This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-64956260
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Barmouth murder accused told partner he didn't mean to kill | Barmouth murder accused told partner he didn't mean to kill |
(3 months later) | |
Margaret Barnes was heard to say "I'm sorry" on the CCTV recording | Margaret Barnes was heard to say "I'm sorry" on the CCTV recording |
The partner of a man accused of killing a woman who mistook his home for a hotel told him he could have escorted her outside, a court has heard. | The partner of a man accused of killing a woman who mistook his home for a hotel told him he could have escorted her outside, a court has heard. |
The prosecution said Margaret Barnes, 71, from Birmingham, was dragged out of the house in Barmouth, Gwynedd, before being kicked and stamped on. | The prosecution said Margaret Barnes, 71, from Birmingham, was dragged out of the house in Barmouth, Gwynedd, before being kicked and stamped on. |
David Redfern, 46, who denies murder or manslaughter, told his partner: "I didn't mean to kill her", jurors heard. | David Redfern, 46, who denies murder or manslaughter, told his partner: "I didn't mean to kill her", jurors heard. |
His partner said: "You could have just escorted her out. It's an old lady." | His partner said: "You could have just escorted her out. It's an old lady." |
Ms Barnes was also heard apologising to Mr Redfern on CCTV, which was shown to Caernarfon Crown Court on Tuesday. | Ms Barnes was also heard apologising to Mr Redfern on CCTV, which was shown to Caernarfon Crown Court on Tuesday. |
The trial heard Mr Redfern had been recorded by a camera near to the front door of his home in which he stated there was "nothing wrong with her". | The trial heard Mr Redfern had been recorded by a camera near to the front door of his home in which he stated there was "nothing wrong with her". |
"All I have done is eject her from my house," he declared. | "All I have done is eject her from my house," he declared. |
Mrs Barnes, a retired factory worker from Birmingham, had, after drinking, mistaken the seaside house for a B&B, the prosecution has claimed. | Mrs Barnes, a retired factory worker from Birmingham, had, after drinking, mistaken the seaside house for a B&B, the prosecution has claimed. |
Prosecuting KC, Michael Jones, said Mr Redfern, of Marine Parade, who had self-confessed anger issues, had forcibly removed Mrs Barnes from the bedroom and pulled her downstairs by the ankles last July. | Prosecuting KC, Michael Jones, said Mr Redfern, of Marine Parade, who had self-confessed anger issues, had forcibly removed Mrs Barnes from the bedroom and pulled her downstairs by the ankles last July. |
He said Mr Redfern and his partner, Nicola Learoyd-Lewis, would not have expected to find her sleeping in their bed. | He said Mr Redfern and his partner, Nicola Learoyd-Lewis, would not have expected to find her sleeping in their bed. |
Margaret Barnes died at the scene on Marine Parade last July | Margaret Barnes died at the scene on Marine Parade last July |
Mr Redfern had phoned the police but "what the defendant did next to Mrs Barnes was out of all proportion". | Mr Redfern had phoned the police but "what the defendant did next to Mrs Barnes was out of all proportion". |
It was "totally unjustified, utterly gratuitous and completely unlawful", said Mr Jones. | It was "totally unjustified, utterly gratuitous and completely unlawful", said Mr Jones. |
He said Mr Redfern kicked or stamped on the "defenceless" woman in a "cruel" attack which caused major liver damage. | He said Mr Redfern kicked or stamped on the "defenceless" woman in a "cruel" attack which caused major liver damage. |
She had also suffered a number of broken ribs. | She had also suffered a number of broken ribs. |
Mrs Barnes, who had been drinking during a social trip to the area, died at the scene, the jury heard. | Mrs Barnes, who had been drinking during a social trip to the area, died at the scene, the jury heard. |
'I'm sorry' | 'I'm sorry' |
On the CCTV recordings, Mr Redfern declared: "I'm sorry for kicking her in the ribs and dragging her down the stairs." | On the CCTV recordings, Mr Redfern declared: "I'm sorry for kicking her in the ribs and dragging her down the stairs." |
He said he was "angry" after finding Mrs Barnes in his bed and called her a "scumbag". | He said he was "angry" after finding Mrs Barnes in his bed and called her a "scumbag". |
As Mrs Barnes' condition worsened outside the property, the jury heard an ambulance operator instruct those at the scene to perform CPR. | As Mrs Barnes' condition worsened outside the property, the jury heard an ambulance operator instruct those at the scene to perform CPR. |
Miss Learoyd-Lewis had begged the woman: "Please don't die. Please don't die." | Miss Learoyd-Lewis had begged the woman: "Please don't die. Please don't die." |
But later she said: "It's too late." | But later she said: "It's too late." |
Mrs Barnes had also been heard to say "I'm sorry" on the CCTV footage. | Mrs Barnes had also been heard to say "I'm sorry" on the CCTV footage. |
The jury heard Mr Redfern claimed Mrs Barnes had been "angry and aggressive" towards his partner and he had behaved "passively". | The jury heard Mr Redfern claimed Mrs Barnes had been "angry and aggressive" towards his partner and he had behaved "passively". |
The prosecution said Mr Redfern would suggest there had been an "accidental trip over Mrs Barnes". | The prosecution said Mr Redfern would suggest there had been an "accidental trip over Mrs Barnes". |
The trial continues. | The trial continues. |
Related Topics | Related Topics |
Wales | |
Barmouth | Barmouth |
Birmingham | Birmingham |
Previous version
1
Next version