This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-64677232
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
BFM journalist Rachid M'Barki suspended in scandal linked to disinformation firm | BFM journalist Rachid M'Barki suspended in scandal linked to disinformation firm |
(3 months later) | |
M'Barki has denied being paid to run stories, but admits to skipping editorial checks | M'Barki has denied being paid to run stories, but admits to skipping editorial checks |
The suspension of a senior journalist at France's leading TV news channel has uncovered what appears to be a well-organised system of corruption and influence buying in the international media. | The suspension of a senior journalist at France's leading TV news channel has uncovered what appears to be a well-organised system of corruption and influence buying in the international media. |
It was reported in January that 54-year-old Rachid M'Barki, a respected BFM veteran, had been summarily removed from his duties as overnight presenter pending an internal enquiry. The reason was a mystery. | It was reported in January that 54-year-old Rachid M'Barki, a respected BFM veteran, had been summarily removed from his duties as overnight presenter pending an internal enquiry. The reason was a mystery. |
But now an investigation by Le Monde newspaper in conjunction with the campaigning organisation Forbidden Stories has revealed more details. | But now an investigation by Le Monde newspaper in conjunction with the campaigning organisation Forbidden Stories has revealed more details. |
According to the investigation, M'Barki ran reports on a variety of subjects - luxury yachts in Monaco, a Sudanese opposition leader, allegations of corruption in Qatar - that had all one thing in common: they were planted by an Israel-based outfit specialising in 'news for hire'. | According to the investigation, M'Barki ran reports on a variety of subjects - luxury yachts in Monaco, a Sudanese opposition leader, allegations of corruption in Qatar - that had all one thing in common: they were planted by an Israel-based outfit specialising in 'news for hire'. |
M'Barki has denied being paid to run the stories, but he admits to bypassing BFM's editorial checks. | M'Barki has denied being paid to run the stories, but he admits to bypassing BFM's editorial checks. |
He says he was offered the reports by an intermediary and exercised his own professional judgment in selecting to use them. | He says he was offered the reports by an intermediary and exercised his own professional judgment in selecting to use them. |
But the investigators say they have evidence that the origin of the stories lies in the shadowy Team Jorge, an operation based in Tel Aviv and run by a former Israeli special forces officer whose real name is Tal Hanan. | But the investigators say they have evidence that the origin of the stories lies in the shadowy Team Jorge, an operation based in Tel Aviv and run by a former Israeli special forces officer whose real name is Tal Hanan. |
Love Putin, Hate France: How info ops target Africa | Love Putin, Hate France: How info ops target Africa |
Could AI swamp social media with fake accounts? | Could AI swamp social media with fake accounts? |
According to Le Monde and Forbidden Stories, Team Jorge is one of several players in a growing world of disinformation mercenaries - private sector experts in intelligence who for a price will use the internet to damage an enemy's reputation or influence an election. | According to Le Monde and Forbidden Stories, Team Jorge is one of several players in a growing world of disinformation mercenaries - private sector experts in intelligence who for a price will use the internet to damage an enemy's reputation or influence an election. |
To get access to Team Jorge, three journalists from the Forbidden Stories consortium posed as potential clients seeking to shape opinion in French-speaking Africa on behalf of a major multinational. | To get access to Team Jorge, three journalists from the Forbidden Stories consortium posed as potential clients seeking to shape opinion in French-speaking Africa on behalf of a major multinational. |
After a lengthy negotiation, they finally arranged a face-to-face meeting and got what amounted to a sales pitch. | After a lengthy negotiation, they finally arranged a face-to-face meeting and got what amounted to a sales pitch. |
Hanan claimed to have intervened in more than 30 elections and to have access to email and social media accounts of prominent African figures. | Hanan claimed to have intervened in more than 30 elections and to have access to email and social media accounts of prominent African figures. |
Central to the Team Jorge offer was a platform called Advanced Impact Media Solutions (AIMS), which generates tens of thousands of fake identities with accounts on Facebook and Telegram. These accounts then spread the content of a campaign. | Central to the Team Jorge offer was a platform called Advanced Impact Media Solutions (AIMS), which generates tens of thousands of fake identities with accounts on Facebook and Telegram. These accounts then spread the content of a campaign. |
