This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/8198700.stm

The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 2 Version 3
MP's rations remark 'offensive' I won't sack Duncan, says Cameron
(about 4 hours later)
A Conservative MP who was secretly recorded saying politicians have had to "live on rations" after the expenses row has come in for renewed criticism. David Cameron has said he will not sack shadow cabinet member Alan Duncan for saying that MPs are living "on rations" following reforms to their expenses.
Ex-sleaze watchdog Sir Alistair Graham said shadow cabinet member Alan Duncan's comments could be offensive to people struggling in the recession. Mr Duncan, the shadow Commons leader, was secretly filmed complaining about the changes and has since offered an "unreserved" apology.
Mr Cameron said: "Alan made a bad mistake and he acknowledges that."
But he added that MPs had to "demonstrate completely" that they understood public anger over expenses.
The secret film, made by Heydon Prowse of Don't Panic magazine, shows Mr Duncan using strong language .
Discussing reforms to expenses, he says: "No-one who's done anything in the outside world or is capable of doing such a thing will ever come into this place ever again the way we're going."
'Worrying'
He apologised after the film was widely shown on the internet and television.
Mr Cameron said he would not sack Mr Duncan, one of the best-known members of his shadow cabinet.
Speaking in his constituency of Witney, Oxfordshire, he added: "I spoke to Alan Duncan yesterday and made it clear in no uncertain terms that when it comes to the mess of expenses, the words we use, just as the actions we take, have got to demonstrate completely that we share the public's real fury at what went on in Parliament.
"Alan made a bad mistake and he has acknowledged that, he has apologised and withdrawn the remarks."
Earlier, the former parliamentary sleaze watchdog Sir Alistair Graham said Mr Duncan's comments could be offensive to people struggling in the recession.
Film maker's secret recording
He added that it was "particularly worrying" from a potential minister.He added that it was "particularly worrying" from a potential minister.
David Cameron is understood to have taken a "dim view" of the remarks, for which Mr Duncan has apologised. But Mr Duncan's fellow Conservative MP Sir Patrick Cormack defended him, telling BBC Radio 4's The World at One: "We don't want a parliament of political anoraks and rich people.
The secret film, made by Heydon Prowse of Don't Panic magazine, shows Mr Duncan using strong language when discussing reforms to the MPs' expenses system. "Those who have a vocation for public life shouldn't be deterred from going into parliament because they can't afford to contemplate it.
FROM THE TODAY PROGRAMME class="" href="http://news.bbc.co.uk/today/hi/default.stm">More from Today programme "Being an MP is an extremely expensive business."
Mr Duncan, shadow leader of the Commons, adds: "No-one who's done anything in the outside world or is capable of doing such a thing will ever come into this place ever again the way we're going." Mr Prowse was invited to the Commons by Mr Duncan after he was filmed digging a pound-shaped hole in the Rutland and Melton MP's lawn in protest at his expenses claims.
Sir Alistair, the former head of the Committee for Standards in Public Life, told the Daily Telegraph: "It is particularly worrying that such a senior figure, in a party that is likely to form a government after the next election, would say something like this."
He added that Mr Duncan had created the impression that MPs were not fully focused on reform. Mr Duncan said his comments about MPs being treated badly were meant as a joke, but he added: "The last thing people want to hear is an MP whingeing about his pay and conditions."
He told the BBC: "It is a huge honour to be an MP and my remarks, although meant in jest, were completely uncalled for. I apologise for them unreservedly."
Mr Cameron's spokesman told the Telegraph: "David thought it was absolutely right that Alan should apologise."
'Charming and generous'
The film was posted on the Don't Panic website at the end of July. It was removed from the site but has now been republished.
Mr Prowse was invited to the Commons by Mr Duncan after he was filmed digging a pound-shaped hole in the MP's lawn in protest at his expenses claims.
The campaigner said he had taken the secret camera along to the meeting in July in the hope of catching Mr Duncan out but he regretted getting him into trouble because he was a "very charming and generous guy".The campaigner said he had taken the secret camera along to the meeting in July in the hope of catching Mr Duncan out but he regretted getting him into trouble because he was a "very charming and generous guy".
But Mr Prowse said he thought it was important to expose the attitude of politicians towards the expenses scandal.But Mr Prowse said he thought it was important to expose the attitude of politicians towards the expenses scandal.
As shadow Commons leader, Mr Duncan has overseen much of the Conservative response to the expenses row and has said he would pay back more than £4,000 of allowances. As shadow Commons leader, Mr Duncan has overseen much of the Conservative response to the expenses row and has said he will pay back more than £4,000 of allowances.
Business Secretary Lord Mandelson, currently standing in for Prime Minister Gordon Brown who is on holiday, told BBC News: "Alan Duncan is very fond of speaking a good game publicly but in private talking and acting quite differently, so I am not surprised he has been found out."