This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-65115212
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Migration dilemma leaves Rishi Sunak confronting an expensive mess | Migration dilemma leaves Rishi Sunak confronting an expensive mess |
(about 11 hours later) | |
The rows about small boat crossings over the Channel are the ultimate example of a political bind. | The rows about small boat crossings over the Channel are the ultimate example of a political bind. |
An international issue, demanding a national response, provoking local anger. | An international issue, demanding a national response, provoking local anger. |
The crossings have shot up. The prime minister has promised to stop them. | The crossings have shot up. The prime minister has promised to stop them. |
At least part of what we are seeing in the debates over sorting places for migrants to stay is the consequence of a failure to do that. | At least part of what we are seeing in the debates over sorting places for migrants to stay is the consequence of a failure to do that. |
Another element is the colossal backlog of asylum claims that need to be processed. But a significant part of all of this is a generational challenge lots of rich countries will face. | Another element is the colossal backlog of asylum claims that need to be processed. But a significant part of all of this is a generational challenge lots of rich countries will face. |
Courtesy of globalisation - smartphones, the internet, satellite television - it has never been easier for poor people in low-income countries, or those caught up in wars, natural disasters or, perhaps in future, the consequences of climate change, to be aware of a richer world they might prefer. | Courtesy of globalisation - smartphones, the internet, satellite television - it has never been easier for poor people in low-income countries, or those caught up in wars, natural disasters or, perhaps in future, the consequences of climate change, to be aware of a richer world they might prefer. |
What they might easily conclude is a rational decision to seek a better life. Which means rich countries, and their governments, have to conclude what a rational response to this is. | What they might easily conclude is a rational decision to seek a better life. Which means rich countries, and their governments, have to conclude what a rational response to this is. |
How can a country be sustainably compassionate, if indeed that is what it chooses to be? And what would that look like, when both of those words would be contested? | How can a country be sustainably compassionate, if indeed that is what it chooses to be? And what would that look like, when both of those words would be contested? |
Rich countries now have to confront what to do about all this, often still in possession of rules and conventions that pre-date the era of the jet aeroplane and mass international travel. | Rich countries now have to confront what to do about all this, often still in possession of rules and conventions that pre-date the era of the jet aeroplane and mass international travel. |
And they - we - confront these challenges burdened by the weight and contradictions of the dilemmas they generate. | And they - we - confront these challenges burdened by the weight and contradictions of the dilemmas they generate. |
What to do practically, politically, logistically, financially, morally? | What to do practically, politically, logistically, financially, morally? |
Right now, the government confronts an expensive mess. | Right now, the government confronts an expensive mess. |
Solutions sought | Solutions sought |
As my colleagues Daniel Sandford and Callum May reported earlier this month, more than 51,000 asylum seekers are currently being put up in nearly 400 hotels around the UK. | As my colleagues Daniel Sandford and Callum May reported earlier this month, more than 51,000 asylum seekers are currently being put up in nearly 400 hotels around the UK. |
It is costing the taxpayer £6m a day. The government is desperate to find a solution. | It is costing the taxpayer £6m a day. The government is desperate to find a solution. |
Something cheaper, something more obviously basic (in the hope that that itself acts as a deterrent) and big sites that can house a lot of people. | Something cheaper, something more obviously basic (in the hope that that itself acts as a deterrent) and big sites that can house a lot of people. |
Former military bases have long been top of the wanted list for ministers - land and buildings relatively easily acquired, that can be converted and up and running quickly. Or so they hope. | Former military bases have long been top of the wanted list for ministers - land and buildings relatively easily acquired, that can be converted and up and running quickly. Or so they hope. |
The political strategy here is this sort of thing is always going to annoy some people, but fewer bigger sites will annoy fewer people, while housing plenty of people. | The political strategy here is this sort of thing is always going to annoy some people, but fewer bigger sites will annoy fewer people, while housing plenty of people. |
The thing is, those they are annoying are getting angry and getting organised. | The thing is, those they are annoying are getting angry and getting organised. |
Conservative-controlled Braintree District Council has asked the High Court to block plans for a migrants site on an old RAF base in Essex. | Conservative-controlled Braintree District Council has asked the High Court to block plans for a migrants site on an old RAF base in Essex. |
And a legal battle looms between the Conservative-led West Lindsey District Council and the government over a similar plan in Lincolnshire. | |
Boats floated | Boats floated |
Some senior voices in government were talking up the prospect of ferries and barges also being used to house migrants - leading to some excitable newspaper front pages. | Some senior voices in government were talking up the prospect of ferries and barges also being used to house migrants - leading to some excitable newspaper front pages. |
Strikingly, while floating accommodation was mentioned by the Immigration Minister Robert Jenrick, there isn't yet any detail about the plans. | Strikingly, while floating accommodation was mentioned by the Immigration Minister Robert Jenrick, there isn't yet any detail about the plans. |
Robert Jenrick's plans to use military bases "being disposed of" face criticism from both sides of the Commons. | Robert Jenrick's plans to use military bases "being disposed of" face criticism from both sides of the Commons. |
Robert Jenrick's plans to use military bases "being disposed of" face criticism from both sides of the Commons. | Robert Jenrick's plans to use military bases "being disposed of" face criticism from both sides of the Commons. |
One figure who worked in government under Labour recalled to me a similar desire to use ships, then to accommodate prisoners. | One figure who worked in government under Labour recalled to me a similar desire to use ships, then to accommodate prisoners. |
Suffice to say they were more than a little sceptical that the idea will ever see the light of day. | Suffice to say they were more than a little sceptical that the idea will ever see the light of day. |
They recalled one minister back then being packed off to Rotterdam to look at an ailing old boat the Dutch government wanted rid of. | They recalled one minister back then being packed off to Rotterdam to look at an ailing old boat the Dutch government wanted rid of. |
But it was concluded it was so decrepit it probably wouldn't make it over the North Sea and the whole plan was quietly dropped. | But it was concluded it was so decrepit it probably wouldn't make it over the North Sea and the whole plan was quietly dropped. |
The challenge is finding the boats, finding the places to put them and building the associated infrastructure, such as offices nearby on land, to make the whole thing work. | The challenge is finding the boats, finding the places to put them and building the associated infrastructure, such as offices nearby on land, to make the whole thing work. |
Ministers now do still seem to be pursuing the idea - as BBC South's political editor Peter Henley reports Portland Port in Dorset has been approached by the Home Office to provide space for what is called an "accommodation facility". | Ministers now do still seem to be pursuing the idea - as BBC South's political editor Peter Henley reports Portland Port in Dorset has been approached by the Home Office to provide space for what is called an "accommodation facility". |
But there are no further details. | But there are no further details. |
Critics of the government say a legacy of mismanaging the asylum system means all these problems now stack up. And it is unquestionable the problems are massive. | Critics of the government say a legacy of mismanaging the asylum system means all these problems now stack up. And it is unquestionable the problems are massive. |
But it is also unquestionable that the next government, of whatever political colour, will inherit much of the same set of problems. | But it is also unquestionable that the next government, of whatever political colour, will inherit much of the same set of problems. |
And they are the same set of problems so many other similar rich countries confront - and will continue to confront for decades to come. | And they are the same set of problems so many other similar rich countries confront - and will continue to confront for decades to come. |
Related Topics | Related Topics |
Rishi Sunak | Rishi Sunak |
Migration | Migration |
Previous version
1
Next version