This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/8258043.stm
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 2 | Version 3 |
---|---|
Tory plans to cut 'surveillance' | Tory plans to cut 'surveillance' |
(about 7 hours later) | |
The Conservatives have set out plans to reverse what they describe as "the rise of the surveillance state". | The Conservatives have set out plans to reverse what they describe as "the rise of the surveillance state". |
They have pledged to scrap two new databases - the ID card register and ContactPoint - and strengthen the powers of the Information Commissioner. | They have pledged to scrap two new databases - the ID card register and ContactPoint - and strengthen the powers of the Information Commissioner. |
The Conservatives say they want to restore public trust in the use of personal data by the state. | The Conservatives say they want to restore public trust in the use of personal data by the state. |
Their proposals come after a series of security breaches and concern about the amount of information that is held. | Their proposals come after a series of security breaches and concern about the amount of information that is held. |
The National Identity register - which underpins the ID card scheme - would be scrapped, as would the ContactPoint database, which holds details of 11 million children and young people. | |
Other proposals include ensuring that government departments are routinely audited by the information commissioner, who would be required to report to Parliament. | |
'Worst of all worlds' | 'Worst of all worlds' |
Shadow justice secretary Dominic Grieve, speaking at the launch of the party's Reverse of the Surveillance State policy document, said: "No-one is suggesting we should not harness IT or surveillance technology to strengthen public protection. | Shadow justice secretary Dominic Grieve, speaking at the launch of the party's Reverse of the Surveillance State policy document, said: "No-one is suggesting we should not harness IT or surveillance technology to strengthen public protection. |
The state has encroached on the privacy of the innocent citizen, but delivered precious little in return Dominic Grieve, shadow justice secretary | The state has encroached on the privacy of the innocent citizen, but delivered precious little in return Dominic Grieve, shadow justice secretary |
"I am not amongst those who nostalgically yearn for some luddite return to a pre-technological age. But, the government's approach to databases and surveillance powers is the worst of all worlds, intrusive, ineffective and enormously expensive." | |
He also criticised a new vetting system for volunteers which he said aimed to "protect the public through automated systems". | He also criticised a new vetting system for volunteers which he said aimed to "protect the public through automated systems". |
But he said: "Over-reliance on the database state has proved a woefully poor substitute for human judgment and care on the frontline of public service delivery. | But he said: "Over-reliance on the database state has proved a woefully poor substitute for human judgment and care on the frontline of public service delivery. |
"The state has encroached on the privacy of the innocent citizen, but delivered precious little in return." | "The state has encroached on the privacy of the innocent citizen, but delivered precious little in return." |
DNA records | DNA records |
He said money spent on surveillance and building databases would be better spent on more "visible" policing, stronger border controls and increasing the number of prison places. | |
And he set out five basic principles guiding Tory policy in this area: "Fewer mammoth databases, that are better run. Fewer personal details held by the state, stored accurately and on a need-to-know basis. | And he set out five basic principles guiding Tory policy in this area: "Fewer mammoth databases, that are better run. Fewer personal details held by the state, stored accurately and on a need-to-know basis. |
"Greater checks and personal control over the sharing of our data by government. And stronger duties on government to keep our private information safe." | "Greater checks and personal control over the sharing of our data by government. And stronger duties on government to keep our private information safe." |
The Tories would have more credibility as opponents of the Big Brother state if they were not planning to reduce checks on police surveillance Chris HuhneLib Dems | |
The Tories are also planning to restrict the storage of DNA records of innocent people, after a ruling from the European Court of Human Rights. | The Tories are also planning to restrict the storage of DNA records of innocent people, after a ruling from the European Court of Human Rights. |
The government has consulted on its own DNA reforms, and is due to publish the results shortly. | The government has consulted on its own DNA reforms, and is due to publish the results shortly. |
Home Secretary Alan Johnson said: "The cases of criminals like Kensley Larrier and Abdul Azad demonstrate that we need to retain information on the DNA database." | Home Secretary Alan Johnson said: "The cases of criminals like Kensley Larrier and Abdul Azad demonstrate that we need to retain information on the DNA database." |
Larrier is a rapist from the North of England who was convicted in 2005 on the strength of a DNA sample taken from him three years earlier when he was arrested for possession of an offensive weapon. | |
Abdul Azad was convicted of a rape committed in Stafford on the strength of DNA evidence taken from him a year earlier in Birmingham when he was arrested for violent disorder. | Abdul Azad was convicted of a rape committed in Stafford on the strength of DNA evidence taken from him a year earlier in Birmingham when he was arrested for violent disorder. |
For the Liberal Democrats, Chris Huhne said: "The Tories would have more credibility as opponents of the Big Brother state if they were not planning to reduce checks on police surveillance. | |
"The party that first backed ID cards and whose councils snoop with enthusiasm is not to be trusted with privacy or civil liberties." |