This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/business/8141863.stm

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
The pros and cons of car firm subsidies The pros and cons of car firm subsidies
(1 day later)
By Jorn Madslien Business reporter, BBC NewsBy Jorn Madslien Business reporter, BBC News
All governments support their incumbent motor industryAll governments support their incumbent motor industry
Amidst early signs of a recovery in global car sales, carmakers like to pretend that they have survived the recession through their own efforts.Amidst early signs of a recovery in global car sales, carmakers like to pretend that they have survived the recession through their own efforts.
Indeed, in many cases they were quick to respond to early signs of the sales slump, instantly idling shifts and cutting jobs, slashing production to match plunging demand.Indeed, in many cases they were quick to respond to early signs of the sales slump, instantly idling shifts and cutting jobs, slashing production to match plunging demand.
In the UK, plants were shut down over Christmas and output was cut 47.5% in December compared with a year earlier, according to industry body SMMT.In the UK, plants were shut down over Christmas and output was cut 47.5% in December compared with a year earlier, according to industry body SMMT.
Indeed, across Europe the vehicle manufacturing sector lost more jobs than any other sector, including retailing, during the last three months of 2008, according to official EU data.Indeed, across Europe the vehicle manufacturing sector lost more jobs than any other sector, including retailing, during the last three months of 2008, according to official EU data.
FictionFiction
But any the notion that only the fittest have survived is fiction. But the notion that only the fittest have survived is fiction.
The motor industry has been nursed back to health by a series of cash injections administered by well-meaning governments, according to Calum MacRae, automotive analyst with the consultants PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC).The motor industry has been nursed back to health by a series of cash injections administered by well-meaning governments, according to Calum MacRae, automotive analyst with the consultants PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC).
"While in the main 2009 has been characterised by a deep economic recession in many markets, intervention has been visible in underpinning both markets and industry players," he says."While in the main 2009 has been characterised by a deep economic recession in many markets, intervention has been visible in underpinning both markets and industry players," he says.
Governments across the world have been prepared to assist the sector through a broad range of initiatives such as:Governments across the world have been prepared to assist the sector through a broad range of initiatives such as:
  • scrappage incentive schemes
  • soft loans
  • fuel economy regulations
  • technology grants
  • increased import tariffs
  • tax reductions
  • surgical bankruptcy
  • scrappage incentive schemes
  • soft loans
  • fuel economy regulations
  • technology grants
  • increased import tariffs
  • tax reductions
  • surgical bankruptcy
All this begs the question - what is in it for taxpayers?All this begs the question - what is in it for taxpayers?
Major benefitsMajor benefits
"The main rationale for direct action," according to Mr MacRae, has been the "industry's role as a significant - some say the most significant - economic multiplier"."The main rationale for direct action," according to Mr MacRae, has been the "industry's role as a significant - some say the most significant - economic multiplier".
The benefits of intervention now will undoubtedly have to be weighed against the future costs Calum MacRae, automotive analyst, PricewaterhouseCoopers Suffering and assistance around the worldThe benefits of intervention now will undoubtedly have to be weighed against the future costs Calum MacRae, automotive analyst, PricewaterhouseCoopers Suffering and assistance around the world
In other words, a recovery for the motor industry should be good news for the economy at large.In other words, a recovery for the motor industry should be good news for the economy at large.
The idea behind the multiplier theory is that the government gets back more than it puts in.The idea behind the multiplier theory is that the government gets back more than it puts in.
It expects the national income from an expanded automotive sector to exceed the sums it spent to keep the wheels turning over.It expects the national income from an expanded automotive sector to exceed the sums it spent to keep the wheels turning over.
This is true at a basic level, where under the scrappage scheme the government gets more back in VAT than the £1,000 it pays towards the scheme.This is true at a basic level, where under the scrappage scheme the government gets more back in VAT than the £1,000 it pays towards the scheme.
But the benefits can be much broader if initial government incentives kick off virtuous cycles.But the benefits can be much broader if initial government incentives kick off virtuous cycles.
Direct support for manufacturers, for instance, through subsidies of so-called "green" technology, can deliver direct benefits, such as extra jobs.Direct support for manufacturers, for instance, through subsidies of so-called "green" technology, can deliver direct benefits, such as extra jobs.
But it can also bring about indirect benefits, such as consumption in other areas of the economy, which should then lead to further job creation, and so forth.But it can also bring about indirect benefits, such as consumption in other areas of the economy, which should then lead to further job creation, and so forth.
Flawed schemeFlawed scheme
But is not all smooth sailing for the car industry.But is not all smooth sailing for the car industry.
