This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-65962091
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Covid Inquiry: Former chief medical officer close to tears over pandemic deaths | |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| Prof Dame Sally Davies tells the Covid inquiry that "it wasn't just the deaths, it was the way they died". | |
| Prof Dame Sally Davies tells the Covid inquiry that "it wasn't just the deaths, it was the way they died". | |
| England's former chief medical officer Dame Sally Davies was close to tears as she apologised to bereaved families by the pandemic at the Covid Inquiry. | |
| "It wasn't just the deaths, it was the way they died... it was harrowing and it remains horrible," she said. | |
| She also said the UK did not have enough resilience to cope with the pandemic, with fewer doctors, nurses or hospital beds than similar countries. | |
| The inquiry is currently examining the UK's preparedness ahead of Covid. | |
| At the same hearing, George Osborne said his spending cuts meant the UK was better able to cope with the pandemic. | |
| The former chancellor argued that without austerity Britain would have been "more exposed" and rejected claims his approach left the health and social care "depleted" ahead of the Covid pandemic. | |
| Ex-PM Cameron admits mistake over pandemic planning | Ex-PM Cameron admits mistake over pandemic planning |
| What is the UK Covid inquiry and how long will it take? | What is the UK Covid inquiry and how long will it take? |
| Covid inquiry criticises government evidence | Covid inquiry criticises government evidence |
| The NHS crisis - decades in the making | The NHS crisis - decades in the making |
| Last week Sir Michael Marmot, a professor of epidemiology at University College London told the inquiry that the UK had entered the pandemic with "depleted" public services. | Last week Sir Michael Marmot, a professor of epidemiology at University College London told the inquiry that the UK had entered the pandemic with "depleted" public services. |
| Asked by inquiry lawyer Kate Blackwell KC if he agreed with the statement, Mr Osborne said: "Most certainly not, I completely reject that." | Asked by inquiry lawyer Kate Blackwell KC if he agreed with the statement, Mr Osborne said: "Most certainly not, I completely reject that." |
| He accepted more money could have been spent on the NHS, but said as chancellor he had to balance demands for resources from other public services. | He accepted more money could have been spent on the NHS, but said as chancellor he had to balance demands for resources from other public services. |
| "You can't just say we like public spending to be higher without explaining where you get money from," he told the inquiry. | "You can't just say we like public spending to be higher without explaining where you get money from," he told the inquiry. |
| He said the public had elected the Conservatives to government in 2010 and 2015 knowing the party was planning to cut public spending. | He said the public had elected the Conservatives to government in 2010 and 2015 knowing the party was planning to cut public spending. |
| During the period, cuts were introduced in welfare spending, school building programs, local government, police, courts and prisons. There was also an overall squeeze on health spending. | During the period, cuts were introduced in welfare spending, school building programs, local government, police, courts and prisons. There was also an overall squeeze on health spending. |
| 'No planning' | 'No planning' |
| Mr Osborne - who was chancellor from 2010 to 2016 - said: "If we had not done that Britain would have been more exposed, not just to future things like the coronavirus pandemic, but indeed to the fiscal crisis which very rapidly followed in countries across Europe. | Mr Osborne - who was chancellor from 2010 to 2016 - said: "If we had not done that Britain would have been more exposed, not just to future things like the coronavirus pandemic, but indeed to the fiscal crisis which very rapidly followed in countries across Europe. |
| "If we had not had a clear plan to put the public finances on a sustainable path then Britain might have experienced a fiscal crisis, we would not have had the fiscal space to deal with the coronavirus pandemic when it hit." | "If we had not had a clear plan to put the public finances on a sustainable path then Britain might have experienced a fiscal crisis, we would not have had the fiscal space to deal with the coronavirus pandemic when it hit." |
| Other organisations have questioned this claim. Writing in a blog, Phil Banfield of the British Medical Association said a "failure to ensure the NHS was properly staffed and resourced in the decade leading up to the pandemic, meant that when it did arrive, there was no capacity to meet the tsunami of demand." | Other organisations have questioned this claim. Writing in a blog, Phil Banfield of the British Medical Association said a "failure to ensure the NHS was properly staffed and resourced in the decade leading up to the pandemic, meant that when it did arrive, there was no capacity to meet the tsunami of demand." |
| On Monday, the Trades Union Congress (TUC) produced a report which said austerity had led to unsafe staffing in public services leaving the UK "hugely unprepared" for Covid. | |
| During the one hour 20 minute question session, Mr Osborne was also asked about the Treasury's planning for potential national lockdown. | During the one hour 20 minute question session, Mr Osborne was also asked about the Treasury's planning for potential national lockdown. |
| He said the department had plans for an outbreak of influenza but added "given what subsequently happened that was very small scale". | He said the department had plans for an outbreak of influenza but added "given what subsequently happened that was very small scale". |
| "There was no planning done by Treasury - or any western Treasury - for asking the entire population to stay at home for months and months on end. | "There was no planning done by Treasury - or any western Treasury - for asking the entire population to stay at home for months and months on end. |
| "If someone had said to you the UK government should be preparing for a lockdown that might last for months, then I have no doubt the Treasury would have developed schemes it did subsequently develop around the furlough and the Covid loans. | "If someone had said to you the UK government should be preparing for a lockdown that might last for months, then I have no doubt the Treasury would have developed schemes it did subsequently develop around the furlough and the Covid loans. |
| "Planning could have been done for a furlough scheme in advance - I'm not clear that would have made a better furlough scheme than the one we as a country actually saw." | "Planning could have been done for a furlough scheme in advance - I'm not clear that would have made a better furlough scheme than the one we as a country actually saw." |
| 'Damaged a generation' | |
| Following Mr Osborne's evidence, England's former chief medical officer Prof Dame Sally Davies told the inquiry the government didn't have plans for Covid but added "it didn't have resilience either". | |
| She said that compared to other similar countries the UK was at the bottom of the table for numbers of doctors, nurses, beds, IT units and ventilators per 100,000. | |
| During her evidence she became emotional when apologising to the relatives of pandemic victims. | |
| "It wasn't just the deaths, it was the way they died. It was horrible and I heard a lot about it from my daughter on the frontline as a young doctor in Scotland. It was harrowing, and it remains horrible," she said. | "It wasn't just the deaths, it was the way they died. It was horrible and I heard a lot about it from my daughter on the frontline as a young doctor in Scotland. It was harrowing, and it remains horrible," she said. |
| She also expressed concern about the impact of the pandemic on children and students. | |
| "We have damaged a generation, and it is awful... watching these people struggle," she said. | |
| Earlier in the day, Sir Oliver Letwin, a senior minister in David Cameron's government, told the inquiry a rapid turnover of civil service staff hindered the government's ability to plan for pandemics. | |
| He also warned that the UK was "wildly under-resilient" and said there should be a minister "solely devoted" to the subject. | |
| Labour said the admissions were "too little, too late", adding the Conservatives "cannot be trusted to protect the public from the emergencies of tomorrow". | Labour said the admissions were "too little, too late", adding the Conservatives "cannot be trusted to protect the public from the emergencies of tomorrow". |
| Related Topics | Related Topics |
| Coronavirus public inquiry | Coronavirus public inquiry |
| Oliver Letwin | Oliver Letwin |
| Coronavirus lockdown measures | Coronavirus lockdown measures |
| George Osborne | George Osborne |