the ‘cancel culture’ movement. |
| On Wednesday evening, the Telegraph reported that Elizabeth Heverin had been banned for two weeks from Aberdeen University student's union for using “discriminatory or racist language” during a virtual hustings about the British Army's presence on campuses. | On Wednesday evening, the Telegraph reported that Elizabeth Heverin had been banned for two weeks from Aberdeen University student's union for using “discriminatory or racist language” during a virtual hustings about the British Army's presence on campuses. |
| Heverin's reference to “Rule, Britannia,” which saw her disciplined by officials at Aberdeen University Students' Association (AUSA), has further highlighted the broad spectrum of views on the phrase from the 18th century song. A number of Twitter users expressed their support for the university union in clamping down on the use of “outdated” rhetoric. “Rule Britannia is awful, racist, jingoistic claptrap that has no place in a modern society,” one commenter wrote. | Heverin's reference to “Rule, Britannia,” which saw her disciplined by officials at Aberdeen University Students' Association (AUSA), has further highlighted the broad spectrum of views on the phrase from the 18th century song. A number of Twitter users expressed their support for the university union in clamping down on the use of “outdated” rhetoric. “Rule Britannia is awful, racist, jingoistic claptrap that has no place in a modern society,” one commenter wrote. |
| Some took a more measured approach, noting that celebrating colonialism does not have a place in modern Britain, and that the students' association had severely overreacted. “Whilst I don't agree with Rule Britannia’s underlying celebrations of colonialism, I think it's a bit harsh to ban a student for just using those words unless she spouted other things we're not aware of,” one tweeted. | Some took a more measured approach, noting that celebrating colonialism does not have a place in modern Britain, and that the students' association had severely overreacted. “Whilst I don't agree with Rule Britannia’s underlying celebrations of colonialism, I think it's a bit harsh to ban a student for just using those words unless she spouted other things we're not aware of,” one tweeted. |
| However, many were keen to hit back at the so-called “cancel culture” and “woke” movements in the UK. | However, many were keen to hit back at the so-called “cancel culture” and “woke” movements in the UK. |
| Heverin herself was shocked by the university's disciplinary action, telling the Telegraph “it feels like I've been prosecuted for the crime of being patriotic… It's scary to think where freedom of speech at the university will go from here.” | Heverin herself was shocked by the university's disciplinary action, telling the Telegraph “it feels like I've been prosecuted for the crime of being patriotic… It's scary to think where freedom of speech at the university will go from here.” |
| The song ‘Rule Britannia!’ along with ‘Land of Hope and Glory’ engendered considerable discourse last year when the BBC proposed to pull the songs from the last night of the Proms concert show. In the end, the BBC succumbed to public pressure and the songs were reinstated. | The song ‘Rule Britannia!’ along with ‘Land of Hope and Glory’ engendered considerable discourse last year when the BBC proposed to pull the songs from the last night of the Proms concert show. In the end, the BBC succumbed to public pressure and the songs were reinstated. |
| The news was met with dismay and anger across many parts of Britain. Tory MP Susan Hall called it a “ridiculous” bow to political correctness. Fellow politician David Davies says the BBC, as an organisation “claiming to support diversity,” can certainly find room for the time-tested British favourites. | The news was met with dismay and anger across many parts of Britain. Tory MP Susan Hall called it a “ridiculous” bow to political correctness. Fellow politician David Davies says the BBC, as an organisation “claiming to support diversity,” can certainly find room for the time-tested British favourites. |
| Like this story? Share it with a friend! | Like this story? Share it with a friend! |
| Dear readers and commenters, | |
| We have implemented a new engine for our comment section. We hope the transition goes smoothly for all of you. Unfortunately, the comments made before the change have been lost due to a technical problem. We are working on restoring them, and hoping to see you fill up the comment section with new ones. You should still be able to log in to comment using your social-media profiles, but if you signed up under an RT profile before, you are invited to create a new profile with the new commenting system. | |
| Sorry for the inconvenience, and looking forward to your future comments, | |
| RT Team. |