This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/61967480
The article has changed 17 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 7 | Version 8 |
|---|---|
| Ukraine war: Kremenchuk shopping centre attack claims fact-checked | Ukraine war: Kremenchuk shopping centre attack claims fact-checked |
| (14 days later) | |
| The aftermath of a missile strike in Kremenchuk | The aftermath of a missile strike in Kremenchuk |
| Within hours of the attack on a shopping centre in the central Ukrainian city of Kremenchuk, false and unproven claims began circulating online. | Within hours of the attack on a shopping centre in the central Ukrainian city of Kremenchuk, false and unproven claims began circulating online. |
| Stories were spread by Russian Telegram channels and by Dmitry Polyanskiy, Russia's deputy ambassador to the United Nations. They included rumours that the attack was "false" or "staged" - and were repeated on Russian television. | Stories were spread by Russian Telegram channels and by Dmitry Polyanskiy, Russia's deputy ambassador to the United Nations. They included rumours that the attack was "false" or "staged" - and were repeated on Russian television. |
| On Tuesday, Russia's defence ministry released a statement claiming the shopping centre was "non-functioning" and that the bombing of a nearby ammunitions dump sparked a secondary fire at the centre. Those claims were denied by Ukrainian officials. | On Tuesday, Russia's defence ministry released a statement claiming the shopping centre was "non-functioning" and that the bombing of a nearby ammunitions dump sparked a secondary fire at the centre. Those claims were denied by Ukrainian officials. |
| What's the truth? | What's the truth? |
| Claim: The shopping centre was 'non-functioning' | Claim: The shopping centre was 'non-functioning' |
| This claim is false. BBC reporters on the ground have spoken to shoppers and employees who were inside the building at the time of the attack. | This claim is false. BBC reporters on the ground have spoken to shoppers and employees who were inside the building at the time of the attack. |
| Multiple posts listing details of missing people who were either working at the shopping centre on the day or went shopping there, were published in a local Telegram channel in the hours after the attack. | Multiple posts listing details of missing people who were either working at the shopping centre on the day or went shopping there, were published in a local Telegram channel in the hours after the attack. |
| One pro-Kremlin "fact-checking" channel suggested that no photographs from inside the shopping centre had been posted on Instagram since March. However, a woman who lives in a nearby village and regularly goes shopping in Kremenchuk, told the BBC that the shopping centre had been "constantly open" and her family had visited it at least once a week. | One pro-Kremlin "fact-checking" channel suggested that no photographs from inside the shopping centre had been posted on Instagram since March. However, a woman who lives in a nearby village and regularly goes shopping in Kremenchuk, told the BBC that the shopping centre had been "constantly open" and her family had visited it at least once a week. |
| Inside the shopping centre things appeared to be relatively normal in a video filmed two days before the attack | Inside the shopping centre things appeared to be relatively normal in a video filmed two days before the attack |
| She also shared video she had taken at the shopping centre from 25 June, showing open shops and people walking inside the building. Other, similar footage posted online appears even more recent - including a YouTube video apparently filmed just a day before the attack, also showing shoppers and businesses open as normal. | She also shared video she had taken at the shopping centre from 25 June, showing open shops and people walking inside the building. Other, similar footage posted online appears even more recent - including a YouTube video apparently filmed just a day before the attack, also showing shoppers and businesses open as normal. |
| A still from a video showing businesses open as usual two days before the attack | A still from a video showing businesses open as usual two days before the attack |
| Some Telegram channels claimed there were no women or children at the shopping centre - implying that the building had been turned into a military facility. That claim is false, according to several eyewitness accounts and online videos. | Some Telegram channels claimed there were no women or children at the shopping centre - implying that the building had been turned into a military facility. That claim is false, according to several eyewitness accounts and online videos. |
