This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/jun/13/no-deal-brexit-planning-crowded-out-efforts-to-prepare-for-pandemic-covid-inquiry

The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 1 Version 2
No-deal Brexit planning ‘crowded out’ efforts to prepare for pandemic No-deal Brexit planning ‘crowded out’ efforts to prepare for pandemic
(about 4 hours later)
Covid inquiry hears that from 2018 planning for UK’s disorderly exit from EU ‘drained resources and capacity’Covid inquiry hears that from 2018 planning for UK’s disorderly exit from EU ‘drained resources and capacity’
Planning for a no-deal Brexit from 2018 “crowded out” government efforts to prepare for a pandemic and contributed to leaving the country unready, the first evidence session of the Covid public inquiry has heard.Planning for a no-deal Brexit from 2018 “crowded out” government efforts to prepare for a pandemic and contributed to leaving the country unready, the first evidence session of the Covid public inquiry has heard.
UK government pandemic planning failed to show “proper foresight” and “even at this stage, before hearing the evidence, it is apparent that we might not have been very well prepared at all”, Hugo Keith KC, counsel to the inquiry, said.UK government pandemic planning failed to show “proper foresight” and “even at this stage, before hearing the evidence, it is apparent that we might not have been very well prepared at all”, Hugo Keith KC, counsel to the inquiry, said.
As lawyers for the bereaved accused UK leaders of presiding over a “carousel of chaos” it emerged the former health secretary Matt Hancock had admitted to the inquiry a “lack of concrete preparedness plans”.
“On coming into post as health secretary, I was advised that the UK was a world leader in preparations for the pandemic,” Hancock has said in his statement. “It did not turn out to be the case.” He is due to give evidence later this month.
Brexit no-deal planning from 2018 onwards “prevented some, or perhaps a majority of the improvements that central government itself understood were required to be made to resilience planning and preparedness”, Keith said. No-deal Brexit planning “drained resources and capacity”.Brexit no-deal planning from 2018 onwards “prevented some, or perhaps a majority of the improvements that central government itself understood were required to be made to resilience planning and preparedness”, Keith said. No-deal Brexit planning “drained resources and capacity”.
Operation Yellowhammer, as the Brexit planning was known, caused the work of a new pandemic flu preparedness board to stall “because of the preoccupation with readiness for Brexit”, lawyers for the bereaved added. Operation Yellowhammer, as the Brexit planning was known, caused the work of a new pandemic flu preparedness board to stall “because of the preoccupation with readiness for Brexit”, the inquiry heard.
“Few real changes were made … leaving government to largely make up the plan as it went along, once Covid arrived finally,” said Pete Weatherby KC, representing the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice group.“Few real changes were made … leaving government to largely make up the plan as it went along, once Covid arrived finally,” said Pete Weatherby KC, representing the Covid-19 Bereaved Families for Justice group.
As scores of bereaved families descended on the west London inquiry into a pandemic that claimed at least 226,977 lives, Keith told the inquiry chair, Heather Hallett, that “extraordinarily” there appeared to have been very little debate inside government before the pandemic “of whether a lockdown might prove to be necessary in the event of a runaway virus, let alone how lockdown could be avoided”. As scores of bereaved families descended on the west London inquiry into a pandemic that claimed at least 226,977 lives, Keith told the inquiry chair, Heather Hallett, that evidence unearthed so far may show that not enough people in the UK government had considered the dangers of a coronavirus.
Evidence unearthed so far may show that not enough people in the UK government considered the dangers of a coronavirus, Keith said. Oliver Letwin, a minister in the Cabinet Office from 2010 to 2016, has told the inquiry the UK was “much better prepared” for an influenza pandemic than Covid. Dr Frank Atherton, the Wales chief medical officer since 2016, said: “The plans were inadequate for a two or three-year shock to the system.”
Proceedings began with an emotional 18-minute video in which bereaved people described their loved ones’ deaths and their devastating aftermath. Lady Hallett warned those present about its emotional weight and gave them a chance to step out. People spoke of losing loved ones in locked-down care homes, dying with Covid contracted in hospital and catching the virus while at work. This was despite the conclusion of the flu pandemic planning exercise Cygnus in 2016 that “the UK’s current preparedness … is not sufficient to cope with the extreme demands of a severe pandemic”.
One woman, who described her anger at not being able to dress her deceased father because he was in a body bag, said: “In order for us to move on, we need to know lessons [have been] learned, and the future generations will be safeguarded from the heartache we’ve had so far.” Weatherby said there was a lack of transparency over pandemic planning and said Hancock was advised that publishing information about Exercise Cygnus, a 2016 flu pandemic planning scheme, “would lead to criticism of lack of preparedness”.
