This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/31/tory-mayor-ben-houchen-calls-labour-mp-andy-mcdonald-a-liar-over-claims-about-teesworks-project
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Tory mayor calls MP a ‘liar and a coward’ over claims about Teesworks project | Tory mayor calls MP a ‘liar and a coward’ over claims about Teesworks project |
| (3 months later) | |
| Ben Houchen dismisses accusations of corruption and and wrongdoing made by Labour MP for Middlesbrough Andy McDonald | Ben Houchen dismisses accusations of corruption and and wrongdoing made by Labour MP for Middlesbrough Andy McDonald |
| A Conservative metro mayor has called a Labour MP a “liar and a coward” as the feuding over a huge regeneration project became increasingly acrimonious. | A Conservative metro mayor has called a Labour MP a “liar and a coward” as the feuding over a huge regeneration project became increasingly acrimonious. |
| Ben Houchen, the mayor of Tees Valley, made the claims against the MP for Middlesbrough, Andy McDonald, during a combative radio interview on Wednesday. | Ben Houchen, the mayor of Tees Valley, made the claims against the MP for Middlesbrough, Andy McDonald, during a combative radio interview on Wednesday. |
| McDonald had previously used parliamentary privilege to allege “industrial-scale corruption” around the Teesworks redevelopment of the former Redcar steelworks, a project taking place in the UK’s largest industrial zone. | McDonald had previously used parliamentary privilege to allege “industrial-scale corruption” around the Teesworks redevelopment of the former Redcar steelworks, a project taking place in the UK’s largest industrial zone. |
| Michael Gove, the levelling up secretary, last week ordered an “independent review” into allegations of “corruption, wrongdoing and illegality” around the redevelopment. Its backers say it will create 20,000 jobs on an area that is Europe’s largest brownfield site. | Michael Gove, the levelling up secretary, last week ordered an “independent review” into allegations of “corruption, wrongdoing and illegality” around the redevelopment. Its backers say it will create 20,000 jobs on an area that is Europe’s largest brownfield site. |
| Accusations of croneyism and corruption have been made after reports in Private Eye and the Financial Times about contracts and land agreements. | Accusations of croneyism and corruption have been made after reports in Private Eye and the Financial Times about contracts and land agreements. |
| Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s World at One, Houchen accused McDonald of “lying” and “abusing his parliamentary privilege” to make allegations of corruption. | Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s World at One, Houchen accused McDonald of “lying” and “abusing his parliamentary privilege” to make allegations of corruption. |
| “Andy McDonald is a liar and he’s a coward. He would never repeat those accusations outside of parliament because he is a liar,” he said. | “Andy McDonald is a liar and he’s a coward. He would never repeat those accusations outside of parliament because he is a liar,” he said. |
| “The reason for the investigation is because Andy McDonald lied and said that there was corruption. He has no evidence, he’s produced no evidence – he didn’t even give any examples or evidence within parliament.” | “The reason for the investigation is because Andy McDonald lied and said that there was corruption. He has no evidence, he’s produced no evidence – he didn’t even give any examples or evidence within parliament.” |
| Houchen said he was “1,000%” confident the independent review would show that the Tessworks project was a good one for the people of Teesside and the country as a whole. | Houchen said he was “1,000%” confident the independent review would show that the Tessworks project was a good one for the people of Teesside and the country as a whole. |
| “I’ll be calling for the Labour party to reimburse the taxpayer for the waste of time that this review ultimately is, because it’s going to show there is no corruption, no illegality and criminality,” he said. | “I’ll be calling for the Labour party to reimburse the taxpayer for the waste of time that this review ultimately is, because it’s going to show there is no corruption, no illegality and criminality,” he said. |
| The presenter, Sarah Montague, made an appeal for McDonald to come on the programme to respond to Houchen’s remarks. | The presenter, Sarah Montague, made an appeal for McDonald to come on the programme to respond to Houchen’s remarks. |
| Twenty minutes later McDonald did just that, although he declined to repeat the “industrial-scale corruption” claim that he made in parliament. | Twenty minutes later McDonald did just that, although he declined to repeat the “industrial-scale corruption” claim that he made in parliament. |
| “This doesn’t pass the smell test, any of it,” he said. “There are so many elements to this that warrant very close scrutiny and investigation.” | “This doesn’t pass the smell test, any of it,” he said. “There are so many elements to this that warrant very close scrutiny and investigation.” |
| Sign up to First Edition | Sign up to First Edition |
| Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters | |
| after newsletter promotion | after newsletter promotion |
| Asked if he would repeat the comments outside parliament, the MP said: “Well, I’m quite happy to sit down with Ben and go through my concerns with him.” | Asked if he would repeat the comments outside parliament, the MP said: “Well, I’m quite happy to sit down with Ben and go through my concerns with him.” |
| Told that it was interesting he would not repeat the accusation, McDonald said Gove had set up an independent investigation that will “opine on these various elements”. If it finds the procurement process has not been a proper one, McDonald said, then people will say “this is not right, this is not the way business should be done and it has been a failure of governance and process”. | Told that it was interesting he would not repeat the accusation, McDonald said Gove had set up an independent investigation that will “opine on these various elements”. If it finds the procurement process has not been a proper one, McDonald said, then people will say “this is not right, this is not the way business should be done and it has been a failure of governance and process”. |
| Asked if the language he used was wrong, McDonald said: “I think it has gained attention for these very serious issues that have been raised by Private Eye and by the Financial Times, and I think hitherto the government has been quite happy to go along with the hard hats and promises approach of Ben Houchen and just say: ‘Nothing to see here.’ | Asked if the language he used was wrong, McDonald said: “I think it has gained attention for these very serious issues that have been raised by Private Eye and by the Financial Times, and I think hitherto the government has been quite happy to go along with the hard hats and promises approach of Ben Houchen and just say: ‘Nothing to see here.’ |
| “There’s a great deal to see here.” | “There’s a great deal to see here.” |
| Labour had wanted the National Audit Office (NAO) to investigate Teesworks. Gove, however, said it was not the NAO’s normal role and will instead appoint a panel himself. | Labour had wanted the National Audit Office (NAO) to investigate Teesworks. Gove, however, said it was not the NAO’s normal role and will instead appoint a panel himself. |
Previous version
1
Next version