This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/8219574.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Fraud Britons lodge Brazil appeal | Fraud Britons lodge Brazil appeal |
(about 3 hours later) | |
Two British law graduates who admitted falsely claiming to have been the victims of a theft in Brazil have formally lodged an appeal. | Two British law graduates who admitted falsely claiming to have been the victims of a theft in Brazil have formally lodged an appeal. |
Shanti Andrews, from Frant, in East Sussex, and Rebecca Turner, of Woolton Hill, in Berkshire, were sentenced to community service and fined last week. | Shanti Andrews, from Frant, in East Sussex, and Rebecca Turner, of Woolton Hill, in Berkshire, were sentenced to community service and fined last week. |
The former University of Sussex students told police they had £1,000 worth of goods stolen on a bus journey. | |
Their lawyer said it could take weeks before their appeal was heard. | Their lawyer said it could take weeks before their appeal was heard. |
Eduardo Tonini said the appeal had been lodged on the basis the women falsely reported a crime but did not go as far as attempting to commit insurance fraud and misrepresenting an offence. | Eduardo Tonini said the appeal had been lodged on the basis the women falsely reported a crime but did not go as far as attempting to commit insurance fraud and misrepresenting an offence. |
"When they were arrested, the charge of falsely communicating a crime was committed, but for them to have tried to commit insurance fraud would have required them to take a crime report to an insurance company, which did not happen," Mr Tonini said. | "When they were arrested, the charge of falsely communicating a crime was committed, but for them to have tried to commit insurance fraud would have required them to take a crime report to an insurance company, which did not happen," Mr Tonini said. |
As they are free they are not considered a priority Eduardo Tonini, lawyer | As they are free they are not considered a priority Eduardo Tonini, lawyer |
"We are just confused about why they were charged with the third offence of misrepresenting a crime. | "We are just confused about why they were charged with the third offence of misrepresenting a crime. |
"We say the charges went two steps too far and should have stopped at the point of falsely communicating a crime." | "We say the charges went two steps too far and should have stopped at the point of falsely communicating a crime." |
The women, both aged 23, who were arrested on 26 July, were sentenced to 14 months in prison but a judge converted the punishment to a community service penalty and a fine reported to total $6,400 (£3,900). | |
They are currently staying in an apartment in Rio de Janeiro. | They are currently staying in an apartment in Rio de Janeiro. |
Mr Tonini said the appeal process in Brazil took longer when the defendants were free. | Mr Tonini said the appeal process in Brazil took longer when the defendants were free. |
"If a defendant is in prison, an appeal can take place much sooner but as they are free they are not considered a priority," he said. | "If a defendant is in prison, an appeal can take place much sooner but as they are free they are not considered a priority," he said. |
'Calm and relieved' | 'Calm and relieved' |
If their appeal fails, the women could face having to carry out community service in a hospital or an institution for the poor, he added. | If their appeal fails, the women could face having to carry out community service in a hospital or an institution for the poor, he added. |
"Another judge will decide what type of community service would be appropriate," he said. | "Another judge will decide what type of community service would be appropriate," he said. |
He said the women were "calm but not 100% happy because of everything that has happened". | He said the women were "calm but not 100% happy because of everything that has happened". |
"They are relieved because they are not going to prison." | "They are relieved because they are not going to prison." |
Miss Andrews and Miss Turner had been due to return to England after a nine-month trip around the world, but were arrested after officers from a specialist tourist support unit apparently became suspicious that they had waited several days before reporting the theft. | Miss Andrews and Miss Turner had been due to return to England after a nine-month trip around the world, but were arrested after officers from a specialist tourist support unit apparently became suspicious that they had waited several days before reporting the theft. |
Police allegedly uncovered some of the items reported stolen in their Rio hostel room. | Police allegedly uncovered some of the items reported stolen in their Rio hostel room. |
Previous version
1
Next version