Keith told the inquiry: “There appears to be the failure to think through the potentially massive impact on education and the economy or [how to] try to control a runaway virus.” Bruce Mann, a former director of the Cabinet Office’s civil contingencies secretariat and an expert witness to the inquiry, will say in his evidence in the coming days that “UK preparedness was wholly inadequate”, the inquiry heard.
Keith also indicated the inquiry would make a judgment on pre-pandemic austerity, as the Trades Union Congress has urged. “If you conclude that as a country, we were insufficiently resilient and that in future, different political and financial choices may have to be made in order to render us better able to [deal with the] shock, you will want to say so,” he told Hallett. Weatherby said he expected evidence “to show little or no ministerial leadership, a chaos of committees, which led to poor planning, and ultimately a reactive rather than proactive response to the virus”.
There had been planning for flu pandemics, but “fundamentally, in relation to significant aspects of the Covid-19 pandemic, we were taken by surprise,” he said. “If the last three-and-a-half years have taught us anything, proper planning, adequate resourcing and swift action saves lives,” he said. “From the families’ perspective, it appears that the UK had none of those three things. They want to know why. And they want it to change.”
He listed the need for decisions on shielding, employment support, managing disruption to schools, borders, and pharmaceutical interventions and the profoundly unequal impact of the pandemic on vulnerable and marginalised people. Proceedings began with an emotional 18-minute video in which bereaved people described their loved ones’ deaths and their devastating aftermath. Hallett warned those present about its emotional weight and gave them a chance to step out. People spoke of losing loved ones in locked-down care homes, dying with Covid contracted in hospital and catching the virus while at work.
“Few of those areas were anticipated, let alone considered in detail,” he said.
Sign up to First EditionSign up to First Edition
Archie Bland and Nimo Omer take you through the top stories and what they mean, free every weekday morningArchie Bland and Nimo Omer take you through the top stories and what they mean, free every weekday morning
after newsletter promotionafter newsletter promotion
Bruce Mann, a former director of the Cabinet Office’s civil contingencies secretariat and an expert witness to the inquiry, will say in his evidence in the coming days that “UK preparedness was wholly inadequate”, the inquiry heard. One woman, who described her anger at not being able to dress her deceased father because he was in a body bag, said: “In order for us to move on, we need to know lessons [have been] learned, and the future generations will be safeguarded from the heartache we’ve had so far.”
Weatherby said he expected the evidence “to show little or no ministerial leadership, a chaos of committees, which led to poor planning, and ultimately a reactive rather than proactive response to the virus”. There had been planning for flu pandemics, but “fundamentally, in relation to significant aspects of the Covid-19 pandemic, we were taken by surprise”, Keith said.
He said there was a lack of transparency over pandemic planning and said the former health secretary Matt Hancock was advised that publishing information about Exercise Cygnus, a 2016 flu pandemic planning scheme, “would lead to criticism of lack of preparedness”. He listed the need for decisions on shielding, employment support, managing disruption to schools, borders, and pharmaceutical interventions and the profoundly unequal impact of the pandemic on vulnerable and marginalised people.
“If the last three-and-a-half years have taught us anything, proper planning, adequate resourcing and swift action saves lives,” he said. “From the families’ perspective, it appears that the UK had none of those three things. They want to know why. And they want it to change.” “Few of those areas were anticipated, let alone considered in detail,” he said.
Keith warned about the urgency of ensuring “that our systems of preparedness are ready”, highlighting the current prevalence of bird flu with “extremely high case fatality rates”. Doctors, represented through the British Medical Association, said the government’s 2012 health service reforms under the former health secretary Andrew Lansley “fractured the links between public health specialists and NHS” and the UK went into the pandemic with too few hospital beds. These failures were “brutally exposed by the pandemic and the systems are now in an even worse state.”
“Fortuitously, they haven’t yet sustained human-to-human transmission,” he said. “Let us say they never do, but the possibility cannot be ruled out.” Keith indicated the inquiry would make a judgment on the effects of pre-pandemic austerity, as the Trades Union Congress has urged. “If you conclude that as a country, we were insufficiently resilient and that in future, different political and financial choices may have to be made in order to render us better able to [deal with the] shock, you will want to say so,” he told Hallett.
The inquiry continues. Meanwhile, lawyers for council directors of public health, who have expertise in handling infectious disease outbreaks, said they were “repeatedly excluded” by central government. The Department of Health and Social Care didn’t have an up-to-date contact list for them and at the start of the pandemic they found out about new policies only through televised Downing Street 5pm briefings, the inquiry heard.
Lawyers for the Department of Health and Social Care will put their case on Wednesday when the inquiry continues.