| Claim: The bombing of a weapons depot spread fire to the shopping centre | Claim: The bombing of a weapons depot spread fire to the shopping centre |
| The Russian Defence Ministry claimed a strike on an arms storage facility detonated ammunition which set the shopping centre on fire. | The Russian Defence Ministry claimed a strike on an arms storage facility detonated ammunition which set the shopping centre on fire. |
| "Western-manufactured weapons and ammunition stockpiled in the warehouse to be sent to a Ukrainian military grouping in Donbas were hit with a high-precision strike," the ministry said. | "Western-manufactured weapons and ammunition stockpiled in the warehouse to be sent to a Ukrainian military grouping in Donbas were hit with a high-precision strike," the ministry said. |
| Ukrainian officials have denied there was a weapons depot nearby. | Ukrainian officials have denied there was a weapons depot nearby. |
| CCTV footage captured near a pond roughly 600 metres north of the shopping centre, on the other side of a factory building, shows two missile strikes in the area. | CCTV footage captured near a pond roughly 600 metres north of the shopping centre, on the other side of a factory building, shows two missile strikes in the area. |
| Video from CCTV cameras of #Kremenchuk. Two very powerful hits were filmed when rubble flies into a pond (Altanka Na Ostrovi Kohnannya). This pond is located 500 m from the shopping mall Amstor.#Ukrainewar #Ukraine #Kremenchuk pic.twitter.com/1IQqx99SAH | Video from CCTV cameras of #Kremenchuk. Two very powerful hits were filmed when rubble flies into a pond (Altanka Na Ostrovi Kohnannya). This pond is located 500 m from the shopping mall Amstor.#Ukrainewar #Ukraine #Kremenchuk pic.twitter.com/1IQqx99SAH |
| Matching the exact spots where the two missiles land in the CCTV video with aerial images of the area, it appears one missile hit close to the eastern end of the shopping centre, while the other struck the northern end of the factory, near the southern edge of the pond. | Matching the exact spots where the two missiles land in the CCTV video with aerial images of the area, it appears one missile hit close to the eastern end of the shopping centre, while the other struck the northern end of the factory, near the southern edge of the pond. |
| The factory mentioned by the Russian defence ministry is located roughly 300 metres north of the shopping centre. The buildings are separated by a wall, vegetation and rail tracks, making the claim that "secondary explosions" caused a large fire with multiple casualties in the shopping centre unlikely. | The factory mentioned by the Russian defence ministry is located roughly 300 metres north of the shopping centre. The buildings are separated by a wall, vegetation and rail tracks, making the claim that "secondary explosions" caused a large fire with multiple casualties in the shopping centre unlikely. |
| This video can not be played | This video can not be played |
| To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser. | To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser. |
| Watch: Drone footage shows the extent of the destruction at the shopping centre | Watch: Drone footage shows the extent of the destruction at the shopping centre |
| Watch: Drone footage shows the extent of the destruction at the shopping centre | |
| According to the Ukrainian online publication Kyiv Independent, a press officer of the regional administration confirmed that the machinery plant had been hit, injuring two individuals. | According to the Ukrainian online publication Kyiv Independent, a press officer of the regional administration confirmed that the machinery plant had been hit, injuring two individuals. |
| Svitlana Rybalko, from the regional State Emergency Service, denied there were weapons stored at the facility."It's a place for making road equipment, machines for road construction," she told the BBC. "There's also a greenhouse nearby where workers grow cucumbers." | Svitlana Rybalko, from the regional State Emergency Service, denied there were weapons stored at the facility."It's a place for making road equipment, machines for road construction," she told the BBC. "There's also a greenhouse nearby where workers grow cucumbers." |
| This video can not be played | This video can not be played |
| To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser. | To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser. |
| Watch: CCTV shows missile striking Ukrainian shopping mall | |
| Watch: CCTV shows missile striking Ukrainian shopping mall | Watch: CCTV shows missile striking Ukrainian shopping mall |