Some of the subsidies are poorly designed and could have negative long-term consequences.Some of the subsidies are poorly designed and could have negative long-term consequences.
Scrappage schemes benefit some manufacturers more than othersScrappage schemes benefit some manufacturers more than others
Take the various scrappage schemes introduced by governments, most notably Germany and the UK.Take the various scrappage schemes introduced by governments, most notably Germany and the UK.
One rather predictable drawback that characterise such schemes is the vacuum left in their wake.One rather predictable drawback that characterise such schemes is the vacuum left in their wake.
When they come to an end, many of those who had been thinking about buying a car will have already done so a bit earlier than planned.When they come to an end, many of those who had been thinking about buying a car will have already done so a bit earlier than planned.
Others may be put off because cars suddenly seem expensive compared with what they were under the schemes.Others may be put off because cars suddenly seem expensive compared with what they were under the schemes.
"Given this, we expect EU light vehicle sales to fall by around 2% in 2010," observes PwC."Given this, we expect EU light vehicle sales to fall by around 2% in 2010," observes PwC.
Another drawback relates to how the scrappage schemes have pushed consumers towards small, cheap cars.Another drawback relates to how the scrappage schemes have pushed consumers towards small, cheap cars.
At the industry level, such a shift erodes profit margins, since it is easier to make money from large luxury cars.At the industry level, such a shift erodes profit margins, since it is easier to make money from large luxury cars.
But at company level - and indeed on the international arena - there are winners and losers from such schemes.But at company level - and indeed on the international arena - there are winners and losers from such schemes.
For instance, following the introduction of scrappage schemes, small car specialists such as Fiat, Citroen or Hyundai have seen rising sales of cars that deliver relatively little profits.For instance, following the introduction of scrappage schemes, small car specialists such as Fiat, Citroen or Hyundai have seen rising sales of cars that deliver relatively little profits.
This, in turn, has eroded the overall market share held by luxury car manufacturers such as BMW and Mercedes, which produce more profitable cars.This, in turn, has eroded the overall market share held by luxury car manufacturers such as BMW and Mercedes, which produce more profitable cars.
In turn, this is pushing car industry earnings towards Italy and France, or South Korea, with Germany losing out.In turn, this is pushing car industry earnings towards Italy and France, or South Korea, with Germany losing out.
Beneficial or detrimental?Beneficial or detrimental?
Many European carmakers are indignant at how scrappage schemes and other government initiatives have favoured rivals from outside their own country, or outside the EU. The schemes distort competition, they insist.Many European carmakers are indignant at how scrappage schemes and other government initiatives have favoured rivals from outside their own country, or outside the EU. The schemes distort competition, they insist.
Industry body Acea, which represents European carmakers, also objects to plans by the EU to remove tariffs on imports from Korea until an effective reciprocal has been made.Industry body Acea, which represents European carmakers, also objects to plans by the EU to remove tariffs on imports from Korea until an effective reciprocal has been made.
Acea insists the plan "effectively opens the door for cheap imports from China and other Asian countries", yet it fails to "sufficiently improve access to the South Korean market".Acea insists the plan "effectively opens the door for cheap imports from China and other Asian countries", yet it fails to "sufficiently improve access to the South Korean market".
Similar arguments - which favour self-beneficial subsidies or tariffs and oppose those benefitting rivals - are continuously made by carmakers across the world.Similar arguments - which favour self-beneficial subsidies or tariffs and oppose those benefitting rivals - are continuously made by carmakers across the world.
In many ways, though, such a debate about which company benefits the most misses the point about the automotive industry's chronic overcapacity.In many ways, though, such a debate about which company benefits the most misses the point about the automotive industry's chronic overcapacity.
Governments around the world, motivated by national pride or fears about job losses, are loath to let domestic carmakers fail, and there is not a single country that does not support its motor industry in some form or another.Governments around the world, motivated by national pride or fears about job losses, are loath to let domestic carmakers fail, and there is not a single country that does not support its motor industry in some form or another.
Whether that is good or bad is debatable.Whether that is good or bad is debatable.
"The benefits of intervention now will undoubtedly have to be weighed against the future costs," explains Mr MacRae. "be they to the long-term health of an industry still plagued by excess capacity; to taxpayers paying down budget deficits; or to future market demand levels being damaged by demand pulled forward now.""The benefits of intervention now will undoubtedly have to be weighed against the future costs," explains Mr MacRae. "be they to the long-term health of an industry still plagued by excess capacity; to taxpayers paying down budget deficits; or to future market demand levels being damaged by demand pulled forward now."