The investigators identified around 20 different international campaigns which they believed Team Jorge had organised. | The investigators identified around 20 different international campaigns which they believed Team Jorge had organised. |
BFM confirm stories ran without approval | BFM confirm stories ran without approval |
Among the material being circulated on social media, they especially noticed two television news reports in French that purportedly ran on BFM. | Among the material being circulated on social media, they especially noticed two television news reports in French that purportedly ran on BFM. |
After checking with BFM's management, they had confirmation: the reports were shown late at night on the channel, but without the knowledge of the editorial team. | After checking with BFM's management, they had confirmation: the reports were shown late at night on the channel, but without the knowledge of the editorial team. |
At that point, on January 11, M'Barki was called in and suspended. | At that point, on January 11, M'Barki was called in and suspended. |
The first of the reports was on the EU's Russia sanctions, and their impact on the luxury yacht business in Monaco. | The first of the reports was on the EU's Russia sanctions, and their impact on the luxury yacht business in Monaco. |
One of the reports contained a number of false claims about the yacht industry in Monaco | One of the reports contained a number of false claims about the yacht industry in Monaco |
It was claimed that 10,000 jobs were at risk and that the industry had appealed to Prince Albert to intervene on their behalf. None of that has been proved. | It was claimed that 10,000 jobs were at risk and that the industry had appealed to Prince Albert to intervene on their behalf. None of that has been proved. |
The second report, broadcast in mid-December, was about a leafleting campaign in Paris accusing a former state prosecutor in Qatar of corruption. | The second report, broadcast in mid-December, was about a leafleting campaign in Paris accusing a former state prosecutor in Qatar of corruption. |
When originally shown in the early hours of the morning, the reports would have gone almost unobserved. | When originally shown in the early hours of the morning, the reports would have gone almost unobserved. |
But that changed when they were picked up by social media and Team Jorge's massed avatars. Suddenly they were viral. | But that changed when they were picked up by social media and Team Jorge's massed avatars. Suddenly they were viral. |
By seemingly planting the reports onto mainstream French television, the organisers would have immeasurably boosted the credibility of what would otherwise have been unsubstantiated gossip. | By seemingly planting the reports onto mainstream French television, the organisers would have immeasurably boosted the credibility of what would otherwise have been unsubstantiated gossip. |
It also would mean Team Jorge had evidence for future clients of its access to western media. | It also would mean Team Jorge had evidence for future clients of its access to western media. |
M'Barki's late night show also ran items on a Sudanese general who was considering running for the presidency, and a trade show in the disputed territory of Western Sahara. | M'Barki's late night show also ran items on a Sudanese general who was considering running for the presidency, and a trade show in the disputed territory of Western Sahara. |
In this second piece, the name of the territory was replaced by the politically-charged term Moroccan Sahara. | In this second piece, the name of the territory was replaced by the politically-charged term Moroccan Sahara. |
The area has been the subject of a long-running territorial dispute between Morocco and the indigenous Sahrawi people, led by the Polisario Front. | The area has been the subject of a long-running territorial dispute between Morocco and the indigenous Sahrawi people, led by the Polisario Front. |
The people or organisations that ultimately commissioned the suspected campaigns remain a mystery, according to Le Monde and Forbidden Stories. | The people or organisations that ultimately commissioned the suspected campaigns remain a mystery, according to Le Monde and Forbidden Stories. |
Some may have been commissioned by governments, but most - like the yacht story - were probably ordered by private interests, the investigation concluded. | Some may have been commissioned by governments, but most - like the yacht story - were probably ordered by private interests, the investigation concluded. |
A worrying sign, the investigators say, of the growing "Uberisation" of the fake news business. | A worrying sign, the investigators say, of the growing "Uberisation" of the fake news business. |
Related Topics | Related Topics |
Middle East | |
Disinformation | Disinformation |
Fake News | Fake News |