This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/64745176
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Keir Starmer's five missions speech fact-checked | Keir Starmer's five missions speech fact-checked |
(4 months later) | |
Labour leader Keir Starmer set out his five missions for government on Thursday. | Labour leader Keir Starmer set out his five missions for government on Thursday. |
We've been looking at some of the claims made in his speech. | We've been looking at some of the claims made in his speech. |
Keir Starmer unveils Labour's five missions for the country | Keir Starmer unveils Labour's five missions for the country |
'If growth over the last 13 years had been as strong as under the last Labour government, we would have £40bn extra to spend' | 'If growth over the last 13 years had been as strong as under the last Labour government, we would have £40bn extra to spend' |
Growth has certainly been slower in the last 13 years than it was in the previous 13 years, when the Labour Party was in power. | Growth has certainly been slower in the last 13 years than it was in the previous 13 years, when the Labour Party was in power. |
Between 1997 and 2010, the economy grew at an average of just under 2% a year. | Between 1997 and 2010, the economy grew at an average of just under 2% a year. |
Labour's argument is that, had growth kept going at that rate (instead of at just below 1.5% a year) the economy would be bigger and the government would take more in taxes. | Labour's argument is that, had growth kept going at that rate (instead of at just below 1.5% a year) the economy would be bigger and the government would take more in taxes. |
Using that method you can come out with that overall figure of about an extra £40bn in the tax take. | Using that method you can come out with that overall figure of about an extra £40bn in the tax take. |
So, it is correct to say that had the economy kept growing at the rate seen before 2010, the government could have tens of billions more to spend now. | So, it is correct to say that had the economy kept growing at the rate seen before 2010, the government could have tens of billions more to spend now. |
However, whether all of the differences in growth rates seen over the last 26 years are down to the decision of the governments of the time is a more contentious question. | However, whether all of the differences in growth rates seen over the last 26 years are down to the decision of the governments of the time is a more contentious question. |
The sluggish growth seen during the 2010s was not a problem unique to the UK, for example, and all economies faced challenges due to Covid. | The sluggish growth seen during the 2010s was not a problem unique to the UK, for example, and all economies faced challenges due to Covid. |
'The worst decade for growth in two centuries' | 'The worst decade for growth in two centuries' |
We have tried to check this claim before, from previous speeches by the Labour leader. | We have tried to check this claim before, from previous speeches by the Labour leader. |
UK economic growth was indeed very poor between 2010 and 2019, with total growth of just over 20%. | UK economic growth was indeed very poor between 2010 and 2019, with total growth of just over 20%. |
But that wasn't as bad as the decade around World War One, for example. Between 1917 and 1926 the economy contracted by almost 10%. | But that wasn't as bad as the decade around World War One, for example. Between 1917 and 1926 the economy contracted by almost 10%. |
We asked Labour how they reached their conclusion and they pointed us towards research from the TUC. | We asked Labour how they reached their conclusion and they pointed us towards research from the TUC. |
It wasn't looking at all decades, but at the 10 years after a recession. | It wasn't looking at all decades, but at the 10 years after a recession. |
It found that the period 2009-2019 had been similar to the decade after 1921, but worse than all other recovery periods since 1808. | It found that the period 2009-2019 had been similar to the decade after 1921, but worse than all other recovery periods since 1808. |
However, that's not the same as it being the worst decade of growth in two centuries. | However, that's not the same as it being the worst decade of growth in two centuries. |
'Zero-carbon British electricity by 2030... will put us ahead of any major economy in the world' | 'Zero-carbon British electricity by 2030... will put us ahead of any major economy in the world' |
Labour announced in September 2022 that it was committed to generating all of the UK's electricity without using fossil fuels by 2030. | Labour announced in September 2022 that it was committed to generating all of the UK's electricity without using fossil fuels by 2030. |
It means Labour is taking a more challenging target than the Conservatives. Boris Johnson announced when he was prime minister in October 2021 that UK electricity would come from clean sources by 2035. | It means Labour is taking a more challenging target than the Conservatives. Boris Johnson announced when he was prime minister in October 2021 that UK electricity would come from clean sources by 2035. |
Sir Keir is right that no other major economy is matching the 2030 target. The G7 group of big economies, for example, has pledged to "predominantly" decarbonise electricity by 2035. | Sir Keir is right that no other major economy is matching the 2030 target. The G7 group of big economies, for example, has pledged to "predominantly" decarbonise electricity by 2035. |
'These missions... will be measurable, so we can track progress and be held to account' | 'These missions... will be measurable, so we can track progress and be held to account' |
While the Labour leader repeatedly said that each of the five missions would have measurable targets, we have not yet been given any of those targets. | While the Labour leader repeatedly said that each of the five missions would have measurable targets, we have not yet been given any of those targets. |
Even the missions that sound like they are easily measurable are more complicated than they look. | Even the missions that sound like they are easily measurable are more complicated than they look. |
For example, the first mission is to have "the highest sustained growth in the G7". | For example, the first mission is to have "the highest sustained growth in the G7". |
We know how to measure which economy has the highest growth, but Labour has declined to tell us yet how they will assess which economy has the highest sustained growth. | We know how to measure which economy has the highest growth, but Labour has declined to tell us yet how they will assess which economy has the highest sustained growth. |
And measuring whether a Labour government manages to "break down the barriers to opportunity at every stage" will also be tricky. | And measuring whether a Labour government manages to "break down the barriers to opportunity at every stage" will also be tricky. |
But Labour has said it will announce the metrics in the future, so we will have to wait and see. | But Labour has said it will announce the metrics in the future, so we will have to wait and see. |
What claims do you want BBC Reality Check to investigate? Get in touch | What claims do you want BBC Reality Check to investigate? Get in touch |
Read more from Reality Check | Read more from Reality Check |
Related Topics | Related Topics |
Keir Starmer | Keir Starmer |
BBC Verify | |
Labour Party | Labour Party |
Previous version
1
Next version