| Satellite images of the area, along with a video released by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky provide further evidence that these were the locations of the strikes. | Satellite images of the area, along with a video released by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky provide further evidence that these were the locations of the strikes. |
| This video also supports an earlier Ukrainian assessment that the missile was an air-launched Kh-22 weapon. | This video also supports an earlier Ukrainian assessment that the missile was an air-launched Kh-22 weapon. |
| This is a medium-range cruise missile developed in the 1960s, originally to attack large warships. There is also a land-attack variant. | This is a medium-range cruise missile developed in the 1960s, originally to attack large warships. There is also a land-attack variant. |
| The weapon is large, liquid-fuelled and supersonic - but inaccurate by today's standards. | The weapon is large, liquid-fuelled and supersonic - but inaccurate by today's standards. |
| The relatively shallow angle of impact further points to its cruise nature. A ballistic missile follows a much more parabolic path. | The relatively shallow angle of impact further points to its cruise nature. A ballistic missile follows a much more parabolic path. |
| Ukraine says the missiles were launched from bombers in the Kursk region of Russia, some 300km (185 miles) away. | Ukraine says the missiles were launched from bombers in the Kursk region of Russia, some 300km (185 miles) away. |
| Claim: The attack was 'staged' or a 'provocation' | Claim: The attack was 'staged' or a 'provocation' |
| Flames engulfing the mall in Kremenchuk | Flames engulfing the mall in Kremenchuk |
| This claim contradicts the official Russian defence ministry statement - even though top diplomats such as Mr Polyanskiy, the deputy UN ambassador, described the Kremenchuk attack as "a new Bucha-style Ukrainian provocation" on Twitter. | This claim contradicts the official Russian defence ministry statement - even though top diplomats such as Mr Polyanskiy, the deputy UN ambassador, described the Kremenchuk attack as "a new Bucha-style Ukrainian provocation" on Twitter. |
| There's simply no evidence - nor has any been offered - that Ukraine bombed the shopping centre, or that the attack was "staged". | There's simply no evidence - nor has any been offered - that Ukraine bombed the shopping centre, or that the attack was "staged". |
| It's the latest example of a common tactic used by supporters of the Russian government - throwing multiple, conflicting, evidence-free narratives out in the immediate aftermath of an attack. | It's the latest example of a common tactic used by supporters of the Russian government - throwing multiple, conflicting, evidence-free narratives out in the immediate aftermath of an attack. |
| The claim echoes other, debunked false assertions by Russia and its supporters, for instance that the attack on a maternity hospital in Mariupol and the killings of civilians in Bucha were somehow faked or staged. | The claim echoes other, debunked false assertions by Russia and its supporters, for instance that the attack on a maternity hospital in Mariupol and the killings of civilians in Bucha were somehow faked or staged. |
| In a Twitter message, Mr Polyanskiy said the attack "will be used by Ukraine to attract as much attention as possible through promoting [a] false version of what happened" and "my tweet doesn't contradict the explanation provided by Russian [Ministry of Defence]". | In a Twitter message, Mr Polyanskiy said the attack "will be used by Ukraine to attract as much attention as possible through promoting [a] false version of what happened" and "my tweet doesn't contradict the explanation provided by Russian [Ministry of Defence]". |
| Reporting by: Olga Robinson, Shayan Sardarizadeh, Daniele Palumbo, Chris Partridge, Joshua Cheetham and Nick Beake. | Reporting by: Olga Robinson, Shayan Sardarizadeh, Daniele Palumbo, Chris Partridge, Joshua Cheetham and Nick Beake. |
| War in Ukraine: More coverage | War in Ukraine: More coverage |
| RUSSIA GRAIN THEFT: The BBC looks at the evidence | RUSSIA GRAIN THEFT: The BBC looks at the evidence |
| NATO: Key challenges for summit | NATO: Key challenges for summit |
| WATCH: A BBC journalist returns to her bombed home | WATCH: A BBC journalist returns to her bombed home |
| READ MORE: Full coverage of the crisis | READ MORE: Full coverage of the crisis |
| What claims do you want BBC Reality Check to investigate? Get in touch | What claims do you want BBC Reality Check to investigate? Get in touch |
| Read more from Reality Check | Read more from Reality Check |