This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/apr/07/at-least-three-senior-liberals-pushed-back-against-indigenous-voice-opposition-in-shadow-cabinet-meeting
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| At least three senior Liberals pushed back against Indigenous voice opposition in shadow cabinet meeting | At least three senior Liberals pushed back against Indigenous voice opposition in shadow cabinet meeting |
| (10 days later) | |
| Exclusive: Simon Birmingham, Marise Payne and Paul Fletcher spoke out against plan as Julian Leeser proposed allowing MPs a free say | Exclusive: Simon Birmingham, Marise Payne and Paul Fletcher spoke out against plan as Julian Leeser proposed allowing MPs a free say |
| At least three leading Liberal moderates – Simon Birmingham, Paul Fletcher and Marise Payne – spoke out in a shadow cabinet meeting against the party’s plan to oppose the Indigenous voice to parliament. | At least three leading Liberal moderates – Simon Birmingham, Paul Fletcher and Marise Payne – spoke out in a shadow cabinet meeting against the party’s plan to oppose the Indigenous voice to parliament. |
| Guardian Australia understands the meeting considered an alternative stance put forward by the shadow attorney general, Julian Leeser, to allow all members a free say on the voice at least until a parliamentary committee could consider calls to amend the constitutional alteration bill. | Guardian Australia understands the meeting considered an alternative stance put forward by the shadow attorney general, Julian Leeser, to allow all members a free say on the voice at least until a parliamentary committee could consider calls to amend the constitutional alteration bill. |
| Birmingham, the shadow foreign affairs minister, Fletcher, the manager of opposition business and Payne, the cabinet secretary, favoured the alternative option but are now bound to the collective cabinet position. Only backbenchers will be free to campaign in favour of the voice. | Birmingham, the shadow foreign affairs minister, Fletcher, the manager of opposition business and Payne, the cabinet secretary, favoured the alternative option but are now bound to the collective cabinet position. Only backbenchers will be free to campaign in favour of the voice. |
| The opposition leader, Peter Dutton, favoured opposition to constitutional entrenchment and this was carried in a meeting attended only by Liberals and not Nationals, who in November resolved to oppose the voice. | The opposition leader, Peter Dutton, favoured opposition to constitutional entrenchment and this was carried in a meeting attended only by Liberals and not Nationals, who in November resolved to oppose the voice. |
| The issue was then discussed in a Liberal party room meeting, at which Bridget Archer, Andrew Bragg, Russell Broadbent and reportedly Richard Colbeck spoke against opposing the voice. | The issue was then discussed in a Liberal party room meeting, at which Bridget Archer, Andrew Bragg, Russell Broadbent and reportedly Richard Colbeck spoke against opposing the voice. |
| Fletcher on Thursday said the party had “taken a decision, a shadow cabinet decision, and that’s the position that we’ve arrived at”. | Fletcher on Thursday said the party had “taken a decision, a shadow cabinet decision, and that’s the position that we’ve arrived at”. |
| “Of course, members of the Liberal party, other than those who have particular frontbench responsibilities, are always free to exercise a conscience vote,” he told the ABC’s Radio National. | “Of course, members of the Liberal party, other than those who have particular frontbench responsibilities, are always free to exercise a conscience vote,” he told the ABC’s Radio National. |
| “Can I make the point, though, that we’ve said we will support the bill to authorise the referendum to proceed.” | “Can I make the point, though, that we’ve said we will support the bill to authorise the referendum to proceed.” |
| On ABC TV, Fletcher said he “will be making the case for Liberal party policy on this issue” but side-stepped a question about his personal vote. | On ABC TV, Fletcher said he “will be making the case for Liberal party policy on this issue” but side-stepped a question about his personal vote. |
| Sign up for Guardian Australia’s free morning and afternoon email newsletters for your daily news roundup | Sign up for Guardian Australia’s free morning and afternoon email newsletters for your daily news roundup |
| Sign up for Guardian Australia’s free morning and afternoon email newsletters for your daily news roundup | Sign up for Guardian Australia’s free morning and afternoon email newsletters for your daily news roundup |
| Asked if he would be prepared to show-and-tell his own vote in the referendum, Fletcher replied: “That’ll be a matter for individuals. | Asked if he would be prepared to show-and-tell his own vote in the referendum, Fletcher replied: “That’ll be a matter for individuals. |
| “I’m a member of shadow cabinet. I support the Liberal party’s position that was arrived at yesterday.” | “I’m a member of shadow cabinet. I support the Liberal party’s position that was arrived at yesterday.” |
| Birmingham on Thursday told ABC Radio Adelaide that he will vote for the constitutional alteration bill. “That enables Australians to have their say at a referendum and I’ll let them then get on and have their say.” | Birmingham on Thursday told ABC Radio Adelaide that he will vote for the constitutional alteration bill. “That enables Australians to have their say at a referendum and I’ll let them then get on and have their say.” |
| Asked if he relished the prospect of campaigning against the voice, Birmingham replied: “The approach I’ll take will be one of respecting the Australian people as they go about making their decision. | Asked if he relished the prospect of campaigning against the voice, Birmingham replied: “The approach I’ll take will be one of respecting the Australian people as they go about making their decision. |
| “I’m going to keep fighting the good fight as I try to in shadow cabinet and through the parliament for Liberal values as I see them and how I think we should take them forward in effective, positive policies at the next election.” | “I’m going to keep fighting the good fight as I try to in shadow cabinet and through the parliament for Liberal values as I see them and how I think we should take them forward in effective, positive policies at the next election.” |
| Sign up to Afternoon Update | Sign up to Afternoon Update |
| Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters | |
| after newsletter promotion | after newsletter promotion |
| Before the Wednesday party room meeting, Birmingham penned an opinion piece for the Sydney Morning Herald and the Age arguing that the Liberals must become “the party of inclusion”. | Before the Wednesday party room meeting, Birmingham penned an opinion piece for the Sydney Morning Herald and the Age arguing that the Liberals must become “the party of inclusion”. |
| “Perceptions of intolerance created by some hasn’t just cost the votes of those who feel judged, it has hurt the Liberal party with all who reject nastiness or divisiveness,” he wrote. | “Perceptions of intolerance created by some hasn’t just cost the votes of those who feel judged, it has hurt the Liberal party with all who reject nastiness or divisiveness,” he wrote. |
| The Liberal party’s stance on the voice has been condemned by Indigenous leaders such as Noel Pearson, who called it a “Judas betrayal”, and Ken Wyatt, the former minister for Indigenous Australians, who quit the Liberal party in protest. | The Liberal party’s stance on the voice has been condemned by Indigenous leaders such as Noel Pearson, who called it a “Judas betrayal”, and Ken Wyatt, the former minister for Indigenous Australians, who quit the Liberal party in protest. |
| Dutton announced the party’s position on Wednesday alongside deputy leader Sussan Ley, and explained Leeser’s absence by saying he “had to head back to Sydney for Passover”. | Dutton announced the party’s position on Wednesday alongside deputy leader Sussan Ley, and explained Leeser’s absence by saying he “had to head back to Sydney for Passover”. |
| Dutton said the Liberal position was a “yes to constitutional recognition” (of a purely symbolic variety, rejected by the Uluru statement from the heart) and a “yes to local and regional voices” in legislation, but a “no to the prime minister’s Canberra voice”. | Dutton said the Liberal position was a “yes to constitutional recognition” (of a purely symbolic variety, rejected by the Uluru statement from the heart) and a “yes to local and regional voices” in legislation, but a “no to the prime minister’s Canberra voice”. |
| In a social media post on Thursday, Dutton said “we support a better way of improving the lives of Indigenous Australians through local and regional advisory bodies”. | In a social media post on Thursday, Dutton said “we support a better way of improving the lives of Indigenous Australians through local and regional advisory bodies”. |
| “We don’t support Mr Albanese’s Canberra Voice bureaucracy that will divide Australians.” | “We don’t support Mr Albanese’s Canberra Voice bureaucracy that will divide Australians.” |
| Guardian Australia contacted Birmingham, Fletcher and Payne for comment. | Guardian Australia contacted Birmingham, Fletcher and Payne for comment. |